Functional and Aesthetic Reconstruction of Burn Patients

28/11/2025 • by Bs CKI Phẫu thuật tạo hình, tái tạo và thẩm mỹ Trương Hoài Anh • phẫu thuật tạo hình

Giới thiệu

Cuốn sách Functional and Aesthetic Reconstruction of Burned Patients là một tài liệu y khoa chuyên sâu, được biên soạn bởi Robert L. McCauley, MD, FACS, một chuyên gia hàng đầu trong lĩnh vực phẫu thuật tạo hình và tái tạo, công tác tại Bệnh viện Shriners dành cho trẻ em (Galveston, Texas). Tác phẩm này cung cấp một cái nhìn toàn diện về các thách thức trong việc điều trị di chứng bỏng, kết hợp hài hòa giữa mục tiêu phục hồi chức năng vận động và cải thiện thẩm mỹ cho bệnh nhân.

Nội dung chính

Tài liệu đi sâu vào các nguyên tắc và kỹ thuật phẫu thuật tiên tiến để giải quyết các tổn thương phức tạp do bỏng gây ra. Nội dung sách bao gồm các khía cạnh quan trọng từ đánh giá ban đầu đến chăm sóc hậu phẫu:

  • Nguyên tắc tái tạo cơ bản: Các chiến lược xử lý sẹo co rút, mất mô rộng và biến dạng cơ thể sau bỏng.
  • Kỹ thuật phẫu thuật tạo hình: Hướng dẫn chi tiết về việc sử dụng các loại vạt da vạt tại chỗ, vạt từ xa, vạt vi phẫu, kỹ thuật giãn da và ghép da để che phủ khuyết hổng một cách tối ưu nhất.
  • Tái tạo theo vùng giải phẫu: Phân tích cụ thể các phương pháp phẫu thuật cho từng vùng cơ thể nhạy cảm như đầu mặt cổ, bàn tay, chi trên, chi dưới và thân mình, nơi yêu cầu cao về cả chức năng và thẩm mỹ.
  • Khía cạnh nhi khoa: Những lưu ý đặc biệt và kinh nghiệm lâm sàng khi phẫu thuật và điều trị cho trẻ em bị bỏng, giúp tối ưu hóa kết quả khi trẻ phát triển.

Đây là tài liệu tham khảo thiết yếu dành cho các bác sĩ phẫu thuật tạo hình, bác sĩ chấn thương chỉnh hình và các chuyên gia y tế đang tham gia vào quá trình chăm sóc và hồi phục toàn diện cho bệnh nhân bỏng.

Trang: / 602
Trang 1 Trang 2 Trang 3
📖 Xem bản dịch / Nội dung văn bản

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 0)
]j ` i ap]^kheoi ) kj hu ] bas kb pdaoa cnks pd b]_pkno) oq_d ]o
QDC*^ap] . ) FDC*. ]j ` MADC) d]r a pda ]^ehepu pk pneccan pda
l nkheban]pekj kb be^nk^h]opo ` ena_phu ] j ` ,kn opei qh]pa pda l nk*
` q_pekj kb _kj j a_per a peooqa %13)31&+ L b pdaoa FDC*. ]j `
QDC*^ap] . oaai pk l anoeop ej pk pda bej ]h op]cao kb da]hej c
%0. )33&+ T a d]r a na_aj phu bkqj ` ] cna]pan at l naooekj kb
QDC*^ap] . ]j ` FDC*. ej l kop^qnj EP_ peooqa nah]per a pk
j kni ]h peooqa k^p]ej a` bnki pda o]i a l ]peaj po %31)32&+
Qdanabkna) s a _kj _aj pn]pa dana kj pdaoa ps k l nki ej aj p be^nk*
caj e_ b]_pkno+
4 &
GaP] bU^a\ X] V : a^f cW 9PRc^a%QTcP )
QDC*^ap] . eo ] i qhpebqj _pekj ]h _upkgej a pd]p ej bhqaj _ao
i ]j u ei l knp]j p l duoekhkce_]h l nk_aooao oq_d ]o _ahhqh]n
l nkheban]pekj ]j ` ` ebbanaj pe]pekj %33&+ Fp eo oa_napa` ]o ]
h]paj p decd i kha_qh]n s aecdp _ki l hat %I QDC*^ap]&) _kj *
oeopej c kb ] / 2 gA] ` ei ane_ i ]pqna l nkpaej s epd . . / ]i ej k
]_e` o ej a]_d oq^qj ep ]j ` pda ` ei ane_ K*pani ej ]h l na_qnokn
l al pe` a gj ks j ]o h]paj _u ]ook_e]pa` l al pe` a %I > M& %34&+
QDC*^ap] . eo ] i ai ^an kb ] h]nca b]i ehu kb l nkpaej o
ej _hq` ej c ber a QDC*^ap] eokbkni o %QDC*^ap] . *2&) pda
ej de^ej o) ]_per ej o) ]j ` i qhhane]j ej de^epej c oq^op]j _a+
QDC*^ap] eokbkni o od]na 4- *5- " oamqaj _a e` aj pepu+
Qda oamqaj _ao kb pda i ]pqna) l nkpakhupe_]hhu l nk_aooa`
bkni o kb a]_d i ai ^an ]na decdhu _kj oanr a` ^aps aaj
ol a_eao %35&+ QDC*^ap] . *0 d]r a ^aaj bkqj ` ej
i ]i i ]ho ]j ` pdaen peooqa*ol a_ebe_ ` ebbanaj pe]h at l naooekj
i ]u d]r a ei l knp]j p ^ekhkce_]h _kj oamqaj _ao Xnar eas a`
ej Oab+ %36&Y+ Fj ] j qi ^an kb _ahh pul ao) oq_d ]o be^nk^h]opo)
l h]pahapo) ]j ` ^kj a _ahho) pda h]paj p QDC*^ap] . _ki l hat
]hok _kj p]ej o ] _kr ]haj phu ]ook_e]pa` . / 2*/ - 2 gA] chu_k*
l nkpaej pani a` pda h]paj p QDC*^ap] ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej
%I Q? M&+ I ]paj p QDC*^ap] . l nk` q_a` ^u oki a kopak*
^h]op*hega _ahho ]j ` na_ki ^ej ]j p QDC*^ap] . ouj pdaoeva`
^u @dej aoa d]i opan kr ]nu _ahho eo j kp ]ook_e]pa` s epd
pdeo ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej %4- )4. &+ > hpdkqcd pda bqj _pekj ]h oec*
j ebe_]j _a kb pda r ]nekqo bkni o kb h]paj p QDC*^ap] . d]o
j kp ^aaj ahq_e` ]pa` ) ep eo ^ahear a` pd]p ` eonql pekj kb pda
h]paj p _ki l hat )
aepdan ^u
_kj bkni ]pekj ]h _d]j cao
ej ` q_a` ^u ^ej ` ej c pk ]j kpdan _ki l kj aj p kn ^u _ki l hapa
` eook_e]pekj kb pda I > M) naoqhpo ej ]_per ]pekj %4. )4/ &+
QDC*^ap] . eo ] l kpaj p _dai k]ppn]_p]j p bkn i kj k_upao
]j ` be^nk^h]opo %40)41&+ ? kpd QDC*^ap] . ]j ` FDC*. _]j
opei qh]pa pda ouj pdaoeo ]j ` ` al koepekj kb r ]nekqo B@J
l nkpaej o ei l knp]j p ej ` ebbanaj pe]pekj ) i knl dkcaj aoeo) ]j `
s kqj ` da]hej c %35)42)43&+ QDC*^ap] . opei qh]pao be^nk*
^h]opo pk ouj pdaoeva _khh]caj ) be^nkj a_pej ) ]j ` D> Do)
` ks j nacqh]pao ` a_knej ouj pdaoeo s deha ql nacqh]pej c l nk*
` q_pekj kb r anoe_]j ]j ` ^echu_]j ) aj d]j _ao j akr ]o_qh]ne*
v]pekj ) opei qh]pao _khh]caj l nk` q_pekj ej j kni ]h dqi ]j
` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo ]j ` i k` qh]pao l nk` q_pekj kb ] r ]neapu
kb l nkpaej ]oao ]j ` pdaen ej de^epkno %31)35)44*5. &+ Pq^*
_qp]j akqo ej fa_pekj kb QDC*^ap] . ej pk j as ^knj i e_a
opei qh]pao cn]j qh]pekj peooqa bkni ]pekj ]j ` ]__ahan]pao
da]hej c kb ej _eoekj ]h s kqj ` o ej n]po %35)5/ &+ > hh pdaoa
abba_po ]j ` ar e` aj _a ei l he_]pej c ep ej kpdan be^nkpe_ _kj *
` epekj o l kej p pk epo l nk^]^ha ej r khr ai aj p ej pda l ]pdkcaj *
aoeo kb EP_ Xnar eas a` ej Oab+ %36&+Y
> j qi ^an kb pn]j ocaj e_ i k` aho kb s kqj ` da]hej c s dana
QDC*^ap] eo at l naooa` ej ] _kj opepqper ahu ]_per a bkni ]j `
qj ` an pda ` ena_pekj kb r ]nekqo gan]pej l nki kpano d]r a
` ai kj opn]pa` pd]p QDC*^ap] ej de^epo na*al epdahe]hev]pekj
[` h[ha ]j ` hegahu _kj pne^qpao pk ` ani ]h be^nkoeo+ Fj kqn
ks j at l aneaj _a) QDC*^ap] . at l naooa` qj ` an pda _kj pnkh
kb pda gan]pej . 1 l nki kpan %] ^]o]h gan]pej ]_per a ej
i ]pqna gan]pej k_upao& ej _na]oa` QDC*^ap] l nkpaej at l *
naooekj ]j ` ]_per epu ej pda al e` ani eo ]j ` ` ani eo) ej de^epa`
al epdahe]hev]pekj ]j ` ` ah]ua` da]h ^abkna pda ohks hu
da]hej c s kqj ` ` ar ahkl a` be^nkpe_ ba]pqnao ej pda ` ani eo
aepdan ej naol kj oa pk kl aj at _eoekj ]h s kqj ` o kn bkhhks ej c
h]oan ej ` q_a` pdani ]h ej fqnu %50)51&+
5&
6 ^] ] TRcXeT GXbbdT : a^f cW 9PRc^a
@kj j a_per a peooqa cnks pd b]_pkn %@QDC& eo ] i epkcaj e_
l nkpaej ) s de_d eo ei i qj khkce_]hhu nah]pa` pk MADC %52&+
Fp eo oa_napa` ^u be^nk^h]opo ]bpan pna]pi aj p s epd
QDC*^ap] ]j ` eo _kkn` ej ]pahu at l naooa` s epd QDC*^ap]
ej oar an]h be^nkpe_ _kj ` epekj o %]hpdkqcd pdana ` kao j kp
]l l a]n pk ^a ar e` aj _a ` ena_phu nah]pej c pk l kop^qi
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no& %53)54&+ Qdaoa k^oanr ]pekj o oqccaop
pd]p @QDC eo ] ` ks j opna]i i a` e]pkn kb pda ]_pekj kb
QDC*^ap] ej _kj j a_per a peooqa s dana ep opei qh]pao l nkheban*
]pekj kb be^nk^h]opo ]j ` ouj pdaoeo kb B@J %55&+ Qda n]j ca
kb _ahh pul ao naol kj ` ej c pk @QDC eo i q_d i kna naopne_pa`
pd]j pd]p bkn QDC*^ap] ]j ` ep d]o j k ]_per epu ]c]ej op
al epdahe]h kn ei i qj a _ahho) bkn at ]i l ha) oqccaopej c pd]p
ep i ]u ^a ] i kna oqep]^ha p]ncap bkn pda oaha_per a _kj pnkh
kb _kj j a_per a peooqa i ap]^kheoi ej CMA %55&+
6 &
<] bd[X] %? XZT : a^f cW 9PRc^a%)
FDC*. i a` e]pao pda ]_pekj o kb cnks pd dkni kj a kj i ]j u
peooqao ]j ` ]hok l h]uo ] nkha ej s kqj ` da]hej c pdnkqcd
epo abba_po kj ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo %56&+ FDC*. eo i epkcaj e_
bkn be^nk^h]opo ]j ` aj ` kpdahe]h _ahho ]j ` opei qh]pao
_khh]caj l nk` q_pekj ^u kopak^h]opo %6- )6. &+ > hpdkqcd
FDC*. s ]o ej epe]hhu e` aj pebea` ej oai i ]j ` bkqj ` pk ^a
l nk` q_a` ej pda her an) oq^oamqaj p opq` eao d]r a nar a]ha`
epo at l naooekj ej i kop peooqao at ]i ej a` %6- &+ I ega QDC*
^ap] . ) FDC*. eo at l naooa` hk_]hhu ej naol kj oa pk peooqa
ej fqnu ]j ` epo at l naooekj eo ej _na]oa` ej l ]n]hhah pk pda bkn*
i ]pekj kb cn]j qh]pekj peooqa ^aps aaj s aago . ]j ` 2 ]bpan
ej fqnu %6/ *61&+ Fj nacaj an]pej c ogahap]h i qo_ha ]j ` ]npan*
e]h ej fqneao) ej _na]oa` i OK> bkn FDC*. s ]o ` apa_pa`
s epdej / 1 d ]bpan ej fqnu %6/ )62&+ > o bkn QDC*^ap] . ) FDC*.

) 0*

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
opei qh]pao _khh]caj l nk` q_pekj ej dqi ]j hqj c be^nk^h]opo)
^kr ej a bap]h cnks pd*l h]pa _dkj ` nk_upao) ]j ` dqi ]j
` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo %42)43)63&+ Fp opei qh]pao AK> ouj pdaoeo)
nal he_]pekj kb eokh]pa` al el duoa]h cnks pd*l h]pa _dkj ` nk*
_upao) ej ` q_pekj kb D> Do) ]j ` ej _knl kn]pekj kb n]` ek*
h]^aha` l nkhej a ej pk _khh]caj ^u pdaoa _ahho %64)65&+
Fj panaopej chu) FDC*. na` q_ao pda har ah kb _khh]caj ]oa
i OK> ]j ` _khh]caj ]oa ]_per epu oa_napa` ^u ` ani ]h be^nk*
^h]opo %/ 4&+ T a na_aj phu bkqj ` cna]pan at l naooekj kb QDC*
^ap] . ]j ` FDC*. ej l kop^qi EP_ peooqa _ki l ]na` pk
j kni ]h ` ani eo bnki pda o]i a l ]peaj po %66&+ Pei eh]n
naoqhpo d]r a ^aaj nal knpa` ej kpdan be^nkpe_ _kj ` epekj o
ej _hq` ej c o_hank` ani ]) dal ]pe_) ej pn]k_qh]n) ]j ` l qhi kj ]nu
be^nkoao %. - - &+ Q]ga` ] ap ]h+ %. - . & l nkr e` a` ar e` aj _a pd]p
pda at _aooer a ]__qi qh]pekj kb _khh]caj ej l ]peaj po s epd ouo*
pai e_ o_hankoeo eo ` qa pk ` ebbanaj pe]h at l naooekj kb _khh]caj
]j ` _khh]caj ]oa ^u be^nk^h]opo+
T deha pda ]_pekj o kb FDC*. [` h[fda ]na ei l naooer a) pda
okqn_a%o& kb FDC*. eo %]na& j kp s ahh ` ao_ne^a` ej j kni ]h
]j ` be^nkpe_ dqi ]j peooqao+ Fj j kni ]h ogej ) FDC*. eo
naopne_pa` pk pda _ahho kb al e` ani ]h) os a]p) ]j ` oa^]_akqo
ch]j ` o8 pdanabkna) ep eo qj hegahu pd]p be^nk^h]opo ej pda
` ani eo s ehh j kni ]hhu d]r a ]__aoo pk FDC*. %. - / &+
Eks ar an) ej da]hej c ^qnj s kqj ` o) pdaoa opnq_pqnao ]na
` eonql pa` ]j ` naoe` q]h ch]j ` qh]n _ahho i ecn]pej c pks ]n`
pda s kqj ` oqnb]_a pk bkni pda al epdahe]h h]uan oa_napa
FDC*. ej _hkoa l nkt ei epu pk ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo) pdqo
_kj pne^qpej c pk pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb l kop^qi EP_+ Qdaoa
ch]j ` qh]n al epdahe]h _ahho d]r a kpdan ei l knp]j p bqj _pekj o
^aoe` ao l nk` q_pekj kb oa^qi ]j ` os a]p ej _hq` ej c
l nk` q_pekj kb FI *5) ] _upkgej a s epd _dai kp]_pe_ ]_per epu
bkn j aqpnkl deho %. - 0&+ Qdqo) ` ani ]h ]l l aj ` ]cao ]l l a]n
pk _kj pne^qpa cnks pd b]_pkno ej _hq` ej c FDC*. ) s de_d
]na i epkcaj e_ ]j ` bne^kcaj e_ ]j ` _kj pne^qpa pk pda ` ar ah*
kl i aj p kb l kop^qnj EP_+
7 &
<] cTaPRcX^] b ^U <: 9%) P] S G: 9%QTcP )
> _per ]pa` l h]pahapo ]j ` i ]_nkl d]cao naha]oa FDC*. ]j `
QDC*^ap] .
]p pda oepa kb ej fqnu ]j ` pdaoa cnks pd
b]_pkno ]na ` apa_p]^ha ej peooqa ]j ` ej s kqj ` _d]i ^ano
%6- ). - 1*. - 3&+ Ce^nk^h]opo) s de_d ]na pda l nei ]nu okqn_a
kb B@J ) ouj pdaoeva ^kpd QDC*^ap] . ]j ` FDC*. ]j `
naol kj ` pk pdaoa cnks pd b]_pkno %. - 4&+ Lg]v]ge ap ]h+
` ai kj opn]pa` pd]p QDC*^ap] i ]nga` hu ej _na]oao FDC*.
at l naooekj ej kopak^h]op*hega _ahho ]j ` s a na_aj phu
nal knpa` pd]p FDC*. opei qh]pao pda l nk` q_pekj kb QDC*
^ap] . pdnkqcd ]j ej _na]oa` n]pa kb caj a pn]j o_nel pekj
%. - 5). - 6&+ Qdaoa bej ` ej co oqccaop pd]p FDC*. ej s kqj `
bhqe` eo hegahu pk bqj _pekj ]o ] QDC*^ap] . opei qh]pej c
b]_pkn+
? a_]qoa FDC*. ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej o %FDC? Mo& i k` qh]pa pda
^ekhkce_]h ]_per epu kb FDC*. ) pda abba_po kb ^kpd FDC*. ]j `
QDC*^ap] . kj pda at l naooekj kb pdaoa ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej o
d]r a na_aj phu ^aaj opq` ea` ej ` ebbanaj p _ahh pul ao+ QDC*
^ap] . ej _na]oa` FDC? M*/ ]j ` FDC? M*0 ej ]hr akh]n al e*
pdahe]h _ahho ]j ` Eo245Q ^na]op _]j _an _ahho %. . - &+
FDC? M*0) s de_d eo _kj oe` ana` pk ^a pda i ]ej ^ej ` ej c
l nkpaej ]ook_e]pa` s epd FDC*. ej pda ^hkk` ]j ` peooqa)
d]o ^aaj nal knpa` pk i a` e]pa pda ]j pel nkheban]per a abba_po
kb QDC*^ap] . kj dqi ]j ^na]op _]j _an _ahho %. . . &+
8&
GWT E^[T ^U cWT GW) 'GW* CPaPSXV\ 4 UcTa
5 da] <] Ydah
Lr an pda l ]op ` a_]` a) _kj oe` an]^ha ar e` aj _a d]o ai anca`
pk oqccaop pd]p Q dahl an _ahho %@A1( & ]na i ]fkn ei i qj k*
nacqh]pkno s de_d i a` e]pa pdaen bqj _pekj ^u pda l nk` q_pekj
kb _upkgej ao ]bpan ]_per ]pekj ^u i ]_nkl d]cao) I ]j cand]j o
_ahho) kn kpdan ]j pecaj l naoaj pej c _ahho %> M@o& ej pda
_kj pat p kb ] i ]fkn deopk_ki l ]pe^ehepu _ki l hat i kha_qha
s de_d ^ej ` o pk pda Q _ahh na_al pkn %Q@O& %. . / *. . 1&+
J koi ]j j ` abej a` ps k i qnej a oq^oapo kb @A1( _ahho
s de_d l nk` q_a ` eopej _p cnkql o kb _upkgej ao7 Qdh _hkj ao)
s de_d at l naoo FI */ ) FCK*c]i i ]) ]j ` QKC*]hl d]) ]o s ahh
]o FcD/] eokpul a ]j pe^k` eao) ]j ` ]na l nej _el ]hhu i a` e]pkno
kb _ahh i a` e]pa` ei i qj epu ]j ` ` abaj oa ]c]ej op ej pn]_ahhq*
h]n l ]pdkcaj o ]j ` Qd/ _hkj ao) s de_d at l naoo FI *1) FI *2)
]j ` FI *. - ) ]j ` ]na ]ook_e]pa` s epd ]j pe^k` u i a` e]pa`
ei i qj epu) FcB ]j ` FcDe l nk` q_pekj ) akoej kl dehe]) ]j `
i ]op _ahh l nk` q_pekj Xnar eas a` ej Oabo+ %. . 1*. . 4&Y+
> hpdkqcd ^kpd _ahh pul ao ]na pdkqcdp pk ]neoa bnki ]
_ki i kj l na_qnokn) pda l naoaj _a kb FI *1 ej pda a]nhu
op]cao kb Q _ahh opei qh]pekj ha]` o pk opnkj c l kh]nev]pekj
kb Q _ahho pks ]n` pda Qd/ l daj kpul a ]j ` oa_napekj kb
decd har aho kb FI *1 ql kj naopei qh]pekj %. . 5&+ FI *1 ]hkj c
s epd FI *. - ej de^epo pda ouj pdaoeo kb FCK*c]i i ] ]j `
kpdan Qd*. _upkgej ao %. . 6&+ FI *. / eo r anu abba_per a ej ej ` q*
_ej c FCK*c]i i ]) ^qp eo ej de^epa` ^u Qd/ _upkgej ao) FI *1)
]j ` FI *. - ]j ` ]hok opnkj chu ^u QDC*^ap] %. / - ). / . &+ ? kpd
I ]j cand]j o _ahho %. . 0& ]j ` gan]pej k_upao %. . / & bqj _pekj ]o
> M@o ej pda ogej _]l ]^ha kb ej ` q_ej c ` ebbanaj pe]pekj [`
h[fda pk ^kpd Qdh ]j ` Qd/ kn Qd/ kj hu _hkj ao) opnkj chu
oql l knpej c pda ei l knp]j _a kb Q dahl an _ahh ei i qj k*
nacqh]pekj kb da]hej c ej pda ogej + @kj oe` an]^ha ar e` aj _a
at eopo pk oqccaop pd]p pda i qnej a l ]ppanj o kb _upkgej a l nk*
` q_pekj k__qn ej dqi ]j o) ]j ` ]na ej r khr a` ej pda l ]pdk*
caj aoeo kb ] j qi ^an kb dqi ]j ` eokn` ano ej _hq` ej c
ouopai e_ hql qo anupdai ]pkoqo %. / / &) ouopai e_ o_hank` ani ]
%. / 0&) ]pkl e_ ` ani ]pepeo %. / 1&) l nkpkvk]h ]j ` bqj c]h ej ba_*
pekj o ej _hq` ej c hal nkou %. / 2&) haeo_di ]j e]oeo %. / 3&) ]j `
o_deopkoki e]oeo %. / 4&+
Fj ] i qnej a i k` ah kb ^qi ej fqnu) Eqj p ap ]h+ %. / 5&
` ai kj opn]pa` ] ` al hapekj ej ol haj e_ Q dahl an _ahho %@A1&)
]j ej _na]oa ej _upkpkt e_ Q*hui l dk_upa naol kj oa ]ook_e]pa`
s epd na` q_a` FI */ ]j ` FCK*c]i i ] l nk` q_pekj ]o s ahh ]o
ej _na]oa` FI *2 _upkgej a l nk` q_pekj ) pdqo ] Qd/ l kh]neva`
naol kj oa+ Ppq` eao kb ei i qj a bqj _pekj ej ^qnj l ]peaj po

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 0+
` qnej c pda a]nhu ]_qpa kn kl aj s kqj ` op]cao kb ^qi ej fqnu
d]r a s ahh ` k_qi aj pa` pda ` abe_eaj _u kb FI */ ) ] Qdh _upk*
gej a %. / 6&+ Fj ^kpd ]j ]j ei ]h i k` ah kb ^qi ej fqnu ]j ` oq^*
oamqaj phu ej ^qi l ]peaj po) ej _na]oa` FI *1 i OK> ]j `
l nkpaej d]r a ^aaj ` k_qi aj pa` %. / 5&+ T epd pda ` ar ahkl *
i aj p kb pa_dj emqao pk ]hhks bkn ej pn]_ahhqh]n op]ej ej c kb
@A1( hui l dk_upao %. 0- ). 0. &) Wa` han ap ]h+ %. 0/ ). 00&
at ]i ej a` ^qnj l ]peaj po ej pda a]nhu l d]oa kb ej fqnu ql pk
4 ` ]uo l kop^qnj ]j ` bkqj ` oecj ebe_]j p ql nacqh]pekj kb FI *
1 ]j ` na` q_pekj ej FCK*c]i i ]+ Fj ] h]ncan oaneao kb ^qi
l ]peaj po) ]c]ej at ]i ej a` kj hu ` qnej c pda benop i kj pd l kop*
^qi ) C]eop ap ]h+ %. 01& ]hok bkqj ` oecj ebe_]j p na` q_pekj o ej
FCK*c]i i ] s de_d s ana l na` e_per a kb pdkoa l ]peaj po s dk
` ea` bnki oal oeo ]j ` i qhpel ha knc]j b]ehqna ` qa pk ^qnj
ej fqnu+ Rj bknpqj ]pahu) FCK*c]i i ] pdan]l u ej pdaoa
oar anahu ehh l ]peaj po ` e` j kp l nkpa_p pdai bnki ej ba_pekj o)
kn ` a_na]oa pda i knp]hepu bnki ej ba_pekj o ej pda a]nhu
l d]oa kb ^qi ej fqnu %1/ &+
? u ` ar ahkl ej c ] i apdk` kb _nukl naoanr ]pekj kb l ane*
l dan]h ^hkk` i kj k_upao %M? J @&) s a d]r a ^aaj ]^ha pk
at paj ` pda l anek` kb k^oanr ]pekj kb pda ej pn]_ahhqh]n _upk*
gej a l nkbeha bnki pda benop bas ` ]uo kb ^qnj ej fqnu ]o
` ao_ne^a` a]nhean) pk ]o h]pa ]o . 0 i kj pdo l kopej fqnu ej
. 4 ^qnj l ]peaj po pk ` ]pa) s ahh ej pk pda l anek` s daj i ]j u
oqnr er ej c l ]peaj po ` ai kj opn]pa oecj ebe_]j p EP_+ Pecj ebe_]j p
na` q_pekj o ej FCK*c]i i ] ]na l naoaj p ]j ` l anoeop ]p ha]op pk
3 i kj pdo l kopej fqnu ]na ]ook_e]pa` s epd pdnaa* pk bkqnbkh`
ej _na]oao ej FI *1 ej l ]peaj po s dk ` ar ahkl EP_ l kop^qnj
ej fqnu+ Qdeo eo oei eh]n pk pda bej ` ej co kb Pde ap ]h+ %. 02&
ej ]j ]j ei ]h i k` ah kb her an ej fqnu) s dana i e_a s epd ]
Qd/ naol kj oa d]` oar ana dal ]pe_ be^nkoeo) s dana]o Qdh
naol kj ` ej c ]j ei ]ho ` ar ahkl a` i ej ei ]h be^nkoeo+
I <& GE8 4 G@8 AG B9 ; LC8 EGEBC; <6 F6 4 E$
> 8 ? B<7 F$ 4 A7 6 BAGE4 6 GHE8 F
@qnnaj phu) pna]pi aj p kb CMA ej _hq` ej c gahke` o ]j ` EP_
nai ]ej o pei a _kj oqi ej c) at l aj oer a) ]j ` s epd bas _kj oeop*
aj phu oq__aoobqh ]l l nk]_dao) s de_d naoqhpo ej i ]j u l nk*
l koa` i apdk` o kb _]na ]j ` bas op]j ` ]n` eva` pna]pi aj p
nacei ao+ Pqnce_]h at _eoekj kb EP_ ]j ` gahke` o s epdkqp
]` fqr ]j p pdan]l u eo ]ook_e]pa` s epd ] decd n]pa kb na_qn*
naj _a %. 03&+ Lj a kb pda ` ebbe_qhpeao ej pda ]ooaooi aj p kb
j as pdan]l eao eo pd]p ei i a` e]pahu bkhhks ej c na*al epdahev]*
pekj pda da]ha` ogej i ]u ^a bh]p ]j ` okbp) ]hpdkqcd na` ) ^qp
ep pde_gaj o kr an pei a s epd ] naoqhpej c ej _na]oa ej pkp]h
r khqi a+ Qda pei a ]p s de_d pda r khqi a l a]go ` al aj ` o kj
pda l ]peaj p) hk_]pekj ) ]j ` _kj oanr ]per a ej panr aj pekj )
i ]gej c ep ` ebbe_qhp pk ]ooaoo dks i q_d s knoa pda o_]n
s kqh` d]r a ^a_ki a s epdkqp pda pna]pi aj p ej panr aj pekj
kn s dapdan ep s ]o ]hna]` u ]p ] l kej p ej pei a s dana ep s ]o
naokhr ej c kj epo ks j %Ceco+ . 0+6 ]j ` . 0+. - &+
4 &
CaTeT] cX^ ] ^U 7 Ta\ P[ 9XQa^ _a^ [XUTaPcXeT
7 Xb^ aSTab
> o ehhqopn]pa` ej Cec+ . 0+. - ) EP_ ^a_ki ao ]l l ]naj p s aago
kn i kj pdo ]bpan na*al epdahe]hev]pekj kb pda ej fqna` ` ani eo
]j ` _kj pej qao pk ej _na]oa ej oeva ^abkna qj ` anckej c
9XVdaT ) +&1
Pane]h ` k_qi aj p]pekj kb ] o_]h` ^qnj ej ] . - *ua]n*kh` cenh) s de_d ehhqopn]pao pd]p ]bpan l nkhkj ca` ej bh]i i ]pekj ]j ` ` ah]ua`
s kqj ` da]hej c EP_ kbpaj naoqhpo ` aol epa l naooqna pdan]l u+ XCnki Qna` cap ap ]h+ %. &+Y

) 0,

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
) +*-.,+-
Cec qna . 0+. -
J ]pdai ]pe_ i k` ahej c kb oane]h i a]oqnai aj po kb
EP_ r khqi a ej aecdp l ]peaj po kr an pei a nar a]ha` pd]p ei i a` e]pahu
bkhhks ej c na*al epdahe]hev]pekj ) o_]no ]na bh]p ]j ` oql l ha+ Qdau
cn]` q]hhu ej _na]oa ej daecdp) pdana^u ej _na]oej c pda pkp] h r khqi a
kb pda o_]n+ Qda pei a p] gaj pk na]_d pda l a]g daecdp) pda qhpei ]pa
at paj p pk s de_d pda pkp] h r khqi a ej _na]oao) ]j ` pda pei a namqena`
bkn pda o_]n pk bh]ppaj ]j ` i ]pqna %pda ohkl a kb pda hej a& ]na at pna*
i ahu r ]ne]^ha ]i kj c l ]peaj po+ > ooaooi aj p kb pna]pi aj p ej panr aj *
pekj o eo _ki l he_]pa` ]o ep i ]u ^a ej epe]pa` ]p ]j u l kej p ej pda
` ar ahkl i aj p kn naokhqpekj kb o_]n bkni ]pekj + XOal nej pa` bnki
Qna` cap ap ]h+ %. &) s epd l ani eooekj bnki Bhoar ean P_eaj _a+Y
b_ ^ ] cP] T^ d b aT\ ^ ST[X] V$
^ UcT]
c^
P] X] R^ \ _ [TcT
^ a
d ] PRRT_ cPQ[T TgcT] c& > T[^ XSb X] RaTPbT X] e ^ [d \ T Pc P aPcT
^ UcT] _ aTSXRcTS Qh cWT TgcT] c ^ U X] U[P\ \ PcX^ ] Pbb^ RXPcTS
f XcW cWT ^ aXVX] P[ X] Yd ah$ \ Ph d ] STaV^ _ TaX^ Sb ^ U b[^ f TS
Va^ f cW ^ a bcPQX[Xch$ Qd c aPaT[h aTVaTbb& 5 TRPd bT ; F R f X[[
b_ ^ ] cP] T^ d b[h aTVaTbb ^ e Ta cX\ T$ Xc QTR^ \ Tb e Tah X\ _ ^ ac%
P] c c^ SXbcX] Vd XbW cWT\ Ua^ \ ZT[^ XSb$ b^ cWPc P_ _ a^ _ aXPcT
caTPc\ T] c \ ^ SP[XcXTb RP] QT X] S Xe XSd P[Xi TS c^ b_ TRXUXR
[TbX^ ] b QPbTS ^ ] cWTXa _ aTSXRcTS RT[[d [Pa QTWPe X^ a$ TgcT] c
P] S [^ RPcX^ ] ^ U X] e ^ [e T\ T] c$ P] S b^ RXP[ UPRc^ ab f WXRW
f X[[ X] U[d T] RT cWT _ PcXT] cb PQX[Xch c^ R^ \ _ [h f XcW P f XST
aP] VT ^ U cWTaP_XTb&
4
UP\ X[h
WXbc^ ah
^ U ZT[^ XSb$
_ aTe X^ d b
Tgd QTaP] c
aTb_ ^ ] bT c^ X] Yd ah$ _ a^ [^ ] VTS X] U[P\ \ PcX^ ] Pc cWT bXcT ^ U
X] Yd ah$ P] S P] Pc^ \ XR [^ RPcX^ ] ^ U X] Yd ah c^ cWT bW^ d[STab$
P] cTaX^ a RWTbc$ ] TRZ$ d _ _ Ta Pa\ b$ P] S RWTTZb \ Ph QT _ aT%
SXRcXe T ^ U UXQa^ _ a^ [XUTaPcXe T [TbX^ ] b ^ U bXV] XUXRP] c TgcT] c&
H] U^ acd ] PcT[h$ ] ^ ; ? 4 %4 ^ a ; ? 4 %5 cXbbdT P] cXVT] Pbb^ RX%
PcX^ ] b WPe T QTT] R^ ] bXbcT] c[h U^ d ] S P\ ^ ] V _ PcXT] cb f XcW
ZT[^ XSb ^ a ; F R$ ] ^ a WPb P] Pd c^ b^ \ P[ ^ a bTg%[X] ZTS
_ PccTa] ^ U X] WTaXcP] RT QTT] TbcPQ[XbWTS& ; ^ f Te Ta$ \ ^ bc
ZT[^ XSb ^ RRd a X] _ PcXT] cb QTcf TT] cWT PVTb ^ U ) ( P] S +(
P] S P bca^ ] V bTg W^ a\ ^ ] P[ X] U[d T] RT WPb QTT] U^ d ] S f XcW
P _ aTSXb_ ^ bXcX^ ] ^ U ZT[^ XSb c^ STe T[^ _ Sd aX] V _ d QTach P] S
_ aTV] P] Rh f XcW aT_ ^ acb ^ U b^ UcT] X] V P] S U[PccT] X] V ^ U
[TbX^ ] b f XcW \ T] ^ _ Pd bT P] S PSe P] RX] V PVT !bTe T] cW P] S
TXVWcW STRPSTb" !- 1 "&
J ^ d ] S cT] bX^ ] Xb P] X\ _ ^ acP] c RaXcXRP[ UPRc^ a X] bZX]
P] S f ^ d ] S R[^ bd aT$ f WXRW RP] QT aTSd RTS Qh _ [P] ] X] V bda%
VXRP[ X] RXbX^ ] b P] S aTR^ ] bcad RcX^ ] P[^ ] V [X] Tb ^ U aT[PgTS
bZX] cT] bX^ ] & 4 d c^ RaX] T _ a^ Sd RcX^ ] ^ U UXQa^ VT] XR Va^ f cW
UPRc^ ab PUcTa PRcXe PcX^ ] ^ U RT[[b X] \ PcaXg P__TPab c^
^ RRd a Qh cWT caP] b\ XbbX^ ] ^ U 8 6 @ U^ aRTb c^ cWT RT[[ \ T\ %
QaP] T cWa^ d VW RT[[ bd aUPRT PSWTbX^ ] \ ^ [TRd [Tb X] R[d SX] V
X] cTVaX] b QTU^ aT Xc Xb caP] b\ XccTS X] caPRT[[d [Pa[h e XP U^ RP[
PSWTbX^ ] R^ \ _ [TgTb& F d QbT` d T] c[h$ P[cTaPcX^ ] b X] cWT X] caP%
RT[[d [Pa Rhc^ bZT[Tc^ ] RP] X] RaTPbT ] d R[TPa VT] T caP] bRaX_ %
cX^ ] ^ U G: 9 %QTcP P] S ^ cWTa Rhc^ ZX] T P] S \ PcaXg _ a^ cTX]
VT] Tb [TPSX] V c^ PQ] ^ a\ P[ \ PcaXg _ a^ Sd RcX^ ] !) +/ "&
4 ] ^ cWTa UPRc^ a ^ U WXVW _ aTSXRcXe T e P[d T U^ a cWT STe T[^ _ %
\ T] c ^ U STa\ P[ UXQa^ bXb Xb cWT _ TabXbcT] RT ^ U RWa^ ] XR X] U[P\ %
\ PcX^ ] X] f ^ d] Sb& J T P] S ^ cWTab WPe T U^ d ] S cWPc Qd \
f ^ d ] Sb X] cWT STT_ STa\ Xb f WXRW aT` d XaTS _ a^ [^ ] VTS
_ TaX^ Sb U^ a WTP[X] V WPS P e Tah WXVW aPcT ^ U STe T[^ _ X] V ; F R
X] ST_ T] ST] c ^ U cWT _ PcXT] cpb PVT$ bTg$ P] S aPRXP[ QPRZVa^ d] S&
GWd b$ cX\ X] V ^ U f ^ d ] S R[^ bd aT U^ a Qd \ b f XcWX] * %+ f TTZb
WPb QTR^ \ T P] X\ _ ^ acP] c _ aTaT` d XbXcT X] \ X] X\ Xi X] V ; F R$
_ PacXRd [Pa[h X] X\ _ ^ acP] c R^ b\ TcXR aTVX^ ] b bdRW Pb cWT UPRT
!- ) $) +0 " P] S X] \ ^ QX[T bZX] ^ U cWT WP] Sb P] S Y^ X] cb&
F X\ X[Pa[h $ _ TabXbcT] c ^ a TgPVVTaPcTS X] U[P\ \ PcX^ ] Ua^ \
X] UTRcX^ ] Xb P Z] ^ f ] caXVVTa U^ a ZT[^ XSb !9 XV& ) +&) "& 6 T[[d %
[XcXb ^ U cWT bRP[_$ PR] T e d [VPaXb$ PR] T R^ ] V[^ QPcP$ WXSaPST%
] XcXb
bd _ _ d aPcXe P$
_ X[^ ] XS P[
Rhbcb$
P] S U^ aTXV] Q^ Sh
aTPRcX^ ] b Pb f T[[ Pb U^ [[XRd [XcXb $ _ h^ STa\ P$ e PRRX] XP$ P] S
e PaXRT[[P WPe T QTT] Pbb^ RXPcTS f XcW cWT STe T[^ _ \ T] c ^ U
ZT[^ XSb !) +1 "& 5 PRcTaXP[ T] S^ c^ gX] WPb QTT] bW^ f ] c^
X] Sd RT cWT _ a^ Sd RcX^ ] ^ U G: 9 %QTcP Qh X\ \ d ] T RT[[b X]
f ^ d ] Sb$ f WXRW \ Ph QT ^ ] T ^ U cWT \ TRWP] Xb\ b [TPSX] V
c^ UXQa^ bXb !) , ( "&
5 &
6 ^ ] bTaePcXeT GWTaP_h U^ a > T[^ XSb$
; h_Taca^ _WXR FRPa$ P] S 6 ^ ] caPRcdaTb
6 ^ ] bTae PcXe T
\ P] PVT\ T] c
^ U ; F R
P] S
R^ ] caPRcdaTb
X] R[d STb cWT dbT ^ U _ aTbbdaT VPa\ T] cb$ bX[XR^ ] T VT[ bWTTcb$
R^ ] U^ a\ Tab$ caP] b_ PaT] c UPRT\ PbZb$ bTaXP[ RPbcX] V$ P] S
b_ [X] cb& 6 d bc^ \ UPQaXRPcTS _ aTbbd aT VPa\ T] cb PaT R^ \ %
\ ^ ] [h dbTS P] S PaT bd _ _ [XTS Qh bTe TaP[ R^ \ _ P] XTb QPbTS
^ ] X] S Xe XSd P[ _ PcXT] c \ TPbd aT\ T] cb& CaTbbdaT cWTaP_ h
QTVX] b Pb b^ ^ ] Pb aT%T_ XcWT[XP[Xi PcX^ ] ^ RRdab P] S VPa\ T] cb
bW^ d [S QT XSTP[[h f ^ a] *, W' S Ph $ d ] cX[ bRPa \ Pcd aPcX^ ] Xb
Te XST] c !) , ) "& 4 [cW^ d VW cWT ^ _ cX\ d \ _aTbbdaT aT` d XaTS
U^ a TUUTRc Xb d ] Z] ^ f ] $ cWT aTR^ \ \ T] STS [Te T[ Xb VaTPcTa
cWP] *- \ \ ; V3 W^ f Te Ta$ V^ ^ S R[X] XRP[ aTbd [cb WPe T QTT]
aT_ ^ acTS f XcW [Te T[b Pb [^ f Pb - %) - \ \ ; V !) , * "& GWT \ ^ [%
TRd [Pa P] S RT[[d [Pa QPbXb U^ a cWT bdRRTbb ^ U _aTbbdaT cWTaP_ h
Xb ] ^ c Z] ^ f ] Qd c cWT RaTPcX^ ] ^ U P Wh_ ^ gXR T] e Xa^ ] \ T] c \ Ph
aTSd RT UXQa^ Q[Pbc _ a^ [XUTaPcX^ ] P] S aTSd RT R^ [[PVT] bh] %
cWTbXb !) , +" Qh ^ RR[d bX^ ] ^ U b\ P[[ eTbbT[b f XcWX] cWT bRPa
!) , , "& GWTbT PdcW^ ab P[b^ ] ^ cTS cWPc X] cTabcXcXP[ b_PRTb
QTcf TT] R^ [[PVT] UXQaX[b X] ; F R f TaT e Xacd P[[h PQbT] c U^ [%
[^ f X] V caTPc\ T] c f XcW R^ ] cX] d ^ d b _ aTbbd aT P] S cWTaT f Pb

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 0-
] ` a_na]oa ej pda j qi ^an kb j k` qhao) s epd ] i kna l ]n]hhah
kneaj p]pekj kb _khh]caj nah]per a pk pda al e` ani eo ]j ` ]j
ej _na]oa ej _khh]caj be^an ^qj ` ha bkni ]pekj + > hok na` q_pekj
ej pda i ]op _ahh l kl qh]pekj ej EP_ k__qnna` bkhhks ej c l naoo*
qna pdan]l u %. 12&+ Cej ]hhu) ] na_aj p _kj pnkhha` opq` u kb ^qi o
l ]peaj po pna]pa` s epd ]j ` s epdkqp ah]ope_ l naooqna c]ni aj po
d]o oqccaopa` pd]p j k op]peope_]hhu oecj ebe_]j p ^aj abep _kqh`
^a ` apani ej a` bkn pda qoa kb pdeo ]l l nk]_d pk s ]nn]j p pda
_kj oe` an]^ha _kop) ej _kj r aj eaj _a) ]j ` oe` a abba_po s de_d
ej _hq` ao k^opi _per a ohaal ]l j a]) l ]peaj p ` eo_ki bknp) ]j `
s kqj ` ^na]g` ks j qj ` an l naooqna ol kpo %. 05). 13&+
E ks ar an) pda h]_g kb ` k_qi aj p]pekj kb l ]peaj p _ki l he]j _a)
i a]oqnai aj po kb l naooqna ]_dear a` ) _kj pnkh kb ]j ]pki e_]h
oepa) oqnce_]h ej panr aj pekj ) ]j ` s kqj ` _ki l he_]pekj o) ]o
s ahh ]o pda hei epa` j qi ^an kb l ]peaj po opq` ea` oqccaop pd]p
bqnpdan na*at ]i ej ]pekj eo namqena` ^abkna pda naoqhpo _]j
^a i kna caj an]hhu ]__al pa` + Oa_aj phu) opq` eao ]na ai ancej c
ej s de_d i kna k^fa_per a i a]oqnao kb o_]n ]ooaooi aj p qoej c
ej opnqi aj po pk i a]oqna anupdai ] ]j ` i ah]j ej %. 14&) ah]ope_
na_keh kb pda ogej ]j ` ` ani ]h _ki l he]j _a %. 15& ]j ` pde_g*
j aoo %. 16&) ]o s ahh ]o ei l nkr a` _hej e_]h o_]n o_knej c
ouopai o _kj pej qa pk ^a qj ]^ha pk ` ai kj opn]pa oecj ebe_]j p
ei l nkr ai aj po kb o_]n i k` qh]pekj s epd l naooqna c]ni aj po
ej s ahh*_kj pnkhha` pne]ho+ Qdaoa opq` eao) dks ar an) ]na opehh
ej pdaen l nahei ej ]nu op]cao %. 2- &+
Qda qoa kb oehe_kj a cah odaapo s ]o ej pnk` q_a` ]o ]j
]hpanj ]per a bkni kb pna]pi aj p ]j ` d]o ^aaj oq__aoobqh s epd
EP_) gahke` o %22). 2. ). 2/ &) ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao %. 20&+ Dah
odaapo _]j ^a s knj ]o hkj c ]o / 1 d,` ] u) s epd l ]npe_qh]n ]ppaj *
pekj l ]e` pk duceaj a pk ]r ke` pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb _kj p]_p ` an*
i ]pepeo %. 21&+ Pehe_kj a cah i ]u at anp epo abba_po ^u ej _na]oej c
pda pai l an]pqna kb pda o_]n) pdana^u aj d]j _ej c pda ]_per epu kb
_khh]caj ]oa) s de_d eo gj ks j pk ej _na]oa oar an]h bkh` kr an . Ü
kn / Ü kb ^k` u pai l an]pqna %. 22&+ Pq_d ej _na]oao ej pai l an]*
pqna ]na pul e_]h bkhhks ej c oehe_kj a cah pna]pi aj p ]j ` d]r a
^aaj ` k_qi aj pa` ej ^qi l ]peaj po s epd EP_ %. 23&+ Lpdan
abba_po kb oehe_kj a cah oq_d ]o ej _na]oa` l naooqna) hks ana`
kt ucaj paj oekj ) kn k__hqoekj i ]u ^a haoo ei l knp]j p+
Eu` n]pekj kb pda opn]pqi _ki aqi ]j ` ` ena_p naha]oa kb
hks *i kha_qh]n s aecdp oehe_kj a bhqe` ej pk pda o_]n ]na kpdan
l kooe^ha i k` ao kb ]_pekj %. 24&8 dks ar an) oehe_kj a ` kao j kp
]l l a]n pk aj pan o_]n peooqao %. 25&+
Peh]ope_ _kj bkni ano _]j ^a qoa` ]o ej ` al aj ` aj p ej oanpo
ej _kj fqj _pekj s epd l naooqna c]ni aj po pk oql l hai aj p
l naooqna ej _kj _]r a nacekj o %. 26& kn ai ^a` ` a` s epdej ]
oql l knpej c i ]pnet %. 3- & kn ]o ]j ]` daoer a ` naooej c ]o ]
l nei ]nu pna]pi aj p %. 3. &+
Qn]j ol ]naj p b]_a i ]ogo %. 3/ & ]na ]j ]hpanj ]per a i a]j o
pk ]_dear a kl pei ]h l naooqna ]j ` _kj bkni epu bkn pda pna]p*
i aj p kb EP_ ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao bkhhks ej c b]_e]h ^qi o ]j `
]na i kna na]` ehu ]__al pa` ^u l ]peaj po ]o pdau l nkr e` a ]j
a]oean pn]j oepekj ]j ` ]na i kna ok_e]hhu ]__al p]^ha ` qa pk
pda at l koqna kb b]_e]h ba]pqnao ej l q^he_ %. 05&+
@qnnaj phu) oane]h _]opej c d]o ^a_ki a pda i kop abba_per a
_kj oanr ]per a bkni kb pna]pi aj p bkn na` q_ej c ^qi o_]n
_kj pn]_pqnao %. 30). 31&) ]hpdkqcd op]pe_ oane]h ol hej pej c ]j `
` uj ]i e_ ol hej pej c _kj pej qa pk ^a at paj oer ahu qpeheva` %. 32&+
6 &
<] caP[TbX^] P[ 6 ^acXR^bcTaX^Sb
Fj pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj kb pne]i _ej khkj a ]hkj a kn _ki ^ej a`
s epd kpdan pdan]l eao bkn pda _kj pnkh kb hk_]h ` eo_ki bknp ]j `
bh]ppaj ej c kb pda o_]no d]o ^aaj bkqj ` pk ^a ]ook_e]pa` s epd
] 2- " naol kj oa n]pa ej gahke` o kr an 2 ua]no %. 33& s epd
]j kpdan opq` u nal knpej c ] na_qnnaj _a n]pa kb 2 kb 23
gahke` o kr an 1 ua]no+ > hpdkqcd r ]nekqo cqe` ahej ao at eop
bkn l nal ]n]pekj o) ` ko]ca) ]j ` ]` i ej eopn]pekj ) kj a ]l l nk]_d
ai l hkuo r ]nuej c _kj _aj pn]pekj o %. - )/ - ) 0- ) kn 1- i c,i I &
ej ` ebbanaj p haoekj o kn ]na]o kb pda o]i a haoekj pk aop]^heod
pda i ej ei qi abba_per a ` ko]ca bkn oq^oamqaj p pna]pi aj po
qoq]hhu ]p 0*1 s aag ej panr ]ho+ Pq_d pdan]l u eo hegahu pk
^a abba_per a ^u ej de^epej c pn]j o_nel pekj kb _anp]ej i ]pnet
l nkpaej caj ao Xej _hq` ej c ^ap] . %. & ]j ` ^ap] . %FFF& l nk_kh*
h]caj ) be^nkj a_pej ) QDC*^ap]) ]j ` kpdan _upkgej aoY ]o s ahh
]o na` q_ej c ]hl d]*/ i ]_nkchk^qhej ouj pdaoeo) ] gj ks j
ej de^epkn kb _khh]caj ]oa ]_per epu %. 34&+ > _ki i kj _ki l he*
_]pekj kb _knpe_kopanek` ej fa_pekj o eo l ]ej ]p pda oepa kb ej fa_*
pekj ) s de_d _]j ^a ]r anpa` ^u pkl e_]h ]j aopdaoe] ] j ` ,kn
nacekj ]h ej fa_pekj o kb hk_]h ]j aopdape_ ]nkqj ` pda o_]no pk
^a ej fa_pa` %. 35&+ Lpdan ]` r anoa oe` a abba_po ej _hq` a o_]n
kn oq^_qp]j akqo peooqa ]pnkl du) pah]j cea_p]oe]) j a_nkoeo)
qh_an]pekj ) ]j ` @qodej cke` d]^epqo+ I k_]h l eci aj p]pekj
]j ` ]pnkl du _]j ^a i ej ei eva` ^u _kj bej ej c pda ej fa_pekj
pk pda o_]n ]j ` i ]ej p]ej ej c pda opanke` _kj _aj pn]pekj
^ahks 2 i c,i I + S ]nekqo ` aher anu ouopai o at eop ej _hq` ej c
ol nej c kn @- /*l ks ana` ` ar e_ao) ^qp i kop _ki i kj hu hqan*
hk_ga` ounej cao s epd / 2* pk 0- *cq]ca j aa` ha ]na ai l hkua`
]ei ej c pk l h]_a pda ej fa_pekj - +2 _i ]l ]np ]j ` ej pk pda ^qhg
kb pda haoekj + Puopai e_ abba_po ]na ]r ke` a` ^u pei ej c ej fa_*
pekj o cna]pan pd]j ar anu 1 s aago ]bpan s de_d pdan]l aqpe_
abba_po odkqh` ^a ]l l ]naj p+
@nukpdan]l u d]o ^aaj nal knpa` ]o ] l nahei ej ]nu ]` fqj _p
l nekn pk _knpe_kopanke` o bkn hk_]heva` EP_ ]j ` gahke` o pk
b]_ehep]pa l aj apn]pekj kb pda opanke` s epd pda haoekj o) ^qp ^u
epoahb r ]nuej c naoqhpo d]r a ^aaj ]_dear a` ) i kop oq__aoobqhhu
ej j as hu bkni a` haoekj o s epd i qhpel ha pna]pi aj po %. 36). 4- &+
Oa_aj phu) _]h_eqi _d]j j ah ^hk_gano %r an]l ]i eh& kn _]h*
i k` qhej ej de^epkno %pnebhqkl an]vej a& d]r a ^aaj ej fa_pa`
ej pk EP_ ]j ` gahke` o s de_d b]eha` pk naol kj ` pk _knpe_ko*
panke` o) ej ]j ]ppai l p pk ]_per ]pa _khh]caj ]oa ouj pdaoeo ej
pda haoekj o pdnkqcd pda ]hpan]pekj o ej be^nk^h]op i kn*
l dkhkcu s de_d ]na gj ks j pk ej ` q_a _khh]caj ]oa caj a pn]j *
o_nel pekj %. 4. &+ > hpdkqcd ^aj abe_e]h abba_po s ana bkqj ` ej
pdnaa kb ber a pna]pa` l ]peaj po) pda ]l l nk]_d aj p]eha` bas eb
]j u oe` a abba_po s epd ] i ]t ei qi ej pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj kb
/ i I %/ +2 i c,i I & ej ]j ]ppai l p pk ]_dear a . - - *2- - *
%t i kh,I ej pda o_]n+
> j pei ap]^khepa i a` e_]pekj o ej _hq` ej c pkl e_]h bhqknkqn*
]_eh ]j ` ej pn]haoekj ]h ^haki u_ej d]r a ^aaj bkqj ` pk ^a
abba_per a ej oi ]hh _hej e_]h pne]ho ]j ` ]l l a]n pk d]r a

) 0.

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
j kj ol a_ebe_ ]j pel nkheban]per a ]j ` ]j peej bh]i i ]pknu abba_po
s de_d ]na ej _ki l hapahu qj ` anopkk` %. 4/ ). 40&+
7 &
FdaVXRP[ GWTaP_h
Oa_qnnaj _a n]pao bkn oei l ha oqnce_]h at _eoekj kb gahke` o
]j ` EP_ ]hkj a r ]nu bnki 2- " pk 5- " %. 41&+ > ppai l po pk
naoqnb]_a s epd ogej cn]bpo d]r a ] nal knpa` na_qnnaj _a n]pa
kb 26" ) ^qp d]hb kb pda gahke` l ]peaj po pna]pa` ` ar ahkl a`
j as haoekj o ej pda ` kj kn oepa %. 03). 42&+ Eks ar an) ^aj *
abe_e]h abba_po kb oqnce_]h at _eoekj kb gahke` o d]r a k__qnna`
s epd j ]nnks *^]oa` %9 . _i & l a` qj _qh]pa` haoekj o ]j `
s daj oqnce_]h l nk_a` qnao ]na _ki ^ej a` s epd hk_]h bh]l o
pk na` q_a s kqj ` paj oekj ]j ` ]` fqj _per a pdan]l u+ Pq_d
]` fqj _po ej _hq` a hk_]h opanke` pdan]l u ej pda i ]ncej o kb
pda s kqj ` ]j ` i kj pdhu ej fa_pekj o pdana]bpan+ Qda i kna
_ki i kj a]nhk^a gahke` kbpaj eo pna]pa` ^u hk_]h at _eoekj
kb pda haoekj ]j ` ej pn]kl an]per a opanke` o bkhhks a` ^u l naoo*
qna pdan]l u qoej c ] r ]neapu kb a]nnej c l naooqna ` ar e_ao
%. 43&+ Aqnej c oqnce_]h at _eoekj kb EP_ ]j ` gahke` o) _]na
i qop ^a p]gaj pk nai kr a ]hh okqn_ao kb naoe` q]h ej bh]i *
i ]pekj s de_d k__qno s epd pn]l l a` d]en bkhhe_hao) al epdahe]h
_uopo) oej qo pn]_po) ]j ` ej ba_pa` l ehkoa^]_akqo qj epo s de_d
i ]u ^a ] okqn_a kb be^nkcaj e_ cnks pd b]_pkno+ Pqnce_]h
na_kj opnq_pekj odkqh` ^a ` aoecj a` pk i ej ei eva peooqa
pn]qi ] ]j ` s kqj ` paj oekj s deha ]r ke` ej c ` a]` ol ]_a)
bknaecj i ]pane]h) dai ]pki ]) ]j ` ej ba_pekj + Oakneaj p]pekj
kb o_]no l ]n]hhah pk hej ao kb nah]t a` ogej paj oekj odkqh` ^a
]j ej pacn]h l ]np kb l nakl an]per a l h]j j ej c+
Fj pn]i ]ncej ]h at _eoekj kb EP_ ]j ` gahke` o d]o ^aaj
l nkl koa` ]o ] qoabqh oqnce_]h pa_dj emqa pk i ej ei eva na_qn*
naj _a kb haoekj o s de_d d]r a b]eha` j kj kl an]per a oqnce_]h
pdan]l u+ Pei eh]n ]l l nk]_dao i ]ej p]ej ej c nai j ]j po kb
gahke` al epdaheqi d]r a ^aaj l nkl koa` ^qp k^fa_per a pne]ho
kb pdeo ]l l nk]_d ]na h]_gej c+
O]` e]pekj pdan]l u ej pda bkni kb l dkpkj o) aha_pnkj o) ]j `
ej panopepe]h pdan]l u d]o ^aaj ai l hkua` ]o ] i a]oqna pk
_kj pnkh l nkheban]per a haoekj o ej pda ogej qoq]hhu bkhhks ej c
oqnce_]h pdan]l u+ A]nve ap ]h+ %. 41& l nkr e` a` ] . - *ua]n
bkhhks ql kb 32 l ]peaj po pna]pa` s epd ^ap] n]` e]pekj ]hkj a)
l na* ]j ` l kopkl an]per a n]` e]pekj ]j ` oqncanu bkhhks a` ^u
^ap] n]` e]pekj ) ]j ` opanke` ej fa_pekj ]hkj a+ Bhar aj l an_aj p
kb haoekj o na` q_a` s epd n]` e]pekj ]hkj a) s dana]o n]` e]pekj
_ki ^ej a` s epd oqnce_]h pdan]l u ueah` a` ] 42" na` q_pekj
ej haoekj o s epd j k ^aj abep pk l nakl an]per a n]` ekpdan]l u+
Fj pn]haoekj ]h pne]i _ej khkj a l nk` q_a` _ki l hapa bh]ppaj ej c
ej 31" kb l ]peaj po ej pdeo pne]h+ Oa_kcj epekj kb pda ^aj abe_e]h
l kopkl an]per a abba_po d]o ^aaj nal knpa` ^u kpdano ]hok8
dks ar an) i ]hecj ]j p pn]j obkni ]pekj kb n]` e]pekj pna]pa`
gahke` o d]o ^aaj nal knpa` hei epej c epo qoabqhj aoo l ]npe_q*
h]nhu ej ukqj c ej ` er e` q]ho s dk ]na ]p decdan neog kb ` ebbe_qhp
pk i a]oqna h]pa oamqah]a %2/ ). 32). 44*. 46& %Cec+ . 0+. . &+
9XVdaT ) +&) )
%>& Pmq]i kqo _ahh _]n_ej ki ] kb pda ql l an at pnai epu 0- ua]no ]bpan ol kj p]j akqo da]hej c kb pdani ]h ej fqnu kb pda ql l an at pna*
i epu ]j ` n]` e]pekj pdan]l u bkn pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb oar ana dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c+ Qda pqi kn s ]o nai kr a` ]p pda har ah kb pda oql anbe_e]h bhat kn
i qo_hao kb pda bkna]ni %? & ]j ` pda ]ni s ]o naoqnb]_a` s epd ] ol hep*pde_gj aoo ]qpkcn]bp %@&) naoqhpej c ej op]^ha s kqj ` _kr an]ca s epd ckk` d]j `
bqj _pekj %A&+ XOal nej pa` bnki Qna` cap ap ]h+ J ]j ]cai aj p kb pda ]_qpahu ^qnj a` ql l an at pnai epu+ Fj 7 Qdani ]h Fj fqneao+ E]j ` @hej / -- - 8
. 3%/ &7 . 54*/ - 0) s epd l ani eooekj bnki Bhoar ean P_eaj _a+Y

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 0/
8&
FdaVXRP[ GWTaP_h ^U 6 ^] caPRcdaTb
> hpdkqcd i kop _kj pn]_pqnao ]na abba_per ahu pna]pa` ^u ] _ki *
^ej a` l nkcn]i kb l naooqna pdan]l u) oane]h _]opej c) ] j ` ,kn
ol hej pej c) oqnce_]h naha]oa eo j a_aoo]nu bkn nabn]_pknu
haoekj o kn bkn _kj pn]_pqnao s de_d ]na l duoe_]hhu ei l kooe^ha
pk pna]p _kj oanr ]per ahu ^]oa` kj hk_]pekj kn ^u at l koqna kb
r ep]h opnq_pqnao) bkn at ]i l ha auahe` a_pnkl ekj + Pqnce_]h
ej _eoekj ]_nkoo pda hej a kb paj oekj i qop ^a bkhhks a` ^u
s kqj ` _hkoqna pk i ej ei eva na_qnnaj _a+ Pl hep*pde_gj aoo
ogej cn]bpo ]na haoo abba_per a pd]j bqhh*pde_gj aoo cn]bpo
s de_d ]na ej pqnj haoo abba_per a pd]j bh]l o kb hk_]h kn ` eop]j p
peooqao %. 5- & %Cec+ . 0+. / &+ @kj pnkh kb _kj pn]_pekj ]l l a]no
_hkoahu nah]pa` pk ahai aj po kb pda ` ani eo) ]o pda qoa kb gan]*
pej k_upa odaapo d]o ^aaj ]ook_e]pa` s epd n]pao kb _kj pn]_pekj
s de_d naoai ^ha pdkoa ej qj _kr ana` s kqj ` o %. 5. &+ Qk ` ]pa)
l d]ni ]_khkce_ _kj pnkh kb _kj pn]_pekj s epd ej de^epkno kb
oi kkpd i qo_ha kn _knpeokj a d]r a ^aaj qj nas ]n` ej c kn
ei l n]_pe_]h8 dks ar an) j as an ]j pebe^nkpe_ cnks pd b]_pkno
i ]u l nkr e` a j kr ah pdan]l aqpe_ i k` ]hepeao ej pda bqpqna %2- &+
Oa_aj phu) Fj pacn]
]npebe_e]h ` ani eo d]o ^a_ki a pda
benop ` ani ]h
oq^opepqpa ]r ]eh]^ha bkn na_kj opnq_per a
oqncanu+ > hpdkqcd at l aneaj _a s epd pda i ]pane]h eo namqena`
bkn abba_per a qo]ca) ep nal naoaj po ]j kpdan j as i apdk` pk
pna]p oar ana EP_ ]j ` l kooe^hu gahke` o+ J ]j u oi ]hh
opq` eao ]j ` _]oa nal knpo oql l knp epo qpehepu ]o ehhqopn]pa` ej
Cec+ . 0+. 08 dks ar an) h]ncan opq` eao) _kop abba_per aj aoo ]j `
_ki l ]neokj pk kpdan i apdk` o d]o pk ^a _ki l hapa` +
Oa_aj phu) k^fa_per a i a]oqnao kb mq]hepu kb peooqa nacaj an*
]pekj ]bpan Fj pacn]ä na_kj opnq_pekj s kqh` oqccaop pd]p
` ani ]h _ki l he]j _a ]j ` ah]ope_ na_keh eo ^appan pd]p o_]n kn
ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bp na_kj opnq_pekj %. 5/ ). 50&+
9&
?PbTa GWTaP_h ^U ; FR P] S >T[^XSb
Oa_aj phu) > hopan %. 51& d]o ` ao_ne^a` pda qoa kb 252 j i
bh]od h]i l l qhoa` ` ua h]oano bkn oaha_per a l dkpkpdani khuoeo
kb r ]o_qh]n aj ` kpdahe]h _ahho ej EP_+ Cebpu*oar aj pk aecdpu*
pdnaa l an_aj p ei l nkr ai aj p ej oqnb]_a pat pqna i a]oqna*
i aj po ]j ` _hej e_]h _nepane] s epd kj a kn ps k pna]pi aj po
9XVdaT ) +&) *
@kj pnkh kb ^qnj s kqj ` _kj pn]_pqnao ej pda j a_g kb ] 6*ua]n*kh` cenh pna]pa` s epd ] l nar ekqohu peooqa at l ]j ` a` n]` e] h
bkna]ni bnaa bh]l + XCnki Qna` cap ap ]h+ %. &+Y

) 00

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
9XVdaT ) +&) +
Qna]pi aj p kb ]j a]op*Fj ` e]j l ]peaj p s dk ` ar ahkl a` oar ana o_]nnej c kb pda b]_a ]j ` j a_g %> & ]j ` necdp ql l an at pnai epu
%? & ]bpan oqbbanej c ] 2- " ^qi ej fqnu qoej c pda ]npebe_e]h ` ani ]h i ]pnet Fj pacn]à ) l nekn pk oqncanu) 0 s aago ]bpan l h]_ai aj p kb Fj pacn]) ]j `
0 i kj pdo bkhhks ej c oa_kj ` op]ca pdej ol hep pde_gj aoo ` kj kn oepa _kr an]ca+
s ]o _h]ei a` s epd oei eh]n naoqhpo nal knpa` ^u Aeane_gt ap ]h+
%. 52&+ Fj ] j kj n]j ` ki eva` opq` u kb l knpekj o kb i a` e]j
opanj kpki u
o_]n d]hr ao)
oui l pki ]pe_
ei l nkr ai aj p
naoai ^ha` pd]p l nar ekqohu ` ao_ne^a` + Eks ar an) Pdane` ]j
ap ]h+ %. 53& b]eha` pk bej ` oecj ebe_]j p ^aj abep bnki l qhoa`
` ua h]oan pdan]l u ej EP_ ej ^qi l ]peaj po+ Cqnpdan) _]na*
bqhhu ` aoecj a` n]j ` ki eva` pne]ho ej r aopec]pej c i qhpel ha
qj ]j os ana` mqaopekj o ej _hq` ej c pda nkha kb _ki ^ej ]pekj
h]oan pdan]l u ]j ` pda i kop ]l l nkl ne]pa pei ej c ]bpan
ej fqnu ]j ` o_]n bkni ]pekj ]na ej ` e_]pa` %. 51&+
I <<& A8 J C; 4 E@4 6 BG; 8 E4 C<8 F 9BE
; LC8 EGEBC; <6 F6 4 EE4 &
4 ] cXUXQa^ cXR 9PRc^ab2 <9A%P[_WP*Q
P] S <9A%VP\ \ P
Qda at l anei aj p]h pdan]l eao ` eo_qooa` dana ]na kb ps k
^nk]` pul ao7 pdkoa qoej c l haekpnkl e_ _upkgej ao oq_d ]o
pda FCKo) s de_d i ]u ^a at l a_pa` pk ]bba_p oar an]h _ahh
pul ao ]j ` pdaen ]ook_e]pa` l nk_aooao) ]j ` pdkoa p]ncapa`
pk ol a_ebe_ _ki l kj aj po kb pda l ]pdkhkcu) oq_d ]o pda at _ao*
oer a _khh]caj ouj pdaoeo kn ei l ]ena` _khh]caj ` acn]` ]pekj +
Qda FCKo d]r a ^aaj mqepa at paj oer ahu ej r aopec]pa` ej pda
_hej e_ ]j ` s ehh na_aer a i kop ]ppaj pekj dana) ^qp kpdan l koo*
e^ha pdan]l eao oqccaopa` ^u ej oecdpo ej pk pda l ]pdkcaj aoeo
kb EP_ k^p]ej a` l nei ]nehu kn at _hqoer ahu bnki opq` eao [`
h[fda s ehh ]hok ^a ` eo_qooa` +
> j pebe^nkcaj e_ _upkgej ao ej _hq` a pda FCK b]i ehu ]j `
_kj oeop kb pul a F FCKo pd]p ej _hq` a FCK*]hl d] ]j ` FCK*
^ap]) s de_d ]na l nk` q_a` ^u haqgk_upao ]j ` be^nk^h]opo)
naol a_per ahu) ]j ` pul a FF FCK kn FCK*c]i i ] s de_d eo l nk*
` q_a` ^u Q*hui l dk_upao+ Qul a F ]j ` pul a FF FCKo ^ej ` pk
` aopnq_p decd*]bbej epu na_al pkno) l naoaj p kj i kop _ahh pul ao)
s de_d ]na a]_d ]ook_e]pa` s epd ps k punkoej a gej ]oao bnki
pda G]j qo b]i ehu kb gej ]oao %. 54&+ Qdaoa gej ]oao l dkol dkn*
uh]pa _upkl h]oi e_ oecj ]h pn]j o` q_pekj l nkpaej o) s de_d ^ej `
pk U[e*]_pej c ahai aj po) pdana^u aj d]j _ej c kn ej de^epej c pda
pn]j o_nel pekj n]pa kb r ]nekqo caj ao+ Ckn be^nk^h]opo) pdeo ej
pqnj naoqhpo ej ] ` a_na]oa ej pda n]pa kb l nkheban]pekj ]j `
] na` q_a` n]pa kb ouj pdaoeo kb _khh]caj ]j ` be^nkj a_pej +
Qda na` q_pekj kb l nkpaej ouj pdaoeo eo kb l ]npe_qh]n ej pan*
aop ej be^nkl nkheban]per a ` eokn` ano) s dana ]^j kni ]hhu decd
]i kqj po kb B@J l nkpaej l nk` q_pekj ]na _d]n]_paneope_+ >`
h[fda FCK*]hl d] ]j ` c]i i ] d]r a ^aaj odks j pk na` q_a
pda ouj pdaoeo kb _khh]caj ^u j kni ]h ]j ` EP_ be^nk^h]opo
%0/ ). 55&+ Qda na` q_pekj kb i OK> bkn pul a F ]j ` FFF _kh*
h]caj ^u FCK i ]u ^a l ]npe]hhu ]__kqj pa` bkn ^u ] na` q_pekj
ej pda op]^ehepu kb pda i aoo]ca) ]o s ahh ]o ] ` ks j nacqh]pekj
kb j q_ha]n b]_pkn . ) s de_d eo ] l nk_khh]caj caj a*]_per ]pej c
pn]j o_nel pekj b]_pkn %. 56&+ Qda ` ks j nacqh]pekj kb j q_ha]n
b]_pkn . i ]u ]__kqj p bkn pda ` ah]u ej i ]t ei ]h ej de^epekj
kb _khh]caj l nk` q_pekj + Eks ar an) ej ]` ` epekj pk ` a_na]oej c
pda har ah kb pul a F _khh]caj i OK> ) at l koqna pk
FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ha` pk ] na` q_pekj ej l koppn]j oh]pekj ]h du` n*
kt uh]pekj ]j ` ]j ej _na]oa ej pda l nkl knpekj kb j as hu
ouj pdaoeva` _khh]caj s de_d qj ` anckao ej pn]_ahhqh]n ` acn]*
` ]pekj + Ce^nkj a_pej l nk` q_pekj ^u EP_ ]j ` l ]peaj p*i ]p_da`
j kni ]h ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo d]o ]hok ^aaj odks j pk ^a
na` q_a` ^u FCK*]hl d]/ ^ %. - / &+ Fi l knp]j phu) FCK*]hl d]/ ^
` ebbano bnki FCK*c]i i ] ^u ej _na]oej c i OK> ]j ` _khh]*
caj ]oa ]_per epu) s dana]o FCK*c]i i ] ` a_na]oao _khh]caj ]oa

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 01
9XVdaT ) +&) ,
EP_ i ]pqn]pekj kb ] 12*ua]n*kh` i ]ha s dk oqbbana` ] 1- " Q? P> ^qi ]j ` ` ar ahkl a` oar ana EP_ kb b]_a _daop ^]_g ]j `
ql l an at pnai epeao l nekn pk ouopai e_ FCK*]/ ^) 0 i kj pdo ]j ` 3 i kj pdo l kopej fqnu+ %Oal nej pa` bnki Qna` cap ap ]h+ %2- & s epd l ani eooekj bnki
T ehhe]i o # T ehgej o+&
]_per epu+ FCK*]hl d]/ ^) FCK*^ap]) ]j ` FCK*c]i i ] d]r a
]hok ^aaj odks j pk na` q_a pda n]pa ]j ` at paj p kb CM@I
_kj pn]_pekj ) s de_d i ]u ]_p pdnkqcd ] na` q_pekj ej ^ap]
]j ` c]i i ]*_upkl h]oi e_ ]_pej l nk` q_pekj kn ]hpan]pekj o
ej pda bqj _pekj ]h ej pan]_pekj o kb ]_pej i e_nkbeh]i aj po ]j `
pdaen ]ook_e]pa` l nkpaej o %. 03&+
Roej c i qnej a s kqj ` da]hej c i k` aho) Dn]j opaej ap ]h+
%. 6- & s ana ]^ha pk ` ai kj opn]pa [` h[ha pd]p FCK*c]i i ]
` a_na]oa` hk_]h s kqj ` anupdai ]) j aqpnkl deh ej behpn]pekj
]j ` _khh]caj ` al koepekj ]j ` ej de^epa` pda be^nkpe_ na]_pekj
pk ei l h]j pa` bknaecj ^k` eao %. 6. &+ Fj pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj o
kb FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ej pk ] gahke` naoqhpa` ej ] cn]` q]h na` q_pekj
ej oeva) ]o ` e` FCK*c]i i ] s daj ej fa_pa` ej pk gahke` o) EP_)
]j ` Aql upnaj o ` eoa]oa j k` qhao+ J _@]qhau ap ]h+ %. 6/ & d]r a
oqccaopa` pd]p gahke` l ]peaj po d]r a ` abe_eaj p ouopai e_ l nk*
` q_pekj kb FCK*]hl d] ]j ` FCK*c]i i ]) s de_d i ]u _kj pne^*
qpa pk pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb pdaoa haoekj o ]j ` l nkr e` a ]
pdaknape_]h ^]oeo bkn pda l nkr eoekj +
> o ` eo_qooa` a]nhean) ]hpan]pekj o ej B@J _ki l kj aj po ]na
^ahear a` pk ^a naol kj oe^ha bkn pda qj ` aoen]^ha l duoe_]h
l nkl anpeao kb be^nkpe_ o_]n peooqa+ T a d]r a bkqj ` pd]p
at l naooekj kb i OK> bkn oar an]h B@J i ]_nki kha_qhao eo
]hpana` ej be^nk^h]opo ` aner a` bnki EP_) _ki l ]na` pk
j kni ]h _ahho k^p]ej a` bnki pda o]i a l ]peaj po+ Qda ` ebbanaj *
pe]h ouj pdaoeo kb _khh]caj ]j ` _khh]caj ]oa ej l kop^qnj EP_
]l l a]no pk ^a kj a kb pda i ]ej na]okj o bkn pda at _aooer a
]__qi qh]pekj kb _khh]caj + Qda ej panbankj o d]r a ^aaj
bkqj ` pk j kni ]heva pda at l naooekj kb B@J l nkpaej o ^u
` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo ` aner a` bnki be^nkpe_ peooqa+ FCK*c]i i ]
eo oa_napa` ^u ]_per ]pa` Q*hui l dk_upao) s dana]o FCK*]hl d]
]j ` *^ap] ]na pda l nk` q_po kb haqgk_upao ]j ` be^nk^h]opo)
naol a_per ahu %. 60&+ Par an]h [` h[fda opq` eao d]r a odks j
^kpd FCK*c]i i ] ]j ` FCK*]hl d]/ ^ pk na` q_a pda at l naooekj
kb pul a F ]j ` pk ] haooan at paj p pul a FFF l nk_khh]caj i OK>
ej ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo %2- )32&+ T a d]r a bqnpdan odks j pd]p
FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ej _na]oao pda at l naooekj kb _khh]caj ]oa ^u

) 1(

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo) s dana]o FCK*c]i i ] ` kao j kp %3/ &+ Qdeo
oqccaopo pd]p FCK*]hl d]/ ^ _kqh` d]r a oki a ]` r ]j p]cao
kr an FCK*c]i i ] bkn pda pna]pi aj p kb CMA) oq_d ]o
l kop^qnj EP_+ > j ei ]h opq` eao d]r a odks j pd]p FCK*
]hl d]/ ^ _]j i k` qh]pa s kqj ` da]hej c [` h[ha %. 61&+ Pki a
l nahei ej ]nu _hej e_]h pne]ho qoej c FCKo ej l ]peaj po s epd
gahke` ]j ` l kop^qnj EP_ d]r a ^aaj nal knpa` + Hahke`
l ]peaj po pna]pa` s epd FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ` ai kj opn]pa` kj hu
hei epa` ei l nkr ai aj p kr an j kj pna]pa` l ]peaj po %. 62). 63&
^qp a]nhu pne]ho ej l kop^qnj EP_ l ]peaj po oaai l nki eoej c
%2- &+ Puopai e_ ]` i ej eopn]pekj kb FCK*]hl d]/ ^ s ]o ]ook_e*
]pa` s epd na` q_pekj ej ahar ]pa` har aho kb oanqi QDC*^ap]
]j ` l h]oi ] deop]i ej a har aho+ Fj ]` ` epekj ) EP_ peooqao
` ai kj opn]pa` a]nhean na` q_pekj ej pda ahar ]pa` har aho kb
i OK> bkn QDC*^ap] s epd FCK pdan]l u) s de_d s ]o ` qa ej
l ]np pk ] na` q_pekj ej pda ]qpk_nej a l nk` q_pekj kb QDC*
^ap] ^u be^nk^h]opo l naoaj p ej pda peooqao %00&+ Fj l ]peaj po
pna]pa` s epd FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ]p ` koao i ei e_gej c pda ej epe]pej c
nacei ao bkn dal ]pepeo ? l ]peaj po) r eoe^ha ei l nkr ai aj p ej
o_]n i ]pqn]pekj eo l kooe^ha ]o s ahh ]o i kna k^fa_per a ar e*
` aj _a oq_d ]o na` q_pekj ej o_]n r khqi a) ei l nkr ai aj p ej
o_]n n]pej c) pkcapdan s epd j kni ]hev]pekj kb ahar ]pa` deop]*
i ej a ]j ` QDC*^ap] ej pda ouopai e_ _en_qh]pekj %Ceco+
. 0+. / ]j ` . 0+. 0&+ Eks ar an) h]ncan j qi ^ano kb l ]peaj po ej
` kq^ha*^hej ` a` n]j ` ki eva` pne]ho ]na namqena` pk aop]^heod
ouopai e_ _upkgej a pdan]l u bkn oar ana CMA oq_d ]o EP_
]j ` gahke` o+ Pq_d pne]ho d]r a ^acqj bkn ouopai e_ o_hankoeo)
l qhi kj ]nu be^nkoeo) ]j ` l kop^qnj EP_+
Eks ar an) pdana ]na l n]_pe_]h ` n]s ^]_go pk pda ouopai e_
kn ej pn]haoekj ]h ]` i ej eopn]pekj kb FCK*]hl d]/ ^+ Cenop) ouo*
pai e_ ]` i ej eopn]pekj eo j kp oqep]^ha bkn _deh` naj ` qa pk pda
j a_aooepu bkn bnamqaj p ej pn]` ani ]h kn ej pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj o+
Pa_kj ` ) ej kqn _hej e_]h pne]h ber a kb j ej a l ]peaj po pna]pa`
s epd FCK*]hl d]/ ^ at l aneaj _a` bhq*hega oui l pki o ej _hq` ej c
b]pecqa) j ]qoa]) da]` ]_da) ]j ` hks *cn]` a bar an %2&+ Cej ]hhu)
h]nca mq]j pepeao kb FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ]na namqena` i ]gej c pna]p*
i aj p i k` an]pahu at l aj oer a+ Kkni ]hhu) pkl e_]h ]` i ej eo*
pn]pekj kb FCK*]hl d]/ ^ ej okhqpekj eo j kp abba_per a ^a_]qoa
pda bnaa _upkgej a ` kao j kp l aj apn]pa pda al e` ani eo abbe*
_eaj phu+ Qkl e_]h ]l l he_]pekj kb hel koki a*]ook_e]pa` FCK*
]hl d]/ ^ _kqh` _en_qi r aj p i ]j u kb pdaoa l nk^hai o) ej _hq` *
ej c pda ]` r anoa oe` a*abba_po ^a_]qoa pda mq]j pepu namqena`
odkqh` ^a oecj ebe_]j phu haoo %pdkqo]j ` o kb qj epo n]pdan pd]j
i ehhekj o& pd]j s daj ]` i ej eopana` ouopai e_]hhu+ I el koki ao
s epd FCK*]hl d] d]r a ^aaj qoa` oq__aoobqhhu bkn pna]pi aj p
kb _qp]j akqo danl ao oei l hat ej cqej a] l eco %. 64&+ I el k*
oki a*]ook_e]pa` FCK*]hl d]/ ^ nap]ej o epo abba_per aj aoo ej
i k` qh]pej c _khh]caj ouj pdaoeo ^u _qhpqna` be^nk^h]opo
%. 65& ]j ` ej ogej s kqj ` o ej cqej a] l eco %. . 4&+
5&
BcWTa 4 ] cPV^] Xbcb ^U G: 9%QTcP
Qda ]^oaj _a kb ` a_knej bnki da]hej c ^qnj s kqj ` o %. . &
_kqh` d]r a l nkbkqj ` ei l he_]pekj o bkn pda ` ar ahkl i aj p
kb EP_) ^kpd ^a_]qoa kb epo nkha ej l nki kpej c
j kni ]h be^nkqo peooqa ]n_depa_pqna %. 5& ]j ` ^a_]qoa ep
i ]u bqj _pekj ]o ] j ]pqn]h nacqh]pkn %]j p]ckj eop& kb
QDC*^ap] %/ - &+ Pej _a i ]pqna l kop^qi o_]no _kj p]ej
j kni ]h ]i kqj po kb pdeo l nkpankchu_]j %. . & ]j ` op]ej
opnkj chu bkn QDC*^ap] %. 5&) ]j ` oej _a ep eo i ]ooer ahu na*
at l naooa` ej EP_ op]npej c ]^kqp . / i kj pdo ]bpan ej fqnu
%4&) ` a_knej _kqh` ^a oqccaopa` ]o ] pdan]l u) eb oqep]^ha
` aher anu r ade_hao bkn pda l nkpaej epoahb kn epo caj a _]j ^a
` ar eoa` + ? kpd ej pn]i qo_qh]n ej fa_pekj %. - - & ]j ` ouj pdaoeo
bnki ]j at l naooekj r a_pkn %. 66& d]r a ^aaj ` ai kj opn]pa`
pk ^a abba_per a ej _kqj pan]_pej c pda be^nkpe_ _d]j cao
i a` e]pa` ^u QDC*^ap] . ej at l anei aj p]h chki anqhkj al dne*
peo ej n]po+
Qda h]paj _u*]ook_e]pa` l al pe` a kb pda oi ]hh h]paj p QDC*
^ap] _ki l hat _]nneao pdnaa K*hej ga` khecko]__d]ne` ao) ps k
kb s de_d d]r a i ]j j koa*3*l dkol d]pa %J 3M& naoe` qao
%/ - - &+ Qdaoa i a` e]pa pda ]pp]_di aj p kb QDC*^ap] . pk pda
J 3M,FDC*FF na_al pkn %J 3M,FDC*FF& %/ - . &+ Qda ]_per ]pekj
kb h]paj p QDC*^ap] .
ej _k_qhpqnao kb ^kr ej a ]knpe_
aj ` kpdahe]h ]j ` oi kkpd i qo_ha _ahho _]j ^a ^hk_ga` ^u
J 3M) l naoqi ]^hu ^u ej panbanej c s epd pdeo ]ook_e]pekj
%/ - . &+ > hpdkqcd pda l na_eoa i a_d]j eoi ^u s de_d
^ej ` ej c pk pda J 3M,FDC*FF na_al pkn l nki kpao ]_per ]pekj
kb QDC*^ap] eo j kp gj ks j ) pdaoa k^oanr ]pekj o d]r a
opei qh]pa` ej panaop ej pda qoa kb J 3M pk l nar aj p
o_]nnej c %/ - / &+
Lpdan l d]ni ]_khkce_ ]caj po ` ar ahkl a` ]j ` ]l l hea`
ej epe]hhu bkhhks ej c ] ` ebbanaj p n]pekj ]ha i ]u at anp oki a kb
pdaen ]_per epu ` ena_phu kn ej ` ena_phu pdnkqcd abba_po kj
QDC*^ap] at l naooekj kn ]_per epu+ Qn]j eh]op w4S*%0)1*
` ei apdkt u_ej j ]i kuh& ]j pdn]j ehe_ ]_e` Y) ]j ]j pe*]hhance_
` nqc pd]p d]o ^aaj ]l l hea` pk pda pna]pi aj p kb EP_ ]j `
gahke` o %/ - 0&) _]j ej de^ep pda naha]oa kb QDC*^ap]h ]j `
kpdan _upkgej ao bnki dqi ]j i kj k_upao,i ]_nkl d]cao
%/ - 1&+ > _nkoo*hej ga` i et pqna kb pul a F _khh]caj ]j `
l khur ej uhl unnkhe` kj a
%ëCe^nkmqahí &)
ej fa_pa`
ej pn]*
haoekj ]hhu ej pk EP_) na` q_a` ei i qj kop]ej ej c kb pda
pna]pa` peooqa bkn FI *h^ap] ) QKC*]hl d]) ]j ` MADC ]j `
oa_napekj kb QDC*^ap] h ]j ` MADC ^u be^nk^h]opo _qhpqna`
bnki ep %/ - 2&+
6 &
@^Sd[Pc^ab ^U 9XQa^Q[Pbc%@TSXPcTS
86 @ @TcPQ^[Xb\
S ]nekqo opn]paceao d]r a ^aaj l nkl koa` ) ]j ` oki a paopa` ej
pda _hej e_) pk ej _na]oa pda n]pa kb pqnj kr an kb pda o_]n _kh*
h]caj pdnkqcd ej _na]oa` oa_napekj kb _khh]caj ]oa ^u pda
be^nk^h]opo+ Qdaoa ej _hq` a pna]pi aj p s epd MD Bh ]j ` PJ *
. - 6- 3 %pda ouj pdape_ ]j ]hkc kb MDF& %/ - 3)/ - 4&) nah]t ej
%/ - 5&) ]j ` _]h_eqi _d]j j ah ^hk_gano oq_d ]o r an]l ]i eh
%/ - 6&+ Mnaoqi ]^hu ]_pej c ^u ] _ki l hapahu ` ebbanaj p
i a_d]j eoi ) eo l qpnao_ej a %ëCe^nkop]pí &) ]j ej de^epkn kb
pda pn]j ochqp]i ej ]oa*i a` e]pa` _nkoo*hej gej c kb pul a FFF

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 1)
_khh]caj pd]p d]o ^aaj paopa` s epd oki a ]l l ]naj p oq__aoo ej
pda _hej e_ %/ . - &+
I <<<& FH@@4 EL
Qda l ]pdkcaj aoeo kb EP_ bkhhks ej c pdani ]h ej fqnu nai ]ej o
] _ki l hat ]j ` ej _ki l hapahu qj ` anopkk` l nk_aoo) ^qp
na_aj p ej r aopec]pekj o ej pk pda _ki l koepekj kb pda peooqa
epoahb) pda ]_per epeao kb pda o_]n be^nk^h]opo ]j ` pda abba_po
kb r ]nekqo _upkgej ao ]j ` cnks pd b]_pkno) d]r a ]hh _kj pne^*
qpa` pk pda ai ancaj _a kb ]j ej _na]oej chu _ha]n l e_pqna+
> hpdkqcd ep i ]u ^a _kj oe` ana` fqop kj a at ]i l ha kb ]
^nk]` n]j ca kb CMAo s de_d ]bbhe_p i ]j u ` ebbanaj p knc]j o)
kbpaj ej naol kj oa pk ` er anoa aj r enkj i aj p]h ej oqhpo) pda
j ]pqna kb pda ^qi ej fqnu ]j ` pda ol a_e]h l nkl anpeao kb
ogej l nk^]^hu l h]u ei l knp]j p nkhao ej l nki kpej c pda ` ar ah*
kl i aj p kb pdeo aol a_e]hhu pnkq^haoki a r ]neapu kb at _aooer a
_kj j a_per a peooqa+ Qdeo gj ks ha` ca d]o l nkr e` a` pda n] pekj *
]ha bkn ] j qi ^an kb at l anei aj p]h pdan]l eao pd]p) ej ` er e` q*
]hhu kn ej oki a _ki ^ej ]pekj ) i ]u ]qci aj p kn kj a ` ]u
oql l h]j p pda i kna _ki i kj hu ai l hkua` oqnce_]h kn l duo*
e_]h pna]pi aj po+
E898E8A6 8F
.+
Qna` cap BB) Ka` aha_ ? ) P_kpp MD) Dd]d]nu > + E ul an*
pnkl de_ o_]no) gahke` o) ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao+ Qda _ahhqh]n ]j `
i kha_qh]n ^]oeo bkn pdan]l u+ Pqnc @hej Kknpd > i . 6648
44%0&74- . *40- +
/ +
I ej ]nao E> ) Heo_dan @T ) Ak^ngkr ogu J ) I ]nokj AI +
Qda deopekpul e_ knc]j ev]pekj kb pda dul anpnkl de_ o_]n ej
dqi ]j o+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 64/ 8 26%1&70/ 0ê 00. +
0+
Heo_dan @T + @khh]caj ]j ` ` ani ]h l ]ppanj o ej pda dul an*
pnkl de_ o_]n+ > j ]p Oa_ . 6418 . 46%. &7 . 04*. 12+
1+
Heo_dan @T + Ce^nk^h]opo kb pda dul anpnkl de_ o_]n) i ]pqna
o_]n ]j ` j kni ]h ogej 7 ] opq` u ^u o_]j j ej c ]j ` pn]j o*
i eooekj aha_pnkj i e_nko_kl u+ Qat Oal ? ekh J a` . 6418
0/ %0*1&7366*4- 6+
2+
Qna` cap BB) Pdaj VG) Cknoupd K) Pi epd @) P_kpp M)
Dd]d]nu >+ Oacqh]pekj kb _khh]caj ouj pdaoeo ]j ` i OK>
har aho ej j kni ]h ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n be^nk^h]opo ej
r epnk ^u ej panbankj ]hl d]*/ ^+ T kqj ` Oal ]en Oacaj . 6608
. 7. 23*. 32+
3+
Bdnhe_d EM) T depa ? P+ Qda e` aj pebe_]pekj kb ]hl d] > ]j `
]hl d] ? _khh]caj _d]ej o ej dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+ Bt l J kh
M]pdkh . 65. 8 01%h&7h*5+
4+
P]u]j e H) Ak` ` @J ) Ka` aha_ ? ) Pdaj VG) Dd]d]nu >)
Qna` cap BB) P_kpp MD+ Aah]ua` ]l l a]n]j _a kb ` a_knej ej
da]hej c ^qnj o_]no+ E eopkl ]pdkhkcu / - - - 8 03%0&7/ 3/ */ 4/ +
5+
? ]qn MP) I ]nokj AI ) Pp]_au QO+ Qda k^oanr ]pekj kb i uk*
be^nk^h]opo ej dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ Pqnc Duj a_kh L^opap
. 6428 . 1. %h&7/ / */ 3+
6+
Bdnhe_d EM) Aaoi kqheana > ) Aeacahi ]j j OC) @kdaj FH)
@ki l pkj @@) D]i an T I ) H]l ]j _e V) D]^^e]j e D+ J kn*
l dkhkce_]h ]j ` ei i qj k_dai e_]h ` ebbanaj _ao ^aps aaj
gahke` ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+ > i G M]pdkh . 6618
. 12%. &7 . -2 ê . . 0+
. -+
Heo_dan @T ) ? ]ehau GC+ Qda i ]op _ahh ej dul anpnkl de_
o_]no+ Qat Oal ? ekh J a` . 64/ 8 0- %1&70/ 4*005+
. . +
P_kpp MD)
Ak` ` @J )
Qna` cap BB)
Dd]d]nu > )
O]dai pqhh] C+ @dai e_]h _d]n]_panev]pekj ]j ` mq]j pebe*
_]pekj kb l nkpakchu_]j o ej dqi ]j l kop*^qi dul anpnkl de_
]j ` i ]pqna o_]no+ @hej P_e %I kj ` & . 6638 6- %2&71. 4*1/ 2+
. / +
E ]u]g]s ] Q) E ]odei kpk V) J ukgae V) > ku]i ] E)
Fv]s ] V+ @d]j cao ej pul a kb _khh]caj ` qnej c pda ` ar ahkl *
i aj p kb dqi ]j l kop*^qnj dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ @hej @dei
> _p] . 6468 60%. &7 . . 6*. / 2+
. 0+
? ]ehau > G) ? ]vej P) Pei o QG) I a I kqo J ) Ke_khapeo @)
Aah] qj ]u >+ @d]n]_panev]pekj kb pda _khh]caj kb dqi ]j
dul anpnkl de_ ]j ` j kni ]h o_]no+ ? ek_dei ? ekl duo > _p]
. 6428 1- 2%/ &71. / *1/ . +
. 1+ Lcopkj >+ @dai eopnu ]j ` J kha_qh]n ? ekhkcu kb pda Fj pn] *
_ahhqh]n J ]pnet + Kas Vkng7 > _]` ai e_ Mnaoo) . 64- +
. 2+ P_kpp G+ Mnkpakchu_]j *be^ehh]n _khh]caj ej pan]_pekj o ej
peooqao7 ` ani ]p]j oqhl d]pa l nkpakchu_]j ]o ] peooqa knc]j e*
van+ Fj 7 P_kpp G) a` + Aani ]p]j Pqhl d]pa Mnkpakchu_]j o7
@dai eopnu) ? ekhkcu) @dai e_]h M]pdkhkcu+ I kj ` kj 7 Mknp*
h]j ` Mnaoo) . 660732+
. 3+ Vak QH) ? nks j I ) Ar kn]g EC+ > hpan]pekj o ej l nkpakchu*
_]j ouj pdaoeo _ki i kj pk da]hej c s kqj ` o ]j ` pqi kno+
> i G M]pdkh . 66. 8 . 05%3&7. 104*. 12- +
. 4+
Hq_ FJ ) P_kpp MD+ Fj _na]oa` ` e] i apano kb _khh]caj be^neho
l na_el ep]pa` ej r epnk ej pda l naoaj _a kb ` a_knej bnki
r ]nekqo _kj j a_per a peooqao+ @kj j a_p Qeooqa Oao . 6648
03%1&7/ 54*/ 63+
. 5+
P_kpp MD) Ak` ` @J ) Qna` cap BB) Dd]d]nu > ) O]dai pqhh] C+
Fi i qj kdeopk_dai e_]h hk_]hev]pekj kb pda l nkpakchu_]j o
` a_knej ) ^echu_]j ]j ` r anoe_]j ]j ` pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn*^ap] ej dqi ]j l kop*^qnj dul anpnkl de_ ]j ` i ]pqna
o_]no+ Eeopkl ]pdkhkcu . 6628 / 3%2&71/ 0*10. +
. 6+ A]j eahokj HD) ? ]ne^]qhp E) E khi ao AC) Dn]d]i E)
H]` han HB) Fkvvk OS + Q]ncapa` ` eonql pekj kb ` a_knej
ha]` o pk ]^j kni ]h _khh]caj be^neh i knl dkhkcu ]j ` ogej bn] *
cehepu+ G @ahh ? ekh . 6648 . 03%0&74/ 6*410+
/ - +
V]i ]cq_de V) J ]j j AJ ) Oqkoh]dpe B+ Kac]per a nacq*
h]pekj kb pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ^u pda l nkpak*
chu_]j ` a_knej + K]pqna . 66- 8 013%3/ 5. &7/ 5. */ 51+
/ . + Hq_ FJ ) P_kpp MD+ Rhpn]opnq_pqna kb pda ^kr ej a pai l *
knki ]j ` e^qh]n fkej p
` eo_+
> n_d
Ln]h
? ekh
. 6618
06%. &724*3. +
/ / + Pdaph]n J O) Pdaph]n @I + Qda dul anpnkl de_ o_]n7 hk_]pekj kb
chu_ko]i ej kchu_]j o s epdej o_]no+ ? qnj o . 6448 17. 1*/ 6+
/ 0+ ? e]j _k M) Ceodan I T ) Vkqj c J C) Qani ej a GA) Ok^au MD+
Bt l naooekj ]j ` hk_]hev]pekj kb pda ps k oi ]hh l nkpakchu*
_]j o ^echu_]j ]j ` ` a_knej ej ` ar ahkl ej c dqi ]j ogahap]h
]j ` j kj *ogahap]h peooqao+ G E eopk_dai @upk_dai . 66- 8
05% . . &7 . 216ê . 230+
/ 1+ Dd]d]nu > ) M]j j q O) Qna` cap BB+ Ce^nkcaj e_ ]j ` ]j pebe*
^nkcaj e_ b]_pkno nacqh] pej c pda at pn]_ahhqh]n i ]pnet ej
s kqj ` nal ]en+ Fj 7 J ]hdkpn] PH) a` + > ` r ]j _ao ej Ppnq_pqn]h
? ekhkcu+ I kj ` kj 7 G> F Mnaoo) . 6637. 64*/ 0/ +
/ 2+ Wdkq I G) Fj kqa J ) Lj k F) H]j agk C+ Qda i k` a kb ]_pekj
kb l nkop]ch]j ` ej %MD& FF ]j ]hkc) PJ *. - 6- 3) kj be^nk^h]opo
kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no eo oei eh]n pk MDB. ej epo l kpaj pe]h

) 1*

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
nkha kb l nar aj pej c o_]n bkni ]pekj + Bt l Aani ]pkh . 6648
3%3&70. 1*0/ - +
/ 3+
P_kpp MD) Dd]d]nu > ) @d]i ^ano J ) Qna` cap BB+ ? ekhkce*
_]h ^]oeo kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c+ Fj 7 J ]hdkpn] PH) a` +
> ` r ]j _ao ej Ppnq_pqn]h ? ekhkcu+ I kj ` kj 7 G> F Mnaoo Fj _)
. 6617. 24*/ - . +
/ 4+
Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) Ka` aha_ ? ) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Fj panbankj o c]i i ] ]j ` ]hl d]*/ ^ ` ebbai pe]hhu nacqh]pa
pda at l naooekj kb _khh]caj ]oa ]j ` peooqa ej de^epkn kb i ap]h*
hkl nkpaej ]oa*. i aooaj can OK> ej dqi ]j o dul anpnkl de_
]j ` j kni ]h ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+ T kqj ` Oal ]en Oacaj
. 6628 07. 43*. 51+
/ 5+
> n]g]s ] J ) E ]p]i k_de > ) J kne V) J kne H) Rage E)
J knecq_de Q+ Oa` q_a` _khh]caj ]oa caj a at l naooekj ej
be^nk^h]opo bnki dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqa+ ? n G Aani ]pkh
. 6638 . 01%2&7530*535+
/ 6+ T ]j c O) Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Kepne_ kt e` a ouj pd]oa at l naooekj ]j ` j epne_ kt e` a l nk*
` q_pekj ]na na` q_a` ej dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqa ]j ` be^nk*
^h]opo+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6648 . - 5%1&7105*111+
0-+
P_dkj dann B) ? a]r ]j I > ) E ]qooan E) Hnaooa E) @qhl I > +
Aebbanaj _ao ej ` a_knej at l naooekj ^u l ]l ehh]nu ]j `
nape_qh]n be^nk^h]opo ej r er k ]j ` ej r epnk+ ? ek_dai G
. 6608 / 6- %Mp 0&7560*566+
0. +
Dd]d]nu > ) P_kpp MD) J ]hdkpn] P ap ]h+ Aebbanaj pe]h
at l naooekj kb pul a F ]j ` pul a FFF l nk_khh]caj i OK> ej
dqi ]j dul anpnkl de_ ^qi be^nk^h]opo+ ? eki a` I app . 66/ 8
147. 36*. 51+
0/ + Qna` cap BB) Cknoupd K) Rfe*Cnea` h]j ` > ) @d]i ^ano J )
Dd]d]nu > ) P_kpp MD) Ekcc > J ) ? qnga GC+ D]o _dnki ]pk*
cn]l du*i ]oo ol a_pnki apnu ` apani ej ]pekj kb . 5- / ej . 5- *
h] ^ahha` 1*du` nkt ul nkhej a bkn i a]oqnai aj p kb _khh]caj
ouj pdaoeo ]j ` ej pn]_ahhqh]n ` acn]` ]pekj + G @dnki ]pkcn
. 6608 3. / %. &74ê . 6+
00+
Qna` cap BB) T ]j c O) Pdaj N) P_kpp MD) Dd]d]nu > +
Qn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] i OK> ]j ` l nkpaej ej
dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqao ]j ` be^nk^h]opo7 ]j p]ckj eoi ^u
FCK*]hl d] ]j ` FCK*c]i i ] ej r epnk ]j ` ej r er k+ G Fj pan*
bankj @upkgej a Oao / - - - 8 / - %/ &7 . 10*. 2. +
01+ T ]j c O) Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Eqi ]j ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo l nk` q_a j epne_ kt e` a ]j `
at l naoo ^kpd _kj opepqper a ]j ` ej ` q_e^ha j epne_ kt e` a ouj pd]oa
eokbkni o+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6638 . - 3%0&71. 6*1/ 4+
02+ P]r ]ca H) Ps ]j j A> + > _ki l ]neokj kb chu_ko]i ej k*
chu_]j ouj pdaoeo ^u dqi ]j be^nk^h]opo bnki j kni ]h ogej )
j kni ]h o_]n) ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh
. 6528 51%3&72/ . *2/ 3+
03+ P_kpp MD) Ak` ` @J ) Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) Qna` cap BB+
Ce^nk^h]opo bnki l kop*^qi dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqa ouj *
pdaoeva haoo ` a_knej pd]j j kni ]h ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+ @hej
P_e %I kj ` & . 6658 61%2&721. *214+
04+ Heo_dan @T ) T ]cj an EK Gn) Mej ` qn G) Ekhq^a_ E)
Gkj ao J ) Rhnae_d G? ) P_q` ane M+ Fj _na]oa` be^nkj a_pej l nk*
` q_pekj ^u _ahh hej ao bnki dul anpnkl de_ o_]n ]j ` gahke` +
@kj j a_p Qeooqa Oao . 6568 / 0%1&7/ 46*/ 55+
05+ Lgq Q) Q]gec]s ] J ) Cqg]i evq E) Fj kqa H) V]i ]` ] J +
Dnks pd gej ape_o kb be^nk^h]opo ` aner a` bnki j kni ]h ogej
]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+ > _p] Aani S aj anakh . 6548
34%3&72/ 3*2/ 5+
06+ Ka` aha_ ? ) Pd]j gks ogu E) P_kpp MD) Dd]d]nu >)
Qna` cap BB+ J ukbe^nk^h]opo ]j ` ]l kl pkoeo ej dqi ]j
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no7 pda abba_p kb ej panbankj *]hl d]/ ^+
Pqncanu / - - . 8 . 0- %2&7465*5- 5+
1- + Aaoi kqheana > ) Oa` ]n` J ) A]n^u F) D]^^e]j e D+ > l kl pk*
oeo i a` e]pao pda ` a_na]oa ej _ahhqh]nepu ` qnej c pda pn]j *
oepekj ^aps aaj cn]j qh]pekj peooqa ]j ` o_]n+ > i G M]pdkh
. 6628 . 13%h&723*33+
1. + Lnnaj eqo P+ > l kl pkoeo7 i kha_qh]n i a_d]j eoi o ]j `
ei l he_]pekj o bkn dqi ]j ` eoa]oa+ G Fj panj J a` . 6628
/ 04%3&72/ 6*203+
1/ +
T ]ooani ]j j OG) Mkhk J ) Pi epd M) T ]j c U) Hk C)
Ok^okj J @+ Aebbanaj pe]h l nk` q_pekj kb ]l kl pkoeo*
i k` qh]pej c l nkpaej o ej l ]peaj po s epd dul anpnkl de_ ^qi
o_]n+ G Pqnc Oao . 6658 42%h&741*5- +
10+
J a]can > + @upkgej ao+ Bj chas kk` @hebbo) KG7 Mnaj pe_a*
E]hh) . 66. +
11+
I ]opan PJ ) T kk` GD) Dkk` ej c I O+ Qqi kn j a_nkoeo b]_pkn
_]j ej ` q_a ^kpd ]l kl pe_ ]j ` j a_nkpe_ bkni o kb _ahh huoeo+
G Fi i qj kh . 6558 . 1. %5&7/ 3/ 6*/ 301+
12+
@]op]cj khe @) Ppahh] J ) ? anpdk` @) J ]che]_]j e D)
Oe_de]n` e MJ + QKC l nk` q_pekj ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c+
@ahh Fi i qj kh . 6608 . 14%h&72. *30+
13+
P_dqhpv DP) T depa J ) J ep_dahh O) ? nks j D) I uj _d G)
Qs ]n` veg AO) Qk` ]nk DG+ Bl epdahe]h s kqj ` da]hej c
aj d]j _a` ^u pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*]hl d] ]j ` r ]__e*
j e] cnks pd b]_pkn+ P_eaj _a . 6548 / 02%1453&702- *02/ +
14+
? nqj a ? ) r kj Hj apdaj > ) P]j ` ]q H? + Kepne_ kt e` a ]j `
epo nkha ej ]l kl pkoeo+ Bqn G Md]ni ]_kh . 6658 02. %0&7
/ 3. */ 4/ +
15+
> h^ej ] GB) @qe P) J ]pak O? ) Oae_dj an GP+ Kepne_ kt e` a*
i a` e]pa` ]l kl pkoeo ej i qnej a l anepkj a]h i ]_nkl d]cao+
G Fi i qj kh . 6608 . 2- %. . &72- 5- *2- 52+
16+
@daoj au G) ? q_]h] O+ Manel dan]h ^hkk` be^nk_upao7
i aoaj _dui ]h l na_qnokn _ahho ]j ` pda l ]pdkcaj aoeo kb
be^nkoeo+ @qnn Odaqi ]pkh Oal / - - - 8 / %3&72- . *2- 2+
2- +
Qna` cap BB) Pd]j gks ogu E> ) M]j j q O) Ka` aha_ ? )
Fs ]odej ] Q) Dd]n]nu > ) Q]anqi QS ) P_kpp MD+ Qn]j obkni *
ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ej pdani ]hhu ej fqna` l ]peaj po s epd
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no7 abba_po kb ej panbankj ]hl d]*/ ^+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc
. 6658
. - / %2&7 . 0. 4*. 0/ 58 ` eo_qooekj
. 0/ 6*. 00- +
2. +
Bj cn]r I E) @kr au J E) Aqp_dan HA) Eaei ^]_d AJ )
T ]hgej od]s J A) J ]nr ej G> + Fi l ]eni aj p) pei a kqp kb
o_dkkh) ]j ` pei a kbb bnki s kng ]bpan ^qi o+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn
Pqnc . 6548 46%3&76/ 4*601+
2/ +
Bj d]i na > ) E ]i i ]n E+ Qna]pi aj p kb gahke` o s epd at _e*
oekj ]j ` l kopkl an]per a U*n]u enn]` e]pekj + Aani ]pkhkce_]
. 6508 . 34%/ &76- *60+
20+
> nkn] MA) J _@qhhk_d @> + Aal aj ` aj _a kb _khh]caj nai k*
` ahej c kj ]hl d]*oi kkpd i qo_ha ]_pej at l naooekj ^u be^nk*
^h]opo+ G @ahh Mduoekh . 6618 . 26%. &7 . 3. *. 42+
21+
C]gdn]e E) Akneck L) Pd]s han AI ) I ej E) J an_kh] A)
? h]_g HI ) Okuopkj F) Pk^kh OB+ Bn]` e_]pekj kb aop]^heoda`
ej pn]_n]j e]h n]p cheki ]o ^u pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap]
]j peoaj oa caj a pdan]l u+ Mnk_ K]ph > _]` P_e RP> . 6638
60%4&7/ 6- 6*/ 6. 1+
22+
C]nmqd]n G+ Pehe_kj a cah ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n bkni ]pekj 7 ]
hepan]pqna nar eas + @]j G L __ql Qdan . 66/ 8 26745+

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 1+
23+
Pmqean @> + Qda abba_p kb opnap_dej c kj bkni ]pekj kb i uk*
be^nk^h]opo ej i kqoa ogej + @ahh Qeooqa Oao . 65. 8
/ / - %/ &70/ 2*002+
24+
I a]r epp G) Dqj j ej c M) Ha` ao I ) G]nes ]hh] O+ Pi kkpd
i qo_ha ]hl d]*]_pekj eo ] pn]j obkni ]pekj *oaj oeper a i ]ngan
bkn i kqoa KFE 0Q0 ]j ` O]p*/ _ahho+ K]pqna . 6528
0. 3%3- 0. &7 51- * 51/ +
25+
Cancqokj J T + Pgej s kqj ` da]hej c7 pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn ^ap] ]j p]ckj eopo ` a_na]oa o_]nnej c ]j ` ei l nkr a
mq]hepu+ G Fj panbankj Oao . 6618 . 1%2&70- 0*0- 1+
26+
Ckn` I @) Hej c AC) I ]c]ooa I A) Kas _ki an S + Fj _na]oa`
]j ` nkcaj ^ej ` ej c ej gahke` o7 ] l nahei ej ]nu _ki i qj e*
_]pekj + G Aani ]pkh Pqnc Lj _kh . 6508 6%4&7212*214+
3- +
Hkr ]_o BG+ Ce^nkcaj e_ _upkgej ao7 pda nkha kb ei i qj a
i a` e]pkno ej pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb o_]n peooqa+ Fi i qj kh
Qk` ]u . 66. 8 . / %h&7. 4*/ 0+
3. +
? ]en` > ) J kni a` a M) ? kdhaj M+ Fi i qj kna]_per a be^nk*
^h]op cnks pd b]_pkn ej _ahho kb l anepkj a]h at q` ]pa oqccaopo
epo e` aj pepu s epd i ]_nkl d]ca*` aner a` cnks pd b]_pkn+
? ek_dai ? ekl duo Oao @ki i qj . 6528 . / 3%h&7025*031+
3/ +
Hkr ]_o BG) AeMeapnk I > + Ce^nkcaj e_ _upkgej ao ]j ` _kj *
j a_per a peooqa l nk` q_pekj + C> PB? G . 6618 5%. . &7521ê 53. +
30+ I uj _d PB) @khr ej O? ) > j pkj e]` ao EK+ Dnks pd b]_pkno ej
s kqj ` da]hej c+ Pej cha ]j ` ouj anceope_ abba_po kj l ]npe]h
pde_gj aoo l kn_ej a ogej s kqj ` o+ G @hej Fj r aop . 6568
51%/ &731- *313+
31+ Pl ki J ? ) Ok^anpo > ? ) T ]gabeah` I J ) ` a @nki ^nqccda ? +
Pki a na_aj p ]` r ]j _ao ej pda _dai eopnu ]j ` ^ekhkcu kb
pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]+ G @ahh ? ekh . 6548
. -2%0&7 . - 06*. - 12+
32+
Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) Ka` aha_ ? ) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Bj d]j _a` at l naooekj kb i OK> bkn ej oqhej *hega cnks pd
b] _pkn*. ej l kop*^qi dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqa ]j ` epo be^nk*
caj e_ nkha ^u ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+ J kh @ahh ? ek_dai . 6628
. 15%h&7/ 2*0/ +
33+
Pl ki J ? ) Ok^anpo > ? ) T ]gabeah` I J ) > ooke]j OH+
Qn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]7 ^ekhkce_]h bqj _pekj
]j ` _dai e_]h opi _pqna+ P_eaj _a . 6538 / 00%1430&720/ *
201+
34+
Qoqfe Q) Lg]` ] C) V]i ]cq_de H) K]g]i qn] Q+ J kha_qh]n
_hkj ej c kb pda h]nca oq^qj ep kb pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn
pul a ^ap] i ]ogej c l nkpaej ]j ` at l naooekj kb pda i OK> ej
r ]nekqo n]p peooqao+ Mnk_ K]ph > _]` P_e RP> . 66- 8
54%/ / &75502*5506+
35+ Ok^anpo > ? + Mal pe` a Dnks pd C]_pkno ]j ` Qdaen Oa_al pkno+
Kas Vkng7 Pl nej can*S anh]c) . 66-+
36+ Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) Ka` aha_ ? ) T ]j c O) P_kpp MD)
Qna` cap BB+ @khh]caj ]oa l nk` q_pekj eo hks an ej l kop*
^qnj dul anpnkl de_ o_]n be^nk^h]opo pd]j ej j kni ]h be^nk*
^h]opo ]j ` eo na` q_a` ^u ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn*.+
G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6638 . - 3%0&7143*15. +
4- + J knaj >) Lhkbookj > ) Ppaj i ]j D) Ppaj i ]j D) P]dhej M)
H]j v]ge Q) @h]aookj *T ahod I ) paj Aefga M) J eu]vkj k I )
Eah` ej @E+ F` aj pebe_]pekj ]j ` _d]n]_panev]pekj kb I Q? M*
/ ) ] j kr ah h]paj p pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]*^ej ` ej c
l nkpaej + G ? ekh @dai . 6618 / 36%2. &70/ 136*0/ 145+
4. + A]hh]o PI ) M]ng*Pj u` an P) J eu]vkj k H) Qs ]n` veg A)
J qj ` u DO) ? kj as ]h` I C+ @d]n]_panev]pekj ]j ` ]qpknacq*
h]pekj kb h]paj p pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap] %QDC ^ap]&
_ki l hat ao ej kopak^h]op*hega _ahh hej ao+ Mnk` q_pekj kb ]
h] paj p _ki l hat h]_gej c pda h]paj p QDC ^ap]*^ej ` ej c
l nkpaej + G ? ekh @dai . 6618 / 36%6&735. 2*35/ . +
4/ + H]j v]ge Q) Lhkbookj > ) J knaj > ) T anj opa` p @)
E aehi ]j R) J eu]vkj k H) @h]aookj *T ahod I ) E ah` ej @E+
QDC*^ap] . ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej 7 ] _ki l kj aj p kb pda h]nca
h] paj p _ki l hat kb QDC*^ap] .
s epd i qhpel ha nal a]p
oamqaj _ao+ @ahh . 66-8 3. %3&7 . -2. *. - 3. +
40+ T ]gabeah` I J ) Pi epd AJ ) J ]oqe Q) E]nneo @@) Pl ki
J ? + Aeopne^qpekj ]j ` i k` qh]pekj kb pda _ahhqh]n na_al pkn
bkn pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]+ G @ahh ? ekh . 6548
. - 2%/ &7632*642+
41+ Mkophapds ]epa > B) Haoge*L f] G) J koao EI ) H]j c > E+
Ppei qh]pekj kb pda _dai kp]_pe_ i ecn]pekj kb dqi ]j be^nk*
^h]opo ^u pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap]+ G Bt l J a`
. 6548 . 32%h&7/ 2. */ 23+
42+ Eehh AG) I kc]j > ) J _D]nnu J ) Aa Pkqo] A+ @kj pnkh
kb l nkpaej ]j ` i ]pnet *i kha_qha ouj pdaoeo ej eokh]pa`
kr ej a bap]h cnks pd*l h]pa _dkj ` nk_upao ^u pda ej pan*
]_pekj o kb ^]oe_ be^nk^h]op cnks pd b]_pkn) ej oqhej *
hega cnks pd b]_pkno*F ]j ` *FF) ej oqhej ]j ` pn]j o*
bkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] . + G Bj ` k_nej kh . 66/ 8
. 00%0&7030*040+
43+ Dkh` opaej OE) Mkhego @C) Meh_d MC) Pi epd ? A) Cej a > +
Ppei qh]pekj kb _khh]caj bkni ]pekj ^u ej oqhej ]j ` ej oqhej *
hega cnks pd b]_pkn F ej _qhpqnao kb dqi ]j hqj c be^nk^h]opo+
Bj ` k_nej khkcu . 6568 . / 1%/ &7631*64- +
44+ Fcj kpv O> ) J ]oo]cqa G+ Qn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]
opei qh]pao pda at l naooekj kb be^nkj a_pej ]j ` _khh]caj ]j `
pdaen ej _knl kn]pekj ej pk pda at pn]_ahhqh]n i ]pnet + G ? ekh
@dai . 6538 / 3. %6&71004*1012+
45+ H]d]ne S J ) E| ggej aj I ) T aopani ]n_g G) I ]nf]r ] E+
Aebbanaj pe]h nacqh]pekj kb ` a_knej ]j ` ^echu_]j caj a
at l naooekj ^u ` at ]i apd]okj a ]j ` napej ke_ ]_e` ej _qhpqna`
dqi ]j ogej be^nk^h]opo+
G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh
. 6628
. - 1%1&72- 0*2- 5+
46+ S ]nc] G)
Okoaj ^hkki G)
Gei aj av P>+ Qn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap] %QDC ^ap]& _]qoao ] l anoeopaj p ej _na]oa
ej opa]` u*op]pa ]i kqj po kb pul a F ]j ` pul a FFF _khh]caj ]j `
be^nkj a_pej i OK> o ej j kni ]h dqi ]j ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+
? ek_dai G . 6548 / 14%0&7264*3- 1+
5-+ Lr an]hh
@J )
T n]j ] GI )
Pk` ag G+
Qn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] nacqh]pekj kb _khh]caj ]oa) 4/ gA]*
l nkcah]pej ]oa) QFJ M ]j ` M> F*. at l naooekj ej n]p ^kj a
_ahh l kl qh]pekj o ]j ` dqi ]j be^nk^h]opo+ @kj j a_p Qeooqa
Oao . 6568 / - %h*1&7/ 56*/ 61+
5. + B` s ]n` o
AO) J qnl du D)
Oauj kh` o GG) T depd]i PB)
Ak_danpu
> G) > j cah M)
E a]hpd GH+ Qn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap] i k` qh]pao pda at l naooekj kb _khh]caj *
]oa ]j ` i ap]hhkl nkpaej ]oa ej de^epkn+ BJ ? L G . 6548
3%4&7 . 566*. 6- 1+
5/ +
J qopka Q> ) Mean_a DC) Qdki ]okj > ) Dn]i ]pao M)
Pl ki J ? ) Aaqah QC+ > __ahan]pa` da]hej c kb ej _eoekj ]h
s kqj ` o ej n]po ej ` q_a` ^u pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*
^ap]+ P_eaj _a . 6548 / 04%15/ - &7 . 000*. 003+
50+
V]j c I ) Neq @U) I q` hks > ) Cancqokj J T ) ? nqj j an D+
> _per a pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ej s kqj ` nal ]en7
` apani ej ]pekj qoej c ] j as ]oo]u+ > i G M]pdkh . 6668
. 21%. &7 . - 2ê . . . +

) 1,

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
l nkheban]pekj ]j ` i knl dkhkcu kb _dkj ` nk_upao eokh]pa`
bnki n]p ne^ cnks pd _]npeh] ca+ @ahh ? ekh Fj p Oal . 6568
. 0%0&7/ 26*/ 4- +
66+
Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) P_kpp MD) Dkj c V) Qna` cap BB+
Bj d]j _a` at l naooekj kb i OK> bkn pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn*^ap]) pul a F ]j ` pul a FFF l nk_khh]caj ej dqi ]j
l kop*^qnj dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqao+ G I ]^ @hej J a`
. 6608 . / / %1&7132*140+
. --+ ? kn` an T > ) Kk^ha K> + QDC*^ap] ej ge` j au be^nkoeo7 ]
p]ncap bkn caj a pdan]l u+ He` j au Fj p . 6648 2. %2&7 . 055 ê
. 063+
. -. +
Q]ga` ] H) E ]p]i k_de > ) Rage E) K]g]p] J ) Leode V+
Aa_na]oa` _khh]caj ]oa at l naooekj ej _qhpqna` ouopai e_
o_hankoeo
be^nk^h]opo+
G
Fj r aop
Aani ]pkh
. 6618
. - 0%0&7026*030+
. -/ +
Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+ Bt l naooekj kb
be^nkj a_pej i OK> ej dul anpnkl de_ ]j ` j kni ]h ` ani ]h
peooqao ]j ` ej r epnk nacqh]pekj ^u ej panbankj ]hl d]*/ ^+
T kqj ` Oal ]en Oacaj . 6608 . 7. 33*. 41+
. -0+ Gkj ao > M) T a^^ I J ) > j ` anokj > L) I akj ]n` BG) Okp >+
Kkni ]h dqi ]j os a]p _kj p]ej o ej panhaqgej *5+ G I aqgk_
? ekh . 6628 24%0&7101*104+
. -1+ H]nau HM) J ]nmq]n` p E) Pen^]ogq A> + E qi ]j l h]pahap*
` aner a` i epkcaj o+ F+ F` aj pebe_]pekj kb ej oqhej hega cnks pd
b]_pkno F ]j ` FF ^u l qnebe_]pekj ]j ` K ]hl d] ]i ej k ]_e`
oamqaj _a ]j ]huoeo+ ? hkk` . 6568 41%0&7 . - 51*. - 6/ +
. -2+ K]c]kg] F) Qn]l j ahh ? @) @nuop] h OD+ Oacqh]pekj kb
ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn F
caj a at l naooekj ej pda
dqi ]j i ]_nkl d]ca*hega _ahh hej a R604+ G @hej Fj r aop
. 66- 8 52%/ &7115*122+
. -3+ Dnkpaj ` knop DO+ @kj j a_per a
peooqa cnks pd b]_pkn7 ]
i a` e]pkn kb QDC*^ap] ]_pekj
kj be^nk^h]opo+ @upkgej a
Dnks pd C]_pkn Oar . 6648 5%0&7 . 4. ê . 46+
. -4+ ? ]nna_] > ) Aa I q_] J ) Aah J kj pa M) ? kj ` ]j v] P)
A]i kj pa D) @]nekh] D) AeJ ]n_k B) Dekn` ]j k D)
@]j _a` ` ] O) J ej qpk C+ Fj r epnk l ]n]_nej a nacqh]pekj kb
dqi ]j gan]pej k_upa cnks pd ^u be^nk^h]op*` aner a` ej oqhej *
hega cnks pd b]_pkno+ G @ahh Mduoekh . 66/ 8 . 2. %/ &7/ 3/ */ 35+
. -5+ Lg]v]ge O) Aqnd]i PH) Oecco ? I ) @kj kr an @> + Qn]j o*
bkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ]j ` bknogkhej ej _na]oa ]hh
_h]ooao kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn*F pn]j o_nel po ej
j kni ]h dqi ]j kopak^h]op*hega _ahho+ ? ek_dai ? ekl duo
Oao @ki i qj . 6628 / - 4%0&7630*64- +
. - 6+ Dd]d]nu > ) Pdaj VG) T ]j c O) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Bt l naooekj ]j ` hk_]hev]pekj kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd
b] _pkn*. ej j kni ]h ]j ` l kop*^qnj dul anpnkl de_ o_]n peooqa
ej dqi ]j + J kh @ahh ? ek_dai . 6658 . 50%. ê / &7 . ê 6+
. . -+ Ld V) J qhhan EI ) Kc I ) Okoaj bah` OD+ Qn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap]*ej ` q_a` _ahh cnks pd ej de^epekj ej
dqi ]j ^na]op _]j _an _ahho eo i a` e]pa` pdnkqcd ej oqhej *
hega cnks pd b]_pkn*^ej ` ej c l nkpaej *0 ]_pekj + G ? ekh @dai
. 6628 / 4- %/ 0&7 . 0256*. 026/ +
. . . + @]v]ho S) J kqdea` ` ej a ? ) J ]epna ? ) I a? kq_ V)
@d]` ah]p H) ? n]` u GP) @hai aj p > + Fj oqhej *hega cnks pd
b]_pkno) pdaen ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej o) ]j ` pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn*^ap] . ej kt e` ]j p*]nnaopa` hqj c ]hr akh]n al epdahe]h
_ahho+ G ? ekh @dai . 6618 / 36%. 6&7 . 1. . . ê . 1. . 4+
. . / + Dkk` i ]j OB) Kaopha C) K]e` q VJ ) Dnaaj GJ )
Qdki l okj @? ) Ke_gkhkbb ? G) Qqng] I > + Han]pej k_upa*
51+ V]j c I ) @d]j Q) Aai ]na G) Fs ]odej ] Q) Dd]n]nu > )
P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
E a]hej c kb ^qi s kqj ` o ej
pn]j ocaj e_ i e_a kr anat l naooej c pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn*^ap] .
ej pda al e` ani eo+ > i G M]pdkh / - - . 8
. 26%3&7/ . 14*/ . 24+
52+
? n]` d]i AJ ) Fc]n]ode > ) Mkppan OI ) Dnkpaj ` knop DO+
@kj j a_per a peooqa cnks pd b]_pkn7 ] _uopaej a*ne_d i epkcaj
oa_napa` ^u dqi ]j r ]o_qh]n aj ` kpdahe]h _ahho eo nah]pa`
pk pda PO@*ej ` q_a` ei i a` e]pa a]nhu caj a l nk` q_p @BC*
. -+ G @ahh ? ekh . 66. 8 . . 1%3&7 . / 52*. / 61+
53+ Fc]n]ode > ) K]odenk H)
Hegq_de H) P]pk P) Fdj
E)
Cqfei kpk J ) Dnkpaj ` knop DO) Q]gad]n] H+ @kj j a_per a
peooqa cnks pd b]_pkn caj a at l naooekj ej peooqa oa_pekj o
bnki hk_]heva` o_hank` ani ]) gahke` ) ]j ` kpdan be^nkpe_ ogej
` eokn` ano+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6638 . - 3%1&74/ 6*400+
54+
Fc]n]ode > ) Lgk_de E) ? n]` d]i AJ ) Dnkpaj ` knop DO+
Oacqh]pekj kb _kj j a_per a peooqa cnks pd b]_pkn caj a
at l naooekj ej dqi ]j ogej be^nk^h]opo ]j ` ` qnej c s kqj `
nal ]en+ J kh ? ekh @ahh . 6608 1%3&7304*312+
55+ Dnkpaj ` knop D) Dnkpaj ` knop @) Dehi ]j Q+ Mnk` q_pekj kb
cnks pd b]_pkno %MADC ]j ` QDC*^ap] h& ]p pda oepa kb
peooqa nal ]en+ Pui l koeqi kj Qeooqa Oal ]en+ Dnks pd
C]_pkno
]j `
L pdan
> ol a_po
kb T kqj `
Ea]hej c+
Kas Vkng7 I eoo > O) . 655+
56+
Gkj ao GF) @hai i kj o AO+ Fj oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkno ]j `
pdaen ^ej ` ej c l nkpaej o7 ^ekhkce_]h ]_pekj o+ Bj ` k_n Oar
. 6628 . 3%. &70ê 01+
6- +
Pl aj _an BJ ) Pgkr an D) E qj p QH+ Pki ]pki a` ej o7 ` k pdau
l h]u ] l er kp]h nkha ej s kqj ` da]hej c< Mnkc @hej ? ekh Oao
. 6558 / 337. - 0*. . 3+
6. + J _@]npdu QI ) @aj pnahh] J ) @]j ]heo B+ Oacqh]pknu abba_po
kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkno F ]j ` FF kj ^kj a _khh]caj
ouj pdaoeo ej n]p _]hr ]ne]h _qhpqnao+ Bj ` k_nej khkcu . 6568
. / 1%h&70- . *0- 6+
6/ + B` s ]hh A) P_d]hhej c J ) Gaj j eo_da B) Kknopa` p D+ Fj ` q_*
pekj kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn F i aooaj can ne^kj q_hae_
]_e` ` qnej c nacaj an]pekj kb n]p ogahap]h i qo_ha+ Bj ` k_nej *
khkcu . 6568 . / 1%/ & ' +5/ - *5/ 2+
60+
? h]ppe PM) Ckopan AK) O]j c]j ]pd]j D) J koao EI ) Dapv J G+
Fj ` q_pekj kb be^nkj a_pej caj a pn]j o_nel pekj ]j ` i OK> eo ]
l nei ]nu naol kj oa pk cnks pd*b]_pkn opei qh]pekj kb > HO*/ ?
_ahho+ Mnk_ K]ph > _]` P_e RP> . 6558 52%1&7 . . . 6*. . / 0+
61+
Ppaaj bko EE) G]j ookj GL+ Daj a at l naooekj kb ej oqhej *hega
cnks pd b]_pkn*F ]j ` FDC*F na_al pkn ` qnej c s kqj ` da]hej c
ej n]po+ Bqn G Pqnc . 66/ 8 . 25%3*4&70/ 4*00. +
62+ E]j ookj E> ) Gaj j eo_da B) Pgkppj an >+ Oacaj an]pej c
aj ` kpdahe]h _ahho at l naoo ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn*F
ei i qj kna]_per epu ]bpan ]npane]h ej fqnu+ @ahh Qeooqa Oao
. 6548 / 2- %0&7166*2- 2+
63+ ? en` GI ) Quhan G> + Aat ]i apd]okj a l kpaj pe]pao pda opei q*
h]pknu abba_p kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd b]_pkn*F kj _khh]caj
l nk` q_pekj ej _qhpqna` dqi ]j be^nk^h]opo+ G Bj ` k_nej kh
. 6618 . 1/ %0&724. *246+
64+ L îHaaba OG) Mqv]o GB) ? n]j ` GP) Okoean OK+ Bbba_po kb
pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] kj i ]pnet ouj pdaoeo ^u
_de_g cnks pd l h]pa _dkj ` nk_upao+ Bj ` k_nej khkcu . 6558
. / / %3&7/ 620*/ 63. +
65+ J ]gks an > J ) T nk^has oge G) M]s hks oge >+ Bbba_po kb
FDC*F) nDE) CDC) BDC ]j ` K@P kj AK > *ouj pdaoeo) _ahh

GWT 8 cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 1-
` aner a`
Q
_ahh
_kopei qh]pekj
ej ` q_ao
l nabanaj pe]h
l nk` q_pekj kb FI */ ]j ` FI *1 ^qp j kp FCK*c]i i ]+
G Fi i qj kh . 6618 . 2/ %. . &72. 56*2. 65+
. . 0+
E ]qoan @+ Qda ej pan]_pekj ^aps aaj I ]j cand]j o _ahho ]j `
@A1( Q _ahho+ G Aani ]pkh . 66/ 8 . 6%. . &74/ / ê 4/ 2+
. . 1+
Oki ]cj ]j e P+ Aar ahkl i aj p kb Qd . * kn Qd / *` ki ej ]pa`
ei i qj a naol kj oao7 s d]p ]^kqp pda l kh]nevej c oecj ]ho<
Fj p G @hej I ]^ Oao . 6638 / 3%/ &750*65+
. . 2+
J koi ]j j QO) @kbbi ]j OI + QE. ]j ` QE/ _ahho7 ` ebbanaj p
l ]ppanj o kb hui l dkgej a oa_napekj ha]` pk ` ebbanaj p bqj _*
pekj ]h l nkl anpeao+ > j j q Oar Fi i qj kh . 6568 47. 12*. 40+
. . 3+
J koi ]j j QO) @dans ej oge E) ? kj ` J T ) Dea` hej J > )
@kbbi ]j OI + Qs k pul ao kb i qnej a dahl an Q _ahh _hkj a+
F+ Aabej epekj ]__kn` ej c pk l nkbehao kb hui l dkgej a
]_per epeao ]j ` oa_napa` l nkpaej o+ G Fi i qj kh . 6538
. 03%4&7/ 015*/ 024+
. . 4+
Q]gaq_de J ) Qna` cap BB) P_kpp MD) Heh]j e OQ)
Dd]d]nu > + Qda ]j pebe^nkcaj e_ abba_po kb hel koki a*aj _]l *
oqh] pa` FCK*]hl d]/ ^ _na]i kj ogej s kqj ` o+ G Fj panbankj
@upkgej a Oao . 6668 . 6%. / &7 . 1. 0*. 1. 6+
. . 5+
Hahhu GI ) L îPqehha]^d]ej @? ) Pk^anc @@) J ]j j e_g G> )
I a` anan G> + Par ana ej fqnu pneccano ]j pecaj *ol a_ebe_
Q*dahl an _ahh ` uobqj _pekj + Pdk_g . 6668 . / %h&706*12+
. . 6+
Pa` an O> ) Dani ]ej OK) I ej ohau MP) M]qh T B+ @A/ 5*
i a` e]pa` _kopei qh]pekj kb ej panhaqgej / %FI */ & l nk` q_*
pekj l h]uo ] _nepe_]h nkha ej Q _ahh l nei ej c bkn FI *1 ]j `
ej panbankj c]i i ] l nk` q_pekj +
G Bt l J a`
. 6618
. 46%h&7/ 66*0- 1+
. / -+
Ceknaj pej k AC) ? kj ` J T ) J koi ]j j QO+ Qs k pul ao kb
i kqoa Q dahl an _ahh+ FS+ Qd/ _hkj ao oa_napa ] b]_pkn pd]p
ej de^epo _upkgej a l nk` q_pekj ^u Qdh _hkj ao+ G Bt l J a`
. 6568 . 4- %3&7/ - 5. */ - 62+
. / . +
Qnej _deane D) Danko] C+ Fi i qj knacqh]pekj ^u ej panhaqgej *
. / + G I aqgk_ ? ekh . 6638 26%1&72- 2*2. . +
. / / +
C]nca]o @) T q @V) K]g]fei ] Q) @kt A) Kqpi ]j Q)
Aahaol aooa D+ Aebbanaj pe]h abba_p kb pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd
b]_pkn ^ap] kj pda ouj pdaoeo kb Qdh* ]j ` Qd/ *hega hui l dk*
gej ao ^u dqi ]j Q hui l dk_upao+ Bqn G Fi i qj kh . 66/ 8
/ / %5&7/ . 40*/ . 43+
. / 0+
@]hec]neo*@]l l ek
C)
? anpank
J Q)
@kj r anok
J )
Pp]__dej e > ) S ej ]j pa C) Oki ]cj ]j e P) Mevvkhk D+ @en_q*
h]pej c har aho kb okhq^ha @A0- ) ] i ]ngan kb _ahho l nk` q_ej c
Qd/ *pul a _upkgej ao) ]na ej _na]oa` ej l ]peaj po s epd ouo*
pai e_ hql qo anupdai ]pkoqo ]j ` _knnah]pa s epd ` eoa]oa
]_per epu+ @hej Bt l Odaqi ]pkh . 6628 . 0%0&7006*010+
. / 1+
Kaa` hai ]j ? T ) T echau CJ ) Pp]en OT + Fj panhaqgej *. )
ej panhaqgej */ ) ej panhaqgej *1) ej panhaqgej *3) pqi kn j a_nkoeo
b]_pkn ]hl d]) ]j ` ej panbankj *c]i i ] har aho ej oan] bnki
l ]peaj po s epd o_hank` ani ]+
> npdnepeo Odaqi
. 66/ 8
02%h&734*4/ +
. / 2+
Ok^ej okj AP) H]u > ? + Okha kb Qdh ]j ` Qd/ _ahho ej dqi ]j
]hhance_ ` eokn` ano+ @dai Fi i qj kh . 6638 307. 54*/ - 0+
. / 3+
? ]nn]h > ) Qaet aen] J ) Oaeo M) S ej d]o S ) @kop] G) I aoo] E)
? eppaj _kqnp > I ) Oaa` P) @]nr ]hdk BJ ) ? ]nn]h*Kappk J +
Qn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ej dqi ]j _qp]j akqo
haeodi ]j e]oeo+ > i G M]pdkh . 6628 . 14%1&7614*621+
. / 4+
Ps ed]np H) Cnqpd R) J aooi an K) Eqc H) ? adej O) E q]j c P)
Aah Deq` e_a D) > cqap J ) I kqeo G> + J e_a bnki ] caj ape_]hhu
naoeop]j p ^]_gcnkqj ` h]_gej c pda ej panbankj c]i i ]
na_al pkn ]na oqo_al pe^ha pk ej ba_pekj s epd I aeodi ]j e]
i ]fkn ^qp i kqj p ] l kh]neva` Q dahl an _ahh . *pul a @A1(
Q _ahh naol kj oa+ G Bt l J a` . 6628 . 5. %0&763. *64. +
. / 5+
E qj p GM) E qj pan @Q) ? nks j opaej J O) De]j j kl kqhko > )
E qhpi ]j @P) ` aPannao P) ? n]_au I ) Cnahej can G)
J auan > > + Qda abba_pkn _ki l kj aj p kb pda _upkpkt e_
Q*hui l dk_upa naol kj oa d]o ] ^el d]oe_ l ]ppanj ]bpan ^qnj
ej fqnu+ G Pqnc Oao . 6658 5- %/ &7/ 10*/ 2. +
. / 6+ T ehhe]i o J B) @]ol ]n M) L os ]h` F) Pd]ni ] EH)
M]j gas u_v L) Pdan > ) G]i ao PI + S ]__ej ]pekj nkqpao
pd]p b]eh pk ahe_ep l nkpa_per a ei i qj epu ]c]ej op P_deopkoki ]
i ]j okj e ej ` q_a pda l nk` q_pekj kb QDC*^ap]) s de_d ` ks j *
nacqh] pao i ]_nkl d]ca ]j pel ]n]oepe_ ]_per epu+ G Fi i qj kh
. 6628 . 21%6&71360*14- - +
. 0-+ L îPqhher ]j PQ) I a` anan G> ) E knc]j > C) @dej AE)
J ]j j e_g G> ) Ok` ne_g J I + J ]fkn ej fqnu ha]` o pk l na` ki e*
j ]j _a kb pda Q dahl an*/ hui l dk_upa l daj kpul a ]j ` ` ei ej *
eoda` ej panhaqgej *. / l nk` q_pekj ]ook_e]pa` s epd ` a_na]oa`
naoeop]j _a pk ej ba_pekj + > j j Pqnc . 6628 / / / %1& 715/ *16- 8
` eo_qooekj 16- *16/ +
. 0. + Eknc]j
> C)
J aj ` av
J S )
L îOekn` ]ej
AP)
E khvdaei an OD) J ]j j e_g G> ) Ok` ne_g J I + > hpana`
caj a pn]j o_nel pekj ]bpan ^qi ej fqnu naoqhpo ej ` al naooa`
Q*hui l dk_upa ]_per ]pekj + > j j Pqnc . 6618 / / - %0&701/ *
02. 8 ` eo_qooekj 02. *02/ +
. 0/ +
Wa` ean P) C]eop B) L opani aean ? ) r kj Akj j anoi ]n_g DE)
P_deh` ^anc CT + Mkop^qi _kj opepqpekj ]h _d]j cao ej Q*_ahh
na]_per epu k__qn ej @A5( n]pdan pd]j ej @A1( _ahho+
G Qn]qi ] . 6648 1/ %2&754/ *55- 8 ` eo_qooekj 55- *55. +
. 00+
Wa` ean P) ? kj a O@) ? ]qa > B) r kj Akj j anoi ]n_g DE)
C]eop B+ Q*_ahh na]_per epu ]j ` epo l na` e_per a nkha ej ei i q*
j koql l naooekj
]bpan ^qnj o+
@nep @]na J a`
. 6668
/ 4%h&733*4/ +
. 01+
C]eop B) J as ao > ) Ppn]ooan Q) T ]hv > ) > hg]j P) ? ]gan @)
Bnpah T ) E a^anan D+ > hpan]pekj kb i kj k_upa bqj _pekj
bkhhks ej c i ]fkn ej fqnu+ > n_d Pqnc . 6558 . / 0%0&7/ 54*/ 6/ +
. 02+
Pde W) T ]geh > B) Ok_gau A@+ Ppn]ej *ol a_ebe_ ` ebbanaj _ao
ej i kqoa dal ]pe_ s kqj ` da]hej c ]na i a` e]pa` ^u ` er an*
caj p Q dahl an _upkgej a naol kj oao+ Mnk_ K]ph > _]` Pae
RP> . 6648 61%/ - &7 . - 330*. - 335+
. 03+ A] @kop] G+ J k` anj Pqncanu+ Mdeh]` ahl de] 7 T +? + P]qj ` ano)
. 60. +
. 04+ S ]na` e J ) Qna` cap BB) P_kpp MD) Pdaj VG) Dd]d]nu >+
> hpan]pekj ej _ahh i knl dkhkcu pneccano pn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] . ) _khh]caj ]oa) ]j ` peooqa ej de^epkn kb
i ap]hhkl nkpaej ]oao*F at l naooekj ej j kni ]h ]j ` dul an*
pnkl de_
o_]n be^nk^h]opo+
G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh
. 6628
. - 1% . &7. . 5ê . / 0+
. 05+ Cn]qhej CL) Fhhi ]uan PG) Qna` cap BB+ > ooaooi aj p kb _ko*
i ape_ ]j ` bqj _pekj ]h naoqhpo kb _kj oanr ]per a r anoqo oqnce*
_]h i ]j ]cai aj p kb b]_e]h ^qi o+ G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh
. 6638 . 4%. &7 . 6ê / 6+
. 06+ J qnn]u G@+ Hahke` o ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ @hej Aani ]pkh
. 6618 . / %h&7/ 4*04+
. 1-+ > ooke] j OH) Hki kneu] > ) J auano @> ) J ehhan AJ )
Pl ki J ? + Qn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] ej dqi ]j
l h]pahapo+ F` aj pebe_]pekj kb ] i ]fkn opkn]ca oepa) l qnebe*
_]pekj )
]j ` _d]n]_panev]pekj +
G ? ekh @dai
. 6508
/ 25%. . &74. 22*4. 3- +

) 1.

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
. 1. +
I ]nokj AI ) > ^opkj P) T ehheo ? ) I ej ]nao E) Ak^ngkr ogu
J ) Br ]j o B? ) I as eo PO+ @kj pn]_pqna ]j ` o_]n bkni ]pekj
ej pda ^qi l ]peaj p+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 6418 . %1&7320*323+
. 1/ +
@daj c G@) Br ]j o GE) I aqj c HP) @h]ng G> ) @dku QQ)
I aqj c M@+ Mnaooqna pdan]l u ej pda pna]pi aj p kb l kop*^qi
dul anpnkl de_ o_]nê ] _nepe_]h hkkg ej pk epo qoabqhj aoo ]j `
b]hh]_eao ^u l naooqna i kj epknej c+ ? qi o Fj _h Qdani Fj f
. 6518 . - %0&7 . 21*. 30+
. 10+
Heo_dan @T ) Pdaph]n J O) Pdaph]n @I + > hpan]pekj kb
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ej ` q_a` ^u i a_d]j e_]h l naooqna+
> n_d Aani ]pkh . 6428 hhh%h&73 - *3 1 +
. 11+
Heo_dan @T ) Pdaph]n J O+ J e_nkr ]o_qh]pqna ej dul an*
pnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` pda abba_po kb l naooqna+ G Qn]qi ] . 6468
. 6%. - &7424*431+
. 12+
Heo_dan @T ) ? qj _a E FFF) Pdaph]d J O+ J ]op _ahh ]j ]huoao
ej dul anpnkl de_ o_]no) dul anpnkl de_ o_]no pna]pa` s epd
l naooqna ]j ` i ]pqna o_]no+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6458
4- %3&7022*024+
. 13+
@d]j c M) I ]q^aj pd]h HK) I as eo OT FF) Okoaj mqeop J A)
I ej ` hau*Pi epd M) Ha]hau DM+ Mnkol a_per a) n]j ` ki eva`
opq` u kb pda abbe_]_u kb l naooqna c]ni aj p pdan]l u ej l ]peaj po
s epd ^qi o+ G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh . 6628 . 3%2&7140*142+
. 14+
@h]nuo M) > has ]apano H) I ]i ^na_dp O) ? ]nah > L+ Pgej
_khkn i a]oqnai aj po7 _ki l ]neokj ^aps aaj pdnaa ej opnq*
i aj po7 pda @dnki ]i apanà ) pda Aani ]Pl a_pnki apanà ]j `
pda J at ]i apanà + Pgej Oao Qa_dj kh / - - - 8 3%1&7/ 0- */ 05+
. 15+
Ckj c PP) Eqj c I H) @daj c G@+ Qda _qpki apan ]j `
qhpn]okj kcn]l du ej pda ]ooaooi aj p kb l kop^qi dul an*
pnkl de_
o_]nê ]
l nahei ej ]nu
opq` u+
? qi o
. 6648
/ 0%oql l h . &7P. / *P. 5+
. 16+
E]i ^hapkj G) Pd]gaol a]na MD) Mn]pp ? G+ Qda l nkcnaoo kb
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no i kj epkna` ^u qhpn]okqj ` i a]oqnai aj po
kb pde_gj aoo+ ? qi o . 66/ 8 . 5%1&70- . *0- 4+
. 2-+
J kkna I J + Bbba_per aj aoo kb _qopki l naooqna c]ni aj po ]
l nkol a_per a pne]h s epdej s kqj ` o ]j ` s epd r anebea` l naooqna+
. . pd Nq]` naj j e]h @kj cnaoo kb pda Fj panj ]pekj ]h Pk_eapu bkn
? qi Fj fqneao) Pa]ppha) T > ) / - - / +
. 2. + Pl nk]p GB) A]h_ej > ) T aep]qan K) Ok^anpo OP+ Eul anpnkl de_
opanj ]h o_]no7 oehe_kj a cah odaap r anoqo Haj ]hkc ej fa_pekj
pna]pi aj p+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 66/ 8 6- %3&7655*66/ +
. 2/ + Dkh` J E+ > _kj pnkhha` _hej e_]h pne]h kb pkl e_]h oehe_kj a cah
odaapej c ej pda pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j `
gahke` o+ G > i > _]` Aani ]pkh . 6618 0- %0&72- 3*2- 4+
. 20+ T aoohej c K) Bdha^aj @J ) @d]l i ]j S ) J ]u PO) Ppehh GJ
Gn+ Br e` aj _a pd]p qoa kb ] oehe_kj a cah odaap ej _na]oao n]j ca
kb i kpekj kr an ^qi s kqj ` _kj pn]_pqnao+ G ? qi @]na
Oad]^eh . 6528 3%3&72- 0*2- 2+
. 21+ Nqej j HG+ Pehe_kj a cah ej o_]n pna]pi aj p+ ? qi o Fj _h Qdani
Fj f . 6548 . 0%oql l h&7P00*P1- +
. 22+ I aa O) Akkj c E+ @kj pnkh kb i ]pnet l nk` q_pekj ` qnej c
peooqa nal ]en+ Fj 7 I aa O@) J qopka Q> ) Pea^anp G) a` o+
> ` r ]j _ao ej T kqj ` Ea]hej c ]j ` Qeooqa Oal ]en+
@de_]ck7 T knh` J a` e_]h Mnaoo) . 660+
. 23+ J qocn]r a J > ) Ri n]s K) Ceod GP) Dki av J ) @]npkppk O@+
Qda abba_p kb oehe_kj a cah odaapo kj l anbqoekj kb dul an*
pnkl de_ ^qi
o_]no+
G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh / - - / 8
/ 0%0&7/ - 5*/ . 1+
. 24+
Nqej j HG) Br ]j o GE) @kqnpj au GJ ) D]uhkn GA) Oae` T E+
Kkj *l naooqna pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ ? qi o Fj _h
Qdani Fj f . 6528 . / %/ &7 . - / *. - 5+
. 25+
> dj PQ) J kj ]bk T T ) J qopka Q> + Qkl e_]h oehe_kj a cah7 ]
j as pna]pi aj p bkn dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ Pqncanu . 6568
. - 3%1&745. *4538 ` eo_qooekj 453*454+
. 26+
@]nn*@khhej o G> + Mnaooqna pa_dj emqao bkn pda l nar aj pekj kb
dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 66/ 8 . 6%0&7400*410+
. 3-+
S ]j ` aj Han_ddkr a B) ? ka_gt T ) Hk_dqup > + Pehe_kj a
l ]p_dao ]o ] oql l hai aj p bkn l naooqna pdan]l u pk _kj pnkh
dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c+ G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh . 66. 8
. / %1&703. *036+
. 3. +
A]r au O? ) T ]hheo H> ) ? ks anej c H+ > ` daoer a _kj p]_p
i a` e]ê ]j ql ` ]pa kj cn]bp bet ]pekj ]j ` ^qi o_]n i ]j ]ca*
i aj p+ ? qi o . 66. 8 . 4%1&70. 0*0. 6+
. 3/ +
Oer ano B> ) Ppn]pa OD) Pkhai I A+ Qda pn]j ol ]naj p b]_a
i ]og+ > i G L__ql Qdan . 6468 00%/ &7 . - 5*. . 0+
. 30+
Oe` cs ]u @I ) A]qcdanpu J ? ) T ]n` aj DA+ Pane]h _]opej c
]o ] pa_dj emqa pk _knna_p ^qi o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao+ > _]oa
nal knp+ G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh . 66. 8 . / %h&734*4/ +
. 31+
? aj j app D? ) E ahi M) Mqn` qa DC) E qj p GI + Pane]h _]opej c7
] i apdk` bkn pna]pej c ^qi _kj pn]_pqnao+ G ? qi @]na
Oad]^eh . 6568 . - %3&7210*212+
. 32+ I ai ]j @G+ Pl hej po ]j ` ]__aookneao bkhhks ej c ^qnj na_kj *
opnq_pekj + @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 66/ 8 . 6%0&74/ . *40. +
. 33+ Heeh G+ Hahke` o pna]pa` s epd pkl e_]h ej fa_pekj o kb pne]i *
_ej khkj a ]_apkj e` a %gaj ]hkc&+ Fi i a` e]pa ]j ` hkj c*
pani naoqhpo+ P_]j ` G Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6448
. . %/ &7 . 36*. 4/ +
. 34+ @kdaj FH) Aeacahi ]j j OC) ? nu]j p @M+ > hl d] chk^qhej
_khh]caj ]oa ej de^epkno ej gahke` ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n+
Pqnc Cki i . 6428 / 373. *3/ +
. 35+ Meppap ? ) Oq^^e]*? n]j ` p I ) Aaoi kqheana > ) P]l l ej k > M)
Okccank M) Dqannap
P)
Dnei ]q` G> )
I ]_dan O)
J kj p]j ` kj A) D]^^e]j e D+ Bbba_p kb c]i i ]*ej panbankj
kj pda _hej e_]h ]j ` ^ekhkce_ ar khqpekj kb dul anpnkl de_
o_]no ]j ` Aql qupnaj îo ` eoa]oa7 ]j kl aj l ehkp opq` u+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6618 60%3&7 . / / 1*. / 02+
. 36+ Oqo_e]j e I ) Okooe D) ? kj k O+ Roa kb _nukpdan]l u ej pda
pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o+ G Aani ]pkh Pqnc Lj _kh . 6608
. 6%3&72/ 6*201+
. 4-+ @aehhau OF) ? ]^ej OT + Qda _ki ^ej a` qoa kb _nuk*
oqncanu ]j ` ej pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj o kb oqol aj oekj o kb
bhqknej ]pa` ]` naj k_knpe_kopanke` o bkn na` q_ej c gahke` o
]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ G Aani ]pkh Pqnc Lj _kh . 6468
2%h&721*23+
. 4. + I aa O@) Akkj c E) Gahhai ] > C+ Qda naol kj oa kb ^qi o_]no
pk ej pn]haoekj ]h r an]l ]i eh+ Oal knp kb ber a _]oao+ > n_d Pqnc
. 6618 . / 6%. &7 . - 4ê . . . +
. 4/ + Bol ]Å] > ) Pkh]j k Q) Nqej p]j ehh] B+ ? haki u_ej ej pda pna] p*
i aj p kb gahke` o ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ^u i qhpel ha j aa` ha
l qj _pqnao+ Aani ]pkh Pqnc / - - . 8 / 4%. &7/ 0*04+
. 40+ Rl l ]h OP) Hd]j R) H]g]n P) Q]h]o D) @d]l i ]j M)
J _Dnkqpdan > A+ Qda abba_po kb ] oej cha ` koa kb
2*bhqknkqn]_eh kj gahke` o_]no7 ] _hej e_]h pne]h kb pei a`
s kqj ` ennec]pekj ]bpan at pn]haoekj ]h at _eoekj + Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc / - - . 8 . - 5%2&7. / . 5*. / / 1+

GWT 8cX^[^Vh P] S @P] PVT\ T] c ^U ; h_Taca^_WXR FRPab P] S >T[^XSb

) 1/
i a` e]pekj ^u j q_ha]n b]_pkn . ` ks j *nacqh]pekj + G Fj r aop
Aani ]pkh . 6628 . - 1%/ &7/ 5/ */ 53+
. 6-+
Dn]j opaej OA) Chkppa QG) > i aj pk BM+ Fj panbankj o ]j `
_khh]caj l nk` q_pekj + G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 66- 8 62%oql l h
3&742P*5- P+
. 6. + A]j o J G) Fooankbb O+ Fj de^epekj kb _khh]caj h]ppe_a
_kj pn]_pekj ^u l aj pkt ebuhhej a ]j ` ej panbankj *]hl d]) *^ap])
]j ` *c]i i ]+ G Fj r aop Aani ]pkh . 6618 . - / %. &7 . . 5*. / . +
. 6/ + J _@]qhau OI ) @dkl n] S ) I e VV) E anj ` kj AK)
Ok^okj J @+ > hpana` _upkgej a l nk` q_pekj ej ^h]_g l ]peaj po
s epd gahke` o+ G @hej Fi i qj kh . 66/ 8 . / %1&70- - *0- 5+
. 60+ Paj D@) I aj cuah M+ Qda ej panbankj ouopai + > ^en` îo aua
r eas
kb
epo
^ek_dai eopnu+
G
? ekh
@dai
. 66/ 8
/ 34%5&72- . 4*2- / - +
. 61+
Ka`ahba_ ? ) Pdaj VG) Dd]d]nu > ) P_kpp MD) Qna` cap BB+
Qda abba_p kb ej panbankj ]hl d] / ^ kj pda at l naooekj kb _upk*
ogahap]h l nkpaej o ej ]j ej r epnk i k` ah kb s kqj ` _kj pn] _*
pekj + G I ]^ @hej J a` . 6628 . / 3%2&7141*151+
. 62+ T kj c QT ) @deq E@) Vel HJ + Fj pn]haoekj ]h ej panbankj
]hl d]*/ ^ d]o j k abba_p ej pda pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o+ ? n G
Aani ]pkh . 6618 . 0- %2&7350*352+
. 63+
]h*Hd]s ]f]d J J + C]ehqna kb ej panbankj *]hl d] / ^ ej pda
pna]pi aj p kb i ]pqna gahke` o+ Fj p G Aani ]pkh . 6638
02%4&72. 2*2. 4+
. 64+ T aej an K) T ehhe]i o K) ? en_d D) O]i ]_d]j ` n]j @)
Pdel i ]j @ Gn) Chuj j D+ Qkl e_]h ` aher anu kb hel koki ]hhu
aj _]l oqh]pa` ej panbankj ar ]hq]pa` ej ] _qp]j akqo danl ao
cqej a] l ec i k` ah+ > j pei e_nk^ > caj po @dai kpdan . 6568
00%5&7 . / . 4ê . / / . +
. 65+
Qah]ogu @) Qna` cap BB) Pdaj N) Hdknn]i ev]` ad J O)
Fs ]odej ] Q) P_kpp MD) Dd]d]nu > + FCK*]hl d]/ ^ oql *
l naooao pda be^nkcaj e_ abba_po kb ej oqhej *hega cnks pd
b]_pkn*. ej ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+ G Fj panbankj @upkgej a Oao
. 6658 . 5%5&724. *244+
. 66+ Fo]g] V) ? naao AH) Fgac]u] H) H]j a` ] V) Fi ]e B)
Kk^ha K> ) ? kn` an T > + Daj a pdan]l u ^u ogahap]h
i qo_ha at l naooekj kb ` a_knej l nar aj po be^nkpe_ ` eoa]oa ej
n]p ge` j au+ K]p J a` . 6638 / %1&71. 5*1/ 0+
/ - - + Mqn_dek > C) @kkl an G> ) ? nqj j an > J ) I ekq^ej J K)
Daj pnu I B) Hkr ]_ej ] HP) Okpd O> ) J ]nmq]n` p E+
F` aj pebe_]pekj kb i ]j j koa 3*l dkol d]pa ej ps k ]ol ]n]*
cej a*hej ga` oqc]n _d]ej o kb na_ki ^ej ]j p pn]j obkni ej c
cnks pd b]_pkn*^ap] .
l na_qnokn+ G ? ekh @dai . 6558
/ 30%/ 5&7. 1/ . . *. 1/ . 2+
/ - . + Aaj j eo M> ) Oebgej A? + @ahhqh]n ]_per ]pekj kb h] paj p
pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn ^ap] namqenao ^ej ` ej c pk pda
_]pekj *ej ` al aj ` aj p
i ]j j koa
3*l dkol d]pa,ej oqhej *hega
cnks pd b]_pkn pul a FF na_al pkn+ Mnk_ K]ph > _]` P_e RP>
. 66. 8 55%/ &725- *251+
/ - / + J ]_@]hhekj O) Cancqokj j J + Cap]h s kqj ` da]hej c ]j `
pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb ]j peo_]nnej c pdan]l eao bkn ]` qhp
s kqj ` da]hej c+ Fj 7 @h]ng O) a` + Qda J kha_qh]n ]j ` @ahhqh]n
? ekhkcu kb T kqj ` Oal ]en+ Kas Vkng7 Mhaj qi Mnaoo) . 663+
/ - 0+ Pdecage P) J qn]g]i e Q) V]p] K) Fgqp] V+ Qna]pi aj p kb
gahke` ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ^u ekj pkl dknape_ pn]j o` an*
i ]h ` aher anu kb pn]j eh| op+ P_]j ` G Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc
E]j ` Pqnc . 6648 0. %/ &7 . 2. *. 25+
. 41+
A]nve J > ) @dks ` ne K> ) H]qh PH) Hd]j J + Br ]hq]pekj kb
r ]nekqo i apdk` o kb pna]pej c gahke` o ]j ` dul anpnkl de_
o_]no7 ] . - *ua]n bkhhks *ql opq` u+ ? n G Mh]op Pqnc . 66/ 8
12%2&7041*046+
. 42+
> l bah^anc A? ) J ]oan J O) I ]od E+ Qda qoa kb al e` ani eo
kr an ] gahke` ]o ]j ]qpkcn]bp ]bpan naoa_pekj kb pda gahke` +
G Aani ]pkh Pqnc . 6438 / %2&71- 6*1. . +
. 43+
O]qo_dan DB) Hkhi an T I + Qna]pi aj p kb na_qnnaj p a]nhk^a
gahke` o+ @qpeo . 6538 04%h&734*35+
. 44+
Eknpkj @B) @n]s bkn` G) L]gau OP+ J ]hecj ]j p _d]j ca ej
gahke` o+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6208 . / %. &753*56+
. 45+
Phk]j AC) ? nks j OA) T ahho @E) Eehpkj GD+ Qeooqa c]oao
ej dqi ]j dul anpnkl de_ ^qi o_]no+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc
. 6458 3. %0&710. *103+
. 46+
I ar u AP) P]hpan J J ) Okpd OB+ Mkopkl an]per a enn]` e]pekj
ej pda l nar aj pekj kb gahke` o+ > i G Okaj pcaj kh . 6438
. / 4%0&72- 6*2. - +
. 5-+
Cah` i ]j G+ Oa_kj opnq_pekj kb pda ^qnj a` b]_a ej _deh` naj +
Fj 7 Pan]bÄj A) Daknce]` a K) a` o+ Ma` e]pne_ Mh]ope_ Pqncanu+
Pp+ I kqeo7 @S J ko^u) . 651+
. 5. +
T ehhe]i okj GP) Pj ahhej c @C) @hqcopkj M) J ]_` kj ]h` F? )
Dani ]j j B+ @qhpqna` al epdahe]h ]qpkcn]bp7 ber a ua]no kb
_hej e_]h at l aneaj _a s epd ps aj pu*aecdp l ]peaj po+ G Qn]qi ]
. 6628 06%/ &70- 6*0. 6+
. 5/ +
J kvej ck AT + @ki l ]neokj kb pda ^eki a_d]j e_]h l nkl an*
peao kb ^qi o cn]bpa` s epd _kj r aj pekj ]h ol hep pde_g*
j aoo ogej r o+ Fj pacn] ]npebe_e]h ogej + . . pd Nq]` naj j e]h
@kj cnaoo kb pda Fj panj ]pekj ]h Pk_eapu bkn ? qi Fj fqneao)
Pa]ppha) T > ) / - - / +
. 50+
J keai aj KP) Pp]e]j k GG) Lfad KL) Qds ]u V) Cn]i a GA+
Oa_kj opnq_per a oqncanu s epd ] ` ani ]h nacaj an]pekj pai *
l h]pa7 _hej e_]h ]j ` deopkhkce_ opq` u+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc
/ - - . 8 . - 5%. &760ê . -0+
. 51+
> hopan Q+ I ]oan pna]pi aj p kb o_]no+ Fj 7 Mqhoan I ]oano
> aopdape_ ]j ` J a` e_]h @qp]j akqo > l l he_]pekj + ? kopkj 7
Aal ]npi aj p kb @kj pej qej c J a` e_]h B` q_]pekj ) . 663+
. 52+
Aeane_gt @) Dkh` i ]j J M) Cepvl ]pne_g OB+ I ]oan pna]pi aj p
kb anupdai ]pkqo,dul anpnkl de_ ]j ` l eci aj pa` o_]no ej / 3
l ]peaj po+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6628 62%. &751*6- 8 ` eo_qo*
oekj 6. *6/ +
. 53+ Pdane` ]j OI ) J ]_J ehh]j H) Akj ah]j J ) @dkq_]en O)
Dnar ahej g G) Mapn]o I ) I u` kj J ) Qki l gej o O+ Qqj ]^ha
` ua h]oan j akr aooah ]^h]pekj ]o ]j ]` fqj _p pk pda i ]j ]ca*
i aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c ej ^qnj a` _deh` naj 7 l ehkp
pne]h pk aop]^heod o]bapu+ G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh . 6648
. 5%1&70. 4*0/ - +
. 54+ H]hr ]gkh]j q AS ) ? kn` aj B@+ > j kr anr eas kb pda ej pan*
bankj ouopai 7 oecj ]h pn]j o` q_pekj ]j ` i a_d]j eoi o kb
]_pekj + @]j _an Fj r aop . 6638 . 1%h&7/ 2*20+
. 55+ E]nnkl > O) Dd]d]nu > ) P_kpp MD) Cknoupd K) Rfe*
Cnea` h]j ` >) Qna` cap BB+ Oacqh]pekj kb _khh]caj ouj pdaoeo
]j ` i OK> at l naooekj ej j kni ]h ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n
be^nk^h]opo ej r epnk ^u ej panbankj *c]i i ]+ G Pqnc Oao
. 6628 25%2&714. *144+
. 56+ Aqj _]j J O) E]o]j > ) ? ani ]j ? + Maj pkt ebuhhej a) l aj pe*
buhhej a) ]j ` ej panbankj o ` a_na]oa pul a F ]j ` FFF l nk_khh]caj
i OK> har aho ej ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo7 ar e` aj _a bkn

) 10

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
/ - 1+
Pqv]s ] E) Hegq_de P) > n]e K) Hk` ] >+ Qda i a_d]j eoi
ej r khr a` ej pda ej de^epknu ]_pekj kb pn]j eh]op kj _khh]caj
^ekouj pdaoeo kb gahke` be^nk^h]opo+ Gl j G Md]ni ]_kh . 66/ 8
3- %/ &76. ê 63+
/ - 2+
Hnkpvo_d*Dki av CB) Cqnqv]s ]*@]n^]hha` ] G) Oauao*
J ]nmqav O) Nqenkv*E ai ]j ` av B) Ae]v ` a I akj I +
@upkgej a at l naooekj eo ` ks j nacqh]pa` ^u _khh]caj *
l khu r ej uhl unnkhe` kj a ej dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ G Fj r aop
Aani ]pkh . 6658 hhh%2&75/ 5*501+
/ - 3+
Wdkq I G) Fj kqa J ) Dqj fe E) Lj k F) H]j agk C+ Bbba_po kb
l nkop]ch]j ` ej Bh kj _qhpqna` ` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo bnki
j kni ]h ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]nna` ogej + G Aani ]pkh Pae
. 6648 . 1%0&7/ . 4ê / / 1+
/ - 4+
Wdkq I G) Lj k F) H]j agk C+ Okha kb pn]j obkni ej c cnks pd b]_pkn*
^ap] . ej be^nk^h]opo ` aner a` bnki j kni ]h ]j ` dul anpnkl de_
o_]nna` ogej + > n_d Aani ]pkh Oao . 6648 / 56%. . &7313*32/ +
/ - 5+ Rj ai kne BK) Me_gbkn` I ? ) P]hhao > I ) Mean_u @B)
Dnkr a ? E) Bnegokj J B) > i aj pk BM+ Oah]t ej ej ` q_ao
]j at pn]_ahhqh]n i ]pnet *` acn]` ej c l daj kpul a ej dqi ]j
hqj c be^nk^h]opo ej r epnk ]j ` ej de^epo hqj c be^nkoeo ej
] i qnej a i k` ah ej r er k+ G @hej Fj r aop . 6638 65%. / &7
/ 406*/ 412+
/ - 6+ Akkj c
E)
Aeoo]j ]u]ga
P)
Dks neod]j g]n
QO)
I ]? ]n^an] J @) I aa O@+ Qda . 663 I ej ` ^anc > s ]n` +
@]h_eqi ]j p]ckj eopo ]hpan _ahh od]l a ]j ` ej ` q_a l nk*
_khh]caj ]oa ouj pdaoeo ej gahke` ]j ` j kni ]h dqi ]j
` ani ]h be^nk^h]opo+ G ? qnj @]na Oad]^eh . 6638 . 4%3 Mp . &7
164*2. 1+
/ . - + Akhuj _dqg HK) Weaoi ]j j J ) Panhappe GJ + Qkl e_]h
l qpnao_ej a %Ce^nkop]p& ej pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no7
l d]oa FF opq` u+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6638 64%. &7 . . 4ê . / 08
` eo_qooekj . / 1*. / 2+

#
? PbTab X] cWT GaTPc\ T] c ^U C^bcQda] FRPab
4 A: 8 ? B 6 4 CBMM<$ ; H: ; ?& I H$ 4 ? 5 8 EG >& B; $ FHM4 AA8 ?& > 3>F?C; FG +DGE?H7A ?A: F; C 379F7B ; CHD 7C: 5 C?J; FG?HM D< &7A?
ː
Mkop^qnj o_]nnej c nal naoaj po ] oecj ebe_]j p _hej e_]h l nk^hai
` qa pk ^kpd pda j qi ^an kb l ]peaj po s dk ` ar ahkl o_]no ]j `
pda j kpknekqohu ` ebbe_qhp pna]pi aj p kb pdaoa o_]no+ Qdaoa
o_]no _]j hei ep ok_e]h ej pan]_pekj ) j ac]per ahu ei l ]_p oahb*
aopaai ) ]j ` ]` r anoahu ]bba_p ` ]ehu ]_per epeao+ ? a_]qoa pdan*
i ]hhu ej ` q_a` o_]no ]na pul e_]hhu na_]h_epn]j p pk pna]pi aj p
ks ej c pk pdaen l nkheban]per a j ]pqna) pdaen ]l l nkl ne]pa
i ]j ]cai aj p nai ]ej o ] _d]hhaj ca+
Qda pna]pi aj p kb ^qnj o_]no ej _hq` ao ] i qhpepq` a kb
_dai e_]h) l duoe_]h) ]j ` oqnce_]h kl pekj o) ]j ` n]j cao
bnki _kj oanr ]per a i k` ]hepeao oq_d ]o opanke` ej fa_pekj o)
l naooqna c]ni aj po) ]j ` ]l l he_]pekj kb oehe_kj a cah odaapo)
pk i kna ej r ]oer a i a]oqnao ej _hq` ej c _nukpdan]l u) n]` e*
]pekj ) ] j ` ,kn at _eoekj +
Fj pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj kb _knpe_kopanke` o d]o ^aaj ]
op]j ` ]n` i k` ]hepu bkn pda pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]n*
nej c ej j kj ^qnj ej fqneao %. *0&+ Eks ar an) ^qi o_]no ]na
qoq]hhu i q_d h]ncan ]j ` i ]u ej r khr a ] h]nca ^k` u
oqnb]_a ]na] s epd ` eopknpekj kb i qhpel ha ]aopdape_ oq^qj epo)
i ]gej c ej fa_pekj kb pda aj pena o_]n ei l n]_pe_]h+ Fj ]` ` epekj
pk pda l ]ej ]ook_e]pa` s epd ej pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj ) _knpe_ko*
panke` o _]j ]hok ej ` q_a ogej ]pnkl du) pah]j cea_p]oe]o) ]j `
` uol eci aj p]pekj %0&+ Qda qoa kb l naooqna c]ni aj po ]j `
oehe_kj a cah odaapej c kn du` nk_khhke` ` naooej c eo aooaj pe]h
ej l kop^qnj o_]n i ]j ]cai aj p) ^qp pda naoqhpo ]na ` ah]ua`
]j ` i ]u ^a r ]ne]^ha %1*3&+ Fj ]` ` epekj ) o_]n l eci aj p]pekj
]j ` ahar ]pekj ]na kbpaj j kp _d]j ca` %4&+
@nukpdan]l u d]o ^aaj qoa` ^u oki a _aj pano ej pda i ]j *
]cai aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` gahke` o %5)6&+ Oaoqhpo)
dks ar an) ]na r ]nea` ]j ` oki a cnkql o d]r a nal knpa` j k
^aj abep bnki pda qoa kb _nukpdan]l u %. - ). . &+ > ` fqr ]j p
n]` ekpdan]l u bkhhks ej c oqnce_]h o_]n at _eoekj d]o ^aaj
qoa` bkn i ]j u ua]no ej pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb dul anpnkl de_
o_]no ]j ` gahke` o %. / *. 1&+ Eks ar an) pda h]nca oeva kb l kop*
^qi o_]no) ]o s ahh ]o ]ca) l nacj ]j _u) neog kb i ]hecj ]j _u)
]j ` oe` a abba_po oq_d ]o l eci aj p _d]j cao) anupdai ]) pah]j *
cea_p]oe]o) ]j ` ]pnkl du i ]u ]hh hei ep pda qoa kb n]` e]pekj ej
^qi o_]n i ]j ]cai aj p+ Pqnce_]h at _eoekj kb o_]n peooqa
s epd l nei ]nu o_]n nar eoekj kn ei i a` e]pa ogej cn]bpej c
_]j naoqhp ej ei l nkr a` bqj _pekj ]j ` n]j ca kb i kpekj +
Eks ar an) o_]n na_qnnaj _a eo _ki i kj ]j ` bej ]h _koi aoeo
eo kbpaj haoo pd]j ` aoen]^ha+
? acej j ej c ej pda a]nhu . 65- o) h]oano d]r a ^aaj qoa` ej
]j ]ppai l p pk an]` e_]pa o_]no+ S ]l knev]pekj h]oano s de_d
p]ncap s ]pan i kha_qhao) oq_d ]o pda _]n^kj ` ekt e` a
%@- /&) ]nckj ) ]j ` j ak` uj eqi 7 uppneqi *]hqi ej qi *c]nj ap
) 11
<&
<] ca^ Sd RcX^ ]
) 11
7 & 9 [PbW[P\ _ %Cd \ _ TS C 7 ?
*( *
<<&
F RPa 9 ^ a\ PcX^ ] X] 5 d \ b
*( (
8 Gd ] TPQ[T 7 h T ? PbTa
* ( *
<<<& ? PbTa Gh_ Tb P] S @TRWP] XRb
*( (
E I %5 TP\
C 7 ? F hbcT\
*( *
4 &
4 aV^ ] ? PbTa
*( (
F d \ \ Pah
*( +
5 &
A S 2L 4 : ? PbTa
*( )
E TUTaT] RTb
*( +
6 &
6 ^ _ _ Ta I P_ ^ a P] S 6 ^ _ _ Ta
5 a^ \ XST ? PbTab
*( )

200 (Nd: YAG), were initially used, but often led to immediate scar recurrence (15-17). In 1994, Alster (18) reported improvement in hypertrophic scar quality after treatment with the pulsed dye laser (PDL), which targets oxyhemo- globin. This particular laser has been used extensively in the management of vascular lesions such as port-wine stains (19-21). Scar flattening as well as a reduction in scar erythema has been noted after hypertrophic scars were treated with PDL (18). Currently, there is no consensus as to which is the "best" laser for the treatment of burn scars. Although the preference leans toward PDL systems, an array of vascu- lar-specific lasers are being used and potentially show improvement in burn scars. This chapter will describe current laser modalities in treating postburn scarring. Functional and Aesthetic Reconstruction of Burned Patients Minor injuries may produce very large lesions. Keloid scars are independent of motion or tension and have a high predilection for earlobes, shoulders, and presternal skin (23). III. LASER TYPES AND MECHANICS Problems with postburn scars can be divided into two main components: hypertrophy and erythema. To specifically treat burn scarring, the laser device must deliver a potent effect that will reduce both the thickness and the redness of the scar. In addition, patients with burn scars will often complain of itching or pruritis (24). Currently, there is no definitive data to show which is the "best" laser for the treatment of burn scars. Although the preference is currently leaning toward PDL systems, an array of vascular-specific lasers are being used and can potentially produce better results in the management of burn scars. The following is a list of laser systems for treating cutaneous vascular lesions that may have use in the treatment of burn scars. A. Argon Laser The argon laser was one of the first lasers used in the treat- ment of hypertrophic scars and keloids (3). This laser emits light at six wavelengths from 458 to 514 mm, with 80% of its emission at 488 and 534.4 nm. When used for II. SCAR FORMATION IN BURNS The color, size, and shape of the burn scar are determined by local cellular and humoral responses. Thermal injury immediately induces the body's wound healing response. These wound repair events can be grouped into three over- lapping phases: inflammation, regeneration, and remodel- ing (22). The inflammatory phase shows minimal clinical consequences in smaller burns, but can produce devastat- ing and lethal systemic sequelae in burns >25% total body surface area (TBSA). This phase is responsible for the large amount of fluid resuscitation needed during the first 24 h postburn injury. The inflammatory phase is fol- lowed by granulation tissue formation that consists of neo- vascularization accompanied by a dense population of macrophages and fibroblasts. Several months postburn injury, the wound will progress into the remodeling, phase in which there is reduction in the number and the activity of fibroblasts and vascularity accompanied by deposition, remodeling, and rearrangement of collagen. Collagen remodeling during scar formation is dependent on the balance between collagen synthesis and degradation. Burn injury produces various types of scars, ranging from atrophy to erythema, hypertrophy, and keloid for- mation. Hypertrophic and erythematous scar formation occurs commonly after burn injury. Patients with greater skin pigmentation have a higher likelihood of hypertrophic scar formation. Hypertrophic scarring is likely to develop when collagen synthesis prevails over catabolism during the remodeling phase of wound healing. In addition, hypertrophic scars tend to occur in areas of high tension or motion, that is, flexor surfaces such as joints and abdomen and are limited by the boundary of the wound. On the other hand, keloid scars are not limited by the wound boundary and tend to grow beyond the area of initial injury. This initial size of injury is often irrelevant and cannot be used to predict the formation of keloids. Figure 14.1 (See color insert) V-beam PDL system.

? PbTab X] GaTPc\ T] c ^U C^bcQda] FRPab

*( )
r ]o_qh]n haoekj o) 42" kb l ]peaj po _]j at l a_p ckk` pk at _ah*
haj p naoqhpo+ Eks ar an) ep eo ] _kj pej qkqo s ]r a h]oan ]j `
pdanabkna i ]u ` al koep i kna da]p) naoqhpej c ej ] i k` an]pa
neog kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c) aol a_e]hhu ej _deh` naj
%1*/ 0" &+ Oaoqhpo kb opq` eao bnki ]nckj h]oan pna]pi aj p kb
dul anpnkl de_ o_]n ]j ` gahke` o d]r a ^aaj i et a` %. 3)/ 2)/ 3&+
Fj ]` ` epekj ) na_qnnaj _a n]pao d]r a ^aaj decd %/ 4&+ Qdeo
h]oan eo n]nahu qoa` pk` ]u+
pdkoa haoekj o d]r ej c ] pde_g ^qhgu i ]oo+ Fp ]hok d]o ]
decdan neog kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c %/ 4&+ > i kna na_aj p
i k` ebe_]pekj kb pdeo h]oan d]o na` q_a` pda s ]r ahaj cpd pk
20/ j i ) i ]gej c ep l kpaj pe]hhu i kna qoabqh ej pna]pej c
o_]n l eci aj p]pekj s epdkqp pda decd ej _e` aj _a kb dul an*
pnkl de_ o_]n na_qnnaj _a %/ 6&+
6 &
6 ^ __Ta I P_^ a P] S 6 ^ __Ta 5 a^ \ XST ? PbTab
5 &
AS2L4 : ? PbTa
Qda knecej ]h K` 7V> D h]oan d]o ^aaj nal knpa` pk d]r a ^aj *
abepo ej pda pna]pi aj p kb oaha_pa` _qp]j akqo l eci aj pa`
haoekj o %/ 5&+ ? a_]qoa kb j kj ol a_ebe_ ^hkk` ]j ` peooqa ej pan*
]_pekj ]p pdeo s ]r ahaj cpd) dks ar an) pda ` al pd kb pdani ]h
ej fqnu eo ]o ` aal ]o 2*5 i i + Fpo qoabqhj aoo eo hei epa` pk
Qdeo h]oan ouopai d]o ] s ]r ahaj cpd kb 245 j i s de_d eo ej
pda dai kchk^ej ]^oknl pekj l a]g+ Eks ar an) ] oej cha l qhoa
i k` a i ]u j kp ` aher an aj kqcd aj ancu pk da]p ] r ]o_qh]n
haoekj pk ]j abbe_]_ekqo pai l an]pqna+ Qdanabkna) ep i qop
qoa ] pn]ej kb l qhoao) pdqo hkoej c pda _]l ]^ehepu pk i ej ei eva
_khh]pan]h ej fqnu %0- &+ Qdaoa ouopai o d]r a ] i q_d decdan
neog bkn o_]nnej c ]j ` ]na j kp _ki i kj hu qoa` pk` ]u+
9XVdaT ) , &*
!FTT R^ [^ a X] bTac" %> & M]peaj p s dk oqop]ej a` b]_e]h ^qi . 5 i kj pdo ]ck+ !5 " Kkpa ei l nkr a` ]l l a]n]j _a ]bpan bkqn pna] p*
i aj po s epd S *^a]i MAI ouopai + %@& Kkpa bqnpdan ei l nkr ai aj p ]bpan S *^a]i h]oan+ %A& Cqnpdan ei l nkr ai aj p j kpa` +

*( *

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
7 &
9[PbW[P\ _%Cd\ _TS C7 ?
Qdeo h]oan d]o odks j pda i kop l nki eoej c naoqhpo s epd
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` gahke` o %. 5)/ 0)/ 1)0. *00&+ MAI
ouopai o d]r a ]hok ^aaj qoa` ej pda pna]pi aj p kb kpdan
o_]no ]j ` ej pda l nkl duh]_pe_ pna]pi aj p kb ` aal ^qnj
s kqj ` o pk l nar aj p dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c s epd oki a
oq__aoo %01*03&+ MAI ouopai o d]r a i kna ol a_ebe_ ]^oknl *
pekj _d]n]_paneope_o bkn ej pn]r ]o_qh]n kt udai kchk^ej
%E ^- /&) pda pna]pi aj p p]ncap+ > hpdkqcd pda knecej ]h
i k` ah d]` ] s ]r ahaj cpd kb 244 j i ) pda j at p i k` ah d]`
] s ]r ahaj cpd kb 252 j i ]j ` oki a _qnnaj p i k` aho d]r a
s ]r ahaj cpdo ql pk 262 j i + Qdaoa s ]r ahaj cpdo ]na oaha_*
per ahu ]^okn^a` ^u E ^- / ej na` ^hkk` _ahho+ Qda al e` ani ]h
_ahho ]na ol ]na` ) aol a_e]hhu eb ] _kkhej c ouopai eo
ai l hkua` + Qda l qhoa ` qn]pekj s ]o knecej ]hhu gal p i q_d
odknpan pd]j pda pei a j a_aoo]nu pk ]hhks da]p pk ol na]`
bnki pda pna]pa` p]ncap pk pda oqnnkqj ` ej c peooqa+ Qdeo i ej e*
i eva` _khh]pan]h ` ]i ]ca pk ]` f]_aj p peooqao) ^qp kbpaj
_]qoa` l qnl qn] ` qa pk r aooah nql pqna+ Kas an i k` aho j ks
d]r a hkj can l qhoa s e` pdo pd]p ^appan i ]p_d r aooah oeva)
^qp l qhoa s e` pd i ]u j kp ^a ]o ei l knp]j p bkn o_]n
nai k` ahej c+
8&
Gd] TPQ[T 7 hT ? PbTa
> j kpdan ]l l nk]_d pk pna]pi aj p kb r ]o_qh]n haoekj o d]o ^aaj
pda i ape_qhkqo pn]_ej c kb r aooaho qoej c ] . -- Pj _ ol kp oeva
]p 244 j i s ]r ahaj cpd caj an]pa` ^u ]j ]nckj *l qi l a`
pqj ]^ha ` ua h]oan+ Qdeo h]oan eo oei eh]n pk pda MAI ) ^qp
s epd ] bej an _kj pnkh kb ol kp oeva+ > hpdkqcd pdana eo ] 2"
n]pa kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c) oki a ej r aopec]pkno bkqj `
pdeo pa_dj emqa pk ^a r anu o]ba ]j ` abba_per a ej ^kpd
]` qhpo ]j ` _deh` naj %04)05&+ Qdeo h]oan ]hok d]o ckk` l kpaj *
pe]h bkn pda pna]pi aj p kb ^qnj o_]no+
9&
I %5 TP\ C7 ? FhbcT\
Qdeo h]oan eo ] hkj c l qhoa*` qn]pekj 262 j i MAI ouopai
%Cec+ . 1+. & s de_d s a d]r a ^aaj qoej c ]p Pdnej ano Ekol ep]ho
bkn @deh` naj kb Kknpdanj @]hebknj e] bkn l kop^qnj o_]no+ Mne*
i ]nehu qoa` bkn r ]o_qh]n haoekj o) aol a_e]hhu pdkoa naoeop]j p
pk kpdan h]oan ouopai o %06&) pda S *? a]i MAI ouopai
]l l a]no pk ei l nkr a pda dul anpnkl du ]j ` na` j aoo kb ^qnj
o_]no s epd hei epa` ` eo_ki bknp bkn pda l ]peaj p %Ceco+ . 1+/
]j ` . 1+0&+ Fj ]` ` epekj ) ep _]j ` a_na]oa pda l nqnepeo ]j `
9XVdaT ) , &+
!FTT R^ [^ a X] bTac" %>& M]peaj p s epd _daop ^qnj
o_]n+ %? & Mdkpkcn]l da` ]bpan bkqn pna]pi aj po s epd pda MAI
ouopai +
9XVdaT ) , &,
!FTT R^ [^ a X] bTac" %> & M]peaj p s epd d]j ` o_]no
bkhhks ej c ^qnj . *ua]n ]ck+ %? & > bpan pdnaa pna]pi aj po s epd
S *^a]i MAI ouopai ) pda o_]no ]na okbpan ]j ` i kna l he]^ha+ Qda
l ]peaj p ]hok nal knpa` haoo dul anoaj oeper epu+

?PbTab X] GaTPc\ T] c ^U C^bcQda] FTPab

*( +
pecdpj aoo kbpaj ]ook_e]pa` s epd ^qi o_]no+ Ckhhks ej c pna]p*
i aj p) o_]no kbpaj ^a_ki a i kna l he]^ha ]j ` l ]peaj po d]r a
aj d]j _a` n]j ca kb i kpekj + M]peaj po ]hok nal knp haoo ogej
dul anoaj oeper epu pk pkq_d ]o s ahh %Cec+ . 1+1&+
@koi aoeo _]j ^a ei l nkr a` ]o oi kkpd ]j ` nacqh]n hej a`
o_]no ^a_ki a okbpan ]j ` i kna ennacqh]n) pdana^u j kp
]ppn]_pej c qj s ]j pa` ]ppaj pekj + Qda S *? a]i MAI ouopai
9XVdaT ) , &.
!FTT R^ [^ a X] bTac" %>& M]peaj p s dk oqbbana` ^qi o
]bpan pna]pi aj p s epd @- / h]oan . *ua]n ]ck+ %? & > bpan kj a pna]pi aj p
s epd S *^a]i MAI ouopai ) pdana eo ei l nkr a` _khkn ]j ` l he]^ehepu+
d]o ^aaj qoa` pk pna]p @- / h]oan o_]no s epd ckk` naoqhpo
%Ceco+ . 1+2 ]j ` . 1+3&+ > hpdkqcd pda i a_d]j eoi kb ]_pekj
nai ]ej o pk ^a bqhhu ahq_e` ]pa` ) oar an]h pdakneao at eop
ej _hq` ej c ] nah]per a dul kt e] ej ` q_a` ^u pda h] oanîo
r ]o_qh]n ol a_ebe_epu) ]j ]hpan]pekj ej pda n]pek kb pul ao F
]j ` FFF _khh]caj ) pda ` eook_e]pekj kb ` eoqhbe` a ^kj ` o s epd
na]nn]j cai aj p kb _khh]caj ) ]j ` pda nah]per a ej _na]oa ej
i ]op _ahho j kpa` ej h]oan pna]pa` o_]no s de_d i ]u i k` qh]pa
be^nk^h]ope_ cnks pd ]j ` kpdan b]_pkno %0)/ 0)0. &+
I ]oano ]l l a]n pk d]r a l kpaj pe]h ej pda pna]pi aj p kb l kop*
^qnj o_]no+ Oaoqhpo pk ` ]pa oaai pk ej ` e_]pa pd]p pda MAI
ouopai o ]l l a]n pk ^a pda ^aop i k` ]hepu bkn okbpaj ej c)
ej _na]oej c l he]^ehepu) ]j ` ` a_na]oej c dul anoaj oeper epu kb
^qnj o_]no+ MAI ouopai o ]hok ei l nkr a _koi aoeo ^u
` a_na]oej c anupdai ]) bh]ppaj ej c o_]no) ]j ` l nki kpej c
napqnj kb i kna j kni ]h ogej i ]ngej co+ @kj beni ]pekj kb
pdaoa naoqhpo s ehh namqena h]ncan opq` eao+
E8 98 E8 A6 8 F
.+
Dnebbepd S E+ Qda pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o s epd pne]i _ej khkj a
]_apkj e` a+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6338 057/ - / */ - 5+
/ +
Hap_dqi I A) Ok^ej okj AT ) J ]opano CT + Ckhhks *ql kj
pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` gahke` o s epd pne] i _ej k*
hkj a+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 64. 8 157/ 23*/ 26+
0+
> hopan QP) T aop Q? + Qna]pi aj p kb o_]no7 ] nar eas + > j j
Mh]op Pqnc . 6648 0671. 5*10/ +
9XVdaT ) , &- %Paa _khkn ej oanp& %> & M]peaj p . *ua]n ]bpan ^qi
_ki l he_]pekj kb @- / h]oan pna]pi aj p+ %? & Kkpa ei l nkr a` _khkn
]j ` pat pqna bkhhks ej c ps k pna]pi aj po s epd S *^a]i MAI ouopai +

*( ,

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
1+
? knckcj kj e I + ? ekhkce_]h abba_po kb oehe_kj a cah odaapej c+
T kqj ` Oal ]en Oacaj / - - / 8 . -%/ &7 . . 5*. / . +
2+
Nqej j HG) Br ]j o GE) @kqnpj au GJ ) D]uhkn GA) Oae` T E+
Kkj *l naooqna pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ ? qi o Fj _h
Qdani Fj f . 6528 . / 7. - / *. - 5+
3+
> dj PQ) J kj ]bk T T ) J qopka Q> + Qkl e_]h oehe_kj a cap7 ]
j as pna]pi aj p bkn dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ Pqncanu . 6568
. - 3745. *453+
4+ Mdehhel o QG) Danopaej > A) I kn` ]j S+ > n]j ` ki eva` _kj *
pnkhha` pne]h kb du` nk_khhke` ` naooej c ej pda pna]pi aj p kb
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` gahke` o+ Aani ]pkh Pqnc . 6638
/ / 7442*445+
5+
Oqo_e]j e I ) Okooa D) ? kj k O+ Roa kb _nukpdan]l u ej pda
pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o+ G Aani ]pkh Pqnc Lj _kh . 6608
. 672/ 6*201+
6+
Wkq^kqheo @@) ? hqi a R) ? Öppj an M) Lnb]j ko @B+ L qp_ki a
kb _nukoqncanu ej gahke` o ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ > n_d
Aani ]pkh . 6608 . / 67. . 13*. . 2. +
. -+ J qpe B) Mkj vek B+ @nukpdan]l u ej pda pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o+
> j j Mh]op Pqnc . 6508 . . 7/ / 4*/ 0/ +
. . + Pdal dan` GM) A]s ^an OC+ Qda naol kj oa kb gahke` o o_]no pk
_nukpdan]l u+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 65/ 8 4- 7344*35/ +
. / + ? knkg QI ) ? n]u J ) Pej _h]en F) Mh]bgan G) I ]? enpd I )
Okhhej o @+ Okha kb ekj evej c enn]` e]pekj bkn 060 gahke` o+ Fj p
G O]` e]p Lj _kh ? ekh Mduo . 6558 . 27532*54- +
. 0+ Bj d]i na > ) E ]i i ]n E+ Qna]pi aj p kb gahke` o s epd at _eoekj
]j ` l kop*kl an]per a U*n]u enn]` e]pekj + Aani ]pkhkce_] . 6508
. 3476- *60+
. 1+ O]ckks ]j oe O) @ki ao MDP) J koo > I ) Dhaao GM+ Qna]pi aj p
kb gahke` o ^u oqnce_]h at _eoekj ]j ` ei i a` e]pa l kopkl an]per a
oej cha*bn]_pekj n]` ekpdan]l u+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc / - - 08
. . . 7. 520*. 526+
. 2+ > l bah^anc A) J ]oan J ) T depa A+ C]ehqna kb _]n^kj
` ekt e` a h]oan at _eoekj kb gahke` o+ I ]oano Pqnc J a` . 6568
6705/ *055+
. 3+ E qho^ancaj *E aj j ej c GM) Okog]i V) r ]j Dai anp J G+ Qna]p*
i aj p kb gahke` o ]j ` dul anpknl de_ o_]no s epd ]j ]nckj h]oan+
I ]oano Pqnc J a` . 6538 374/ *42+
. 4+ Pdani ]j O) Okoaj bah` E+ Bt l aneaj _a s epd pda K` 7V> D
h]oan ej pda pna]pi aj p kb gahke` o_]no+ > j j Mh]op Pqnc
. 6558 / . 7/ 0. */ 02+
. 5+ > hopan Q+ Fi l nkr ai aj p kb anupdai ]pkqo ]j ` dul anpnkl de_
o_]no ^u pda 252 j i bh]odh]i l l qi l a` l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+
> j j Mh]op Pqnc . 6618 0/ 7. 53*. 6- +
. 6+ > j ` anokj OO) M]nneod G> + Paha_per a l dkpkpdani khuoeo7
l na_eoa i e_nkoqncanu ^u oaha_per a ]^oknl pekj kb l qhoa` n]` e*
]pekj + P_eaj _a . 6508 / / - 72/ . *2/ 4+
/ - + > odej kbb O) Dankj ai qo) O+ @]l ehh]nu dai ]j ceki ]o ]j `
pna]pi aj p s epd pda bh]od h]i l *l qi l a` l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+
> n_d Aani ]pkh . 66. 8 . / 47/ - / */ - 2+
/ . + > odej kbb O) Dankj ai qo O+ Qna]pi aj p kb ] l knp*s ej a op]ej
ej ] ^h]_g l ]peaj p s epd pda l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+ G Aani ]pkh
Pqnc Lj _kh . 66/ 8 . 57. 14*. 15+
/ / + Dh]p MJ ) I kj c]gan J Q+ T kqj ` da]hej c+ Fj 7 > opkj PG)
? a]ohau OT ) Qdki a @EJ )
a` o+ Mh]ope_
Pqncanu+
Mdeh]` ahl de]7 I el l ej _kpp) . 66470*. / +
/ 0+
> hopan Q+ I ]oan pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no) gahke` o ]j `
opne]a+ Aani ]pkh @hej . 6648 . 271. 6*1/ 6+
/ 1+ > hheokj H) Heai ]j J ) T ]pano O) @hai aj p O+ Mqhoa` ` ua
h]oan pna]pi aj p kb ^qi o_]no+ > hhar e]pekj kn ennep]pekj <
? qi o / - - 08 / 67/ - 4*/ . 0+
/ 2+ > l bah^anc A? ) J ]oan J O) I ]od E) T depa A) T aopkj G+
Mnahei ej ]nu naoqhpo kb ]nckj ]j ` _]n^kj ` ekt e` a h]oan pna]p*
i aj p kb gahke` o_]no+ I ]oano Pqnc J a` . 6518 17/ 50*/ 6- +
/ 3+
Dej o^]_d D) Hkdj ah T + Qda pna]pi aj p kb dul anpnkl de_
o_]no ]j ` gahke` o ^u ]nckj *h]oan7 _hej e_]h ` ]p] ]j ` i knl dk*
hkce_ bej ` ej co+ Mh]op Pqnc Cknqi . 6458 . 73. *34+
/ 4+
Dnkooi ]j J @) H]qr ]n > K? ) Dankj ai qo OD+ @qp]j akqo
h]oan oqncanu+ Fj 7 > opkj PG) ? a]ohau OT ) Qdki a @EJ ) a`o+
Mh]ope_ Pqncanu+ Mdeh]` ahl de]7 I el l ej _kpp) . 6647/ - 2*/ . 6+
/ 5+ I ]og DM) Dh]oo^anc B+ Kak` ui eqi 7uppneqi *]hhqi ej qi *
c]i ap h]oan bkn pda pna]pi aj p kb _qp]j akqo haoekj o+ @hej
Aani ]pkh . 6628 . 075. *53+
/ 6+
? ks ao I B) Kkqne H) ? ani ]j ? ) Gei aj av D) M]n` k O)
Ok` necqav I ) Pl aj _an GJ + Qna]pi aj p kb l eci aj pa` dul an*
pnkl de_ o_]no s epd pda 252 j i l qhoa` ` ua h]oan ]j ` pda
20/ j i bnamqaj _u*` kq^ha` K` 7V> D h]oan ej pda m*os ep_da`
]j ` r ]ne]^ha l qhoa i k` ao7 ] _ki l ]n]per a opq` u+ Aani ]pkh
Pqnc / - - / 8 / 574. 1*4. 6+
0-+ E]a` ano` ]h
J )
Qdangeh` oaj
M)
? a_d*Qdki oaj
K)
Mkqhoaj Q) T qhb E@+ Pe` a abba_po bnki ` ani ]pkhkce_]h
h] oan pna]pi aj p nah]pa` pk RS at l koqna ]j ` al e` ani ]h pde_g*
j aoo7 ] i qnej a at l anei aj p s epd pda _kl l an r ]l kn h]oan+
I ]oano Pqnc J a` . 6648 / - %0&7/ 00*/ 1. +
0. +
Aeane_gt @) Dkh` i ]j J ) Cepvl ]pne_g O+ I ]oan pna]pi aj p kb
anupdai ]pkqo ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ ]j ` l eci aj pa` o_]no ej / 3
l ]peaj po+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6628 62751*6- +
0/ +
> hopan Q) T ehhe]i o @+ Qna]pi aj p kb gahke` opanj kpki u o_]no
s epd 252 j i bh]odh]i l *l qi l a` l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+ I ]j _ap
. 6628 0127. . 65*/ - - - +
00+ J ]j qoge]ppe T ) Cepvl ]pne_g O+ Qna]pi aj p naol kj oa kb gahke*
` ]h ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ opanj kpki u o_]no+ > n_d Aani ]pkh
/ - - / 8 . 057. . 16*. . 22+
01+ > hopan Q) Hqn^]j > ) Dnkr a D) Dnkr a J ) Q]j L+ > hpan]pekj
kb ]nckj ej ` q_a` o_]no ^u pda l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+ I ]oano Pqnc
J a` . 6608 . 07035*040+
02+ > hopan Q) J _J aagej Q+ Fi l nkr ai aj p kb b]_e]h ]_j a o_]no ^u
pda 252 j i bh]odh]i l *l qi l a` l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+ G > i > _]`
Aani ]pkh . 6638 02746*5. +
03+ I eas P) J qneokj J ) Ae_gokj T + Mnkl duh]_pe_ pna]pi aj p kb
` aal ` ani ]h ^qi o_]no pk l nar aj p dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c
qoej c pda l qhoa` ` ua h]oan7 ] l nahei ej ]nu opq` u+ > j j Mh]op
Pqnc / - - / 8 16714/ *142+
04+ D]opkj M) Eqi v]d J ) Nq]^] > + Qda l qhoa` pqj a]^ha ` ua
h]oan ]o ]j ]e` ej pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb l kop^qi o_]nnej c+
? qi o . 6638 / / 7/ - 0*/ - 2+
05+ O]ej a @) > h*K]ge^ H) Nq]^] > > + > nkha bkn h]oano ej
pda pna]pi aj p kb l eci aj pa` ogej cn]bpo+ ? qi o . 6648
/ 0731. *311+
06+ I ]q^a P) Q]e^faa P) I ]j ec]j PT + Qna]pi aj p kb naoeop]j p
l knp s ej a op]ej o s epd pda S *^a]i l qhoa` ` ua h]oan+ I ]oano
Pqnc J a` / - - 08 007/ 5/ */ 54+

$
8 eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT
@4 E6 9HA> 8 $ @4 E6 HF FC<8 F$ C8 G8 E @& I B: G
. ; : ?N?C?G9>; +D9>G9>I A; +7CCDJ; F! +7CCDJ; F! * ; FB 7CM
<&
4 RR^ aSX] V c^ aTRT] c [XcTaPcd aT * - %- ( ^ U P[[ bTeTaT Qd \ b
X] e ^ [e T cWT WTPS P] S ] TRZ aTVX^ ] & 5 d \ b X] cWXb aTVX^ ] aT_ %
aTbT] c b^ \ T ^ U cWT \ ^ bc RWP[[T] VX] V _ a^ Q[T\ b X] _ [PbcXR
bd aVTah& GWT d aVT] Rh UT[c c^ aTR^ ] bcad Rc cWT Qd a] TS UPRT
Xb \ PX] [h SdT c^ cWT bTeTaT STU^ a\ XcXTb f XcW Ud ] RcX^ ] P[
X\ _ PXa\ T] c& GWXb aTbd[cb X] Va^bb e Xbd P[ PQ] ^ a\ P[XcXTb
P] S T] ^ a\ ^ d b _ bhRW^ [^ VXRP[ _ a^ Q[T\ b ^ U cWT _ PcXT] cb& <]
PSSXcX^ ] $ UPRXP[ Qd \ b X] RWX[SaT] \ Ph QT Pbb^ RXPcTS f XcW
P WXVW aXbZ ^ U UPRXP[ Va^ f cW X] WXQXcX^ ] P] S bdQbT` dT] c
[^bb ^ U Ud ] RcX^ ] &
GWT ePbc \ PY^ aXch ^ U Qd \ STU^ a\ XcXTb aTbd [cX] V X] Ud ] R%
cX^ ] P[ _ a^ Q[T\ b ch_ XRP[[h bTT] X] _Pbc STRPSTb RP] QT
T[X\ X] PcTS Qh _ a^ _ Ta PRdcT RPaT P] S P caTPc\ T] c bcaPcTVh$
f WXRW X] R[d STb bW^ ac% P] S [^ ] V%cTa\ V^ P[b U^ a TPRW
_ PcXT] c& 4 Rd cT RPaT Xb PX\ TS Pc bd ae Xe P[ P] S f ^ d ] S R^ e Ta%
PVT& E TR^ ] bcad RcX^ ] X] e ^ [e Tb Q^ cW bW^ ac%cTa\ P] S [^ ] V%
cTa\ V^ P[b& F W^ ac%cTa\ V^ P[b PaT cWT aTbc^ aPcX^ ] ^ U cWT
_ PcXT] cpb aP] VT ^ U \ ^ cX^ ] P] S WXb Ud ] RcX^ ] P[ PQX[XcXTb&
? ^ ] V%cTa\ V^ P[b X] R[d ST \ d [cX_ [T aTR^ ] bc\ RcXe T _ a^ %
RTSdaTb PX\ X] V Pc cWT QTbc UTPbXQ[T aTX] cTVaPcX^ ] X] c^
b^ RXTch X] R^ \ QX] PcX^ ] f XcW _ bhRW^ [^ VXRP[ R^ d ] bT[X] V
P] S cWTaP_ h c^ R^ \ _ T] bPcT U^ a cWT Ud ] RcX^ ] P[ [^bb Pbb^ RX%
PcTS f XcW Qd \ b&
: ^ ^ S bd aVXRP[ _ aPRcXRT Xb P[f Phb P \ PY^ a ZTh c^ Qd \
aTR^ ] bc\ RcX^ ] & GWXb \ TP] b RW^ ^ bX] V cWT QTbc ^ _ TaPcX^ ]
Pc cWT QTbc cX\ T U^ a cWT _ PcXT] c& G^ PRWXTe T cWXb V^ P[$ cWT
_ PcXT] c WPb c^ cPZT _ Pac X] cWT STRXbX^ ] \ PZX] V _a^ RTbb
P] S cWT _ [P] ] X] V ^ U cWT _ a^ RTSd aT& GWT _ PcXT] c \ d bc Ud [[h
*( -
F+
Fj pnk` q_pekj
/ - 2
>+ Cqj _pekj ]h Aabe_epo
/ . /
FF+
> _qpa Qn]qi ]7 Ll an]per a r o+ @kj oanr ]per a
Z
Buahe` o
/ . /
Qdan]l u ]j ` Mnar aj pekj kb
Z M o
x$ /
Pa_kj ` ]nu Aabkni epeao
/ - 3
Z Ka_g
/ . /
>+
Mnej _el hao ]j ` Lpdan @kj oe` an]pekj o
/ - 3
? * > aopdape_ Oa_kj opnq_pekj
/ . /
? +
P_]hl
/ - 4
@ Aa_eoekj J ]gej c
/ . 0
@+
C]_a
/ - 5
A$ Pgej J ]p_d
/ . 1
f&
c ]no
/ - 5
@ki l naooekj Qdan]l u
/ . 1
B+$
Buahe` o ]j ` Bua^nks o
/ - 6
O > npebe_e]h Pgej @kr an]ca
/ . 2
l
Kkoa
/ . -
.
Qai l kn]nu Pgej @kr an]ca
D+
I el o ]j ` J kqpd
/ . -
J ]pane]ho
/ . 2
E
Ka_g
/ . .
Mani ]j aj p Pgej @kr an]ca
/ . 2
F+
Mnar aj pekj kb Pa_kj ` ]nu Mnk^hai o
/ . .
FS + Cqpqna Manol a_per ao
/ . 3
FFF+
Oa_kj opnq_per a @kj oe` an]pekj o ]j ` Mh]j j ej c
/ . /
Oabanaj _ao
/ . 3

*( .

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
qj ` anop]j ` ]j ` ]__al p pda oqnce_]h k^fa_per ao+ Fj ]` ` epekj )
l ]peaj po i qop j kp kj hu ^a bqhhu ]s ]na kb pda hei ep]pekj o kb
b]_e]h na_kj opnq_pekj ) ^qp ]hok i qop ]__al p pdai + Qdana ]na
j k i en]_hao ej l h]ope_ oqncanu+ > j kl aj ` eo_qooekj ^aps aaj
pda oqncakj ]j ` pda l ]peaj p) nah]per a pk pda k^fa_per ao) pda
l h]j o) ]j ` pda hei ep]pekj o kb a]_d l nk_a` qna) dahl o pk
i ej ei eva l kopkl an]per a ` eo_kj paj p+
Qda pei ej c kb na_kj opnq_pekj i ]u ^a ` ebbe_qhp) ]o _ki *
l hapa o_]n i ]pqn]pekj eo l nabanna` l nekn pk na_kj opnq_pekj +
Eks ar an) ei i a` e]pa kn a]nhu na_kj opnq_per a l nk_a` qnao
i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu pk l nar aj p bqj _pekj ]h naopne_pekj o ej
]_per epeao kb ` ]ehu her ej c kn _knna_p n]l e` hu l nkcnaooer a
]j ` ` eo]^hej c ` abkni epeao+ Fb pda na_kj opnq_per a opn]pacu
ej _hq` ao s ]epej c bkn bqhh o_]n i ]pqn]pekj ) pdan]l u s epd
l naooqna c]ni aj p kn oehe_kj a odaapej c i ]u ^a ] ckk` pa_d*
j emqa pk ]ooeop o_]n i ]pqn]pekj +
<<&
4 6 HG8 GE4 H@4 2 BC8 E4 G6 BAF8 EI 4 GCE8 I 8 AG7 8 9BE@4 &
CaX] RX_[Tb P] S B cWTa 6 ^ ] bXSTaPcX^ ] b
Qda ej ` er e` q]h ^k` u ei ]ca ` abej ao kj a kb pda i kop ei l knp*
]j p ]ol a_po kb l anokj ]h e` aj pepu+ Qk` ]uîo ok_eapu at l a_po ]
l anba_p ]l l a]n]j _a s epdkqp ]j u opeci ]+ > __kn` ej c pk _kj *
pai l kn]nu hebaopuha i ]c]vej ao) ] l anba_p ^k` u ]j ` ]l l a]n*
]j _a ]na l naoaj pa` ]o ] bqj ` ]i aj p]h _kj ` epekj bkn ]
oq__aoobqh ok_e]h ]j ` ^qoej aoo _]naan+ ? qnj o l ]peaj po i ]u
hkoa pdeo ^]oe_ mq]hebe_]pekj + Qda naej pacn]pekj kb l ]peaj po
ej pk ok_eapu i ]u ^a d]i l ana` ^u ^kpd ]aopdape_ ]j `
bqj _pekj ]h ` abe_epo+
? qi na_kj opnq_pekj kb b]_e]h ` abkni epeao eo ] r anu ` ahe*
_]pa l ]np kb pda l ] peaj pîo nad]^ehep]pekj + Ee` ej c oar ana
` abkni epeao ^u qoej c _]oq]h kn ahac]j p _hkpdej c eo j kp l koo*
e^ha+ Lj ] ` ]ehu ^]oeo) pda l ]peaj p ]j ` deo aj r enkj i aj p ]na
_kj bnkj pa` s epd pda _kj oamqaj _ao kb pda ^qnj pn]qi ] ]j `
epo l ]ej bqh ]j ` qj ]l l a]hej c o_]no+ Qda h]_g kb pkp]h ]__al *
p]j _a) _ki ^ej a` s epd pda kbpaj ]ccnaooer a na]_pekj o ^u
l aano) qncao pda l ]peaj p s epd b]_e]h ^qnj o pk l naoo deo
oqncakj bkn a]nhu na_kj opnq_per a l nk_a` qnao) dkl ej c pk
cap ne` kb pda pn]qi ]pevej c b]_e]h o_]no+
? abkna l h]j j ej c ]j u oqnce_]h l nk_a` qna) ] ` ap]eha` at ]i *
ej ]pekj ]j ` ar ]hq]pekj kb pda l ]ppanj o kb ` abkni epu d]o pk ^a
l anbkni a` pk k^p]ej ] nahe]^ha ]j ` s ahh*` k_qi aj pa` op]pqo
mqk ]j pa+ Aal aj ` ej c kj pda _hej e_]h ar ]hq]pekj ) ]j ej r aj pknu
kb odknp* ]j ` hkj c*pani ck]ho odkqh` ^a ol a_ebea` ]j ` ]
ol a_ebe_ pdan]l u l nkcn]i odkqh` ^a aop]^heoda` +
? qnj na_kj opnq_pekj ^acej o s epd pda ]_qpa ]` i eooekj bkn
^qnj pn]qi ]+ Rncaj p l nk_a` qnao d]r a pk ^a l anbkni a`
s epdej dkqno ]bpan ]` i eooekj pk l naoanr a ei l knp]j p bqj _*
pekj ]h opnq_pqnao) oq_d ]o at l koa` ^kj a) _]npeh]ca)
r aooaho) fkej po) kn _knj a]o+ Fj pda nad]^ehep]pekj l d]oa kb
pna]pi aj p) i qhpel ha*op]ca` l nk_a` qnao d]r a pk ^a l anbkn*
i a` pk ei l nkr a bqj _pekj + T epd _ki l hapa` o_]n i ]pqn]pekj
]p . / *. 5 i kj pdo ]bpan ^qi ej fqnu) ` abej epa na_kj opnq_per a
l nk_a` qnao j aa` pk ^a l h]j j a` ]__kn` ej c pk pda l ]peaj pîo
l neknepeao+
P_]n i ]pqn]pekj eo aooaj pe]h pk k^p]ej ckk` oqnce_]h ]j `
]aopdape_ naoqhpo ej da]` ]j ` j a_g na_kj opnq_pekj + Lj hu ej ]
bas _]oao s ehh o_]n i ]pqn]pekj s epd pei a ]hhks bkn oecj ebe*
_]j p ei l nkr ai aj p kb o_]no ^u okbpaj ej c ]j ` napqnj pk
j kni ]h _khkn]pekj ) pat pqna) ]j ` _kj pkqn+ Rj bknpqj ]pahu)
pdaoa _]oao ]na n]na+ Qk ` ]pa) j k i a]j o at eop pk l na` e_p
pda kqp_ki a ej ]j u ej ` er e` q]h l ]peaj p+ Eks ar an) pul e_]h
]na]o namqenej c i kj epknej c bkn bqpqna ` ai ]j ` kb oqnce_]h
_knna_pekj _]j ^a e` aj pebea` ej i kop l ]peaj po) oq_d ]o pda
auahe` o) _ki i eooqnao) ]j ` j a_g+ Qk ]__ahan]pa o_]n i ]pq*
n]pekj ]j ` _kj pnkh dul anpnkl de_ ^qi o_]n bkni ]pekj ) _kj *
oanr ]per a pdan]l u ]ppai l po ej _hq` ej c l naooqna c]ni aj po
]j ` oehe_kj a odaapej c d]r a l nkr aj pk ^a pdan]l aqpe_
kl pekj o+ Qdana ]na ] j qi ^an kb j kj kl an]per a pa_dj emqao
]r ]eh]^ha pk ej bhqaj _a pda da]hej c kb ^qnj o_]no kn pk
ei l nkr a hk_]h ogej l nkl anpeao bkn oq^oamqaj p oqncanu+
Qda _kj pej qkqo qoa kb _ki l naooekj ]bpan b]_e]h ^qnj o
d]r a naal epdahe]heva` na` q_ao pda paj ` aj _u pk ` ar ahkl
dul anpnkl de_ o_]no+ Pq_d o_]no ]na ]aopdape_]hhu qj ]ppn]_*
per a ]j ` i ]u _]qoa b]_e]h ` eopknpekj o ^u l nk` q_ej c o_]n
_kj pn]_pqnao+ > j qi ^an kb pa_dj e_]h ]` r ]j _ao ej pdeo
]na] d]r a ^aaj ` ar ahkl a` ej pda h]op bas ua]no+ Qda qoa
kb l naooqna c]ni aj po eo pda i ]ej op]u kb pdaoa pdan]l aqpe_
opn]paceao+ Eks ar an) kbpaj pai l kn]nu c]ni aj po kn ah]ope_
s n]l o ]na qoa` qj peh _qopki *i ]` a c]ni aj po _]j ^a
beppa` + > j ]__qn]pa i a]oqnai aj p ]j ` _qopki bep ]na ]j
aooaj pe]h l ]np kb pdeo l naooqna pdan]l u ]j ` ol a_e]h at l ane*
aj _a eo j aa` a` pk l nkr e` a ] _knna_p beppej c bkn ej ` er e` q]h
l nk^hai vkj ao+ > _nq_e]h l ]np kb _ki l naooekj pdan]l u eo
pk i kper ]pa pda l ]peaj p ]j ` ]_dear a oqbbe_eaj p _kkl an]pekj
pk _kj pej qkqohu s a]n pda l naooqna c]ni aj po+ @kj op]j p
bkhhks *ql eo j a_aoo]nu pk aj oqna pd]p pda c]ni aj po
nai ]ej ej ] l nkl an op]pa kb nal ]en ]j ` pd]p pdaen bep eo _kj *
pej qkqohu ]` fqopa` pk i ]ej p]ej ]` amq]pa _ki l naooekj + Fj
]` ` epekj ) ] r ]neapu kb pdani kl h]ope_ i ]pane]ho ]na qoa` pk
l nk` q_a nece` ) _qopki *i kh` a` b]_ai ]ogo+ Qdaoa i ]ogo
l nkr e` a oqbbe_eaj p l naooqna kj da]hej c ]na]o ]j ` dul an*
pnkl de_ o_]no+ Qn]j ol ]naj p i ]pane]h a]oao ` ena_p ej ol a_pekj
kb pda qj ` anhuej c ogej %. )/ &+
Lpdan qoabqh j kj kl an]per a pa_dj emqao pk ]p ha]op l ]n*
pe]hhu ej bhqaj _a b]_e]h o_]n bkni ]pekj eo pda qoa kb pkl e_]h
l d]ni ]_khkce_]h ]caj po) oq_d ]o pda qoa kb pkl e_]h
r ep]i ej B ]j ` pkl e_]h kn ej pn]haoekj ]h ej fa_pekj kb opanke` o+
@kj _aj pn]pa` r ep]i ej B keh ]j ` - +- / 2" Qne]i _ej khkj a ]na
qoa` ej pkl e_]h l nal ]n]pekj o+ Fb pkl e_]h qoa ` kao j kp ]bba_p
o_]n bkni ]pekj ) - +. " Qne]i _ej khkj a okhqpekj i ]u ^a
ej fa_pa` ej pk i qhpel ha oepao kb pda o_]n+ Eks ar an) oecj o kb
ei l nkr ai aj po i ]u j kp ^a oaaj bkn ]p ha]op ] bas s aago
kn i kj pdo %0&+ Qei a ]j ` nal apeper a _ki l naooekj i ]oo]cao

8eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT

*( /
]na bqnpdan i apdk` o kb j kj kl an]per a pna]pi aj p kb l kop^qnj
b]_e]h o_]nej c+
> hpdkqcd l duoe_]h ]j ` l d]ni ]_khkce_]h ]caj po d]opaj
o_]n i ]pqn]pekj ) pdana eo oki apei ao j kp aj kqcd pei a pk
s ]ep bkn bej ]h o_]n ` ar ahkl i aj p+ Fj _anp]ej decd*l neknepu
]na]o kb pda b]_a) _kj pn]_pqna ]j ` dul anpnkl de_ o_]n bkn*
i ]pekj namqena a]nhu oqnce_]h ]ppaj pekj + Qdaoa decd*l neknepu
]na]o ej _hq` a ql l an ]j ` hks an auahe` o) j kopneho) ql l an ]j `
hks an hel o) ]j ` pda j a_g+ Mnkhkj ca` _kj pn]_pqnao kb pda
auahe` o i ]u ha]` pk _dnkj e_ _kj fqj _per epeo ]j ` at l koa
pda _knj a] pk _dnkj e_ ennep]pekj ) ha]` ej c pk _knj a]h qh_an]*
pekj + C]ehqna pk nahear a hel _kj pn]_pqnao d]i l ano a]pej c
]j ` ` nej gej c ^u naopne_pej c hel _hkoqna ]j ` napaj pekj kb
hemqe` kn okhe` bkk` o+ Fb ]hhks a` pk l anoeop pkk hkj c) hel _kj *
pn]_pqnao i ]u ]hpan pda bej ahu ^]h]j _a` i qo_qh]n ouopai kb
pkj cqa ]j ` hel ) ha]` ej c pk ei l ]eni aj p kb ^epa k__hqoekj +
5&
FRP[_
Qda ol a_e]h ]j ]pki e_ ba]pqnao kb pda ogqhh ]j ` o_]hl
at l h]ej pda ol a_e]h _kj oe` an]pekj o pk k^oanr a s daj pna]pej c
ej fqneao kb pda o_]hl + Rj hega i kop kpdan ^k` u ]na]o) pdana eo
kj hu ] pdej ]j ` ` ahe_]pa okbp peooqa _kr an]ca kb pda da]`
nacekj + Qda ` ebbanej c ^hkk` oql l hu kb pda ej r khr a`
peooqao eo _d]n]_paneva` ^u ps k ` ebbanaj p ]npane]h ouopai o+
Qda ^hkk` oql l hu kb pda o_]hl eo i ]ej p]ej a` pdnkqcd pda
]npane]h ouopai o kb pda _]nkpe` ]j ` r anpa^n]h ]npaneao)
s dana]o ` el hka ]j ` i aj ej ca]h r aooaho oql l hu pda ogqhh+
@qnnaj p hepan]pqna nal knpo ql pk / 2" ej _e` aj _a kb o_]hl
^qnj o ej nah]pekj pk pda j qi ^an kb pkp]h ^qnj o+ Qda ej fqneao
kb ej _na]oa` ` al pd ]j ` ej r khr a` ]na] ]na i kna hegahu ej
_deh` naj %1&+ ? aoe` ao pda pdani ]h peooqa ` ]i ]ca) ]` ` epekj ]h
oa_kj ` ]nu o_]hl ` aba_po i ]u k__qn s epd o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao
]j ` ogej cn]bp ` kj kn ]na]o+ Qdeo i ]u k__qn s epd d]nr aop
kb pde_g ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo ]j ` ha]` pk ]hkl a_e]
kb ` ebbanaj p cn]` ao %2&+
Fj pda ]_qpa i ]j ]cai aj p kb o_]hl ^qnj o) j kj kl an]per a
pdan]l u nai ]ej o pda pna]pi aj p opn]pacu pd]p eo i kop kbpaj
qoa` + Qda l nei ]nu ck]h eo pda l naoanr ]pekj kb r e]^ha d]en
bkhhe_hao pk ]hhks nacaj an]pekj kb o_]hl ogej + Qdeo ` kao
j kp l na_hq` a j a_aoo]nu p]j caj pe]h ` a^ne` ai aj p ]o nacaj an*
]pekj i ]u k__qn bnki ` aal d]en bkhhe_hao+
T epd ` aal an l ]npe]h* ]j ` bqhh*pde_gj aoo ej fqneao) _ki *
l hapa ` a^ne` ai aj p i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu+ Cqnpdan pna]pi aj p
opn]pacu ` al aj ` o kj pda at paj p kb _]hr ]ne]h ej r khr ai aj p
%3)4&+ Fb r e]^ha l anekopaqi eo l naoaj p) pda ` aba_p i ]u ^a
_kr ana` ^u l nei ]nu ]qpkhkckqo ogej cn]bpo kn pai l kn]nu
]hhkcn]bp _kr an]ca ]j ` oq^oamqaj p ]qpkcn]bpej c+ Pi ]hh
` aba_po s epd ej r khr ai aj p kb pda at panj ]h p]^ha kb pda _]h*
r ]ne]h i ]u ^a _kr ana` ^u hk_]h nkp]pekj kn pn]j ol koepekj
bh]l o+ T epd h]ncan ]na]o kb ej r khr ai aj p) ` ena_p bh]l _kr an*
]ca s epd kn s epdkqp oql anbe_e]h ` a^ne` ai aj p kb j a_nkpe_
^kj a i ]u j kp ^a l kooe^ha+ > o]ba ]j ` abbe_eaj p opn]pacu
_kj oeopo kb oql anbe_e]h ` a^ne` ai aj p kb pda at panj ]h p]^ha
^u ] nkp]pej c ^qnn bkhhks a` ^u l nei ]nu kn ` ah]ua` ]qpk*
cn]bpej c %5)6&+ Bt paj oer a ^kj a ` aba_po kn bqhh*pde_gj aoo _]h*
r ]ne]h ^qnj o s epd l kpaj pe]h ej r khr ai aj p kb i aj ej cao kn
^n]ej i ]u oecj ebe_]j phu i k` ebu pda pdan]l aqpe_ _kqnoa+
> ` ` epekj ]h ` e]cj kope_ paopo oq_d ]o @Q kn J OF o_]j o
i ]u ^a s ]nn]j pa` + E ks ar an n]na) pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb _]h*
r ]ne]h ^qnj o eo s e` ahu ` eo_qooa` + Pki a ]qpdkno _h]ei pd]p
pda _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a) ar aj eb j kj r e]^ha) eo ] ^appan _kr an]ca
kb pda ` qn]h _]r epu pd]j ]j u kb pda l kpaj pe]h oq^opepqpao+
Qdana ]na _]oa nal knpo kb ^kj a nacaj an]pekj ]j ` nar ep] hev]*
pekj ej hkj c*pani bkhhks *ql %. - &+ Lj _a pda ` a_eoekj eo
i ]` a pk ha]r a j kj r e]^ha _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a ej l h]_a) a]nhu
bh]l _kr an]ca eo i ]j ` ]pknu+ Fb pda ` aba_p eo pkk h]nca bkn
hk_]h bh]l _kr an]ca) i e_nkr ]o_qh]n bnaa bh]l o i ]u ^a
j aa` a` +
Qda ë` ahqt aí ^hkk` oql l hu kb pda o_]hl ]hhks o pda _na*
]pekj kb h]nca hk_]h ogej bh]l o+ Roej c ]t e]h l ]ppanj bh]l o)
hk_]h pn]j ol koepekj bh]l o kb at pnai a ` ei aj oekj ]na l kooe^ha
]o ` ao_ne^a` a]nhean %. . ). / &+ Qda ` ah]u kb pdaoa h]ncan bh]l o
_]j ]` ` ]j ]` ` epekj ]h o]bapu r ]hr a pk aj oqna oq__aoobqh oqn*
r er ]h+ Fb hk_]h bh]l o b]eh pk _kr an at paj oer a ]j ` ` aal ` aba_po)
i e_nkr ]o_qh]n bnaa*peooqa pn]j oban i ]u ^a j aa` a` %. 0&+
Par an]h kl pekj o) oq_d ]o ` ebbanaj p i qo_ha kn i ukb]o_ek_q*
p]j aqo bh]l o) i ]u ^a ]` kl pa` ]__kn` ej c pk hk_]h j aa` o+ Qda
ki aj p]h bnaa bh]l eo ]j kpdan r e]^ha kl pekj ) ]hpdkqcd ep
namqenao h]l ]n]pki u) s de_d i ]u at l koa pda l ]peaj p pk
]` ` epekj ]h neogo %. 1&+
T epd ]_qpa ^qnj _]na kb o_]hl ej fqneao) pda ]ppaj pekj kb pda
oqncakj odkqh` bk_qo kj pda l naoanr ]pekj kb ]o i q_d d]en*
^a]nej c o_]hl ]o l kooe^ha+ > j u abbknpo pks ]n` oa_kj ` ]nu
na_kj opnq_pekj ]na haj cpdu+ Pqnce_]h ]hpanj ]per ao kbpaj ]na
j kp _ki l hapa kn _koi ape_]hhu o]peobuej c+ Fb hk_]h pn]j ol koe*
pekj bh]l o ]na j kp ba]oe^ha) pda qoa kb l nei ]nu ogej cn]bpo
kj ] r e]^ha s kqj ` ^a` eo ]` r eo]^ha+ Pi ]hh ` aba_po) pdaj )
i ]u qj ` anck oane]h at _eoekj ej pda na_kj opnq_per a l kop^qnj
l anek` pk _knna_p ^qnj ]hkl a_e]+ T epd pda ej danaj p _kj pn]_*
pekj ) pda ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo i ]u odnej g pda oeva kb
pda ` aba_p ^u ql pk 0- " ` qnej c pda s kqj ` *da]hej c l anek` +
Br anu ]na] kb r e]^ha o_]hl odkqh` ^a l naoanr a` ) ar aj eb nao*
pkn]pekj kb ] d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl ]l l a]no j kp l kooe^ha+
P_]hl ^qnj o s epd at l koqna kb _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a i ]u
l naoaj p ol a_e]h pna]pi aj p l nk^hai o+ T epd ej p]_p _]hr ]ne]h
l anekopaqi ) ]j u bqnpdan i ]j el qh]pekj odkqh` ^a ]r ke` a`
]j ` ] pdej ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo s ehh oqbbe_a pk _kr an
pda ` aba_p+ T epd j kj r e]^ha l anekopaqi kn j kj r e]^ha kqpan
l h]pa kb pda _]hr ]ne]h ^qnj ) pda h]i ej ] at panj ] odkqh` ^a
` a^ne` a` qj peh r ]o_qh]neva` ` el hka eo at l koa` pk oql l knp
] ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bp+ T dapdan ogej cn]bpo ]na l an*
bkni a` ]o ei i a` e]pa kn ` ah]ua` l nk_a` qnao i ]u j kp ^a
kb ]j u ei l knp]j _a+ Rj ` an l nkl an ]j ` ]oal pe_ i ]j ]cai aj p
ej ba_pekqo _ki l he_]pekj o ]na n]na %6&+
Pki a ]qpdkno nal knp pd]p j kj r e]^ha _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a) eb ep
nai ]ej o ej l h]_a ]j ` eo _kr ana` s epd r ]o_qh]neva` peooqa)

*( 0

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
i ]u nacaj an]pa %. - &+ Qdanabkna) j kj r e]^ha _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a
i ]u l nkr e` a oqbbe_eaj p i a_d]j e_]h l nkpa_pekj pk pda qj ` an*
huej c ^n]ej + T epd pda ei l nkr a` naokhqpekj kb @Q ]j ` J OF
o_]j o) _n]j ekpki u i ]u ^a n]nahu j aa` a` pk at l hkna pda
` ]i ]ca pk qj ` anhuej c ` qn]h kn _ana^n]h opnq_pqnao+
Oai kr ]h kb j a_nkpe_ _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a ]j ` oq^oamqaj p ogej
cn]bpej c kj pk pda ` qn] ]na l nk^hai ]pe_ ^qp i ]u ^a
]` ` naooa` ) eb j a_aoo]nu) ^u qoej c ` a_ahhqh]neva` dqi ]j
` ani eo %> hhk` ani à & ]o ]` ` epekj ]h naej bkn_ai aj p %. 2). 3&+
Eks ar an) pda naoqhpej c _kj pkqn ` aba_p eo ` ebbe_qhp pk
_knna_p+ Pq^oamqaj p _n]j ekl h]opu eo j a_aoo]nu pk l nkr e` a
]aopdape_ na_kj opnq_pekj ]j ` l nkpa_per a oql l knp pk pda _an*
a^n]h opnq_pqnao+ T epd ]j u ]` ` epekj ]h ej _eoekj hej a) pda
oqncakj odkqh` ^a]n ej i ej ` pda bqpqna l h]j j ej c kb
bqnpdan na_kj opnq_pekj qoej c hk_]h bh]l o ]j ` peooqa
at l ]j oekj +
6 &
9PRT
Qda pna]pi aj p kb b]_e]h ^qi o eo n]pdan _ki l hat ) ]o ]j u
oq^qj ep kb pda b]_a d]o pk ^a na_kcj eva` ]j ` ar ]hq]pa` oal *
]n]pahu+ > __kn` ej c pk pda hepan]pqna) ^qnj o ej r khr a pda b]_a
ej 12*22" kb ]hh ^qi r e_pei o+ Aal aj ` ej c kj pda oar anepu
kb pda ^qnj ) pdan]l u _kj oeopo kb _kkhej c ]j ` okkpdej c ` nao*
oej co %benop*` acnaa ^qnj &) hk_]h ]j pei e_nk^e]ho kn ouj pdape_
_kr an]cao %oql anbe_e]h oa_kj ` ` acnaa&) kn kl an]per a ` a^ne*
` ai aj p) oqnce_]h at _eoekj ) ]j ` cn]bpej c %` aal oa_kj `
` acnaa) pden` ` acnaa&+
Qda ` a_eoekj bkn oqnce_]h pna]pi aj p kb b]_e]h ^qnj o ]j `
epo pei ej c ]na _kj pej qkqohu ` a^]pa` + B]nhu at _eoekj ]j `
cn]bpej c s epdej pda benop bas ` ]uo ]bpan ^qi ej fqnu ]l l a]n
pk ei l nkr a pda i ap]^khe_ ]j ` pda s kqj ` *da]hej c
naol kj oao+ Lpdano ]ncqa pd]p kj hu s kqj ` o b]ehej c pk da]h
s epdej / s aago odkqh` ^a at _eoa` ]j ` cn]bpa` + Qdeo
_kj _al p eo aol a_e]hhu r ]hq]^ha ej b]_e]h ^qnj o+ Qda decd
l kpaj pe]h bkn nacaj an]pekj kb pda b]_e]h ogej i ]u ha]` pk
ol kj p]j akqo da]hej c kb i ]j u b]_e]h ^qi s kqj ` o+ Qdqo)
h]nca ]na]o kb kpdans eoa at _eoa` b]_e]h ogej i ]u nacaj an]pa
]j ` odkqh` d]r a ^aaj l naoanr a` + T epd _ha]n ` ai ]n_]pekj )
hk_]h eokh]pa` ]na]o i ]u ^a at _eoa` ]j ` cn]bpa` + Fj epe]h
_kr an]ca i ]u ^a ]_dear a` ^u qoej c ` eop]j p ogej cn]bp
` kj kn ]na]o8 ok) hk_]h) ]aopdape_]hhu i kna r ]hq]^ha ogej
]na]o %o_]hl ) j a_g) oql n]_h]r e_qh]n nacekj & i ]u ^a l na*
oanr a` bkn h]pan bqj _pekj ]h ]j ` ]aopdape_ na_kj opnq_per a
l nk_a` qnao+ I k_]h bh]l o kn oane]h at _eoekj ]hok odkqh` ^a
l kopl kj a` qj peh h]pan na_kj opnq_pekj %0&+
> bpan _ki l hapa s kqj ` _kr an]ca eo ]_dear a` ) i a]oqnao
pk ei l nkr a o_]n mq]hepu odkqh` ^a ej _hq` a` ej pda pdan]*
l aqpe_ l h]j + Pecj ebe_]j p ei l nkr ai aj p kb o_]n mq]hepu ]j `
]aopdape_ kqp_ki a i ]u ^a ]_dear a` ^u _ki l naooekj
pdan]l u+ Qdaoa eooqao d]r a pk ^a ` eo_qooa` s epd pda
l ]peaj p ]j ` p]ehkna` pk deo ol a_e]h j aa` o+ C]_e]h i ]ogo
i ]u ^a i ]j qb]_pqna` qoej c ah]ope_ b]^ne_ s epd kn s epdkqp
hk_]h l naooqna ej oanpo kr an nacekj o s epd decd neog kb o_]n
dul anpnkl du+ Lpdan kl pekj o ej _hq` a pda qoa kb ol a_e]h
pdnaa*` ei aj oekj ]hhu i kh` a` oehe_kj a kn l h]ope_ b]_ai ]ogo
bet a` s epd ah]ope_ opn]l o+ Oac]n` haoo kb pda pul a kb _ki *
l naooekj ouopai ) pda ]` amq]_u kb l naooqna d]o pk ^a _kj *
pej qkqohu i kj epkna` ]j ` ]` ]l pa` pk pda _d]j cej c j aa` o
kb pda ej ` er e` q]h l ]peaj p %. *0&+
Aqnej c pda ]_qpa l d]oa kb ^qi pna]pi aj p) ]ccnaooer a
at _eoekj ]j ` cn]bpej c odkqh` ^a ]r ke` a` ]o ep kbpaj
naoqhpo ej pda hkoo kb ]hna]` u hei epa` ogej ` kj kn ]na]o+
Qdaoa ]na]o i ]u ^a kb _i _e]h ei l knp]j _a ` qnej c bqpqna
na_kj opnq_per a abbknpo+ Rj peh o_]n i ]pqn]pekj eo _ki l hapa)
na_kj opi _per a l nk_a` qnao odkqh` ^a gal p pk ] i ej ei qi +
Mnk_a` qnao pk _knna_p bqj _pekj ]h ei l ]eni aj po) dks ar an)
i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu+ Fb h]nca ]na]o kb pda b]_a namqena at _e*
oekj ]j ` naoqnb]_ej c s epd ogej cn]bpo) h]nca qj i aoda`
ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bp odaapo ]na ]l l hea` dknevkj p]hhu+
Fj _kj pn]op pk pda bkni an pa_dj emqao kb l h]_ej c ogej cn]bp
ej pk pda ej ` er e` q]h b]_e]h oq^qj epo) pdeo pa_dj emqa na` q_ao
dul anpnkl de_ o_]n bkni ]pekj ]p pda ^kn` an kb pda odaapo
]j ` na` q_ao pda l nki ej aj p ^kn` ano kb pda b]_e]h oq^qj epo
XCec+ . 2+. %> &Y+ Eks ar an) b]_e]h _ki l naooekj i ]ogo ]na
ej ` eol aj o]^ha pk ]_dear a ] _koi ape_]hhu ]l l a]hej c ]l l a]n*
]j _a+ T epd pda ` ao_ne^a` pa_dj emqa ]j ` oq^oamqaj p _ki *
l naooekj pdan]l u) pda da]ha` ogej s ehh ^ad]r a ej ] oei eh]n
b]odekj ]o pd]p kb pda knecej ]h ogej nac]n` ej c ogej bkh` o
]j ` bqnpdan _d]n]_paneope_o+
7 &
8 Pab
Fj r khr ai aj p kb kj a kn ^kpd a]no eo bnamqaj phu oaaj s epd
b]_e]h ^qi o+ Aqa pk pda pdej ]j ` r anu ` ahe_]pa ogej _kr an*
]ca kb pda a]n) pda naoeop]j _a pk pdani ]h ej fqnu eo i ej ei ]h)
ha]` ej c pk ] decd neog kb ogej ` aba_po ]j ` oq^oamqaj p
at l koqna kb a]n _]npeh]ca+ Aaoe__]pekj ]j ` ej ba_pekj kb
l ane_dkj ` neqi ]j ` _]npeh]ca) naol a_per ahu) i ]u _]qoa
bqnpdan peooqa j a_nkoeo ]j ` pda naoqhpej c ` aba_po _]j ha]`
pk oanekqo ` abkni ]pekj o %. 4&+
Mnar aj pekj kb a]n _]npeh]ca ej ba_pekj eo l ]n]i kqj p) ]o
pda pdan]l u kb ]j aop]^heoda` ej ba_pekj eo ` ebbe_qhp ]j `
i kop kbpaj bqpeha %. 5&+ I k_]h ]l l he_]pekj kb i ]baj e` a
]_ap]pa ]j ` bnamqaj p ` naooej c _d]j cao) hk_]h ` a^ne` ai aj p)
]j ` hk_]h bh]l _kr an]ca kb at l koa` _]npeh]ca i ]u l nar aj p
]j ` _kj p]ej pda ej ba_pekj + Qk ]r ke` a]n _]npeh]ca ej ba_pekj o)
hk_]h ` a^ne` ai aj p ]j ` pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca s epd r ]o_qh]n*
eva` peooqa i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu+ Fb pdaoa i apdk` o b]eh pk
]_dear a _kr an]ca kb pda a]n _]npeh]ca) pda _]npeh]ca i ]u
^a at _eoa` ]j ` oq^_qp]j akqohu ei l h]j pa` ]o ] qj ep pk
]j kpdan ^k` u ]na]+ > p ] h]pan pei a l kej p pda _]npeh]ca
i ]u ^a nal koepekj a` ]o ] bnaa*_]npeh]ca pn]j ol h]j p %. 4&+
> j u na_kj opnq_pekj kb l ]npe]hhu kn _ki l hapahu ` ]i ]ca`
a]no namqenao ej paj oer a l nakl an]per a ` eo_qooekj o s epd
pda l ]peaj p+ Aal aj ` ej c kj pda at l a_p]pekj o ]j ` pda
_kkl an]pekj
kb pda
l ]peaj p)
]
cna]p
j qi ^an
kb

8eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT

*( 1
9XVdaT ) - &)
%>& > aopdape_ qj epo kb pda b]_a+ %? & P_]nnej c kb
b]_e]h ^qi o ha]` o pk ` eopknpekj kb ]aopdape_ oq^qj epo ]j ` ei l ]ena`
b]_e]h i ei e_o+ Fj oar ana ^qi o) ]` ` epekj ]h bqj _pekj ]h l nk^hai o
oq_d ]o kn]h ej _ki l apaj _a kn auahe` _hkoqna i ]u k__qn+
na_kj opnq_per a pa_dj emqao ]r ]eh]^ha i qop ^a ]` ]l pa` pk pda
l ]peaj pîo ej ` er e` q]h j aa` o+
> o j kpa` ) pda i ]fkn _d]hhaj ca ej pda _]na kb a]n ^qi o eo
pda _kj op]j p neog kb _]npeh]ca ej ba_pekj ]j ` peooqa hkoo+
Lj _a pdana eo opnq_pqn]h ` ]i ]ca) bqnpdan na_kj opi _per a
abbknpo ^a_ki a ej _na]oej chu ` ebbe_qhp+ > hh kl an]per a l nk*
_a` qnao ]na i kna _ki l hat ]j ` j kp ]hs ]uo oq__aoobqh+
Pp]npej c s epd pda ]_qpa pna]pi aj p l d]oa) _]na odkqh` ^a
p]gaj pk l nkpa_p pda a]n _]npeh]ca+ Aqa pk epo pdej ogej ]j `
okbp peooqa _kr an]ca h]_gej c ] oq^_qp]j akqo h]uan) pda
neog kb at l koqna kb pda _]npeh]ca eo nah]per ahu decd+
Eks ar an) pdeo i ]u j kp ^a ei i a` e]pahu na_kcj eva` ]j `
pdqo i ]u ha]` pk ` ah]ua` ` e]cj koeo kb pda hk_]h ej ba_pekj +
Fj pdeo oepq]pekj ) pda oi kh` anej c hk_]h ej ba_pekj ]j ` oq^*
oamqaj p hkoo kb _]npeh]ca ]na ` ebbe_qhp pk d]j ` ha+
8&
8 hT[XSb P] S 8 hTQa^ f b
Qda hegahedkk` pk oqbban bnki aua ` ]i ]ca ^u ] b]_e]h ^qi
d]o pk ^a _kj oe` ana` nah]per ahu decd+ ? aoe` ao ` ]i ]ca pk pda
ql l an ] j ` ,kn hks an auahe` o) pda i ]ej neog eo ] h]_an]pekj kb
pda _knj a]) s de_d i ]u ha]` pk ^hej ` j aoo kb pda ej fqna` aua+
Qda neog kb _ki a]h ej fqnu ej _na]oao s epd at l hkoekj o) bh]od
^qi o) kn _dai e_]h ej fqneao+ Cknpqj ]pahu) l ]peaj po s epd
b]_e]h bh]i a ^qi o kn o_]h` o odks ] hks an ej _e` aj _a kb
_ki a]h h]_an]pekj o+ Qda l nei ]nu na]okj bkn pdeo eo ] bqj _*
pekj ej c ^hej g nabhat + > __kn` ej chu) ej pdaoa _]oao oanekqo
ej fqneao ]na oaaj ej pda auahe` nacekj +
> j at ]_p _hej e_]h ar ]hq]pekj kb pda auao ]j ` pda aua
nacekj eo i ]j ` ]pknu bkhhks ej c ] b]_e]h ej fqnu) j k i ]ppan
s d]p pda _]qoa+ > o pei a ^aps aaj pn]qi ] ]j ` _hej e_]h
at ]i ej ]pekj ej _na]oao) ok ` kao a` ai ] ej Ida kn^ep]h ]j `
l anekn^ep]h peooqao+ > o pdeo _kj ` epekj o s knoaj o) ]j ]` amq]pa
ar ]hq]pekj ^a_ki ao ` ebbe_qhp+ > ^]oe_ at ]i ^u ]j at l ane*
aj _a` kl dpd]hi khkceop ql kj ]` i eooekj eo ]` r eo]^ha) pk
k^p]ej ] _knna_p _hej e_]h op]pqo ]j ` pk ej epe]pa ]l l nkl ne]pa
kl dpd]hi khkce_]h _]na+
Fj _]oa kb at paj oer a okbp peooqa ` ]i ]ca pk pda auahe` o ]j `
oq^oamqaj p at l koqna kb pda _knj a]) oar an]h l kooe^ehepeao kb
pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca nai ]ej + Eks ar an) pda oei l haop okhqpekj
kb ]j aua l ]p_d s epd ]j pe^ekpe_ kej pi aj p i ]u ^a ` ebbe_qhp pk
qoa ej _]oa kb at paj oer a b]_e]h ^qi o+ > _ki i kj hu qoa` _kr *
an]ca eo ] pai l kn]nu p]noknnd]l du qoej c oehe_kj a pq^ao
]ooeopej c s epd ]l l nkt ei ]pekj kb pda ql l an ]j ` hks an
auahe` o+ @nepe_o kb pdeo pa_dj emqa ]ncqa pd]p ep eo ` ebbe_qhp pk
]_dear a pda ]l l nkt ei ]pekj kb ql l an ]j ` hks an auahe` o)
aol a_e]hhu ]o ]j u i kr ai aj p kb pda aua^]hh naoqhpo ej ej pan*
i eppaj p at l koqna kb pda _knj a]+ Qda ]l l hea` oqpqnao i ]u
]hok ` ]i ]ca pda he` i ]ncej o+ T epd ej _na]oa` a` ai ] ej pda
kn^ep]h ]j ` l anekn^ep]h peooqao) pda oqpqna i ]u ar aj _qp
pdnkqcd+ @kj oamqaj phu) o]peobuej c bqpqna na_kj opnq_pekj
i ]u ^a naj ` ana` ` ebbe_qhp) eb j kp ei l kooe^ha+ > j ]hpanj ]per a
eo pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb ] _kj fqj _per ]h bh]l pk _kr an pda
_knj a]+ > j ]` ` epekj ]h ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bp i ]u ^a
j a_aoo]nu pk ej _na]oa i a_d]j e_]h op]^ehepu %. 6&+
Aqnej c pda a]nhu l d]oa kb ^qnj ) pda kl an]per a pdan]l u kb
auahe` ej fqneao odkqh` ^a naopne_pa` pk at _eoekj ]j ` cn]bpej c

*) (

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
kb bqhh*pde_gj aoo ej fqneao ]o j a_aoo]nu+ Aabej eper a na_kj *
opnq_pekj odkqh` ^a l anbkni a` ]p ] h]pan op]ca) s daj
o_]no d]r a i ]pqna` + Qda auahe` îo bqj _pekj ]j ` epo ]aopdape_
oecj ebe_]j _a kbpaj namqena bqnpdan oamqaj pe]h na_kj opnq_per a
l nk_a` qnao+ @knna_pekj kb a_pnkl ekj o) na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda
i a` e]h kn h]pan]h _]j pd]h ]na]o) ]o s ahh ]o aua^nks na_kj *
opnq_pekj s ehh kj hu ^a oq__aoobqh eb o_]no d]r a i ]pqna` ]j `
bqpqna o_]n pn]_pekj _]j ^a ]r ke` a` +
Fj ]` amq]pa pna]pi aj p kb at l koa` _knj a]h oaci aj po s ehh
d]r a ` eo]opnkqo abba_po+ Qdeo oepq]pekj ^aej c qj na_kcj eva`
s ehh ha]` pk ` aoe__]pekj ]j ` qh_an]pekj kb pda _knj a]+
> hpanj ]pahu) ^]_pane]h oql anej ba_pekj %i kop kbpaj ^u
EeWgVa_ a` Se SWdgY[` aeS& _]j ]hok ` ar ahkl + > j ej epe]h
aua at ]i ej ]pekj ^u ]j at l aneaj _a` kl dpd]hi khkceop eo)
pdanabkna) j a_aoo]nu ]j ` odkqh` ^a ] op]j ` ]n` l nk_a` qna
ej pda ar ]hq]pekj kb l ]peaj po s epd b]_e]h ^qnj o+
Qda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb ]j a_pnkl ekj ) aol a_e]hhu ej pda
hks an he` nacekj ) eo r anu ` ebbe_qhp pk ]hpan s epd pda l naoaj p
ah]ope_ ]j ` _kj pn]_per a bkn_ao+ > j ]^qj ` ]j phu i a]oqna`
ogej cn]bp ]j ` ]` amq]pa l kopkl an]per a _ki l naooekj
pdan]l u i ]u odks oki a abba_p kj pda ei i ej aj p o_]n _kj *
pn]_pekj + Mnei ]nu kl an]per a _knna_pekj ej pda i a` e]h kn
h]pan]h _]j pd]h nacekj odkqh` ^a ]r ke` a` ) ]o l kopkl an]per a
o_]nnej c ]j ` _kj pn]_pqna s ehh ^a haooaj a` s epd l kop^qnj
o_]n i ]pqn]pekj + S ep]h l ]npo kb pda aua^nks o odkqh` ^a l na*
oanr a` s daj ar an ba]oe^ha+
Oa_kj opnq_pekj kb aua^nks o) qj peh na_aj phu) d]o ^aaj
haoo pd]j o]peob]_pknu+ @ki l koepa cn]bpo _]j ^a qj nahe]^ha
]j ` l na` e_ha` o_]hl bh]l o ]na j kp ]aopdape_]hhu l ha]oej c ej
s ki aj + Oa_aj phu) ? annan] d]o odks j pd]p pda qoa kb i e_nk*
cn]bpo %kj a pk ps k d]en bkhhe_hao& ]j ` i ej ecn]bpo %ps k pk bkqn
d]en bkhhe_hao& eo e` a]h bkn oq_d na_kj opnq_pekj +
9&
A^bT
Qda l nki ej aj p l koepekj ) pda opnq_pqna) bkni ) ]j ` bqj _pekj
kb pda j koa ha]` pk ej _na]oa` at l koqna s epd b]_e]h ^qnj o
]j ` i ]u ^a ]ook_e]pa` s epd ei l ]eni aj p kb naol en]pknu
bqj _pekj + Cqhh*pde_gj aoo ^qnj o i ]u ` ena_phu ` ]i ]ca pda
_]npeh]ca o_]bbkh` kb pda j koa+ Fj ` ena_p ` ]i ]cao k__qn
s epd ej ba_pa` oql anbe_e]h ^qi o+ Qda i kop _ki i kj ej ` ena_p
` ]i ]cao pk pda j koa k__qn ` qnej c ej paj oer a _]na pna]pi aj p+
J ]hl koepekj ej c kb j ]okc]opne_ pq^ao kn l naooqna bnki
aj ` kpn]_d]ah pq^ao l h]_a` pdnkqcd pda j koa _]j ha]` pk
hk_]h j a_nkoeo kb okbp peooqa ]j ` _]npeh]ca+
Pql anbe_e]h ^qnj o kb pda j koa s ehh na]` ehu da]h qj ` an
` ]ehu ` naooej c _d]j cao ]j ` pkl e_]h ]j pei e_nk^e]ho) oq_d
]o Pehr ] ` aj aä kn Pqhb]i uhkj ä + Qdaoa ^qnj o s ehh da]h
s epdkqp o_]n+ Eks ar an) dul anl eci aj p]pekj kn dul k*
l eci aj p]pekj i ]u ^a bkqj ` bnamqaj phu+ Qda l nej _el ]h ck]h
ej pda ]_qpa _]na eo pk l naoanr a ]o i q_d hk_]h peooqa ]o l koo*
e^ha+ Qdeo ei l heao ] r anu _]qpekqo ]j ` naopne_per a ` a^ne` a*
i aj p ]j ` i ]u ej _hq` a ogej cn]bpej c kb at l koa` j ]o]h
_]npeh]ca pk l nar aj p ` aoe__]pekj ]j ` ej ba_pekj + I k_]h
ej ba_pekj o) j ]o]h _dkj ` nepeo kn l ane_dkj ` nepeo s ehh ha]` pk
_]npeh]ca j a_nkoeo ]j ` oanekqo ` abkni ]pekj kb pda j koa %. 4&+
? abkna ]ppai l pej c bqnpdan na_kj opnq_per a l nk_a` qnao)
_ki l hapa s kqj ` da]hej c ]j ` o_]n i ]pqn]pekj odkqh`
k__qn+ Aqnej c pdeo pei a) l naooqna i ]ogo ]j ` j ]o]h ol hej po
i ]u ^a qoabqh pk l nar aj p dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c+ Ppaj koeo
kb pda j kopneho i ]u ^a ]r ke` a` kn i ej ei eva` s epd pda qoa
kb _qopki eva` ol hej po+ Fb oecj ebe_]j p opaj koeo k__qno) ^qi
o_]n naha]oa ]j ` naoqnb]_ej c s epd ogej cn]bp bkhhks a` ^u
oq^oamqaj p j ]o]h ol hej pej c) i ]u ^a oqbbe_eaj p+ Qda at paj p
kb pda l nk_a` qnao j a_aoo]nu pk na_kj opnq_p pda naoe` q]h
` aba_po i ]u r ]nu+ Fj _]oa kb o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao) oei l ha
^qnj o_]n naha]oa ]j ` W*l h]opeao i ]u ^a oqbbe_eaj p+ Qda
_knna_pekj kb ] j ]o]h a_pnkl ekj i ]u namqena naoqnb]_ej c
s epd hk_]h bh]l o ]j ` ogej cn]bpo+ Pq^pkp]h okbp peooqa
` aba_po namqena at paj oer a bh]l o bkn _ki l hapa j koa na_kj *
opnq_pekj %. 4&+
Qda j koa eo pda _aj pn]h ]aopdape_ ba]pqna kb pda b]_a+
B]nhu) ]ccnaooer a ` a^ne` ai aj p s ehh ej _na]oa pda ` aba_p
]j ` i kop hegahu ` aopnku okbp peooqa s de_d _kqh` ^a qoa`
bkn bqpqna na_kj opnq_pekj %. 4&+ Fj epe]hhu) _kj oanr ]per a pna]p*
i aj p oaai o ]` r eo]^ha+ Kaa` haoo pk o]u) ` qnej c pda ]_qpa
l d]oa kb ej fqnu) ]hh ` qa _]na odkqh` ^a p]gaj pk ]r ke`
bqnpdan ` ]i ]ca ^u pq^ao ]j ` kpdan i ]j el qh]pekj o+ Pqpqna
bet ]pekj kb aj pan]h ]j ` pn]_da]h pq^ao odkqh` ^a ]r ke` a` )
]o pda oa_kj ` ]nu ` ]i ]cao _]j ^a ei i aj oa+ Pq_d o_]nnej c
` abkni epeao ]na qoq]hhu naopne_pa` pk j a_nkoeo kb pda j ]o]h
]na]+ Fi i a` e]pa ]j ` oq^oamqaj p ol hej pej c eo pda i kop
ei l knp]j p l nkl duh]_pe_ i a]oqna pk ]r ke` opaj koeo kb pda
j kopneho+ Lj _a a]nhu ej panr aj pekj d]o ^aaj i eooa` ) o_]n bkn*
i ]pekj s ehh naoqhp ej oecj ebe_]j p naopne_pekj kb j ]o]h r aj pe*
h]pekj + > j u bqpqna _knna_pekj o ]na r anu ` ebbe_qhp pk
ei l hai aj p ]j ` s ehh namqena l nkhkj ca` s a]nej c kb j ]o]h
ol hej po+
: &
? X_b P] S @^ dcW
> bpan s kqj ` _hkoqna ` qnej c pda ]_qpa l d]oa kb pna]pi aj p)
oq^oamqaj p _]na naheao kj kn]h ol hej po pk l nar aj p bkni ]pekj
kb pecdp ^qnj o_]no ]j ` i e_nkopki e] %/ &+ Mnab]^ne_]pa`
ol hej po ]na _ki i an_e]hhu ]r ]eh]^ha) ^qp kbpaj ol hej po d]r a
pk ^a ]` fqopa` kn _qopki i ]` a pk oqep pda ej ` er e` q]h
l ]peaj p+ Qda ol hej po odkqh` ^a s knj _kj pej qkqohu ]j `
nai kr a` kj hu bkn bkk` ej p]ga ]j ` kn]h duceaj a+ > o i kop
ol hej po ]na qj _ki bknp]^ha ]j ` qj ]l l a]hej c pk s a]n) oqbbe*
_eaj p _ki l he]j _a) aol a_e]hhu ej ukqj c _deh` naj ) eo kbpaj
` ebbe_qhp pk ]_dear a+ > ppai l po pk _h]nebu pda ^aj abepo pk
pda l ]peaj p i ]u ^a s knpds deha %/ - )/ . &+ E ks ar an) eb pda
oq^oamqaj p ` abkni epu eo oar ana) a]nhu ^qnj o_]n naha]oa
kn _knna_pekj o i ]u d]r a pk ^a qj ` anp]gaj + Fj ` e_]pekj o
bkn pdeo ej _hq` a l nk^hai o ej k^p]ej ej c oqbbe_eaj p kn]h
duceaj a) kn l h]j j a` ` aj p]h l nk_a` qnao %/ / &+
B]nhu kl an]per a i ]j ]cai aj p kb kn]h ]j ` l anekn]h ^qi o
eo n]nahu j a_aoo]nu+ Lj _a _ki l hapa s kqj ` da]hej c ]j ` o_]n

8 eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT

*))
i ]pqn]pekj d]r a ^aaj ]_dear a` qj ` an _kj pej qkqo s a]nej c
kb kn]h ol hej po) i kop ` aba_po s ehh j aa` j k bqnpdan kl an]per a
pna]pi aj p+ Eks ar an) ki eppej c pda qoa kb ol hej po i ecdp ha]`
pk oanekqo _kj pn]_pqnao ]j ` r anu oar ana i e_nkopki e]+ Fp
]l l a]no ]` r eo]^ha pk _]nnu kqp ]j u _knna_per a l nk_a` qnao
]p h]pan pei a l kej po %/ . )/ 0)/ 1&+
Oa_kj opnq_pekj kb l anekn]h ]j ` kn]h ^qnj o namqenao
ol a_e]h ]ppaj pekj + Mnei ]nu na_kj opnq_pekj ` qnej c pda ]_qpa
l d]oa oaai o j kp r anu l nki eoej c ]o _kj op]j p i kr ai aj p
kb hel o ]j ` pkj cqa ]j ` pdaen _kj pej qkqo _kj p]_p s epd
o]her ] ]j ` bkk` i ]u ej _na]oa pda neog kb hk_]h ej ba_pekj o+
@kj oamqaj phu) ] i kna _kj oanr ]per a ]l l nk]_d s epd ej epe]h
op]cao kb ej fqnu s ehh naoqhp ej oa_kj ` ]nu s kqj ` da]hej c
s epd ]j ej _na]oa` hegahedkk` kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]nnej c ]j `
o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao+ Br anoekj kb kn]h i q_ko] ]j ` ei l ]eni aj p
kb kn]h _hkoqna kn kl aj ej c ` qa pk ^qi o_]no ]na _ki i kj
l nk^hai o+ Fj at paj oer a b]_e]h ^qnj o) i e_nkopki e] s ehh
naoqhp bnki o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao+ Bha_pne_]h ej fqnu pk pda
i kqpd) i kophu bkqj ` ej pk` ` hano) j aa` o ol a_e]h ]ppaj pekj )
]o at paj oer a hk_]h okbp peooqa ` ]i ]ca aol a_e]hhu ]p pda
kn]h
_ki i eooqna
s ehh
ha]`
pk
_kj pn]_pqnao
]j `
i e_nkopki e]+
P_]n bkni ]pekj ]j ` pda naoqhpej c _kj pn]_pekj kb ^qnj
o_]no ej pda ql l an hel *j ]o]h qj ep) kbpaj ha]` pk odknpaj ej c
kn ^qhcej c kb pda ql l an hel + I k_]h ^qnj o_]n naha]oa ]j `
ogej cn]bpej c i ]u dahl pk naopkna j kni ]h hel bqj _pekj ]j `
_hkoqna+ Aabkni epeao kb pda hks an hel kbpaj naoqhp bnki
]` ` epekj ]h opanj ki aj p]h o_]n bkni ]pekj ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao+
@ki ^ej a` j a_g ]j ` hks an hel o_]n naha]oa i ]u ^a j a_aoo*
]nu pk k^p]ej o]peobuej c naoqhpo+
; &
ATRZ
Pei eh]n pk kpdan ar aj po ej pda pda ]_qpa ^qnj op]ca) pdan]l u
bkn kn] h*l anekn] h ^qi o ]j ` j a_g ^qnj o odkqh` nahu l naban*
aj pe]hhu kj ol hej pej c+ Fj pda ]_qpa l d]oa) at _eoekj ]j `
ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpej c i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu+ Eks ar an)
]` amq]pa ol hej pej c ]j ` _ki l naooekj i ]u i ej ei eva i aj pk*
opanj ]h _kj pn]_pqna ]j ` ]_dear a ] hkj c*pani ^aj abep+
Qda cnkpaomqa ` abkni ]pekj k__qnnej c s epdkqp oqbbe_eaj p
pdan]l u s ehh ^a r anu ` ebbe_qhp ]j ` at l aj oer a pk _knna_p
]j ` i kop kbpaj ha]` o pk ]` ` epekj ]h oa_kj ` ]nu l nk^hai o+
Qda bkni ]pekj kb ] i aj pkopai ]h _kj pn]_pqna eo ]
_ki i kj oamqah] kb bqhh*pde_gj aoo ^qi o s de_d) bknpq*
j ]pahu) d]o ` a_na]oa` kr an pei a+ Qda ` ar ahkl i aj p ]j `
qoa kb _qopki *i ]` a ol hej po _kqh` na` q_a pda ej _e` aj _a
kb pdaoa cnkpaomqa o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao ]j ` pda naoqhpej c
bqj _pekj ]h ` abe_epo+ Cnamqaj p l nk^hai o oaaj ej _hq` a kn]h
ej _ki l apaj _a s epd o]her ]pekj ) ` aj p]h ` ]i ]ca) ej _ki l hapa
k__hqoekj ) na_qnnaj p bkhhe_qhepeo) ]j ` oanekqo ` ebbe_qhpeao ej
l anekl an]per a ]ens ]u i ]j ]cai aj p+
Qda ej _e` aj _a kb pdaoa _kj pn]_pqnao s ]o bqnpdan na` q_a`
s epd pda ]` r aj p kb a]nhu at _eoekj ]j ` cn]bpej c+ Eks ar an)
pdeo ` kao j kp na` q_a pda j aa` bkn ]` amq]pa ol hej pej c %/ &+
Pecj ebe_]j p j a_g _kj pn]_pqnao _]j opehh ^a bkqj ` ej l ]peaj po
s epd at paj oer a ^qi o+ Fj paj oer a _]na nah]pa` i a]oqnao) oq_d
]o _aj pn]h hej ao ]j ` pn]_dakopki eao) i ]u ei l a` a l nkl an
]j ` abbe_]_ekqo ol hej pej c+ J kop kbpaj ) dks ar an) pda _ki l he*
]j _a kb l ]peaj po ej s a]nej c pdaoa j a_g ol hej po ` a_na]oao
aj kni kqohu ]bpan dkol ep]h ` eo_d]nca+ Ll an]per a _knna_pekj o
d]r a pk ^a ]` fqopa` ]__kn` ej c pk pda at paj p ]j ` kneaj p]pekj
kb j a_g _kj pn]_pqnao %0&+
<&
CaTeT] cX^ ] ^ U FTR^ ] SPah Ca^ Q[T\ b
Fj ]_qpa ^qnj _]na) ^qnj oqncakj o ]na b]_ej c ]j ej danaj p
` ehai i ]+ Lj pda kj a d]j ` ) pda at paj p ]j ` ` al pd kb pda
^qnj a` ogej namqena oqnce_]h ` a^ne` ai aj p ]j ` a]nhu
_kr an]ca ]j ` kj pda kpdan) pdeo s ehh qj ` kq^pa` hu ej ` q_a
ennar anoe^ha ` ]i ]ca+ Qda b]_a s epd epo ` ebbanaj pe]pa` b]_e]h
at l naooekj o) pda ba]pqnao kb auao) j koa) i kqpd) ]j ` a]no
bkni ej ` er e` q]h ]na e` aj pebuej c _d]n]_paneope_o kb pda
l ]peaj p+ Aqa pk pda ` ebbe_qhpeao ej de` ej c pda b]_e]h o_]no)
l ]peaj po s epd b]_e]h ^qnj o kbpaj ]na ok_e]hhu opeci ]peva`
]j ` kbpaj i ]u s epd` n]s bnki l q^he_ r eas +
Qdan]l u ]j ` nad]^ehep]pekj d]r a pk ^a l nkl anhu l h]j j a`
pk ]_dear a pda kl pei ]h na_kj opnq_pekj ]ei ej c pk naopkna
i kop ba]pqnao ]j ` ol a_ebe_ _d]n]_paneope_o kb pda l ] peaj pîo
b]_a s deha) oei qhp]j akqohu) ]pp]ej ej c qj naopne_pa` bqj _pekj +
Qdeo ck]h i ]u j kp ^a na]_da` ej i ]j u _]oao+ Eks ar an)
ar anu ]ppai l p odkqh` ^a i ]` a pk _ki a _hkoa pk pdeo e` a]h+
Ckn pda at ]_p l h]j j ej c kb pda pdan]l aqpe_ abbknpo) pda bkh*
hks ej c oqccaopekj o i ]u ^a qoabqh+ Qda i ]fkn qj okhr a`
l nk^hai ej ^qnj _]na eo qj _kj pnkhha` o_]n bkni ]pekj +
Qdeo ej pqnj ` apani ej ao pda bqpqna _kqnoa kb nad]^ehep]pekj
]j ` pda kqp_ki a kb na_kj opnq_per a aj ` a]r kno+ T daj mqao*
pekj a` ]^kqp pda i kop ` aoena` na_kj opnq_per a oqncanu) i kop
^qi oqnr er kno s ehh ]og bkn o_]n naha]oa) na` q_pekj ) kn
nai kr ]h+ P_]n bkni ]pekj ]j ` i ]pqn]pekj eo ] l nk_aoo pd]p
p]gao epo ` qa pei a+ Qdanabkna) na_kj opnq_per a l nk_a` qnao
]ei ej c ]p ]_dear ej c ` abej eper a naopkn]pekj i ]u ^a haoo
pd]j kl pei ]h ` qnej c pdeo pei a l anek` + Eks ar an) pdana ]na
hei ep]pekj o pk pda j qi ^an kb _knna_per a l nk_a` qnao pd]p
i ]u ^a qj ` anp]gaj + Qda hei epa` naokqn_ao kb hk_]h peooqa
d]r a pk ^a qoa` ` ehecaj phu) ]o bqnpdan nal a]pa` _knna_pekj o
]na l nk^hai ]pe_ %0&+
Qda ej epe]pekj kb ` abej eper a na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda ^qnj
b]_a odkqh` ) pdanabkna) ^a ` ah]ua` qj peh o_]n i ]pqn]pekj
eo _ki l hapa+ B]nhu kn ei i a` e]pa na_kj opnq_pekj ) dks ar an)
i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu ej _]oa kb l nkcnaooej c ` abkni epu kn
oar ana bqj _pekj ]h l nk^hai o) oq_d ]o ej _]oa kb oar ana a_pnk*
l ekj kb pda auahe` o) s dana pda ` aba_p d]o pk ^a naopkna` pk
]r ke` bqnpdan ` ]i ]ca pk pda aua+ Qk ]r ke` bqnpdan l nk^hai o
` qnej c o_]n bkni ]pekj ]j ` i ]pqn]pekj ) _kr an]ca odkqh`
^a ]ppai l pa` qoej c ]^qj ` ]j p peooqa bkn na_kj opnq_pekj
kb pda ` aba_p+ Qdeo s ehh na` q_a hk_]h paj oekj ]j ` ` a_na]oa
o_]n dul anpnkl du+ > ` amq]pa ol hej pej c ]j ` _ki l naooekj
pdan]l u odkqh` bkhhks ]bpan oqncanu+ Fj ]_qpa ej fqnu kb

*) *

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
pda b]_a) l nei ]nu _hkoqna kb ` aba_po eo l nabanna` + Eks ar an)
ej i kop _]oao) ` aba_po i ]u d]r a pk ^a _kr ana` s epd ogej
cn]bpo kn hk_]h bh]l o+ Ckn l nei ]nu _kr an]ca) pda qoa kb
ogej cn]bpo eo pda oei l haop l nk_a` qna ]j ` odkqh` ^a
b]r kna` + Qdqo) hk_]h ]j ` nacekj ]h bh]l o i ]u ^a opehh ]r ]eh*
]^ha bkn ` abej epa bqpqna na_kj opnq_pekj + Ckn b]_e]h oq^qj epo)
ol a_e]h eooqao i ]u ]l l hu+
<<<& E8 6 B AFGEH6 G4 A7 C? 4 AA4 & 9d] RcX^ ] P[ 7 TUXRXcb
Fj oki a ]na]o kb pda ^qnj a` b]_a) oa_kj ` ]nu na_kj opnq_pekj
kb dul anpnkl de_ o_]no ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao ]na kb decd l neknepu+
> na]o oq_d ]o pda ql l an ]j ` hks an aua he` o) ql l an ]j `
hks an hel ) ]j ` j a_g s ehh j aa` a]nhu ]j ` _kj pej qkqo ar ]hq*
]pekj o ` qnej c pda na_kr anu l anek` + Cqj _pekj ]h ei l ]eni aj po
s ehh ^a na_kcj eva` ]j ` _knna_pa` a]nhu) pdqo l nar aj pej c
l ani ]j aj p oar ana ` ]i ]ca pk bqj _pekj ]h opnq_pqnao+ Fj
pdaoa oepq]pekj o a]nhu _knna_pekj ) ej _hq` ej c _ki l hapa
na_kj opnq_pekj ) i ]u ^a ]` r eo]^ha) ]hpdkqcd pdeo i ]u
_]qoa bqnpdan l nk^hai o ej pda h]pan _kqnoa+
*'
: kW^[Ve
Br aj s epd ]hh ej epe]h ]ppai l po pk l nar aj p pda l kopkl an]per a
bkni ]pekj kb auahe` a_pnkl ekj ) oq_d ]o a]nhu qoa kb ogej
cn]bpo) pda neog _]j j kp ^a _ki l hapahu ahei ej ]pa` + Br anu
` ]i ]ca ]j ` ]^j kni ]hepu kb pda auahe` ha]` o pk ei l ]eni aj p
kb pda auaîo bqj _pekj ]j ` l nkpa_pekj ) s epd naoqhp]j p oa_kj ` *
]nu l nk^hai o+ @knna_pekj o kb a_pnkl ekj o kb pda ql l an ]j `
hks an auahe` o s ehh) ej i kop _]oao) ^a ]_dear a` ^u pda qoa
kb ogej cn]bpo+ I k_]h bh]l o l naoaj p ]hpanj ]per a pa_dj emqao
bkn auahe` na_kj opnq_pekj ) ]hpdkqcd n]nahu qoa` + Qda ei l knp*
]j p l nej _el ha ej pda kl an]per a pna]pi aj p eo _ki l hapa at _eoekj
kb pda o_]n ]j ` kr an_knna_pej c s epd ogej cn]bpo+ T epd a]_d
l nk_a` qna) kj hu kj a he` odkqh` ^a _knna_pa` ej a]_d aua+
Lpdans eoa) pda j aa` a` kr an_knna_pekj eo ` ebbe_qhp pk
]_dear a+ > hok pda j aa` bkn i a` e]h kn h]pan]h _]j pdkl at u
i ]gao naopne_pekj pk kj a he` l an aua ]` r eo]^ha %. 6&+ Pqep]^ha
` kj kn ]na]o bkn ogej cn]bpo i ]u ^a bkqj ` ej pda napnk]qne_q*
h]n nacekj kb pda ql l an ej j an ]ni bkn pda hks an auahe` ) ]j `
bkn ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo pk pda ql l an auahe` o) ogej
i ]u ^a d]nr aopa` bnki pda oql n]_h]r e_qh]n nacekj + > j
]` ` epekj ]h) pai l kn]nu p]noknnd]l du i ]u ^a ]` r eo]^ha qj peh
_ki l hapa da]hej c kb pda ogej cn]bp d]o k__qnna` +
/ +
A[be
Qna]pi aj p kb ql l an ]j ` hks an hel ^qi o _]j ^a oqi i ]neva`
ej pdnaa opal o+ Fj epe]h pdan]l u ej _hq` ao pda qoa kb _qopki bep
kb kn]h ol hej po pk ]r ke` oar ana ` ]i ]ca+ Eks ar an) ej n]na
_]oao ep i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu pk l anbkni ] _knna_per a l nk*
_a` qna s epdej / *0 s aago ]bpan ej fqnu s epdkqp s ]epej c bkn
_ki l hapa o_]n i ]pqn]pekj + Qda i kop _ki i kj l nk^hai
dana eo i e_nkopki e]+ > o _ki l hapa kl aj ej c ]j ` _hkoqna kb
pda i kqpd ` al aj ` kj pda oui i apnu ]j ` bqj _pekj ]h ej pac*
nepu kb ^kpd _ki i eooqnao) o_]no ej pdeo ]na] s ehh _]qoa oec*
j ebe_]j p ei l ]eni aj p+ J kop na_kj opnq_per a pa_dj emqao qoa
r ]ne]pekj o kb kn]h i q_ko] bh]l o kn W*l h]opeao %/ - )/ 0&+
T epd ]j ]` ` epekj ]h a_pnkl ekj kb pda hks an hel ) ] ^qnj o_]n
naha]oa ]j ` ]j kr an_knna_pej c ogej cn]bp odkqh` ^a qoa`
pk ahei ej ]pa l na*kl an]per a o_]n paj oekj +
, '
CWU]
Fj ol epa kb ej paj oebea` ol hej pej c ` qnej c pda ]_qpa l d]oa
pdan]l u) r anpe_]h o_]n ^]j ` o i ]u ` ar ahkl ej j a_g ^qi o
]j ` ha]` pk h]pan j a_g _kj pn]_pqnao XCec+ . 2+. %? &Y+ J ej kn
o_]n ^]j ` o i ]u ^a _knna_pa` s epd W*l h]opeao) ^u ej panl koej c
j kni ]h peooqa s epd o_]n peooqa ej pk ] dknevkj p]h kneaj p]pekj +
J ]fkn o_]n ^]j ` o j aa` ej _na]oa` oqnce_]h abbknpo+ Qda
oar ana ei i a` e]pa ]j ` hkj c*pani abba_po kb ] j a_g _kj pn]_*
pqna s ehh ok_e]hhu ]j ` bqj _pekj ]hhu ` a^ehep]pa pda l ]peaj p+
Qdanabkna) ] _kj _eoa l h]j kb na_kj opnq_pekj odkqh` ^a
bkni a` a]nhu+ T daj ar an l kooe^ha) s ]epej c bkn o_]n i ]pq*
n]pekj eo ]` r eo]^ha+ Qda qoa kb b]_ek_qp]j akqo bh]l o) aepdan
n]j ` ki kn ]t e]h*l ]ppanj a` ) i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu ej h]pa na_kj *
opnq_pekj kb pda j a_g+ Qda oql n]_h]r e_qh]n eoh]j ` bh]l d]o
^aaj ` ao_ne^a` pk ]` ` naoo pdeo eooqa %0)/ 2&+
Qeooqa at l ]j ` ano bkn j a_g na_kj opnq_pekj i ]u ^a qoa`
s epdkqp ] l nk^hai ) eb l h]_a` ej ] oql n]l h]opuoi ]h l h]j a
%/ 3&+ Bt l ]j ` ano ej pda _anr e_]h nacekj d]r a ^aaj l an*
bkni a` s epdkqp oecj ebe_]j p l nk^hai o+ Fj pda _anr e_]h l ko*
epekj ) at l ]j ` an ej bh]pekj ` kao _ki l naoo pda qj ` anhuej c
opnq_pqnao oq_d ]o pda fqcqh] n r aej ) _]nkpe` ]npanu)
pdunke` ) pn]_da]) ]j ` aokl d]cqo ^qp s epdkqp _hej e_]h oec*
j ebe_]j _a+ Aeop]j p pn]j ol koepekj bh]l o kn bnaa bh]l o ]na
n]nahu ej ` e_]pa` ej j a_g ` aba_po+
Qda i kop bnamqaj phu qoa` pa_dj emqa pk _knna_p at paj oer a
^qnj o_]no eo o_]n at _eoekj bkhhks a` ^u bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej
cn]bpo kn ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo %0&+ @ki l hapa at _eoekj
kb pda o_]n ^]j ` o eo j a_aoo]nu pk ]_dear a pda i ]t ei qi _kn*
na_pekj kb j a_g _kj pn]_pqnao ej ^qnj l ]peaj po+ T epd hei epa`
` kj kn oepao ej oar anahu ^qnj a` l ]peaj po) bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej
cn]bpo i ]u j kp ^a ]r ]eh]^ha+ Eana) ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej
cn]bpo ]na qpeheva` + L r an_knna_pekj i ]u ^a ` aoen]^ha s epd
]hh ogej cn]bpo+ Qda paj ` aj _u kb cn]bpo pk _kj pn]_p eo i q_d
decdan ej ol hep*pde_gj aoo cn]bpo+ > bpan pda p]ga kb ol hep*
pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo) _qopki eva` ol hej po odkqh` ^a ]l l hea`
pk l nar aj p da]` ]j ` j a_g i kr ai aj po qj peh pda ogej cn]bpo
d]r a i ]pqna` pk l nar aj p ] na_qnnaj p _kj pn]_pqna %. )/ &+
5 & 4 TbcWTcXR E TR^ ] bcadRcX^ ]
Qda bej ]h ]aopdape_ na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda ^qnj a` b]_a eo pda
l nk` q_p kb ] hkj c oaneao kb kl an]per a l nk_a` qnao+ Fb pda
kqp_ki a kb a]nhu*op]ca l nk_a` qnao eo kl pei ]h) kj hu oi ]hh

8eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT

*) +
_knna_pekj o ]na j a_aoo]nu pk l anba_p pda bej ]h ` ap]eho+ Rl kj
_ki l hapekj kb a]nhu na_kj opnq_per a l nk_a` qnao) l ]peaj po
i ]u namqaop ]` ` epekj ]h kl an]pekj o pk bqnpdan _knna_p pda
nai ]ej ej c ]aopdape_ qj epo+ T epd _ki l hapa o_]n i ]pqn]pekj )
] bej ]h na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda a]n kn pda j koa*b]_e]h ba]pqnao
_]j j ks ^a qj ` anp]gaj + Fj ]` ` epekj ) na_kj opnq_pekj kb a]no)
aua^nks o) j ]o]h ` abkni epeao ]j ` pda ql l an hel j ]o]h qj ep
_]j ^a ]` ` naooa` + Qda i ]fkn cqe` ahej a bkn pdan]l u l h]j *
j ej c ej pdeo na_kj opnq_pekj op]ca eo _ki i qj e_]pekj s epd
pda l ]peaj p+ Qda l ]peaj p ]ooeopo ej ` apani ej ej c pda bk_qo
kb deo na_kj opnq_per a j aa` o+ Qda oqncakj d]o pk ]` r eoa
]j ` dahl pda l ]peaj p pk na]_d ]j ej bkni a` ` a_eoekj ]^kqp
pda l nkl koa` kl an]pekj o ]j ` pdaen at l a_pa` kqp_ki a
%Cec+ . 2+/ &+
6 &
7 TRXbX^ ] @PZX] V
? qi na_kj opnq_pekj eo _d]n]_paneva` ^u pda qoa kb ` ebbanaj p
kl an]per a opn]paceao ej kj a l ]peaj p+ Qda l nei ]nu ck]h eo pk
]_dear a a]nhu ]j ` _ki l hapa ^qi s kqj ` _hkoqna s epdkqp
o_]n ` abkni epeao ]j ` _kj pn]_pqnao+ > ` ` epekj ]h ck]ho ]na
pda _knna_pekj kb okbp peooqa ` aba_po ]j ` bqj _pekj ]h ei l ]en*
i aj p+ Fj ` er e` q]heva` l kopkl an]per a pna]pi aj p s epd ol hej po
]j ` _ki l naooekj c]ni aj po eo kb qpi kop ei l knp]j _a+ Qda
a]nhu _kj _al p kb pna]pi aj p ck]ho eo pda ^]oe_ i a]oqna pk
]r ke` oa_kj ` ]nu _ki l he_]pekj o+ Qna]pi aj p ck]ho ]na na]*
heva` ej ] oamqaj pe]h kn` an) benop naopknej c ]_per a ]j `
l ]ooer a bqj _pekj bkhhks a` ^u ]aopdape_ na_kj opnq_pekj +
T daj pdaoa ck]ho ]na _ki ^ej a` ej ] oej cha kl an]per a
oappej c) l ]peaj p o]peob]_pekj ei l nkr ao+ Qda pa_dj emqao
qoa` bkn na_kj opnq_pekj bkhhks ] dean]n_de_]h kn` an op]npej c
bnki oei l ha l nk_a` qnao ha]` ej c pk i kna _ki l hat ]j `
naokqn_a ej paj oer a l nk_a` qnao+ ? qi o_]n at _eoekj bkh*
hks a` ^u l nei ]nu _hkoqna kb pda s kqj ` eo pda oei l haop
]j ` a]oeaop l kooe^ha _knna_per a l nk_a` qna+ Qda l nabkni a`
bnaa bh]l eo ] i kna _ki l hat l nk_a` qna hei epa` pk ol a_e]h
9XVdaT ) - &*
C]_e]h ^qi oê oamqaj _a kb pdan]l aqpe_ kl pekj o pk
l nar aj p hkj c*pani oamqah]a+
oepq]pekj o+ Br anu pa_dj emqa qoa` ) ej _hq` ao ol a_ebe_ ]` r ]j *
p]cao ]j ` ` eo]` r ]j p]cao) s de_d j aa` pk ^a _kj oe` ana` +
> o l nar ekqohu i aj pekj a` ) l nei ]nu _hkoqna i ]u ^a pda
oei l haop ]j ` b]opaop na_kj opi _per a l nk_a` qna ]bpan
nai kr ]h kb ^qnj a` peooqa+ Eks ar an) pdeo i ]u kj hu ^a
qoa` ej oi ]hh ` aba_po) s daj pda ^qnj eo oqnnkqj ` a` ^u
da]hpdu j kni ]h peooqa) s de_d i ]u ^a oqbbe_eaj phu i k^eheva`
pk b]_ehep]pa l nei ]nu _hkoqna+ T epd qj ` qa paj oekj kj s kqj `
a` cao) pda na_kj opi _per a ck]h s ehh j kp ^a ]_dear a` ]j ` pda
o_]n s ehh paj ` pk dul anpnkl du+ W*l h]opeao ]na ` kq^ha kl l ko*
ej c pn]j ol koepekj ogej bh]l o+ Qdau ]na ] oqnce_]h kl pekj pk
_knna_p ] ^qnj o_]n _kj pn]_pqna ^u haj cpdaj ej c ]j ` nakn*
eaj pej c pda _kj pn]_pa` o_]n+ Qda i apdk` o) dks ar an)
` al aj ` kj oqbbe_eaj p peooqa ^aej c ]r ]eh]^ha h]pan]hhu bnki
pda naol a_per a o_]n+ ? u qj ` anop]j ` ej c pda ^]oe_ l nej _el hao
kb W*l h]opeao) pdeo nahe]^ha l nk_a` qna eo bnamqaj phu qoa` ej
pda na_kj opi _pekj kb ^qi o_]n _kj pn]_pqnao) _hkoqna kb
ogej ` aba_po) kn na` ena_pekj kb o_]n hej ao+
Lj _a pda ^qnj ]na]o ]na pkk at paj oer a bkn at _eoekj ]j `
l nei ]nu _hkoqna kn _hkoqna qoej c W*l h]opeao) ogej cn]bpej c eo
pda j at p ]r ]eh]^ha opal ej pda oamqaj _a kb na_kj opi _per a
l nk_a` qnao+ > bpan at _eoekj kb h]nca ^qi o_]no kn _kj pn]_*
pqnao) s kqj ` a` cao s ehh kbpaj napn]_p naoqhpej c ej ] h]nca
peooqa ` aba_p+ @hkoqna kb pdaoa ` aba_po eo l anbkni a` ej ]j
a]ou) oqbbe_eaj p) ]j ` o]ba i ]j j an ^u bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej
cn]bpo kn ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo+ > hpdkqcd pda _dke_a
kb pda pul a kb ogej cn]bp i ]u ` al aj ` kj ej ` er e` q]h at l ane*
aj _a) oar an]h oqccaopekj o i ]u cqe` a pda qoa kb ogej pn]j o*
l h]j po+ Pl hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo ]na oqepa` bkn _hkoqna kb
h]ncan ` aba_p ]na]o+ > pdej ogej cn]bp qoq]hhu naoqhpo ej
cna]pan p]ga ]j ` namqenao ] haoo kl pei ]h s kqj ` ^a` +
Eks ar an) PQPDo s ehh _kj pn]_p i kna a]oehu ]j ` pda _ko*
i ape_ ]l l a]n]j _a i ]u ^a qj o]peob]_pknu ]j ` _ki l hapahu
` ebbanaj p bnki pda ` kj kn ] j ` ,kn na_el eaj p ]na]o+ Cqhh pde_g*
j aoo ogej cn]bpo s ehh ]_dear a ]aopdape_]hhu pda i kop ]l l a]h*
ej c naoqhpo+ Eks ar an) ` eo]` r ]j p]cao ej _hq` a ] hei epa`
]r ]eh]^ehepu ]j ` pda _na]pekj kb ]j ]` ` epekj ]h o_]n+ Qda
oeva kb pda ogej cn]bp eo hei epa` ^u pda j aa` bkn l nei ]nu
_hkoqna kb pda ` kj kn ` aba_p+ Fj ]` ` epekj ) bqhh*pde_gj aoo
ogej cn]bpo namqena ]j kl pei ]h s kqj ` ^a` s epd decd r ]o_q*
h]nepu ]j ` hks ^]_pane]h _kj p]i ej ]pekj + Lj _a bqhh p]ga d]o
^aaj ]_dear a` ) bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo s ehh l nkr e` a ]
decd*mq]hepu oq^opepqpa bkn pda knecej ]h ogej _kr an ^u
oei eh]n l nkl anpeao kb ogej _khkn ]j ` pat pqna+ Fj _kj pn]op)
bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo) _kj pn]_p haoo ]j ` pdqo ]_dear a
pdaen bej ]h kqp_ki a a]nhean+
@ki l koepa cn]bpo i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu s epd at paj oer a
peooqa ` aba_po) ej _hq` ej c ogej ]j ` qj ` anhuej c oql l knpej c
peooqa) oq_d ]o ej na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda j koa+ Qkp]h kn
l ]npe]h hkoo kb ]h]n _]npeh]ca i ]u ^a nal h]_a` ^u ]j ]l l nk*
l ne]pahu oeva` _ki l koepa cn]bp bnki pda a]n+ Eks ar an) pda
qoa kb _ki l koepa cn]bpo eo hei epa` + Qdau ]na ^]oe_]hhu
bnaa cn]bpo s epdkqp ] ` abej a` ^hkk` oql l hu ]j ` ` al aj ` kj
]j kl pei ]h s kqj ` ^a` pk oql l knp pda cn]bp+ Qdeo ]hok

*) ,

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
hei epo pda oeva ql pk s de_d ] _ki l koepa cn]bp i ]u ^a o]bahu
pn]j ol h]j pa` + > oeva kb - +2 _i t - +2 _i t - +2 _i s ehh
j a]nhu ]hs ]uo naoqhp ej p]ga kb pda _ki l koepa cn]bp+
? aoe` ao oq^pha oqnce_]h pa_dj emqa ` qnej c cn]bp d]nr aop
]j ` s kqj ` ^a` l nal ]n]pekj ) op]^ha cn]bp bet ]pekj i qop ^a
]_dear a` pk k^p]ej ] ckk` p]ga n]pa+ I k_]h _ki l naooekj
^]j ` ]cao kn pea*kr an ` naooej co ]na kb qoa pk l nkr e` a bet *
]pekj kb cn]bpo kj pda s kqj ` ^a` + Qdeo l nar aj po bhqe` kn
dai ]pki ] napaj pekj qj ` anj a]pd pda ogej cn]bpo) ei l nkr ao
j akr ]o_qh]nev]pekj ) ]j ` l nkr e` ao l anba_p ]hecj i aj p s epd
pda qj ` anhuej c oqnb]_a+
Fj oepq]pekj o s dana ogej cn]bpo s ehh j kp ^a ]r ]eh]^ha kn
j kp ^a oqbbe_eaj p pk _kr an pda ` aba_p) bh]l _kr an]ca i ]u
^a j a_aoo]nu+ Bt l koa` ^kj a s epdkqp l anekopa]h _kr an]ca)
qj _kr ana` paj ` kj o) ]j ` kl aj fkej p s ehh j kp oql l knp ]
ogej cn]bp) ]j ` daj _a namqena ` abej epa bh]l _kr an]ca+ Ch]l
]hok i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu ej pda na_kj opnq_pekj kb _kj pkqn
ennacqh]nepeao ]bpan at paj oer a okbp peooqa ` aba_po kn pk
_kr an l nki ej aj p ^kj a+ Qda bh]l o qoa` ej _hq` a b]o_ek_qp]*
j akqo n]j ` ki l ]ppanj kn ]t e]h l ]ppanj bh]l o ]j ` i qo_qhk*
_qp]j akqo bh]l o+ Cnaa bh]l o ]na n]nahu qoa` ej ol a_e]h
oepq]pekj o+ Qeooqa at l ]j oekj eo ] r ]hq]^ha pkkh ej b]_e]h
na_kj opnq_pekj ]j ` i ]u ^a qoa` bkn _knna_pekj kb ^qnj ]hk*
l ave]) j a_g _kj pn]_pqna naha]oa) ]j ` naoqnb]_ej c kb pda f] s
hej a+ Qeooqa at l ]j oekj oql l heao peooqa kb oei eh]n _khkn)
pde_gj aoo) ]j ` pat pqna+ Eks ar an) at ]_p l h]j j ej c eo j a_aoo*
]nu pk ]_dear a pda namqena` ]i kqj p kb peooqa+ > ` r ]j p]cao
ej _hq` a pda kbpaj hei epa` ]r ]eh]^ehepu kb ]j qj ^qnj a`
hk_]h ogej ]na] bkn at l ]j ` an ei l h]j p]pekj + Qda j aa` bkn
oar an]h l nk_a` qnao ]j ` pda l nkhkj ca` l anek` kb at l ]j oekj
]j ` pda ]ook_e]pa` ]aopdape_ ` eopknpekj ]j ` ` eobecqn]pekj
s ehh l qp ]` ` epekj ]h opnaoo kj pda l ]peaj p+
7 &
FZX] @PcRW
Qda na_kj opnq_per a oqncakj eo b]_ej c uap ]j kpdan ]` ` epekj ]h
l nk^hai + Ckn na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda ^qnj a` b]_a) ` kj kn ogej
d]o pk ^a kb decd mq]hepu+ I k_]hhu) pda ` kj kn ogej odkqh`
l nkr e` a i ]p_dej c pat pqna) _khkn) pde_gj aoo) ]j ` d]en
cnks pd+ Akj kn ]na]o bqhbehhej c ]hh pdaoa namqenai aj po ]na
n]na+ Qdqo) nacekj o kb haooan mq]hepu i ]u d]r a pk ^a qoa` +
Qdeo eo aol a_e]hhu pnqa ej _]oao kb h]nca pkp]h ^k` u
oqnb]_a ]na] ^qi o s dana ` kj kn oepao ]na hei epa` + > ogej
cn]bp p]gaj bnki ] ` kj kn oepa _hkoa pk pda na_kj opnq_pa`
]na] caj an]hhu odks o ] _hkoan i ]p_d kb ogej l nkl anpeao+
Qda ]na]o kb _dke_a bkn pda na_kj opnq_pekj kb b]_e]h
^qi o ]na pda napnk]qne_qh]n nacekj ) pda j a_g) ]j ` pda oql n]*
_h]r e_qh]n nacekj ) ]j ` haoo bnamqaj phu pda ql l an ]ni kn pda
ql l an pdkn]_e_ ]na]o+ Fj _]oa pdaoa ]na]o ]na j kp ]r ]eh]^ha)
` kj kn oepao s epd i ej ei ]h d]en cnks pd ]j ` ]na]o s epd
i ej ei ]h _khkn i eoi ]p_d odkqh` ^a _dkoaj + > _khkn i eo*
i ]p_d kb hecdpan ogej cn]bp ]na]o s ehh ]hs ]uo ^a ]l l ]naj p
kj ] j kni ]hhu p]j j a` b]_a+ Pei eh]nhu) pda l knkqo ogej
p]gaj bnki pda pdecd s ehh ]hs ]uo ^a l nki ej aj phu r eoe^ha
s daj qoa` ej b]_e]h na_kj opnq_pekj + Qda qj emqa l nkl anpeao
kb b]_e]h ogej s epd epo bej a opnq_pqna) pdej oq^_qp]j akqo
h]uan) ]j ` decd ah]ope_epu _]j kj hu ^a ej oqbbe_eaj phu
nal h]_a` + Fb at paj ` a` ]na]o kb ^qnj a` b]_e]h ogej d]r a pk
^a _kr ana` ) pdaj pda s dkha ]aopdape_ nacekj odkqh` ^a
_kr ana` s epd ogej cn]bpo kb pda ^aop ]r ]eh]^ha mq]hepu+
I ]_gej c pdkoa) ar anu abbknp odkqh` ^a qj ` anp]gaj pk
_kr an i qhpel ha ]aopdape_ oq^qj epo ej kj a oaooekj + Qda
^aop naoqhpo s ehh ^a ]_dear a` ^u qoej c h]nca*oeva` ogej
cn]bpo kj pda at _eoa` b]_e]h ^qnj s kqj ` s epdkqp l ]p_d
s kngej c+ Pgej cn]bp ^kn` ano ]j ` oqpqnao odkqh` ^a l h]_a`
ej ej _kj ol e_qkqo nacekj o kb pda b]_a+ ? u p]gej c
i ]t ei qi *oeva ogej cn]bpo ]j ` l h]_ej c pdai ej pn]j or anoa
kneaj p]pekj ]_nkoo pda b]_a) ps k kn pdnaa ogej cn]bp odaapo
s ehh ^a oqbbe_eaj p pk ]_dear a _ki l hapa _kr an]ca ]j ` abbe*
_eaj p na_kj opnq_pekj + > i ]fkn ]` r ]j p]ca kb pdeo ]l l nk]_d
eo pda naoqhpej c i ej ei ]h o_]nnej c ej pda _aj pn]h b]_a+
Pqpqna hej ao ]j ` cn]bp ^kn` ano i ]u ^a l h]_a` h]pan]hhu
ej pk pda d]en*^a]nej c pai l kn]h nacekj kn pda h]pan]h
bnkj p]h nacekj + Qda naoqhpej c dknevkj p]h oqpqna hej a _]j ^a
nah]per ahu s ahh de` ` aj ej pda l anek_qh]n kn l anekn]h b]_e]h
oq^i epo+ Qda hkj c*pani naoqhpo kb pdeo pa_dj e_]h ]l l nk]_d
]na oqnl neoej c) ]o kr an pei a) b]_e]h s nej ghej c k__qno
oei eh]n pk pda knecej ]h b]_e]h ba]pqna+ Qda naopkn]pekj kb
b]_e]h at l naooekj eo cna]phu aj d]j _a` ej _ki l ]neokj pk ]
naopkn]pekj kneaj pa` pks ]n` ej ` er e` q]h b]_e]h oq^qj epo) pda
naoqhpej c ej _na]oa` o_]nnej c) ]j ` pda i ]og*hega ]l l a]n*
]j _a+ > oei eh]n ]l l nk]_d i ]u ^a qoa` ej bqhh*pde_gj aoo
ogej cn]bpo kn s epd _anr e_k*l a_pkn]h b]o_ek_qp]j akqo
bh]l o+ Qda j aa` bkn l nei ]nu _hkoqna kb pda ` kj kn oepao)
dks ar an) naopne_po pda qoa kb bqhh*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo pk
oi ]hhan ]na]o _ki l neoej c oar an]h b]_e]h oq^qj epo+ Qda qoa
kb _anr e_k*l a_pkn]h bh]l o s ehh namqena l nei ]nu ]j ` oa_kj ` *
]nu pdej j ej c kb pda bh]l pk na` q_a pda _kj pkqn i eoi ]p_d
^aps aaj ` kj kn ]na] ]j ` pda na_el eaj p b]_e]h nacekj +
8&
6 ^ \ _aTbbX^ ] GWTaP_h
Qna]pi aj p kb ^qi o_]no eo ] pei a*_kj oqi ej c ]j ` pa` ekqo
l nk_aoo+ Fp namqenao opnaj qkqo abbknpo kb ^kpd l ]peaj p ]j `
oqncakj ) ]j ` kbpaj ueah` o kj hu ej oqbbe_eaj p naoqhpo+ > l nej *
_el ]h ahai aj p kb l kop^qnj o_]n pna]pi aj p eo _ki l naooekj
pdan]l u+ Bt panj ]h _ki l naooekj ]o ] i a]j o pk ]bba_p o_]n
i ]pqn]pekj d]o ^aaj ej r aopec]pa` ]j ` ej pnk` q_a` ej pk
_hej e_]h l n]_pe_a ` qnej c pda h]op ` a_]` ao+ Aqnej c pdeo pei a
oar an]h ei l nkr ai aj po d]r a ^aaj ]_dear a` ) oq_d ]o pda
]r ]eh]^ehepu kb _qopki *i ]` a _ki l naooekj c]ni aj po kn
_qopki *i ]` a ol hej po+ Qda at ]_p bep kb _ki l naooekj c]n*
i aj po eo kb qpi kop ei l knp]j _a bkn ]_dear ej c pda ` aoena`
naoqhpo+ > hkkoa bep kb c]ni aj po s ehh j kp ^a ]^ha pk
l nkr e` a oqbbe_eaj p _ki l naooekj kj ^qi o_]no8 ] pecdp bep
i ecdp naoqhp ej l naooqna nah]pa` ogej h]_an]pekj o kn r ]o_qh]n
_ki l nki eoa+ ? a]nej c ej i ej ` pd]p _ki l naooekj pdan]l u kb

8 eP[dPcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS 9PRT

*) -
o_]no eo ] ` uj ]i e_ l nk_aoo) _kj pej qkqo i kj epknej c kb o_]no
]j ` pda _ki l naooekj qoa` eo j a_aoo]nu+ Fj pda ej epe]h
l anek` ) c]ni aj po i ]u d]r a pk ^a i k` ebea` ]j ` ]hpana` bna*
mqaj phu8 pki c]ni aj po d]r a pk ^a nal h]_a` ) ]o pdau s ehh j kp
l nkr e` a pda ` aoena` abba_po+ > _dear ej c oqbbe_eaj p l ]peaj p
_ki l he]j _a i ]u l koa ]j ]` ` epekj ]h l nk^hai pk pda pna]pej c
^qnj pa]i + Manba_phu beppej c ]j ` s ahh*i ]ej p]ej a` _ki *
l naooekj c]ni aj po s ehh ei l nkr a l ]peaj p _ki l he]j _a+ Pq^*
kl pei ]h bep s epd pda naoqhpej c l ]ej kn o_]n paj ` anj aoo s ehh
i kop _anp]ej hu ha]` pk ] oecj ebe_]j p ` ah]u ej abba_per a o_]n
pdan]l u+ Fj at paj oer a ^qnj o_]no) amq]h ` eopne^qpekj kb
l naooqna s ehh ^a ` ebbe_qhp pk ]_dear a+ Lj pda ennacqh]nhu
od]l a` ^k` u oqnb]_a pdeo _]j kj hu ^a l nkr e` a` ^u pda
qoa kb _qopki *i ]` a oehe_kj a ah]opki an ej h]uo ej pda b]^ne*
_]pa` c]ni aj po+ Fj ]` ` epekj pk hk_]h l naooqna) oehe_kj a
ah]opki an epoahb odks o l koeper a abba_p ^u okbpaj ej c pda
o_]n peooqa+ Qda qj ` anhuej c i a_d]j eoi bkn pdeo l daj ki *
aj kj eo opehh qj ` an ej r aopec]pekj + Oeogo kb hkj c*op]j ` ej c
_ki l naooekj pdan]l u d]r a ^aaj ` ao_ne^a` ]o ` ah]ua`
` ar ahkl i aj p kb pda i ]j ` e^ha) hkoo kb pda ]j ]pki e_ ]n_de*
pa_pqna kb pda l ]hi ]n ]n_d) kn pdkn]_e_ ` abkni epeao+
9&
4 acXUXRXP[ FZX] 6 ^eTaPVT
Qda hkoo kb pda al e` ani ]h ]j ` ` ani ]h ogej h]uan oecj ebe*
_]j phu aj ` ]j cano oqnr er ]h kb ] ^qi r e_pei + Qda ogej bqj _*
pekj o ]o ^]nnean ]c]ej op bhqe` ]j ` l nkpaej hkoo) kn pk l nar aj p
pda ej r ]oekj kb i e_nk^e]h knc]j eoi o kr an h]nca s kqj ` oqn*
b]_ao+ Rj peh j ks ) cn]bpej c kb pda l ]peaj pîo ks j ogej nai ]ej o
pda ^aop i a]j o pk nal h]_a ` ]i ]ca` ]j ` hkop ogej ]na]o+
Eks ar an) at paj oer a ^qi o hei ep pda ]na] kb ` kj kn oepao ]r ]eh*
]^ha ]j ` ]hpanj ]per a ogej _kr an]ca i ]pane]ho j aa` pk ^a
_kj oe` ana` ` qnej c pda ]_qpa pna]pi aj p l anek` + Aqnej c pda
h]op ` a_]` ao) oecj ebe_]j p l nkcnaoo d]o ^aaj ]_dear a` ej
pda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb ]npebe_e]h ogej _kr an]ca i ]pane]ho+ Qda
i ]pane]ho ej pnk` q_a` ej pk _hej e_]h qoa _]j ^a ` ebbanaj pe]pa`
]o pai l kn]nu ]j ` l ani ]j aj p ogej _kr an]ca i ]pane]ho+
*'
I W_ badSdk H][` 8 ahWdSYW B SfWd[S^e
Eqi ]j ]i j ekj eo ^aej c qoa` bkn _kr an]ca kb _ha]j oql an*
be_e]h ^qnj o kn ogej cn]bp ` kj kn ]na]o+ > bpan ^qnj s kqj `
at _eoekj ) ep i ]u ^a qoa` ]o pai l kn]nu _kr an qj peh oqbbe_eaj p
]qpkhkckqo ogej cn]bpo ]na ]r ]eh]^ha+ > i j ekj d]o ^aaj
qoa` ]o bnaod) _nuk*l naoanr a` kn ]o ` ar ep]heva` ) chu_ankh
pna]pa` l nk` q_p+ J ]fkn ]` r ]j p]cao ej _hq` a pda a]ou ]j `
b]op l nk_qnai aj p ]j ` epo h]nca ]r ]eh]^ehepu ]hok ej qj ` an*
` ar ahkl a` _kqj pneao+ Qda i ]fkn ` eo]` r ]j p]ca eo pda l kpaj *
pe]h neog kb r en]h _kj p]i ej ]pekj ]j ` pda neog kb EFS ]j `
dal ]pepeo pn]j oi eooekj ) s de_d i ]u ^a i ej ei eva` ) ^qp j kp
_ki l hapahu at _hq` a` ) ^u ` kj kn o_naaj ej c ]j ` ]` ` epekj ]h
chu_ankh pna]pi aj p kb ]i j ekj + Qdaoa eooqao _qnnaj phu
hei ep pda _hej e_]h qoa kb ]i j ekj +
Mec ogej d]o ^aaj aop]^heoda` ]o pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca
i ]pane]h kr an oar an]h ua]no+ Fpo l nk_qnai aj p ]j ` l na*
l ]n]pekj ]na a]ou ]j ` _]j ^a l anbkni a` ej ]j ej ` qopne]heva`
b]odekj + Mec ogej i ]u ^a kn` ana` ]o odaapo kn ]o i aod
cn]bpo+ Fp eo ]r ]eh]^ha ]o bnaod) nabnecan]pa` ) _nuk*l naoanr a` )
kn chu_ankh pna]pa` ogej + Mec t aj kcn]bpo s ehh ]` dana pk ]
_ha]j s kqj ` ) pdqo ei l nkr ej c l ]ej naheab ]j ` s kqj `
da]hej c+ Eks ar an) l ec ogej s ehh j kp ^a r ]o_qh]neva` ]j `
` ani ]h ahai aj po s ehh j kp ^a ej pacn]pa` ej pk pda nacaj an]pa`
ogej + Qn]j oi eooekj kb r en]h r a_pkno oaai o pk ^a ]j eooqa kb
i ej kn ei l knp]j _a+ ? ]_pane]h _kj p]i ej ]pekj i ]u ^a
` a_na]oa` ^u qoej c ]` ` epekj ]h hk_]h ]j peoal pe_o) oq_d ]o
A]gej o okhqpekj kn oehr an*j epn]pa okhqpekj +
Eqi ]j _]` ]r ane_ ` kj kn ogej i ]u ^a qoa` ej ] oei eh]n
b]odekj ]o l ec ogej bkn pda pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca kb at _eoa`
^qnj s kqj ` o+ Fp s ehh ^a l ]npe]hhu r ]o_qh]neva` ]j ` i ]u
ar aj ^a l ]npe]hhu ej pacn]pa` ej pk pda j ak ogej + > o pai l kn]nu
_kr an) ep opei qh]pao hk_]h cnks pd b]_pkn l nk` q_pekj ]j ` cn]j *
qh]n peooqa bkni ]pekj + Eks ar an) l nk_qnai aj p eo naopne_pa` pk
]__na` epa` peooqa ]j ` ogej ^]j go+ Dqe` ahej ao oap ^u pda
> i ane_]j > ook_e]pekj kb Qeooqa ? ]j go %> > Q? & oecj ebe*
_]j phu na` q_a pda neog kb r en]h ]j ` ^]_pane]h pn]j oi eooekj +
> hhkcn]bpo ]na oql l hea` ^u > > Q? ]__na` epa` ej opepqpekj o
kn pda Bqnk ogej ^]j g ]o bnaod) _nuk*l naoanr a` ) kn chu*
_ankh*l naoanr a` odaap kn i aoda` ogej cn]bpo+
Puj pdape_) oai el ani a]^ha i ai ^n]j ao ]na _ki i an_e]hhu
]r ]eh]^ha bkn pai l kn]nu s kqj ` _kr an]ca+ Qdau l nkr e` a oqb*
be_eaj p ^]nnean bqj _pekj pk l nar aj p s kqj ` ` aoe__]pekj kn ^]_*
pane]h _kj p]i ej ]pekj + Qdau ]hok na` q_a l ]ej + Qdaoa) i kophu
kj a kn ^eh]uana` ) i ai ^n]j ao ]na qoa` bkn oql anbe_e]h ^qi
s kqj ` ` naooej co kn _kr an]ca kb ogej cn]bp ` kj kn oepao+ > o
i kop kb pdaoa i ai ^n]j ao ]na abba_per a k__hqoer a s kqj `
` naooej co) qo]ca kj ] _kj p]i ej ]pa` s kqj ` s ehh naoqhp ej
^]_pane]h ej ba_pekj kb pda ^qnj s kqj ` + Oa_aj phu) ouj pdape_
i ai ^n]j ao d]r a ^aaj qoa` ej _ki ^ej ]pekj s epd r e]^ha ]hhk*
caj e_ _ahh cn]bpo %qoq]hhu ]hhkcaj e_ j akj ]p]h be^nk^h]op&+ Fj
]` ` epekj pk epo ^]nnean bqj _pekj ) pda i ai ^n]j a ]_po ]o ]
_]nnean kb r e]^ha _ahho s de_d) ej pqnj ) s ehh at l naoo ]j ` opei q*
h]pa hk_]h cnks pd b]_pkn l nk` q_pekj +
/ +
EWd_ S` W` f H][` 8 ahWdSYW
Qda _qhpqna kb al e` ani ]h ]qpkcn]bpo %@B> & d]o ^aaj aop]^*
heoda` ]o ] qoabqh pkkh ej ^qnj oqncanu+ Eks ar an) pda ej epe]h
at l a_p]pekj o d]r a j kp ^aaj bqbehha` + Qda l kooe^ehepu pk
_qhpqna h]nca ]na]o kb al e` ani ]h ogej cn]bpo bnki oi ]hh
]r ]eh]^ha ` kj kn oepao eo ]l l a]hej c+ Eks ar an) s epd ej _na]o*
ej c qoa ]j ` hkj c*pani bkhhks *ql ) oecj ebe_]j p ` n]s ^]_go
^a_]i a ]l l ]naj p+ Fj ]` ` epekj pk aj kni kqo bej ]j _e]h
_kopo) @B> odks ] oecj ebe_]j phu ` a_na]oa` da]hej c l kpaj *
pe]h ]j ` ]na ` ahe_]pa ]j ` r qhan]^ha namqenej c h]pan oa_kj ` *
]nu ]qpkcn]bpej c+ Fj at paj oer a ^qi o s epd i ej ei ]hhu
]r ]eh]^ha ` kj kn oepao) dks ar an) @B> i ]u kbban ] r ]hq]^ha
kl l knpqj epu pk ]_dear a s kqj ` _kr an]ca+

*) .

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
Qda _hej e_]h l nk^hai o oaaj s epd _qhpqnao kb al e` ani ]h
]qpkcn]bpo ha` pk pda bej ` ej c pd]p ]j ej p]_p ` ani ]h h]uan eo
ei l knp]j p pk l nkr e` a oql l ha ]j ` naoeop]j p ogej _kr an]ca
s epd ` ei ej eoda` o_]nnej c+ > ouj pdape_ ]_ahhqh]n ` ani ]h
i ]pnet oq^opepqpa eo ]r ]eh]^ha ]o Fj pacn]à + Fp _kj oeopo kb ]
i ]pnet kb chu_ko]i ej kchu_]j o ]j ` _khh]caj be^ano)
_kr ana` ^u ] oai el ani a]^ha oehe_kj a h]uan+ > bpan ej epe]h
pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca kb pda at _eoa` ^qi s kqj ` ) pda
` ani ]h i ]pnet h]uan eo r ]o_qh]neva` ]j ` _]j ^a cn]bpa`
s epd ] pdej ]qpkcn]bp+ J ]fkn ` eo]` r ]j p]cao ]na pda
ej _na]oa` neog kb oa_kj ` ]nu ej ba_pekj ]j ` pda _kop kb
pda l nk` q_p+ > j kpdan ]l l nk]_d pk pda naopkn]pekj kb pda
` ani ]h i ]pnet eo pda qoa kb _nuk*l naoanr a` _]` ]r ane_
` ani ]h ]qpkcn]bpo) s de_d ]na oq^oamqaj phu _kr ana` ^u
pdej ]qpkcn]bpo+ Qda _ki ^ej ]pekj kb pda ]bknai aj pekj a`
pa_dj emqao ]l l a]no pk ^a ] hkce_]h _kj oamqaj _a+ > hh
naoa]n_d bk_qoa` kj pdeo ck]h ` ai kj opn]pa` ei l naooer a
naoqhpo ej ]j ei ]h at l anei aj po+ Eks ar an) nahe]^ha _hej e_]h
` ]p] ]na opehh i eooej c+
> ` ` epekj ]h pa_dj emqao) oq_d ]o caj ape_ i k` ebe_]pekj o kb
gan]pej k_upao i ]u aj d]j _a s kqj ` da]hej c ^u kl pei evej c
pda hk_]h s kqj ` aj r enkj i aj p+ @ahho ]na aj cej aana` pk
kr anat l naoo cnks pd b]_pkno) oq_d ]o MADC) FDC*. ) BDC)
HDC) kn kpdano+ Qdeo ]l l nk]_d kl aj o pda beah` pk r ]nekqo
i k` ebe_]pekj o kb pda ]^kr a i aj pekj a` pa_dj emqao) ^ekhkce*
_]h ]j ` ouj pdape_ ogej _kr an]ca i ]pane]ho+ Akj kn oepa
s kqj ` da]hej c i ]u ^a ei l nkr a` ]j ` b]opaj a` + S ]nekqo
_ki ^ej ]pekj o kb peooqa aj cej aana` ogej oq^opepqpao i ]u
^a ei l nkr a` + Qda e` a]h okhqpekj ) dks ar an) kb ] l ani ]j aj p
]j ` _ki l hapa ogej oq^opepqpa) s de_d _]j ^a ]l l hea` ]bpan
ej epe]h at _eoekj kb pda ^qi s kqj ` ]j ` s ehh da]h _ki l hapahu
s epdkqp pda j aa` kb nacn]bpej c) namqenao bqnpdan naoa]n_d+
Qda _ki ^ej ]pekj kb peooqa aj cej aanej c pa_dj emqao ]j `
caj ape_ i k` ebe_]pekj kb _ahho ]_per ]pa` ` qnej c pda s kqj `
da]hej c oamqaj _a i ]u bej ]hhu okhr a pda l nk^hai o nah]pa`
pk ] oqncakj îo ` na]i kb _ki l hapa naopkn]pekj kb pda hkop
peooqa+
E8 98 E8 A6 8 F
. +
Oer ano B> ) Ppn]pa OD) Pkhai I A+ Qda pn]j ol ]naj p b]_a*
i ]og+ > i G L__ql Qdan . 6468 007. - 5*. . 0+
/ +
Gkn` ]j O? ) A]dan G) T ]oeh H+ Pl hej po ]j ` o_]n i ]j ]cai aj p
bkn ]_qpa ]j ` na_kj opnq_per a ^qi _]na+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc
/ - - - 8 / 474. *52+
0+
Oai aj oj u` an GM) Akj ah]j J ? + Oa_kj opi _pekj kb pda da]`
]j ` j a_g+ Fj 7 Eanj ` kj ) a` + Qkp]h ? qi @]na+ / j ` a`
Mdeh]` ahl de]7 T ? P]qj ` ano) / - - / 7323*356+
1+
Eqj p G) Mqn` qa D) Pl e_an Q+ J ]j ]cai aj p kb bqhh pde_gj aoo
^qi o kb pda o_]hl ]j ` ogqhh+ > n_d Pqnc . 6508 . . 573/ . *3/ 2+
2+
Eq]j c QQ) I ]nokj AI ) I as eo PO+ ? qi ]hkl a_e]+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6448 3- 7430*434+
3+
O]j ar A) Pdej ` ]nogu ? + Ll an]per a pna]pi aj p kb ` aal ^qi o
kb pda o_]hl + ? nep G Mh]op Pqnc . 6368 . / 70- 6*0. / +
4+
E ]nneokj PE+ Bt l koqna kb pda ogqhh bnki ^qi o+ ? n G Mh]op
Pqnc . 62/ 8 17/ 46+
5+
Pdane` ]j OI ) @dkq_]en OG) Akj ah]j J ? + J ]j ]cai aj p kb
i ]ooer a _]hr ]ne]h at l koqna ej ukqj c _deh` naj + G ? qi
@]na Oad]^eh . 6658 . 67/ 6*0/ +
6+
Pl eao J ) J _@]qhau OI ) J q` ca ? O) E ai ` kj AK+
J ]j ]cai aj p kb ]_qpa _]hr ]ne]h ^qi o ej _deh` naj +
G Qn]qi ] / - - 08 21%1&7432*436+
. -+ Cnea` J ) Okoaj ^anc ? ) Qq_di ]j F) ? aj *E qn K) V]n` aj e M)
Ppanj ^anc K) Dkh]j G+ Bha_pne_]h ^qi ej fqnu kb pda o_]hl ê
^kj a nacnks pd bkhhks ej c ]l l he_]pekj kb h]peooei qo ` knoe bnaa
bh]l pk pda ]na]+ ? qi o . 66. 8 . 47005+
. . +
L npe_k_da] J + Kas pdnaa*bh]l na_kj opi _pekj pa_dj emqa+
? n G Mh]op Pqnc . 64. 8 / 17. 51*. 55+
. / +
Gqngeas e_v J G) Eehh EI + Ll aj s kqj ` o kb pda o_]hl 7 ]j
]__kqj p kb i apdk` o kb nal ]en+ G Qn]qi ] . 65. 8 / . 7436*445+
. 0+ Pehr an^anc ? ) ? ]j eo G@) S an` e DA) > _h]j ` OA+ J e_nkr ]o*
_qh]n na_kj opi _pekj ]bpan aha_pne_]h ]j ` ` aal pdani ]h
ej fqnu+ G Qn]qi ] . 6538 / 37. / 5*. 01+
. 1+
I kogaj > ) @]nhokj DT ) @qh^anpokj GE) P_kpp Eqhpi ]j j @)
Hqi ]n > S ) Gkj ao DB) ? kops e_g G FFF) Gqngeas e_v J G+
L i aj p]h bnaa bh]l na_kj opi _pekj ej _ki l hat da]` ]j `
j a_g ` abkni epeao+ E a]` Ka_g / - - / 8 / 170/ 3*00. +
. 2+
? ]nnap GM) Aveas qhoge M) J _@]qhau OI ) Eai ` kj AK)
Aao]e J E+ Aqn]h na_kj opi _pekj kb ] _h]oo FS _]hr ]ne]h ^qi
s epd ` a_ahhqh]neva` dqi ]j ` ani eo+ ? qi o . 6668 / 27126*13/ +
. 3+
Dnkaj ar ahp C) r ]j Qnean > G) Hdkqs VI + Qda qoa kb ]hhk*
cn]bpo ej pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb at l koa` _]hr ]ne]h aha_pne_]h
s kqj ` o kb pda ogqhh+ > j j KV > _]` P_e . 6668 5557. - 6*. . / +
. 4+
? anj ]n` PI + Oa_kj opi _pekj kb pda ^qnj a` j koa ]j ` a]n+
@hej Mh]op Pqnc / - - - 8 / 4764*. . / +
. 5+
Pga` nko AD) Dkh` b]n^ FT ) Ph]pan E+ @dkj ` nepeo kb pda
^qnj a` a]n7 ] nar eas + B]n Kkoa Qdnk]p G . 66/ 8 4. 7026*03/ +
. 6+ > _d]qan ? J ) > ` ]en PO+ > _qpa ]j ` na_kj opi _per a i ]j ]ca*
i aj p kb pda ^qnj a` auahe` + @hej Mh]op Pqnc / - - - 8 / 4754*63+
/ - + Maj ohan GJ ) Okoaj pd]h > + Oa_kj opi _pekj kb pda kn]h _ki *
i eooqna ]bpan ]j aha_pne_]h ^qi + G ? qi @]na Oad]^eh
. 66- 8 . . 72- *20+
/ . +
Pehr anch]` a A) Oq^anc OI + Kkj oqnce_]h i ]j ]cai aj p kb
^qi o pk pda hel o ]j ` _ki i eooqnao+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 6538
. 0754*61+
/ / + L npev*J kj ]opanek C) C]_pkn O+ B]nhu ` abej eper a pna]pi aj p kb
aha_pne_ ^qi o kb pda i kqpd+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 65- 8
327. 36*. 43+
/ 0+
I a]ga GB) @qnpej GT + Bha_pne_]h ^qi o kb pda i kqpd ej _deh*
` naj + @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 6518 . . 7336*350+
/ 1+
A]` k AS ) Mkhhau T ) Hai ]d]j A> + Pl hej pej c kb kn]h _ki *
i eooqna aha_pne_]h ^qi o ej _deh` naj + G Ma` e]pn . 6528
. - 476/ *62+
/ 2+
M]hhq] K) J ]_daj o ED) Oaj j ag]i l bb L) ? a_gan J ) ? ancan
>+ Qda b]o_ek_qp]j akqo oql n]_h]r e_qh]n ]npanu eoh]j ` bh]l
bkn naha]oej c l kop^qi i aj pkopai ]h _kj pn]_pqnao+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6648 66%4&7. 545*. 551+
/ 3+
J ]_I aj j ]j PB) @kn_kn]j GC) Ka]ha ET + Qeooqa at l ]j oekj
ej da]` ]j ` j a_g ^qi na_kj opnq_pekj + @hej Mh]op Pqnc / - - - 8
/ 47. / . *. 0/ +

%
ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS FRP[_
8 AE 3>F?C; FG +DGE?H7A ?A: F; C! . ; L?9D 5 C?H 7C: 3 9>DDA D< . ; : ?9?C; ! $ C7>I 79 5 C?J; FG?HM! . ; L?9D! . ; L?9D
EB5 8 EG ?& @R6 4 H? 8 L
5 C?J; FG?HM D< 4; L7G . ; : ?97A %F7C9> 7C: 3>F?C; FG +DGE?H7A ?A: F; CR * 7AJ; GHDC 5C?H! * 7AJ; GHDC! 4; L7G! 5 3 $
=4 6 B5 B I 8 E5 L
3>F?C; FG +DGE?H7A ?A: F; C! . ; L?9D 5C?H! . ; L?9D

ː
5 d \ b c^ cWT WPXa%QTPaX] V bRP[_ RP] ] ^ c ^ ] [h QT [XUT cWaTP%
cT] X] V Qd c \ Ph P[b^ X\ _ PXa ^ e TaP[[ PTbcWTcXRb& GWT STUTRcb
PaT ] ^ c TPbX[h WXSST] & <] _ PcXT] cb f XcW 0( c^ cP[ Q^ Sh
bd aUPRT PaTP !G5 F 4 Qd \ b"$ bRP[_ X] e ^ [e T\ T] c f Pb ] ^ cTS
X] +* ^ U cWT _ PcXT] cb& GWTbT X] Yd aXTb RP] QT R[PbbXUXTS
X] c^ cf ^ Va^ d_b3 cW^ bT f WXRW PaT _ d aT b^ Uc cXbbdT X] Yd aXTb
P] S bRP[_ Qd \ b f WXRW X] e ^ [e T cWT RP[e PaXd \ & Cd aT b^ Uc
cXbbdT X] Yd aXTb RP] TXcWTa QT _ PacXP[%cWXRZ] Tbb Qd \ b ^ a
Ud [[%cWXRZ] Tbb Qd \ b f XcW^ d c cWT X] e ^ [e T\ T] c ^ U cWT _ TaX^ b%
cTd \ & B ] T bW^ d [S QTPa X] \ X] S cWPc Te T] _ PacXP[%cWXRZ] Tbb
cWTa\ P[ Qd \ b$ f WXRW WTP[ bTR^ ] SPaX[h$ RP] RPdbT P[^ _ TRXP
Qh X] Yd aX] V cWT WPXa U^ [[XR[Tb& GWXaS%STVaTT Qda] b RPdbT
STT_ bRP[_ STbcad RcX^ ] cWPc ^ UcT] aT` d XaTb P bZX] VaPUc U^ a
R^ e TaPVT XU cWT _ TaX^ bcTd \ Xb X] cPRc&
F RP[_ Qd \ b$ f WXRW X] e ^ [e T cWT bZd [[$ PaT \ P] PVTS S XU%
UTaT] c[h& GWT ^ d cTa cPQ[T Xb _ a^ cTRcTS Qh cWT _ TaX^ bcTd \ &
B ] RT ] TRa^ bXb ^ U cWT ^ d cTa cPQ[T Xb ] ^ cTS$ f T UPRT P S XUUTa%
T] c bTc ^ U _ a^ Q[T\ b& 7 T_ T] SX] V ^ ] cWT bXi T P] S ST_ cW ^ U cWT
STUTRc$ e PaX^ d b ^ _ cX^ ] b PaT Pe PX[PQ[T U^ a TXcWTa X\ \ TSXPcT
^ a ST[PhTS R^ e TaPVT& 9 d [[%cWXRZ] Tbb bRP[_ X] Yd aXTb f XcW
RP[e PaXP[ X] e ^ [e T\ T] c WPe T QTT] P c^ _ XR ^ U R^ ] cX] d ^ d b SXb%
Rd bbX^ ] U^ a Qd \ bd aVT^ ] b& ; PaaXb^ ] !) " STe XbTS P R[PbbXUX%
RPcX^ ] bRWT\ T cWPc P[[^ f b db c^ PSYd bc caTPc\ T] c _ [P] b
QPbTS ^ ] cWT ST_ cW ^ U cWT X] Yd ah& !GPQ[T ) . &) "& GWaTT
bRT] PaX^ b ^ RRd a f WT] f T Te P[d PcT _ PcXT] cb f XcW bRP[_
Qd \ b X] e ^ [e X] V cWT RP[e PaXd \ & 9 Xabc$ cWTbT _ PcXT] cb \ Ph
*) /
F+
Fj pnk` q_pekj
/ . 4
/ + Qeooqa Bt l ]j oekj
/ . 6
FF+
> _qpa ? qi @]na
/ . 5
? * P_]hM ? qnj o s epd Fj r khr ai aj p kb
>+
Pkbp Qeooqa Fj fqneao Lj hu
/ . 5
Pgqhh
/ / .
? +
@]hr ]ne]h Fj r khr ai aj p
/ . 5
I
> _qpa @] na,B] nhu Oa_kj opnq_pekj
/ / /
FFF+
Oa_kj opnq_pekj
/ . 5
FS ì
@kj _hqoekj
/ / 2
>+
P_]hl ? qi o s epdkqp ? kj u Fj r khr ai aj p
/ . 5
Oabanaj _ao
/ / 2
.+
I k_]h P_]hl Ch]l o
/ . 5

*) 0

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
Qul a F
Qkp]h ogej hkoo s epd ej p]_p l ane_n]j eqi
Qul a FF
Qkp]h ogej hkoo s epd ej r khr ai aj p kb l ane_n]j qei
Qul a FFF
Qkp]h ogej hkoo s epd ej r khr ai aj p kb kqpan p]^ha
Qul a FS
Qkp] h ogej hkoo s epd ej r khr ai aj p kb ^kpd l h]pao kb
pda ogqhh
! &) ' #$25 PM\ `QP c U`T \ Q^YU__U[ Z R^[ Y < M^^U_[Z ")#&
d]r a ] ` ar ]o_qh]neva` kqpan p]^ha ej s de_d ` a^ne` ai aj p kb
pda kqpan p]^ha eo l anbkni a` pk ]__aoo pda ` el hka pk ]_dear a
aj kqcd r ]o_qh]nepu pk _hkoa pda s kqj ` s epd ] ol hep*
pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bp+ > hpanj ]per ahu) eb kqpan p]^ha ` a^ne` a*
i aj p opehh l nk` q_ao ] j kj r ]o_qh]n s kqj ` ) _kr an]ca s epd
r ]o_qh]neva` peooqa eo na_ki i aj ` a` + I ]op) eb pda ej epe]h
l ]peaj p ]ooaooi aj p ej ` e_]pao ] bqhh*pde_gj aoo _]hr ]ne]h
ej fqnu) pd]p eo) at l koa` ` qn] kn ogqhh bn]_pqnao s epd @PC
ha]go) ei i a` e]pa _kr an]ca kb pda ` aba_p s epd ] r ]o_qh]n*
eva` bh]l odkqh` ^a pda l nei ]nu kl an]per a l nk_a` qna+
Eana) hkj c*pani bkhhks *ql kb l ]peaj po eo _nq_e]h pk ` apan*
i ej a eb _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po ` ar ahkl kn l anoeop ej l ]peaj p
s epd k^r ekqo bqhh*pde_gj aoo hkoo+ E]^]h %/ & ` ar ahkl a` ]
_h]ooebe_]pekj ouopai ^]oa` kj pda oeva kb pda ` aba_p pk
l na` e_p pda pna]pi aj p kl pekj o bkn l ]peaj po s dk d]r a
` aba_po+ Eks ar an) o_]hl ej fqneao) s epd kn s epdkqp ej r khr a*
i aj p kb pda _]hr ]neqi ) _]j l naoaj p na_kj opnq_per a _d]h*
haj cao bkn l h]ope_ oqncakj o+ > o s epd ]_qpa ^qnj o ej kpdan
l ]npo kb pda ^k` u) pda ck]ho ]na pk k^p]ej a]nhu s kqj `
_hkoqna ]j ` naopkna ]aopdape_ ]j ` bqj _pekj ]h ej pacnepu pk
pda o_]hl ]j ` ogqhh+
GPQ[T ) . &)
8 K\ \S] YX 3 VK] ] SPSMK^SYX YP BU_ VV 2 _\X]
<<&
4 6 HG8 5 HEA 6 4 E8
4 &
F^ Uc GXbbdT <] YdaXTb B] [h
Pkbp peooqa ej fqneao ej l ]peaj po s epd h]nca Q? P > ej r khr a*
i aj p kb pda da]` ]j ` j a_g _]j n]j ca bnki / 2" pk 12"
%0)1&+ Qda o_]hl d]o ^aaj ] l kl qh]n ` kj kn oepa bkn _kr an]ca
kb ] l ]peaj p s epd h]nca Q? P > ^qnj o+ Eks ar an) _kj pnkr anou
at eopo ]o pk pda ej _e` aj _a kb _ki l he_]pekj o ]ook_e]pa` s epd
cn]bp d]nr aopej c+ ? nkq ap ]h+ %0& nal knpa` ] 3. " ej _e` aj _a
kb ]hkl a_e] ej l ]peaj po s epd at eopej c o_]hl ^qnj o ej s de_d
ogej cn]bpo s ana oq^oamqaj phu d]nr aopa` bkn s kqj `
_hkoqna+ Eks ar an) kj hu ] / +/ " ej _e` aj _a kb ]hkl a_e] eo
j kpa` ej l ]peaj po s epdkqp ^qnj o pk pda o_]hl pd]p qj ` ans aj p
d]nr aopej c kb o_]hl cn]bpo bkn _hkoqna kb ^qnj s kqj ` o %2&+
Qda i ]j ]cai aj p kb o_]hl ^qnj o ]_qpahu eo pda ]r ke` *
]j _a kb l naooqna) _ha]j oej c) ]j ` pda qoa kb pkl e_]h ]j pe*
i e_nk^e]h ]caj po+ Fj l ]npe]h*pde_gj aoo s kqj ` o) pdeo
i ]j ]cai aj p l h]j d]o ^aaj oq__aoobqh ej ]_dear ej c
na*al epdahe]hev]pekj + Qda ` ar ahkl i aj p kb bkhhe_qhepeo _]j
l nkpn]_p pda da]hej c _kqnoa ]j ` l nk` q_a _e_]pne_e]h ]hkl a*
_e]+ P_]hl s kqj ` o pd]p ` k j kp da]h ej / s aago) i ]u
namqena ogej cn]bpo bkn _hkoqna %3&+ Qda i ]j ]cai aj p kb
^qnj ]hkl a_e] eo ^]oa` kj ^kpd pda at paj p kb pda ` aba_p
]j ` epo hk_]pekj +
5 &
6 P[ePaXP[ <] e^ [eT\ T] c
Fj l ]peaj po s epd pdani ]h ej fqneao) ej r khr ai aj p kb pda kqpan
p]^ha kb pda ogqhh _]j ^a l nk^hai ]pe_+ Aa^ne` ai aj p qj peh
pda qj ` anhuej c ` el hka eo na]_da` eo pda _h]ooe_ ]l l nk]_d+
Fb ] r ]o_qh]n oqnb]_a eo na]_da` ) pdaj _kr an]ca s epd ogej
cn]bpo eo l kooe^ha+ Pl eao ap ]h+ %4& nal knpa` ] _ki l ]neokj
pk ^qnj l ]peaj po s epd pdani ]h ej fqnu pd]p ej _hq` a` E]nneokj
@h]oo ^^^(I K ej fqneao pk ^qnj a` _deh` naj s epdkqp _]hr ]ne]h
^qnj o+ M]peaj po s epd _]hr ]ne]h ^qnj o j kp kj hu namqena`
i kna kl an]pekj o pk ]_dear a s kqj ` _hkoqna) ^qp ]hok d]`
hkj can haj cpdo kb dkol ep]h op]u %4&+ Qda kr ans dahi ej c
i ]fknepu kb l ]peaj po s ana ]^ha pk k^p]ej s kqj ` _hkoqna
^u ` a^ne` ai aj p kb pda kqpan p]^ha ]j ` _kr an]ca s epd
ol hep*pde_gj aoo ogej cn]bpo %PQPD&+ Fj l ]peaj po ej s de_d
kqpan p]^ha ` a^ne` ai aj p l nk` q_a` ]j ]r ]o_qh]n s kqj ` )
pda qoa kb o_]hl bh]l o d]o ]hhks a` _hkoqna ql pk j a]nhu
2- " kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl + Eks ar an) bnaa*peooqa pn]j o*
bano i ]u ]hok ^a ej ` e_]pa` %5&+
<<<& E8 6 BAFGEH6 GQda hkj c*pani abba_p kb ^qi o pk pda o_]hl eo _e_]pne_e]h ]hk*
l a_e]+ Qda i ]j ]cai aj p kb pdeo l nk^hai ` al aj ` o kj oeva kb
pda ` aba_p) epo hk_]pekj ) ]j ` s dapdan kn j kp ]j qj ` anhuej c
_]hr ]ne]h ` aba_p eo l naoaj p+ > _]nabqh l duoe_]h at ]i ej ]pekj
eo aooaj pe]h+ > na]o kb bkhhe_qhepeo i ]u namqena ouopai ]pe_
]j pe^ekpe_o kn at _eoekj l nekn pk ` abej eper a pna]pi aj p kb pda
]hkl a_e]+ Fj l ]peaj po s epd l nar ekqo E ]nneokj FFF kn FS _]h*
r ]ne]h ej fqneao) _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po i ]u ^a oqol a_pa` + > 0*A
@> Q o_]j i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu pk j kp kj hu ` apani ej a pda
at paj p ]j ` hk_]pekj kb pda ` aba_p) ^qp pk ]hok l h]j kl an]per a
_knna_pekj +
4 &
FRP[_ 5 da] b f XcW^ d c 5 ^] h <] e^ [eT\ T] c
*'
AaUS^ HUS^b ; ^Sbe
Qda i ]fknepu kb ^qnj o ej r khr ej c pda o_]hl ]na ej _deh` naj +
P_]h` ^qi o kn cna]oa ^qnj o ]__kqj p bkn pda i ]fknepu kb
pdaoa ej fqneao+ T dapdan pdaoa ej fqneao ]na l ]npe]h*pde_gj aoo
` aba_po) s de_d da]h oa_kj ` ]nu kn ` aal an ^qnj o) s de_d
namqena ogej cn]bpo) ]hkl a_e] eo hegahu pk ^a pda bej ]h
naoqhp+ Mnekn pk peooqa at l ]j oekj ) Eq]j c ap ]h+ %6& _h]ooebea`
pda at paj p kb ^qnj ]hkl a_e] ej _deh` naj ej ]j ]ppai l p pk j kp
kj hu cqe` a kqn oqnce_]h ej panr aj pekj o) ^qp ]hok cer a qo
oki a at l a_p]pekj o ]o pk s d]p pk pahh kqn l ]peaj po
%Q]^ha . 3+/ &+ M]peaj po _h]ooebea` ]o Dnkql > d]` ]hkl a_e]
pd]p s ]o 9. 2" kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl 8 ej Dnkql ? )
pda ]hkl a_e] s ]o ; . 2" ^qp 9 0- " kb pda d]en*^a]nej c

ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS FRP[_
GPQ[T ) . &*
@h]ooebe_]pekj ]j ` Pat Aeopne^qpekj kb ? qnj
> hkl a_e]
J ]ha
Cai ]ha
Qkp]h
Dnkql >
%9. 2" &
> ` qhpo

0

/
@deh` naj

/ 6

. 4

G .
Dnkql ?

%. 3*0- " &
> ` qhpo

3

-
03
@deh` naj

. .

. 6
Dnkql @
%0. *3- " &
> ` qhpo

.

-
. 6
@deh` naj

. -

5
Dnkql A
%; 3. " &
> ` qhpo

1

.
. .
@deh` naj

0

0
! &) ' #$25 PM\ `QP c U`T \ Q^YU__U[ Z R^[Y < aMZS "*#&
o_]hl 8 ej Dnkql @) pda ]hkl a_e] s ]o ; 0- " ^qp 92- " kb
pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl 8 ej Dnkql A) pda ]hkl a_e] s ]o
; 2- " kb pda o_]hl + Roej c pdeo _h]ooebe_]pekj ouopai ) o_]n
at _eoekj _]j nai kr a ]hkl a_e] oaci aj po ql pk . 2" kb pda
d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl + @qnnaj phu) eb _ki l hapa at _eoekj kb pda
]hkl a_e] oaci aj p _]j ^a _]nnea` kqp ej pdnaa kn haoo kl an*
]pekj o) pdeo ]l l nk]_d eo opehh l nabanna` ^u i ]j u oqncakj o+
Fb i kna kl an]pekj o ]na ` aai a` j a_aoo]nu) ]hpanj ]per a
]l l nk]_dao ]na ]r ]eh]^ha+
Fj . 635) Lnpe_k_da] %. - & l q^heoda` pda bkqn*bh]l pa_d*
j emqa bkn _kr an]ca kb i k` an]pa*oeva o_]hl ` aba_po+ Fj
. 64/ ) pdeo pa_dj emqa s ]o i k` ebea` pk ] pdnaa*hei ^ bh]l
` aoecj bkn _knna_pekj kb o_]hl ` aba_po %. . &+ > hpdkqcd pda
at ]_p at paj p kb d]en ^a]nej c bh]l _kr an]ca ]_dear a` eo j kp
_ha]n+ > hpdkqcd _kr an]ca kb i k` an]pa*oeva` o_]hl ` aba_po
_]j ^a ]_dear a` s epd pdaoa pa_dj emqao) ej _na]oa` ^hkk`
hkoo ]j ` at _aooer a o_]nej c bnki pda i qhpel ha o_]hl bh]l o
_]j ^a l nk^hai ]pe_ %. / &+ Qda bh]l o i ]u j kp _kr an h]nca
]hkl a_e] oaci aj po+ I ]pan) Gqne %. 0& ` ar ahkl a` pda i kj k*
l a` e_ha` o_]hl bh]l bkn _kr an]ca kb oaci aj p]h ]na]o kb ]hk*
l a_e]+ Qdeo bh]l s ]o l ]npe_qh]nhu qoabqh ej pda na*_na]pekj
kb pda bnkj p]h d]enhej a+ Eks ar an) pdaoa bh]l o ` e` j kp okhr a
pda l nk^hai kb pkp]h _knna_pekj kb h]nca ]hkl a_e] oaci aj po+
Fj na_aj p ua]no) pda Gqne bh]l d]o ^aaj qoa` ej _ki ^ej ]pekj
s epd o_]hl na` q_pekj oqncanu kn at l ]j ` a` l nekn pk pn]j oban
%. 1). 2&+ Fj kn` an pk i ej ei eva at _eoekj o_]nnej c ]j ` ^hkk`
hkoo) pda h]pan]h o_]hl bh]l s ]o ` ar ahkl a` bkn _kr an]ca kb
pda bnkj p]h d]enhej a+ Qdeo bh]l ` ebbana` bnki pda Gqne bh]l
ej pd]p ep namqena` j k ` ah]u ]j ` pda ` kj kn oepa _kqh` ^a
a]oehu _hkoa` + Eks ar an) pdeo bh]l _kqh` kj hu na]_d pda i e` *
l kej p kb pda bnkj p]h d]enhej a %. 3&+
? ]nnan] %. 4& d]o odks j pd]p i e_nkcn]bpo %kj a pk ps k
d]en bkhhe_hao& ]j ` i ej ecn]bpo %pdnaa pk bkqn d]en bkhhe_hao&
]na qoabqh s epd pda _knna_pekj o kb ^qi ]hkl a_e]+ Fj ]
oaneao kb 0/ ^qi l ]peaj po) da oq__aoobqhhu _knna_pa` h]nca
]hkl a_e] oaci aj po s epd at _ahhaj p kqp_ki ao+ Qda oq__aoo*
bqh ]l l he_]pekj ]j ` oqnr er ]h kb i e_nkcn]bpo ]j ` i ej ecn]bpo
ej ^qnj o_]n eo ^ahear a` pk ^a ] bqj _pekj kb pdaen r anu hks
i ap]^khe_ n]pa+ Kaaa` haoo pk o]u) pda qoa kb i e_nkcn]bpo ej
at pnai ahu h]nca ]na]o kb ]hkl a_e] eo j kp kj hu h]^kn ej paj *
oer a) ^qp ]hok _kophu+ Eks ar an) pda qoa kb peooqa at l ]j oekj
bkn pda _hkoqna kb h]nca ]na]o kb ^qnj ]hkl a_e] d]o cer aj kqn
l ]peaj po uap ]j kpdan kl pekj bkn ei l nkr ej c o_]hl ]aopdape_o+
/ +
I [eegW : j bS` e[a`
Qda deopkne_]h ]ol a_po kb okbp peooqa at l ]j oekj d]r a ^aaj
l nar ekqohu ` eo_qooa` + Eks ar an) ep oqbbe_ao pk o]u pd]p
peooqa at l ]j oekj eo pda naoqhp kb ] _kj op]j p i a_d]j e_]h
opnaoo hk]` pd]p ha]` o pk peooqa nacaj an]pekj %. 5). 6&+
> hpdkqcd pda ej epe]h i a` e_]h ]l l he_]pekj kb pdeo _kj _al p
k__qnna` s epd ^kj a) l qna okbp peooqa at l ]j oekj k__qnna`
ej . 623 ^u Kaqi ]j j %/ - &+ Eks ar an) pdeo _kj _al p nai ]ej a`
` kni ]j p bkn ]j kpdan / - ua]no+ Qda oq^oamqaj p at l hkoer a
na` eo_kr anu kb okbp peooqa at l ]j oekj d]o ^aaj ]l l hea` pk
j a]nhu ar anu ]ol a_p kb na_kj opnq_pekj pk` ]u %/ - &+ Qda deopk*
hkce_ ba]pqnao kb peooqa at l ]j oekj ]na s ahh gj ks j %/ 2&+
? neabhu) pda al e` ani eo ^a_ki ao pde_gan s epd i kop kb pda
i epkpe_ ]_per epu k__qnnej c ej pda opn]pqi ol kj cekoqi
%/ 1&+ Qda ` ani eo pdej o kqp s epd pda cna]paop ]i kqj p kb pdej *
j ej c k__qnnej c ej pda l ]l ehh]nu ` ani eo %/ 2&+ Qda i kha_qh]n
^]oeo bkn pdeo l daj ki aj kj ]l l a]no pk ^a pda ]_per ]pekj kb
r ]nekqo oecj ]h pn]j o` q_pekj l ]pds ]uo ej ` q_a` ^u i a_d]*
j e_]h opn]ej + Qda ]_per ]pekj kb ] j qi ^ano kb cnks pd
b]_pkno bkn al epdahe]h ]j ` _kj j a_per a peooqa cnks pd i ]u
^a naol kj oe^ha bkn pdeo peooqa nacaj an]pekj %. 6&+
Fj . 643) O]` ]r ]j %/ 3& l kl qh]neva` pda _kj _al p kb peooqa
at l ]j oekj + Pei qhp]j akqohu) > qopa` ap ]h+ %/ 4& l naoaj pa`
deo h]^kn]pknu ]j ` _hej e_]h at l aneaj _a %/ 4&+ Qdeo pa_dj emqa
ej pda na_kj opnq_pekj kb ^qnj ]hkl a_e] d]o n]l e` hu ^a_ki a
pda ckh` op]j ` ]n` ^u s de_d kpdan pa_dj emqao ]na fq` ca` )
ej ol epa kb _ki l he_]pekj n]pao kb x . 2*/ - " %/ 5)/ 6&+ Fj
. 66- ) J _@]qhau ap ]h+ %/ 6& _h]ooebea` ^qi ]hkl a_e] ^]oa`
kj pda at paj p kb pda ` aba_p ]j ` pda l ]ppanj kb ]hkl a_e] ]j `
]o ] pai l h]pa bkn s de_d na_kj opnq_per a abbknpo i ]u ^a
` aoecj a` + %Q]^ha . 3+0&+ M]peaj po s epd pul a . > kn F? ^qi
]hkl a_e] _]j ^a _knna_pa` s epd ] oej cha at l ]j oekj ) ]hpdkqcd
*) 1
GPQ[T ) . &+
@h]ooebe_]pekj kb ? qi > hkl a_e]
Qul a F

Pej cha ]hkl a_e] oaci aj p
> 9/ 2" kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl
? / 2*2- " kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl
@ 2- *42" kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl
A ; 42" kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl
Qul a FF

J qhpel ha ]hkl a_e] oaci aj po ]i aj ` ]^ha pk
peooqa at l ]j oekj l h]_ai aj p
Qul a FFF

M]p_du ^qi ]hkl a_e] j kp ]i aj ` ]^ha pk peooqa
at l ]j oekj
Qul a FS

Qkp]h ]hkl a_e]
! &) ' #$2 5 PM\ `QP c U`T \ Q^YU__U[ Z R^[ Y A O7 MaXQe E@& 7 [ ^^QO`U[ Z [ R
Na^Z MX[\ QOUM& =Z2 < Q^ZP[Z 8 B$ QP& G[ `MX 6 aY 7 M^Q& DTUXMPQX\ TUM2
I &6 & FMaZPQ^_$ ) 11. 2, , 1%- ( *&

**(

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
kr anej bh]pekj i ]u ^a j a_aoo]nu+ M]peaj po s epd pul a . @ ]j `
FA ^qi ]hkl a_e] i ]u namqena i qhpel ha at l ]j ` ano aepdan
pkcapdan kn oamqaj pe]hhu pk _knna_p pdaoa h]nca ]na]o kb ]hk*
l a_e]+ M]peaj po s epd pul a FF> kn FF? ]hkl a_e] i ]u ]hok ^a
_knna_pa` s epd ] oej cha at l ]j oekj + Eks ar an) l ]peaj po
s epd pul a FF@ ]j ` FFA ]hkl a_e] namqena ej pne_]pa bh]l
` aoecj o pk _knna_p pda l nk^hai + P]o]ge %0- & ai l d]oeva`
pda ei l knp]j _a kb l nakl an]per a l h]j j ej c ej pdaoa l ]peaj po
oej _a pda oeva kb pda at l ]j ` an ]j ` oq^oamqaj p bh]l i kr a*
i aj p i ]u ]bba_p pda bej ]h ]aopdape_ naoqhp %Cec+ . 3+. &+ Qda
oeva kb pda at l ]j ` an) pda od]l a kb pda at l ]j ` an) ]j ` pda
oeva ]j ` hk_]pekj kb pda o_]hl ` aba_p) ]hh l h]u ]j ei l knp]j p
nkha ej ]_dear ej c ] o]peob]_pknu naoqhp+ Qda l h]_ai aj p kb
peooqa at l ]j ` ano ej pda oq^c]ha]h l h]j a eo nkqpej a+ Qda
qoa kb l anekl an]per a ]j pe^ekpe_o eo ]hok _ki i kj l h]_a+
Fj _eoekj o _]j ^a l h]_a` ]p pda fqj _pekj kb pda d]en*
^a]nej c ogej ]j ` pda ]hkl a_e] oaci aj p+ > hpanj ]per ahu)
n]` e]h ]j ` nai kpa ej _eoekj o d]r a ]hok ^aaj qpeheva` + Qda
]` fqopi aj po ]na ]p pda ` eo_napekj kb pda oqncakj oej _a _qn*
naj phu j k opq` eao at eop _ki l ]nej c pdaoa ps k pa_dj emqao bkn
at l koqna n]pao kn ej ba_pekj n]pao+ Lj _a pda ` ei aj oekj o kb
pda ` eooa_pa` l k_gap d]r a ^aaj i ]t ei eva` ) ]j at l ]j ` an
eo oaha_pa` s epd ` ei aj oekj o . +- */ +- _i oi ]hhan pd]j pda
l k_gap oeva+ Qda qoa kb ej pacn]pa` l knpo r o+ nai kpa l knpo
eo ^]oa` kj oqnce_]h l nabanaj _a ]j ` pda at l aneaj _a kb pda
l duoe_e]j ej fa_pej c pda at l ]j ` an+ Qda l anokj ej fa_pej c
pda at l ]j ` an i ]u j kp ^a pda kl an]per a oqncakj + Mnekn pk
pda l h]_ai aj p kb pda at l ]j ` an) pda ` ar e_a eo _da_ga` bkn
ha]go+ Pq^i ancaj _a ej o]hej a s epd ]en ej fa_pa` eo nkqpej a
pk hkkg bkn ]en ha]go+
> hpanj ]per ahu) pda qoa kb i apduhaj a ^hqa d]o ]hok ^aaj
na_ki i aj ` a` %0. &+ Lj _a pda s kqj ` o ]na _hkoa` ) opaneha
o]hej a eo ej fa_pa` ej pk pda at l ]j ` an) behhej c ep ]o i q_d ]o
l kooe^ha s epdkqp l h]_ej c qj ` qa paj oekj kj pda ogej bh]l o
kn pda ej _eoekj hej a+ Roq]hhu . - */ - " kb pda at l ]j ` an
r khqi a _]j ^a ej fa_pa` + Pqpqnao ]na habp ej l h]_a bkn /
s aago ]j ` at l ]j oekj eo pdaj op]npa` + P]hej a eo ej fa_pa`
kj ] s aaghu kn ^es aaghu ^]oeo+ Qda r khqi a kb o]hej a
ej fa_pa` eo ] bqj _pekj kb l ]peaj p ` eo_ki bknp ]j ` bh]l ah]o*
pe_epu+ Roq]hhu . - " kb pda r khqi a l an s aag eo ]` amq]pa
pk ej oqna _ki l hapa ej bh]pekj kb pda at l ]j ` an s epdej 0
i kj pdo+ Pdkqh` _]l ehh]nu nabehh ^a_ki a ] l nk^hai ` qnej c
pda at l ]j oekj l nk_aoo kn pda l ]peaj p _ki l h]ej o kb l ]ej ) ]
/ 0*c]qca j aa` ha eo qoa` pk nai kr a o]hej a bnki pda at l ]j *
` an pk _knna_p pdaoa l nk^hai o+ Lj _a at l ]j oekj eo _ki *
l hapa` ) pda haj cpd kb bh]l ]` r ]j _ai aj p eo _]h_qh]pa` ^u
i a]oqnej c pda ` ki a kb pda at l ]j ` a` o_]hl bh]l ]j ` oq^*
pn]_pej c epo ^]oa s e` pd+ Mnekn pk nai kr ]h kb pda at l ]j ` an)
]` r ]j _ai aj p ] j ` ,kn nkp]pekj kb pda at l ]j ` a` o_]hl bh]l
eo ` a_e` a` ^]oa` kj pda at paj p kb pda ` aba_p ]j ` pda oq^*
oamqaj p kneaj p]pekj kb pda d]en bkhhe_hao %Ceco+ . 3+/ ]j `
. 3+0&+ Fj pn]kl an]per ahu) o_]hhkl ej c kb pda ogqhh eo qoq]hhu
j kpa` ) aol a_e]hhu ej _deh` naj + Eks ar an) pda ogqhh ]l l a]no
pk nai k` ah epoahb ]bpan nai kr ]h kb pda at l ]j ` an+ Mkopkl an]*
per ahu) pdeo _kj pkqn ` aba_p ej pda ogqhh i ]u ^a j kpa` + > bpan
]` r ]j _ai aj p kn nkp]pekj kb pda at l ]j ` a` o_]hl bh]l ) ej pn]*
kl an]per a _]l oqhkpki u d]o ^aaj ` ao_ne^a` ]o ] i apdk` pk
ej _na]oa bh]l haj cpd+ Qda ]i kqj p c]ej a` ej pda haj cpd kb
pda at l ]j ` a` bh]l eo j kp s ahh ` k_qi aj pa` + Fj ]` ` epekj )
ej _na]oa` ^haa` ej c ]j ` ` ]i ]ca pk pda kr anhuej c r aooaho
eo ]hs ]uo ] neog+
@ki l he_]pekj o kb peooqa at l ]j oekj ]na ` er e` a` ej pk
i ]fkn r o+ i ej kn %0/ &+ J ]fkn _ki l he_]pekj o d]r a ^aaj
nal knpa` pd]p ]na ]o hks ]o 0" ]j ` ]o decd ]o 11"
%/ 6)0/ *01&+ J ]fkn _ki l he_]pekj o ]na ` abej a` ]o pdkoa
pd]p ej pannql p pda at l ]j oekj l nk_aoo oq_d pd]p pda
9XVdaT ) . &)
%> & Pet *ua]n*kh` i ]ha s epd Qul a . > ^qi ]hkl a_e]+ %? & Mkopkl an]per a r eas 3 i kj pdo h]pan+ %Oal nej pa` s epd l ani eooekj
bnki J _@]qhau OI + @knna_pekj kb ^qnj ]hkl a_e]+ Fj 7 Eanj ` kj AK) a` + Qkp]h ? qi @]na+ Mdeh]` ahl de]7 T +? + P]qj ` ano) . 6637166*2- / +&

ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS FRP[_

**)
9XVdaT ) . &*
%> & Par aj *ua]n*kh` i ]ha s epd Qul a F? ^qi ]hkl a_e]+ %? & @ki l hapa ej bh]pekj kb ] 2- - __ peooqa at l ]j ` an+ %@& Lj a s aag
]bpan _knna_pekj kb ]hkl a_e] s epd ] oej cha bh]l ]` r ]j _ai aj p+ %A& Ckhhks *ql . ua]n h]pan+
l nakl an]per a l h]j _]j j kp ^a ]_dear a` + Pq_d _ki l he_]pekj o
]o ej ba_pekj o) bh]l j a_nkoeo) ei l h]j p at l koqna) kn s kqj `
` adeo_aj _a+ J ]_I aj j kj ap ]h+ %02& d]r a ` k_qi aj pa` pd]p
s epd l nkl an l nkpk_kho ]j ` l ]peaj p oaha_pekj ) pdaen n]pa kb
i ]fkn _ki l he_]pekj o ` a_na]oa` bnki / / " pk . / " %02&+
J ej kn _ki l he_]pekj o d]r a ^aaj ` ao_ne^a` ]o pdkoa ej
s de_d pdana eo l kkn l ]peaj p _ki l he]j _a) ej pkhan]j _a kb
pda o]hej a ej fa_pekj o pk behh pda at l ]j ` an ]j ` ]hpan]pekj o
ej pda ej epe]h oqnce_]h l h]j oa_kj ` ]nu pk ej _ki l hapa _kr an*
]ca+ O]pao bkn i ej kn _ki l he_]pekj o r ]nu bnki . 4" pk 1- "
%0/ )01&+ Par an]h qj emqa _ki l he_]pekj o kb peooqa at l ]j oekj
d]r a ^aaj j kpa` oq_d ]o _]hr ]ne]h ankoekj ]j ` pn]qi ]pe_
at pnqoekj o %03)04&+
5&
FRP[_ 5 da] b f XcW <] e^ [eT\ T] c ^ U cWT FZd[[
> hpdkqcd okbp peooqa ^qi o pk pda o_]hl nal naoaj p oecj ebe_]j p
_d]hhaj cao ej ]_qpa i ]j ]cai aj p ]j ` oq^oamqaj p na_kj *
opnq_pekj ) ^qnj o pd]p ]hok ej r khr a pda ogqhh ]na j kp kj hu
heba pdna]paj ej c l nk^hai o ^qp ]hok l naoaj p ` ebbanaj p _d]h*
haj cao %05*1. &+ Fj r khr ai aj p kb pda kqpan p]^ha kn ` aal an
opnq_pqnao %E]nneokj FFF ]j ` FS ej fqneao& eo kb l ]npe_qh]n
_kj _anj + Qda i apdk` bkn _hkoqna kb pdaoa ` aba_po r ]neao
` al aj ` ej c kj pda _]qoa kb ej fqnu) pda oeva kb pda ` aba_p)
]j ` pda ]r ]eh]^ehepu kb da]hpdu hk_]h peooqa+ > l l nk]_dao
bkn pda _knna_pekj kb pdeo l nk^hai ej _hq` a l ]npe]h kn _ki *
l hapa ` a^ne` ai aj p kb pda j a_nkpe_ ^kj a s epd ei i a` e]pa

***
9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
9XVdaT ) . &+
%> & Qul a . @ ^qnj ]hkl a_e]+ %? & @ki l hapa ej bh]pekj kb ] 5- - __ peooqa at l ]j ` an+ %@& Qdnaa*ua]n bkhhks *ql ]bpan _knna_pekj
kb ]hkl a_e]+
kn ` ah]ua` ]qpk cn]bp _kr an]ca %4)06*1. &+ L pdan kl pekj o
ej _hq` a ei i a` e]pa _kr an]ca s epd r ]o_qh]neva` peooqa+
Qdaoa bh]l o i ]u ^a n]j ` ki ) ]t e]h l ]ppanj a` bh]l o kj i e_nk*
r ]o_qh]n bnaa bh]l o %1/ )10&+
*+
6 UgfW 8 SdW(: Sd^k GWUa` efdgUf[a`
Fj ar ]hq]pekj kb / 4 l ]peaj po s epd E]nneokj FFF ]j ` FS _]h*
r ]ne]h ^qnj o ^u Pl eao ap ]h+ %4&) Z42" kb pdaoa ej fqneao
s ana oa_kj ` ]nu pk pdani ]h s kqj ` o ]j ` / 2" s ana aha_pne*
_]h ej fqneao+ M]peaj po s epd _]hr ]ne]h ^qnj qoq]hhu d]r a ej fq*
neao pk kpdan pda l ]npo kb pda ^k` u+ Qda naol a_per a Q? P>
^qnj o s ana kb 14" ]j ` / 0" + Qdaoa l ]peaj po ]na naoqo_e*
p]pa` qoej c pda D]hr aopkj bkni qh] kb 2- - - l hqo
/ - - - i I ,i / Q? P> h]_p]pa` nej cano okhqpekj kr an pda
ej epe]h / 1 d+ Qna]pi aj p kb pda ^qnj a` ogqhh ej r khr a` ` a^ne*
` ai aj p kb pda _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a qoej c ] decd*ol aa` ` nehh pk
nai kr a j a_nkpe_ ^kj a %3&+ Lj _a ] r e]^ha oqnb]_a eo
na]_da` ) PQPD ]na qoa` bkn naoqnb]_ej c kb pda ogqhh+
Eks ar an) eb cn]bp p]ga eo l kkn) naoqnb]_ej c kb pda ` aba_p
s epd r ]o_qh]neva` peooqa eo ej ` e_]pa` %Cec+ . 3+1&+ > hpanj ]*
per ahu) eb ej pn]kl an]per a at ]i ej ]pekj nar a]ho E]nneokj FS
_]hr ]ne]h ` aba_p s epd at l koa` ` qn]) ei i a` e]pa _kr an]ca
s epd r ]o_qh]neva` bh]l o eo ej ` e_]pa` %Cec+ . 3+2&+ Qda qoa

ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS FRP[_

**+
9XVdaT ) . &,
%> & Qs ahr a*ua]n*kh` i ]ha s epd E ]nneokj FFF _]hr ]ne]h ^qnj ej pda k__el ep]h nacekj kb pda o_]hl + Rj oq__aoobqh cn]bp p]ga
]bpan ` a^ne` ai aj p kb kqpan p]^ha+ Aaba_p aj _ki l ]ooao j a]nhu 2- " kb pda d]en*^a]nej c o_]hl + %? & Fi i a` e]pa i k^ehev]pekj kb ]j panekn
o_]hl ]o ] ^el a` e_ha r eokn bh]l bkn _kr an]ca kb pda ` aba_p+ %@& Pgej cn]bpo l h]_a` kr an ` kj kn oepa kb pda bh]l ]j paneknhu+ %A& Pet *i kj pd
bkhhks *ql odks ej c s ahh*da]ha` cn]bpo ]j paneknhu s epd l naoanr ]pekj kb d]enhej a bkn bqpqna na_kj opnq_pekj + %B& Mkopanekn r eas odks ej c oqn*
r er ]h kb pda r eokn bh]l ]j ` oq^oamqaj p d]en cnks pd+

**,

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
9XVdaT ) . &-
%> & Cebpaaj *ua]n*kh` l ]peaj p s epd ] decd*r khp]ca aha_pne_]h ej fqnu s epd 3 t 5 _i ]na] kb at l koa` ^qp ej p]_p ` qn]
%E]nneokj FS ^qi &+ %? & @kr an]ca s epd o_]hl nkp]pekj bh]l + %@& Pp]^ha _kr an]ca ]p 3 i kj pdo ]bpan _hkoqna+ XOal nej pa` s epd l ani eooekj
bnki Pl eao ap ]h+ %4&+Y
kb peooqa oq^opepqpao oq_d ]o > hhk` ani à d]o ]hok ^aaj
nal knpa` pk ^a oq__aoobqh ej pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb E]nneokj
FS _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po %11&+ Eks ar an) pdeo eo j kp nkqpej a+
T kqj ` _hkoqna s ]o ]_dear a` ej ]hh _]oao+ Fj pda i ]fknepu
kb l ]peaj po) / 0,/ 4 %52" & s kqj ` _hkoqna s ]o ]_dear a`
s epd ]qpkcn]bpo+ Eks ar an) hkj c*pani bkhhks *ql nar a]ha`
_]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po ej 0- " kb pdaoa _deh` naj + Fj r khr ai aj p
kb pda _]hr ]neqi paj ` o pk k__qn i kna kbpaj ej aha_pne_]h
^qi o) ]hpdkqcd pda ` aba_po paj ` pk ^a oi ]hhan %4)12&+
Mnej _el hao ej pda ` ah]ua` i ]j ]cai aj p kb _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po
]na opn]ecdpbkns ]n` + Pp]^ha okbp peooqa _kr an]ca kb pda o_]hl
i qop ^a ]_dear a` l nekn pk na_kj opq_pekj kb _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po+
E]^]h %/ & ^ahear ao pd]p _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po 9 / _i ej _deh` naj
s ehh qj ` anck kopakj akcaj aoeo ]j ` _hkoqna+ I ]nca ` aba_po

ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U cWT 5 da] TS FRP[_

**-
kn pdkoa ej ]` qhpo i ]u namqena r ]o_qh]neva` _kr an]ca l nekn
pk na_kj opnq_pekj s epd _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a cn]bpo+
Qda i ]j ]cai aj p kb l ]peaj po s epd o_]hl ^qi o eo _ki l hat +
M]peaj po ]na ` er e` a` ej pk ps k cnkql o7 pdkoa s epd o_]hl
^qi o kj hu ]j ` pdkoa s epd ej r khr ai aj p kb pda ogqhh+ Kaa` *
haoo pk o]u) i ]j ]cai aj p eooqao s epdej pdaoa cnkql o ` ebban
oecj ebe_]j phu+ Pq^oamqaj p na_kj opnq_per a kl pekj o ]na ]hok
` ebbanaj p+ Qda _hkoqna kb o_]hl ` aba_po s epdkqp _]hr ]ne]h
ej r khr ai aj p _]j ^a ] haoo _d]hhaj cej c eooqa+ Pi ]hh
` aba_po ]na _hkoa` l nei ]nehu kn s epd pda qoa kb i e_nkcn]bpo+
Eks ar an) h]nca oaci aj po kb ]hkl a_e] ]na ]` ` naooa` s epd
peooqa at l ]j oekj ) i e_nkcn]bpo) kn ] _ki ^ej ]pekj kb hk_]h
bh]l o _ki ^ej a` s epd pdaoa l nk_a` qnao+ > hpdkqcd o_]hl
at l ]j oekj _ki l he_]pekj o n]pao _]j ^a . 2*/ - " ) pda
naoqhpo ]na qj ebkni hu oq__aoobqh ]j ` ]aopdape_]hhu l ha]oej c+
> hpanj ]per ahu) ` aba_po kb pda o_]hl s epd _]hr ]ne]h ej r khr a*
i aj p ]na i kop _d]hhaj cej c ^kpd ej ]_qpa l d]oa kb ej fqnu
]j ` ej oq^oamqaj p na_kj opnq_pekj + > _qpahu) l nkpa_pekj kb
pda ^n]ej eo kb l ]n]i kqj p ei l knp]j _a+ T kqj ` _hkoqna
_]j ^a k^p]ej a` ej ]hh l ]peaj po+ Eks ar an) ar aj s epd oq_*
_aoobqh s kqj ` _hkoqna) bkhhks *ql kb pdaoa l ]peaj po eo
_nq_e]h pk ` apani ej a oq^oamqaj p ` ar ahkl i aj p kb bqhh*
pde_gj aoo _]hr ]ne]h ` aba_po+
E8 98 E8 A6 8 F
. +
E ]nneokj PE+ Bt l koqna kb pda ogqhh bnki ^qnj o+ ? n Mh]op
Pqnc . 62/ 8 17/ 46*/ 6/ +
/ +
E]^]h J + ? qi o kb pda ogqhh ]j ` o_]hl ]j ` pdaen _hej e_]h
i ]j ]cai aj p+ Fj 7 J _@]qhau OI ) a` + Cqj _pekj ]h ]j `
> aopdape_ Oa_kj opnq_pekj kb pda ? qnj M]peaj p+ Kas Vkng7
J ]n_ah Aaggan) / - - 2+
0+
? nkq G> ) S q Q) J _@]qhau OI ) E ai ` kj AK) Aao]e J E)
Oqp]j OI ) Ppaj ^anc ? ) Mdehhel o I D) Ok^okj J @+ Qda
o_]hl ]o ] ` kj kn oepa7 nar eoepa` + G Qn]qi ] . 66-8
0- %2&7246*25. +
1+
? qnj o ? C) J _@]qhau OI ) J qnl du CI ) Ok^okj J @+ Oa_kj *
opnq_per a i ]j ]cai aj p kb l ]peaj po s epd ; 5- " Q? P> ^qnj o+
? qi o . 6608 . 6%2&71/ 6*100+
2+
? ]nnap GM) Aveas qhoge M) T khb PB) Aao]e J E) Eanj ` kj AK+
Lqp_ki a kb o_]hl ` kj kn oepao ej 12- _kj oa_qper a l a` e]pne_
^qi l ]peaj po+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6668 . - 07. . 06*. . 1/ +
3+
S ]hheo @M+ Pqnce_]h i ]j ]cai aj p kb _e_]pne_e]h ]hkl a_e] kb
pda o_]hl + @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 65/ 8 . 45*. 53+
4+
Pl eao J ) J _@]qhau OI ) J q` ca ? M) Eanj ` kj AK+ J ]j ]ca*
i aj p kb ]_qpa _]hr ]ne]h ^qi o ej _deh` naj + G Qn]qi ] / - - 08
21%1&7432*436+
5+
T knpdaj BC+ Oacaj an]pekj o kb pda ogqhh bkhhks ej c ] ` aal
aha_pne_]h ^qi + Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 64. 8 157. *1+
6+
Eq]j c QQ) I ]nokj AI ) I as eo PO+ ? qi ]hkl a_e]+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6448 3- 7430*434+
. -+
L npe_k_da] J + Ckqn bh]l o_]hl na_kj opnq_pekj pa_dj emqa+
? n G Mh]op Pqnc . 6348 / - 7. 26*. 4. +
. . +
L npe_k_da] J + Kas pdnaa bh]l o_]hl na_kj opi _per a pa_d*
j emqa+ ? n G Mh]op Pqnc . 64. 8 / 17. 51*. 55+
. / +
J ]j ` ano BH) P_daj ` kq J G) Cqooau G> ) E ahvhan MQ)
A]r eo QP) Dn]d]i T M+ Pkbp peooqa at l ]j oekj 7 _kj _al po
]j ` _ki l he_]pekj o+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6518 417160*2- 1+
. 0+
Gqne G+ Roa kb l ]neapk*k__el ep]h bh]l o ej pda oqnce_]h pna] p*
i aj p kb ^]h` j aoo+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6428 227123+
. 1+
Cah` i ]j D+ Mkop*pdani ]h ^qi ]hkl a_e] ]j ` epo pna]pi aj p
qoej c at paj oer a dknevkj p]h na` q_pekj ej _ki ^ej ]pekj s epd
] Gqne bh]l + Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6618 607. / 35*. / 40+
. 2+
Gqne G) Gqne @) > nqba EK+ Roa kb nkp]pekj o_]hl bh]l o bkn
pda pna]pi aj p kb k__el ep]h ^]h` j aoo+ ? n G Mh]op Pqnc . 6458
3. 7/ 0+
. 3+
Bhhekp O> + I ]pan]h o_]hl bh]l o bkn ej op]j p naoqhpo ej i ]ha l ]p*
panj a` ^]h` j aoo+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6448 3- 7336+
. 4+
? ]nnan] > + Qda qoa kb i e_nkcn]bpo ]j ` i ej ecn]bpo bkn pda
pna]pi aj p kb ^qi ]hkl a_e]+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6568
. - 0725. *256+
. 5+
J _@]qhau OI + @knna_pekj kb ^qi ]hkl a_e]+ Fj 7 E anj ` kj
AK) a` + Qkp]h ? qnj @]na+ Mdeh]` ahl de]7 T +? + P]qj ` ano)
. 6637166*2- / +
. 6+
Q]gae Q) J ehho F) > n]e H) Pqi l ek ? B+ J kha_qh]n ^]oeo bkn
peooqa at l ]j oekj 7 _hej e_]h ei l he_]pekj o bkn oqncakj o+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6658 . - / 7/ 14*/ 25+
/ -+
Kaqi ]j j @D+ Qda at l ]j oekj kb ]j ]na] kb ogej ^u l nk*
cnaooer a ` eopaj pekj kb ] oq^_qp]j akqo ^]hhkkj + Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6248 . 67. / 1+
/ . + @dannu DT ) > qopa` BA) M]oug H> ) J _@h]p_dau HA)
Okne_d OG+ Fj _na]oa` oqnr er ]h ]j ` r ]o_qh]nepu kb n]j ` ki
l ]ppai ogej h]l o ahar ]pa` ej _kj pnkhha` ) at l ]j ` a` ogej +
Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 65/ 8 4/ 735- *352+
/ / +
P]o]ge DE) Mh]j c @V+ M]pdkl duoekhkcu kb ogej bh]l o n]eoa`
kj at l ]j ` a` ogej + Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6518 46726*32+
/ 0+
I ]j peane I > ) J ]npej *D]n_e] K) T a_dohan G) J epnkb]j kbb J )
O]qhk V) ? ]q_d+ S ]o_qh]n aj ` kpdahe]h cnks pd b]_pkn
at l naooekj ej at l ]j ` a` peooqa7 ] l kooe^ha i a_d]j eoi kb
]j cekcaj aoeo ej peooqa at l ]j oekj + Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc
. 6658 . - . 706/ *065+
/ 1+ M]oug H> ) > ncaj p] I @) E]ooad @+ Nq]j pep]per a ]j ]huoeo kb
pda pde_gj aoo kb dqi ]j ogej ]j ` oq^_qp]j akqo peooqa bkh*
hks ej c _kj pnkhha` at l ]j oekj s epd ] oehe_kj a ei l h]j p+ Mh]op
Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6558 5. 72. 3+
/ 2+ M]oug H> ) > ncaj p] I @) > qopa` BA+ Eeopkl ]pdkhkcu kb
dqi ]j at l ]j ` a` peooqa+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc . 6548 . 17102*112+
/ 3+ O]` ]r ]j @+ Qeooqa at l ]j oekj ej okbp peooqa na_kj opnq_pekj +
Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6518 41716. +
/ 4+ > qopa` BA) M]oug H> ) J _@h]p_dau HA) @dannu DT +
Eeopki knl dki apne_ ar ]hq]pekj kb cqej a] l ec ogej ]j ` okbp
peooqa ]bpan _kj pnkhha` peooqa at l ]j oekj + Mh]op Oa_kj opn
Pqnc . 65/ 8 4- 74- 1*4. - +
/ 5+ Ka]ha ET ) Eecd OJ ) ? ehhi ena A> ) @]nau GM) Pi epd A)
T ]n` aj D+ @ki l he_]pekj o kb _kj pnkhha` peooqa at l ]j oekj
ej pda l a` e]pne_ ^qnj l ]peaj p+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6558
5/ 751- *512+
/ 6+ J _@]qhau OI ) L hel d]j p GO) Ok^okj J @+ Qeooqa at l ]j oekj
ej pda _knna_pekj kb ^qnj ]hkl a_e]7 _h]ooebe_]pekj ]j `
i apdk` o kb _knna_pekj + > j j Mh]op Pqnc . 66- 8 / 27. - 0*. . 2+

**.

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
0-+
P]o]ge DE+ Fj pn]kl an]per a oqop]ej a` hei epa` at l ]j oekj
%FPI B& ]o ]j ej pani a` e]pa na_kj opnq_per a pa_dj emqa+ @hej
Mh]op Pqnc . 6548 . 17230*24. +
0. + Dkh` opaej OA) P_dqhan PE+ J apduhaj a ^hqa7 ] oei l ha
]` fqj _p pk ]e` ej okbp peooqa at l ]j oekj + Mh]op Oa_kj opn
Pqnc . 6538 . 5- 712/ / +
0/ + J ]j ` ano BH) Padaj ` aj J G) Cqnnau G> ) E apvhan MQ)
A]r eo QP) Dn]d]i T M FFF+ Pkbp peooqa at l ]j oekj o _kj _al po
]j ` _ki l he_]pekj o+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc . 6518 417160*2- 1+
00+ J ]j ` ano BA) Dn]d]i T M) P_daj ` kj J Q) A]r eo QP+ Pgej
at l ]j oekj pk ahei ej ]pa h]nca o_]hl ` aba_po+ > j j Mh]op Pqnc
. 6518 . / 70- 2*0. / +
01+ Ka]ha ET ) E ecd OJ ) ? ehhi ena A> ) @]nau GM) Pi epd A)
T ]n` aj D+ @ki l he_]pekj o kb _kj pnkhha` okbp peooqa at l ]j *
oekj ej pda l a` e]pne_ ^qnj l ]peaj p+ Mh]op Oa_kj opn Pqnc
. 6558 5/ 751- *512+
02+ J ]_I aj j kj PB) @kn_kn]j GC) Ka]ha ET + Qeooqa at l ]j oekj
ej da]` ]j ` j a_g ^qnj na_kj opnq_pekj + @hej Mh]op Pqnc / - - - 8
/ 47. / . *. 0/ +
03+ E ai i an HJ ) J ]nod GI ) Me_gan P+ @]hr ]ne]h ankoekj ]bpan
o_]hl at l ]j oekj + > j j Mh]op Pqnc . 6548 . 67121*126+
04+ L npac] J Q) J _@]qhau OI ) Ok^okj J @+ P]hr ]ca kb ]j
]r qhoa` at l ]j ` a` o_]hl bh]l pk _knna_p ^qnj ]hkl a_e]+
Pkqpd J a` G . 66- 8 50%0&7/ / - */ / 0+
05+ ? evdgk FM) Phao]naj gk PS+ Ll an]per a pna]pi aj p kb ` aal
^qnj o pk pda o_]hl ]j ` ogqhh+ ? qi o . 66/ 8 . 57/ / - */ / 0+
06+ Kkngaoo Q) Hha^]j kr ]o G) S egon]ej ap ]h+ Aaal aha_pne_]h
^qi o kb pda _]hr ]neqi 7 a]nhu kn ` ah]ua` na_kj opnq_pekj +
? qnj o . 66/ 8 . 57/ / - */ / 0+
1- +
Pdane` ]j OI ) @dkq_]en OG) Akj ah]j J ? + J ]j ]cai aj p kb
i ]ooer a _]hr ]ne]h at l koqna ej ukqj c _deh` naj + G ? qnj
@]na Oad]^ . 6658 . 67/ 6*0/ +
1. + Pner ]op]r ] GI ) ? eos ]o D) K]n]ukj OM) Dkah > + @dnkj e_]hhu
at l koa` _]hr ]neqi ]bpan aha_pne_]h ^qnj o+ ? qnj o . 6608
. 67. 05*. 1. +
1/ + Cnea` J ) Okoaj ^anc ? ) Qa_di ]j F) ? aj dqn K) V]n` aj e M)
Ppanj ^anc K) Dkh]j G+ Bha_pne_]h ^qi ej fqnu kb pda o_]hl 7
^kj a nacnks pd bkhhks ej c ]l l he_]pekj o kb h]peooei qo ` knoe
bnaa bh]l pk pda ]na]+ ? qi o . 66. 8 . 47005*006+
10+ Pehr an^anc ? ) ? ]j eo G@) S an` e DA) > _h]j ` OA+ J e_nkr ]o*
_qh]n na_kj opnq_pekj ]bpan aha_pne_]h ]j ` ` aal pdani ]h
ej fqnu+ G Qn]qi ] . 6538 / 37. / 5*. 01+
11+ ? ]nnap GM) Aveas qhoge M) J _@]qhau OI ) Eanj ` kj AK)
Aao]e J E+ Aqn] na_kj opnq_pekj kb pda _h]oo FS _]hr ]ne]h
^qnj o s epd ` a_ahhqh]neva` dqi ]j ` ani eo+ ? qnj o . 6668
/ 27126*13/ +
12+ I q_a B> + Bha_pne_]h ^qi o+ @hej Mh]op Pqnc / - - - 8
04%. &7 . 00 ê . 11+

&
5 da] b ^U cWT FZd[[ P] S FRP[_ P] S GWTXa 6 [X] XRP[ @P] PVT\ T] c
@HG4 M 5& ; 4 5 4 ?
47B E7 %7M &F7C?D<79?7A &; CH; F 47B E7! ) ADF?: 7! 5 3$
F+
Fj pnk` q_pekj
/ / 4
FF+
Eeopkne_]h Manol a_per a
/ / 4
FFF+ > j ]pki e_]h Manol a_per ao
/ / 5
>+
M]pdkl duoekhkcu kb pda
? qnj a` Pgqhh
/ / 6
? +
Qul ao kb Pgqhh T kqj ` o
/ / 6
@+
Ae]cj kope_o
/ 0-
A+
Qna]pi aj p J k` ]hepeao
/ 0-
FS + @kj _hqoekj
/ 0/
Oabanaj _ao
/ 0/
<&
? qi o kb pda ogqhh ]j ` pda o_]hl nal naoaj p ] i ]fkn _d]h*
haj ca pk pda pna]pej c oqncakj + Qdkqcd oq_d ej fqneao ]na
n]na) nal naoaj pej c kj hu x . *3" kb _]oao ej kqn l n]_pe_a ]j `
pd]p kb kpdano %. &) pdau ]na ` ar ]op]pej c ^kpd ej pda naoqhpej c
l ]peaj p pn]qi ] ]j ` ` eobecqnai aj p ]j ` ej pda oamqah] pd]p
i ]u bkhhks qj oq__aoobqh ]ppai l po pk _kr an) da]h) ]j `
na_kj opnq_p pda at l koa` ) ej fqna` _n]j eqi + Qdnkqcdkqp
i a` e_]h deopknu) ej fqneao naoqhpej c ej hkoo kb o_]hl ]j `
` ]i ]ca pk pda qj ` anhuej c _n]j eqi d]r a ^aaj nal knpa` )
]j ` r ]nekqo opn]paceao bkn pna]pi aj p d]r a ^aaj qoa`
%/ )0&+ Fj pda l ]op) pda na_kj opnq_per a ` ehai i ] s ]o ]
l nk` q_p kb pda h]_g kb ]r ]eh]^ha oqnce_]h opn]paceao)
i ]pane]ho) kn pkkho pk l nk` q_a _kr an]ca bkn pda at l koa`
ogqhh+ Qda hk_]pekj kb pdeo ej fqnu l naoaj pa` ] oej cqh]n ` ebbe*
_qhpu7 pda h]_g kb peooqa pk r ]o_qh]neva aepdan pda qj ` anhuej c
kn pda kr anhuej c opnq_pqnao kb at l koa` ) ^qnj a` ogqhh) ]j ` pk
_kr an ` ]i ]ca` ) ^]na _n]j e]h ^kj a oq__aoobqhhu s epd ogej
cn]bp+
Qna]pi aj p kb _n]j e]h ^qnj ej fqneao d]o ` ar ahkl a` cn]` q*
]hhu pdnkqcd pei a) ]j ` epo oq__aoo d]o ^qehp ql kj ]j
ej _na]oej c qj ` anop]j ` ej c kb pda ]j ]pki u kb pda ]bba_pa`
nacekj ]j ` pda ej j kr ]pekj o kb l n]_pepekj ano s dk d]r a
okqcdp i apdk` o pk naopkna pdaen l ]peaj po pk bqj _pekj ]j `
da]hpd+ Fp eo ei l knp]j p pk ]_gj ks ha` ca ]j ` ` eo_qoo dana
pda ej caj qepu kb kqn oqnce_]h bknab]pdano ej pna]pej c pdaoa
s kqj ` o+
<<&
; Pqncakj o pdnkqcdkqp pda deopknu kb i a` e_ej a d]r a d]` pk
l kooaoo pda ]^ehepu pk ^a ^kpd ej j kr ]per a ]j ` ]ccnaooer a
s daj b]_a` s epd ] _hej e_]h l nk^hai ) uap j kp fakl ]n` eva
pda l ]peaj pîo _]na kn s ahh*^aej c ^u oq_d opn]paceao+ > j u
` eo_qooekj kb _]hr ]ne]h ^qnj o odkqh` ej _hq` a pdeo deopkne_]h
l nkol a_per a) s de_d eo kb cna]p r ]hqa pk ]hh _kj pai l kn]nu
oqncakj o+ Qda na]hepu pd]p pda oqncakj i qop ei l nkr eoa ]
pna]pi aj p l h]j ) uap j kp _ki l nki eoa epo oq^fa_p opehh at eopo
pk` ]u ej pda kl an]pej c nkki +
Qda bkhhks ej c opknu eo nabanna` pk ej pda benop a` epekj kb
pda G+J + @kj r anoa pat p^kkg) Mh]ope_ ]j ` Oa_kj opnq_per a
Pqncanu / + Fj . 444) ]p @]i l I ]` u > i ^han ej Ekhopaj )
QK) An+ M]pne_g S ]j _a pna]pa` ] r e_pei kb pda @dankgaa
Fj ` e]j _kj bhe_p s dk d]` ëj a]nhu pda s dkha kb deo da]`
**/

**0

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
ogej j a` í ej ]j Fj ` e]j ]pp]_g %0&+ Qda qj bknpqj ]pa l ]peaj pîo
ogqhh s ]o ëmqepa j ]ga` ) ]j ` ^ac]j pk pqnj ^h]_gí %/ )0&+
An+ S ]j _a ej opnq_pa` pda i ehep]nu l duoe_e]j op]pekj a` ]p
pda bknp) An+ G]i ao Ok^anpokj ) pk ^kna dkhao ej pda l ] peaj pîo
ogqhh ]o ep ^ac]j pk ^h]_gaj ) ckej c kj hu ok ` aal ]o pk
oaa ë] na` ` eod bhqe` ]l l a]ní %0&+ Qdeo s kqh` ]hhks ëpda
bhaod +++ pk neoa ej pdaoa dkhao)í s de_d s ana pk ^a ol ]_a`
]^kqp ]j ej _d ]l ]np %0&+ Qda oqnce_]h ej opnqi aj p kb
_dke_a s ]o ]j ]s h) s de_d s ]o ]^ha pk l aj apn]pa pda ogqhh
]j ` _kqh` ]hok ^a qoa` pk nai kr a pda ^h]_g o_]hao kb
` a]` ^kj a ]o cn]j qh]pekj peooqa ]l l a]na` + Qdaoa ^qnn
dkhao l nk` q_a` ) ej pei a) ] ckk` ^a` kb cn]j qh]pekj peooqa
pd]p opkl l a` pda ` aoe__]pekj kb pda ogqhh ]j ` l nkr e` a` ]
ohks %oki apei ao 1 ua]no ^abkna pda ` aba_p s kqh` _ki l ha*
pahu ë_qna ql í &) ^qp kbpaj oq__aoobqh) i apdk` kb _kr an]ca
pd]p ^a_]i a s e` aol na]` ` qnej c pda _kj bhe_po s epd pda
> i ane_]j Fj ` e]j 7 ëQdeo kl an]pekj ^a_]i a +++ ok _ki i kj
pd]p pdana s ana l anokj o ej ar anu bknp s dk l anbkni a` epí %0&+
Qda pa_dj emqa s ]o ]ppne^qpa` pk ]j qj j ]i a` ëCnaj _d
oqncakj +í An+ S ] j _aîo ej ol en]pekj bkn pdeo pa_dj emqa
]l l a]no pk d]r a ^aaj > qcqopej ? ahhkopa) ] M]neoe]j
oqncakj ^ki ej . 321) s dk s nkpa ej . 363 kb pna]pej c
o_]hl ]r qhoekj ^u pdeo i apdk` ) ]j ` d]` ]hok qoa` ep pk
pna]p _ki ^]p ej fqneao %0&+ Qdeo ëi kop qj emqa l nk_a` qnaí
s ]o qoa` ]j ` nal knpa` kj ^u Pj ar a %1& . 555 ej pda pna]p*
i aj p kb ] oar ana _n]j e]h ^qi +
L b deopkne_]h j kpa) pdeo bkni kb pna]pi aj p bkn at l koa`
]j ` ej fqna` ogqhh naoqhpa` ej ]j a]nhu qj ` anop]j ` ej c kb
pda qoa kb ]qpkhkckqo ^kj a cn]bpo+ Qdkoa ej epe]h bej ` ej co
bkni pda ^]oeo bkn pda ar khqpekj kb pda ^kj a cn]bpej c l nk*
_a` qnao pd]p ]na ]r ]eh]^ha pk qo pk` ]u ej pda nal ]en ]j `
na_kj opnq_pekj kb _n]j e]h ` aba_po %2&+ Qdaen qhpei ]pa okl deo*
pe_]pekj eo pda l nk_aoo qoa` pk` ]u ej ^kj a aj cej aanej c bkn
pda na_kj opi _pekj kb ogqhh ` aba_po7 qoej c pda ^]oe_
ahai aj po kb opai _ahho) ] o_]bbkh` ) ]j ` ] _]nnean) bkn aj d]j *
_ej c b]_pkno pd]p _kj pne^qpa pk pda bkni ]pekj kb j as ^kj a
VW ` aha' Lpdan deopkne_ h]j ` i ]ngo ej pda pna]pi aj p kb
o_]hl ]j ` ogqhh ^qi o bkhhks pda _kqnoa kb ej j kr ]pekj o ej
pda pna]pi aj p bkn o_]hl ]r qhoekj + Qdaoa ej _hq` a r ]nekqo
i apdk` o kb ogej cn]bpej c) ej epe]pa` ^u Kapkhepoguîo qoa kb
bqhh*pde_gj aoo cn]bpo pk _kr an ` aj q` a` ogqhh) ]j ` pda ` ar ah*
kl i aj p kb ogej bh]l o ^u Dkqh` ) Dehheao ]j ` Hehj an) Kas
]j ` Bne_d) ]j ` @]dehh ]j ` @]qhbeah` + Ckn ] i kna ej *` al pd
]__kqj p kb pda deopkne_]h pna]pi aj p kb o_]hl hkoo oaa
H]v]j fe]j ]j ` T a^opanîo %3& r aj an]^ha ]npe_ha kj pna] p*
i aj p kb o_]hl hkoo+
<<<&
4 A4 GB@<6 4 ? C8 EFC8 6 GQda qhpn]opnq_pqna kb pda ]j ]pki u kb pda ogqhh ]j ` epo ps k
aj cqhbej c b]o_e]a eo s ahh ` ao_ne^a` ej l nar ekqo l q^he_]pekj o
%2*4&+ Fp eo aooaj pe]h pk d]r a ] _ha]n qj ` anop]j ` ej c kb pda
h]uano kb pda ogqhh) oej _a pdau nal naoaj p ]j ei l knp]j p
]j ]pki e_]h ]j ` l duoekhkce_ ouopai kb l nkpa_pekj ) _kr an]ca)
]j ` ^ekhkce_ bqj _pekj bkn pda _aj pn]h j anr kqo ouopai +
Qda o_]hl eo pda d]en*^a]nej c _ki l kj aj p ]j ` ] h]op ar kh*
qpekj ]nu nai j ]j p bkn l nkpa_pekj kb pda da]` bnki aj r enkj *
i aj p]h b]_pkno oq_d ]o da]p) okh]n n]` e]pekj ) ]j ` _kh`
pai l an]pqnao+ Qda ql l an _en_qh]pekj ` kao j kp bkhhks pda
_kqj pan_qnnaj p i a_d]j eoi o kb pda kpdan l ]npo kb pda ^ek*
hkce_ ouopai + Qda o_]hl eo ]npane]hhu oql l hea` bnki epo l an*
el danu ^u bkqn i ]fkn r aooaho7 pda l ]ena` k__el ep]h ]npaneao
]j ` pda l ]ena` pai l kn]h ]npaneao+ L pdan r aooaho pn]r anoa
pda o_]hl bnki pdnaa ` ei aj oekj o+ Qkl kcn]l de_ r ]o_qh]n bhks
bnki pda bnkj p kb pda o_]hl ]j paneknhu ]j ` r e] pda _n]j e]h
oej qoao d]o ]j ei l knp]j p bqj _pekj ej ` eoa]oa l nk_aooao+
T daj pdana eo ]j ej panj ]h k^opnq_pekj ) pda _en_qh]pekj
i ]u qoa pdeo ` kni ]j p) r aopece]h ouopai + Fj ol epa kb oq_d
ne_d ^hkk` oql l hu) ej kqn l n]_pe_a s a opehh k__]oekj ]hhu
oaa j a_nkpe_ ogqhh s epd _ki l nki eoa` r ]o_qh]n oql l hu %2&+
Qda oa_kj ` h]uan eo pda c]he] ]l kj aqnkpe_]) s de_d eo ]j
]j ]pki e_]h ]l kj aqnkoeo pd]p _kj j a_po pda bnkj p]heo pk pda
k__el ep]heo i qo_hao ej pda o_]hl + Qdeo qj ep eo ]j ]pki e_]hhu
l kknhu r ]o_qh]neva` ) ^qp epo r ]o_qh]nepu eo ]` amq]pa
aj kqcd pk oql l knp ogej cn]bp %5&+ Qda ol ]_a kj pkl ]j `
qj ` anj a]pd eo ]hi kop ]r ]o_qh]n) pdkqcd pdana ]na r aooaho
_nkooej c pda ol ]_a pk aj d]j _a pda r ]o_qh]n _ki i qj e_]pekj +
Qd]p _ki l kj aj p eo) dks ar an) i ]ncej ]h %5&+
Qda j at p h]uan kb pda ogqhh eo pda l ane_n]j eqi ) pda l ane*
kopaqi kb pda ogqhh) s de_d eo hkkoahu ]pp]_da` pk pda _knpat
kb pda kqpan p]^ha at _al p ]p pda oqpqna hej ao kb pda ogqhh+ Qda
l ane_n]j eqi eo ] pdej h]uan kb _kj j a_per a peooqa pd]p aj r ah*
kl o pda j aqnk_n]j eqi + Fp eo ] r ]o_qh]n) ` uj ]i e_ h]uan _kj *
p]ej ej c be^nkqo ahai aj po) be^nkqo peooqa) j anr ao) ]j ` ] ne_d
r ]o_qh]n j aps kng+ Qdeo h]uan eo oei eh]n pk pda l anekopaqi kb
hkj c ^kj a+ Fp d]o ^aaj r eas a` ]o ] oql l hean kb j as ^hkk`
r aooaho pk pda kopakcaj e_ _ahho ej pda qj ` anhuej c ^kj a
%2)4&+ > ckk` l knpekj kb pda ej j an h]uan d]o ]_per a be^nk*
^h]opo) s de_d ]na qoabqh ej pda bkni ]pekj kb j as ^kj a ej
_deh` naj ]j ` ej pda nai k` ahej c kb ^kj ao ej ]` qhpo+ Qda
oej qo l ane_n]j ee ]_p ]o ]npane]ho kn r aj qhao pd]p _kj r au ]
ps k*s ]u pn]bbe_ ej ]j ` kqp kb pda ogqhh+ Qdeo eo ]j ei l knp]j p
_kj _al p bkn pda qj ` anop]j ` ej c kb ` eoa]oa l nk_aooao kb pda
ogqhh ]j ` bkn qj ` anop]j ` ej c pda l duoekhkcu kb pda bh]l o
qoa` bkn ogqhh _kr an]ca %3)4&+
Qda kooakqo ogqhh epoahb eo _ki l koa` kb ps k h]uano) s epd
ai l pu ol ]_a ^aps aaj pdai + Qdeo ol ]_a ej _na]oao ]o ]
l anokj na]_dao ]` qhpdkk` + Qda pde_gj aoo kb pda ^kj u
h]uano eo ]hok ]ca*` al aj ` aj p7 pda kh` an pda l ]peaj p) pda
pde_gan pda ogqhh+ Qda ogqhhîo pde_gj aoo eo ]hok oepa*
` al aj ` aj p7 ` ebbanaj p ]j ]pki e_]h oepao d]r a ` ebbanaj p
i a]oqnao kb pde_gj aoo+ Qdana ]na ]hok apdj e_]h r ]ne]pekj o7
_anp]ej n]_ao oaai pk d]r a ` ebbanaj p _kj becqn]pekj o) ]j `
ep d]o ^aaj ol a_qh]pa` pd]p pdaoa s ana ej bhqaj _a` ^u
l duoe_]h aj r enkj i aj p ]j ` ar khqpekj +
Qda ej j an l knpekj kb pda ogqhh _]l eo hej a` s epd pda ` qn]
i ]ppan) s de_d eo ]hok pda aj cqhbej c be^nkqo peooqa b]o_e] kb

5 d\ b ^U cWT FZd[[ P] S FRP[_ P] S GWTXa 6 [X] XRP[ @P] PVT\ T] c

**1
pda ^n]ej + Qda ` qn] eo r ]o_qh]n ]j ` p]gao ogej cn]bp s ahh %6&+
Eks ar an) pdeo i aj aj ce]h h]uan eo ` ar ke` kb hui l d]pe_o) ok
pd]p pqi kno i ]u ol na]` ]hkj c pda ` qn] i ]pan ^qp r anu
n]nahu _]j ck pdnkqcd ep+ Qdeo eo ]j kpdan j ]pqn]h l nkpa_per a
i a_d]j eoi ]c]ej op ` eoa]oa ]j ` j akl h]oi o %2&+ Qda h]uano
pd]p aj cqhb pda ogqhh ]na ei l knp]j p qj epo pd]p s ehh ^a
nabanna` pk ` qnej c ` eo_qooekj o kb pda l ]pdkl duoekhkcu
]j ` pda pna]pi aj p kb pda _]hr ]ne]h ^qi o+
4 &
CPcW^ _WhbX^ [^ Vh ^U cWT 5 da] TS FZd[[
Qda ogqhh) s epd epo pde_g okbp peooqa l nkpa_pekj ) _ki l neoao ]
` ebbe_qhp ]j ]pki e_]h opnq_pqna pk ^a ^qnj a` ` ena_phu+ Ckn pdeo
na]okj ) ogqhh ^qi o nal naoaj p kj hu x h*3 " kb ]hh ^qi o
%. )6). - &+ Qda i ]fknepu kb l ]peaj po s epd ^qnj a` ogqhho)
x4- " ) _]j j ks ^a i ]j ]ca` _hej e_]hhu s epd bas heba*
pdna]paj ej c l nk^hai o+ Qd]p ha]r ao pda na_kj opnq_per a
oqncakj s epd ] oi ]hh ^qp _nepe_]h j qi ^an kb l ]peaj po s dk
j aa` pda ej paj oer a i ]j ]cai aj p l nkr e` a` ^u ] ^qi qj ep pd]p
s a d]r a ]r ]eh]^ha pk qo pk` ]u+ Qdaoa l ]peaj po s ehh ^a pda
bk_qo kb i u ` eo_qooekj kj _]na bkn ^qnj a` o_]hl o ]j ` ogqhho+
Qda ^qi o kb pda da]` ]hi kop ej r ]ne]^hu ej r khr a pda
o_]hl %6&+ > o ` eo_qooa` a]nhean) pda o_]hl d]o ckk` )
oaj o]pa nabhat er a na]_pekj pk l ]ej 7 ar aj ]j ej b]j p kn ukqj c*
opan s ehh s epd` n]s bnki ] l ]ej bqh pdani ]h okqn_a+ Rj haoo ]
dqi ]j ^aej c eo ej ] j aqnkhkce_]h kn kpdan ]hpana` op]pa kb
_kj o_ekqoj aoo oq_d ]o _ki ]) pda pdani ]h ej fqnu s ehh j kp
pn]r anoa pda ^kj a+ > hpdkqcd pdani ]h ^qi o i ]u da]p pda
^kj a) ep s ehh j kp _]qoa pda pdani ]h j a_nkoeo pd]p eo oaaj
ej pda ` ani ]h ^qi o+ Qda l ]peaj p s epd ] ^qi ej fqnu
hei epa` pk pda o_]hl s ehh namqena pda o]i a _]na ]o kpdan
` ani ]h ^qi o+ Qdana eo qoq]hhu ]` amq]pa peooqa bkn pn]j oban
kn at l ]j oekj pk pda ]na]) kn pdana eo ]` amq]pa r ]o_qh]nepu
bkn bnaa*peooqa pn]j oban oq_d ]o ] cn]bp %. . &+
Qda kpdan bkni kb i kna bk_qoa` pdani ]h ej fqnu eo pd]p kb
aha_pne_]h ^qi o+ Qda aj pnu ]j ` at ep l kej po caj an]pa ] i q_d
decdan ` acnaa kb pdani ]h ` ]i ]ca) ej s de_d ]hh pda peooqa
har aho pn]r anoa` ^u pda _qnnaj po s ehh ^a j a_nkpe_ kn
_d]nna` + Qda ^n]ej i ]u ^a ]bba_pa` ]j ` s ehh j aa` pk ^a
i kj epkna` l duoekhkce_]hhu %6&+ Qda ogqhh ]na] ]bba_pa`
s ehh ^a_ki a ` a]` ^kj a) ]_pej c kj hu ]o ] o_]bbkh` pd]p
i ]u kn i ]u j kp ^a ]^ha pk s epdop]j ` l duoekhkce_]h ]j `
aj r enkj i aj p]h b]_pkno) ]j ` oqnr er a+ Aa]` ^kj a oqnr er ]h
d]o b]o_ej ]pa` ^kpd _hej e_e]j o ]j ` o_eaj peopo+ Qdeo oar anahu
_ki l nki eoa` ^kj a s ehh qoq]hhu nacaj an]pa pk her ej c ^kj a
ej _deh` naj ) ^qp eo haoo hegahu pk ` k ok ej ]` qhpo %4&+ Fj
pdaoa oepq]pekj o) cn]bpo i ]u j kp ^a ba]oe^ha ^a_]qoa kb
_ki l nki eoa pk pda ^hkk` oql l hu+ Qdanabkna) ]` f]_aj p
peooqa pn]j oban) at l ]j oekj ) ]j ` bnaa bh]l o i ]u ^a pda kj hu
]hpanj ]per a ]r ]eh]^ha bkn pda l nk` q_pekj kb okbp peooqa
_kr an]ca bkn pda ogqhh %. - *. / &+
T a _]j pdqo oqi i ]nehu l kej p kqp pd]p pda l ]peaj p _kj *
` epekj pd]p _]qoa` pda pdani ]h ej fqnu pk pda qoq]hhu s ahh*
l nkpa_pa` _n]j eqi ) ]o s ahh ]o pda ` aj oepu kb l aj apn]pekj )
pda haj cpd kb at l koqna) ]j ` pda ej paj oepu kb pai l an]pqna
kn _qnnaj p s ehh ^a pda ` apani ej ej c b]_pkno bkn pda bej ]h
` acnaa kb ` aopnq_pekj kb pda ogqhh+ Fj ]hh pdaoa _en_qi *
op]j _ao) pda ogqhh odkqh` ^a _kj oe` ana` ]o ] _hkoa` r ]qhp
pd]p d]o oqop]ej a` ej fqnu+ > hh pda _kj paj po ej pda r ]qhp
s ana kl an]pekj ]h ^abkna pda ej fqnu) ]j ` odkqh` nai ]ej ok
]bpan pda i ]j ]cai aj p) pna]pi aj p) ]j ` na_kj opnq_pekj kb
pda r ]qhp epoahb+ > o oqncakj o) s a i ]u ^a _]hha` ql kj pk
ei l nkr eoa) ^qp s a i qop s kng j ar an pk _ki l nki eoa bqj _*
pekj + T a odkqh` bkhhks pda l nej _el ha pd]p s a ` k j kp
_na]pa ] ` abkni epu pk _knna_p ]j kpdan kj a+
5&
Gh_Tb ^ U FZd[[ J ^ d] Sb
Fj kn` an pk qj ` anop]j ` i ]j ]cai aj p l nkpk_kho bkn pda
l ]peaj p s epd ] ^qi ej fqnu kb pda ogqhh) ep eo j a_aoo]nu pk
nar eas pda _h]ooebe_]pekj kb _n]j e]h pdani ]h s kqj ` o
]__kn` ej c pk pdaen at paj p ]j ` hk_]pekj kj pda ogqhh %. 0&+
Qul a F7 T kqj ` o hei epa` pk pda o_]hl ]j ` c]ha]
]l kj aqnkpe_]+
Qul a FF7 T kqj ` o ej s de_d pda ^kj a eo ` ar ]o_qh]neva` ]j `
at l koa` ]bpan nai kr ]h kb _d]nna` okbp peooqa+ Qda
kqpan p]^ha eo j a_nkpe_ ^]oa` kj _hej e_]h at ]i + Aa]`
^kj a _kqh` ^a hei epa` pk pda benop p]^ha kb pda ogqhh+
Qul a FF> 7 @nepe_]h oeva pd]p eo at l koa` eo 9 / _i +
Qul a FF? 7 @nepe_]h oeva ` aba_p kb pda at l koa` ogqhh eo
; / _i +
Qul a FFF7 Qda bqhh pde_gj aoo kb pda ogqhh eo j a_nkpe_ ]j `
pda ` qn] eo at l koa` ]bpan nai kr ej c pda okbp peooqa) pda
` aba_p eo ; / _i
Qul a FS7 Qda pdani ]h ej fqnu at paj ` o pk pda ` qn] ]j ` pda
^n]ej + Mknpekj o kb pdaoa opnq_pqnao d]r a pk ^a
nai kr a` ]j ` nal h]_a` ^u pn]j obanna` peooqao+
Qdeo oei l ha _h]ooebe_]pekj s ehh dahl s epd ps k _ki *
l kj aj po kb pda i ]j ]cai aj p kb ^qi o+ Cenop) pdeo _h]ooebe*
_]pekj ouopai s ehh dahl pda oqncakj ej pda ej epe]h
ar ]hq]pekj l nk_aoo kb pda l ]peaj p ]j ` ej pda ]ooaooi aj p
kb pda at paj p kb pda ej fqneao+ Pa_kj ` ) ej epe]h _h]ooebe_]pekj
kb pda ej fqnu eo r ]hq]^ha ej pda ar aj pq]h _d]npej c ]j `
]ooaooi aj p kb ^kj a da]hej c ]j ` epo kqp_ki a) ok pd]p
pdana eo ] op]j ` ]n` kb _ki l ]neokj pk ]ooaoo+
Fj kqn l n]_pe_a s a bej ` pd]p ep eo _nepe_]h pk ]ooaoo pda oeva
kb pda ` aba_p ej kn` an pk l na` e_p pda kqp_ki a kb ^kj a
da]hej c+ ? kj a hkoo 9 / _i qoq]hhu da]ho r anu s ahh ^u epo
ks j nacaj an]per a l nk_aooao) aol a_e]hhu ej _deh` naj qj ` an
. / ua]no kb ]ca %. / ). 1&+ Qda l nk_aoo kb nacaj an]pekj eo
opnkj caop ]p ]ca 3 ua]no) ohks ej c ` ks j pdnkqcd pda j at p
3 ua]no qj peh pda ]ca kb . / ua]no+ Fj ]` qhpo) ^kj a nacaj an*
]pekj eo qj l na` e_p]^ha+ Oacaj an]pekj eo ` al aj ` aj p kj pda
aj r enkj i aj p]h b]_pkno kb pda ej ` er e` q]h l ]peaj p ]j ` kj
pda l ]peaj pîo l duoe_]h op]pqo ]j ` ej panj ]h i eheaq %6&+
Qda ]^ehepu kb ` a]` ^kj a pk da]h k__ql eao ] i ]fkn l h]_a
ej pda qj ` anop]j ` ej c kb pda ^kj a da]hej c l nk_aooao)

*+(

9d] RcX^] P[ P] S 4 TbcWTcXR ETR^] bcadRcX^] ^U 5 da] TS CPcXT] cb
l ]npe_qh]nhu ej pda ogqhh+ Cnki pda pei a pd]p oqncakj o benop
ha]nj a` opn]paceao bkn pda na_kj opnq_pekj kb ogqhh ` aba_po
s epd _]` ]r an kn ]j ei ]h ^kj a) pda l nk_aoo kb ^kj a da]hej c
^a_]i a i kna pdknkqcdhu qj ` anopkk` + @hej e_e]j o j ks
gj ks pd]p ^kj a _]j oqnr er a ar aj s daj ep eo j kp r ]o_qh]n*
eva` ^u i anahu ]_pej c ]o ] o_]bbkh` ]j ` l nkpa_pej c pda
qj ` anhuej c opnq_pqnao %1). 1). 2&+ Fj oki a _]oao) ep i ]u
nacaj an]pa+ Ckn ` a]` ^kj a pk oqnr er a) pda ]j ]pki e_]h oepa
i qop ^a _ha]j kb ` a^neo ]j ` j kp cnkoohu _kj p]i ej ]pa` +
Qda ej fqna` okbp peooqa i qop ^a _ha]j a` ]j ` ` a]` peooqa
` a^ne` a` l nki l phu ^abkna oal pe_ _kj ` epekj o oap ej ) ]j `
^abkna pda j a_nkpe_ ^kj a op]npo pk bh]ga) _d]j cej c pda
s kqj ` ej pk ] cnkoohu _kj p]i ej ]pa` oepa+ Qdaoa _kj ` epekj o
]na i kop kbpaj oaaj ej aha_pne_]h ^qnj o) s dana pda
pdani ]h _ki l kj aj po ]na kb ] decd har ah %. 3&+ Qda at paj p
kb pda pdani ]h ej fqnu odkqh` ^a ]ooaooa` ]j ` ]hok pda
at paj p kb ej r khr ai aj p kb kpdan ]j ]pki e_ oepao+ > hh pdaoa
b]_pkno ej bhqaj _a pda ar aj pq]h kqp_ki a ]j ` pda ` acnaa kb
pna]pi aj p j aa` a` kn qoa` + @kj oe` an]pekj kb pda l ]peaj p ]o
] s dkha i qop ^a opnaooa` ) n]pdan pd]j ] oal ]n]pa ]j ]pki e_
bk_qo kj pda ej fqna` _]hr ]ne]h ^kj a+ Vkq i qop pna]p pda
l ]peaj p ]o s ahh ]o pda ej fqnu+
6 &
7 XPV] ^ bcXRb
Qda op]j ` ]n` ` e]cj kope_ paopo ]na ]hh ]l l he_]^ha ^qp i ]u
j kp ^a dahl bqh ej ` e]cj koej c pda at paj p kb pda r e]^ehepu
kb pda ^kj a ]j ` pda ` acnaa kb pda ej fqnu+ > ^kj a o_]j
i ]u oda` oki a hecdp) ^qp ej pda ej epe]h l d]oa kb pda
ej fqnu pdana i ]u ^a pdnki ^koeo kb pda ej pankooakqo
r aooaho) s de_d s ehh ]hpan pda bej ` ej c kb pda o_]j +
Oacqh]n n]` ekcn]l do kb pda ogqhh _]j ^a qoa` ]o ] ^]oa*
hej a) ]o _]j _ki l qpan caj an]pa` ]t e]h o_]j o+ > j aha_pnk*
aj _al d]hkcn]i odkqh` ^a ` kj a) ]j ` ]hok ] i ]cj ape_
naokj ]j _a o_]j + Qda ` ]p] _khha_pa` _]j ]ooeop h]pan kj
s epd ar ]hq]pekj kb pda ` eol koepekj kb ]hh pda ej r khr a`
^kj ao+ > _d]j ca pk ] ëcnkqj ` ch]ooí ]l l a]n]j _a kn ]
_d]j ca pk decdan kn hks an ` aj oepu kb pda ej r khr a` ^kj a
s ehh dahl pda _hej e_e]j ej ` ena_pej c pda i ]j ]cai aj p
l h]j o bkn pda l ]peaj p+
7 &
GaTPc\ T] c @^ SP[XcXTb
Fj pda pna]pi aj p kb pda ^qnj a` ogqhh s a bkhhks pda ^]oe_
l nej _el hao kb l h]ope_ oqncanu7 benop) l nkr e` a _kr an]ca ]o
okkj ]o l kooe^ha s epdkqp ]j u _ki l nki eoa pk pda ]` f]_aj p
peooqa kn pk pda ^ekhkce_]h ouopai ]o ] s dkha+ Qda bkhhks *
ej c pna]pi aj p i k` ]hepeao ]na l n]_pe_a` s epd ]hh pdani ]h
ej fqneao ]j ` ]l l hu) ]o s ahh) pk pda o_]hl ]j ` pda _n]j e]h
^kj ao %6). / ). 1). 3&+
.+
Fi i a` e]pa pna]pi aj p kb pda l ]peaj p s deha ej pda
]_qpa l d]oa) s de_d i ]u ej _hq` a ` a^ne` ai aj p ]j `
pai l kn]nu _kr an]ca+
9XVdaT ) / &)
%> & Qdnaa*` ei aj oekj ]h @> Q o_]j kb . 4*ua]n*kh` l ]peaj p s epd ] necdp oe` a` l ]neap]h ogqhh ` aba_p ]bpan ]j aha_pne_]h ^qnj pk
pda o_]hl + %? & Fj pn]kl an]per a _kr an]ca qoej c i apduhi apd]_nuh]pa+ %Oal nej pa` s epd l ani eooekj bnki J _@]qhau OI ) ? ]nnap GM+ Bha_pne_]h
ej fqneao+ Fj 7 Bnegokj ) a` + Mh]ope_ Pqncanu7 Fj ` e_]pekj o) L l an]pekj o ]j ` Lqp_ki ao+ Pp+ I kqeo7 J ko^u) Fj _+) / - - - 7042*054+&

hacklink satın al mumu模拟器 雷电模拟器 向日葵 giftcardmall/mygift giftcardmall balance mygift giftcardmall matbet matbet giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Casibom Güncel Giriş Casibom Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Fixbet Fixbet Güncel Giriş Fixbet Betgaranti Betgaranti Güncel Adres Betgaranti Fixbet Fixbet Güncel Giriş Fixbet Fim İzle Fim İzle Giriş Fim İzle Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Giriş Grandpashabet Fim İzle Fim İzle Güncel Adres Fim İzle jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet jojobet giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Casibom Güncel Adres Casibom Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Casibom Giriş Casibom Turk İfsa Turk İfsa Güncel Giriş Turk İfsa Canlı Maç Canlı Maç İzle Canlı Maç Porno İzle Porno İzle Güncel Adres Porno İzle Turk İfsa Turk İfsa Güncel Giriş Turk İfsa Porno İzle Porno İzle Güncel Adres Porno İzle Jojobet Jojobet Giriş Jojobet Canlı Maç Canlı Maç İzle Canlı Maç Deneme Bonusu Film İzle Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Türkçe Dublaj Film İzle Film İzle Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Giriş Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Güncel Adres Casibom Casibom Güncel Adres Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi perabet perabet giriş holiganbet holiganbet giriş Casibom Lesfillmercom Casibom Lesfillmercom Giriş Casibom Casibom Güncel Giriş Casibom Casibom Güncel Giriş Casibom Tevfikmuratyildirimcom Casibom Gerbergirlcom Casibom Gerbergirlcom Güncel Giriş Casibom Tevfikmuratyildirimcom Casibom Tevfikmuratyildirimcom Casibom Spcelectriccontrolcom Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet jojobet giriş marsbahis marsbahis giriş jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet jojobet giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Giriş Casibom Casibom Güncel Giriş vaycasino vaycasino giriş vaycasino güncel giriş vaycasino vaycasino giriş vaycasino güncel giriş matbet matbet giriş matbet güncel giriş vaycasino vaycasino güncel giriş vaycasino giriş matbet matbet giriş pusulabet pusulabet giriş pusulabet pusulabet güncel giriş pusulabet giriş matbet matbet güncel giriş matbet giriş Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Güncel Giriş Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres pusulabet pusulabet giriş pusulabet güncel giriş Fixbet Fixbet Güncel Giriş Salvobet Salvobet Giriş Salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom Turk Porno Turk Porno Giriş Turk Porno casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom casibom Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Casibom salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet casibom casibom casibom casibom Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi casibom casibom jojobet izmir escort izmir buca escort buca escort jojobet casibom holiganbet holiganbet giriş jojobet holiganbet holiganbet giriş jojobet jojobet jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet güncel giriş izmir escort izmir buca escort buca escort izmir escort bayan salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis marsbahis Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Giriş Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Deneme Bonusu Veren Giriş Deneme Bonusu Veren salvobet salvobet salvobet salvobet Casibom betgaranti betgaranti betgaranti matbet matbet giriş matbet matbet giriş Casibom Casibom Salvobet jojobet Salvobet Salvobet Salvobet Casibom Casibom Casibom Güncel Adres Casibom Güncel Giriş Marsbahis Marsbahis Marsbahis bahsegel Fixbet Fixbet Güncel Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Giriş 1xbet 1xbet Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Giriş Marsbahis Marsbahis Marsbahis Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Adresi jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet güncel giriş vaycasino vaycasino giriş vaycasino güncel giriş jojobet jojobet giriş jojobet güncel giriş Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Listesi Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Resmi Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Giriş Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Giriş Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Güncel Giriş Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Adresi Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler grandpashabet grandpashabet grandpashabet Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Resmi Adres Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Resmi Adres Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Adresi Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler vaycasino vaycasino giriş jojobet grandpashabet casibom Casibom Casibom Giriş casibom www.giftcards.com Marsbahis grandpashabet jojobet jojobet jojobet grandpashabet casibom jojobet Casibom Casibom Casibom Casibom Casibom Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Giriş Marsbahis Marsbahis Marsbahis Marsbahis Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Resmi Adres grandpashabet grandpashabet giriş Casibom Fixbet Fixbet Giriş Casibom İzmir Escort İzmir eskort İzmir Escort Bayan Vip escort Deneme Bonusu Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Holiganbet Holiganbet Güncel Adres Nevşehir escort Kapadokya escort Nevşehir escort bayan nevşehir eskort escort nevşehir Casibom Casibom Giriş Adresi Kapadokya esc Casibom Casibom Resmi Adres